Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Again, I don’t know if it works because I have witnessed probable cures, but then again, I am aware of the lurking variable factor, so who knows. I find it hard to believe that there is a population out there who runs to these “quacks” without any justification whatsoever. I find it hard to believe that thousands of practicing homeopaths are either brainwashed idiots or money-grubbing little creeps.

A placebo by any other name is still a placebo.
But doctors aren't allowed to fool their patients, they can't prescribe placebos.
Here comes the interesting bit though: according to the law, a placebo by any other name is not a placebo any more, but something else.
So lots of doctors prescribe homeopathy, knowing full well it doesn't do jack, but also knowing it doesn't hurt and will provide the patient comfort because "they received a box of pills to take".

Most homeopaths are either deluded or money-grubbing little creeps.
 
This is the theory of Water Memory.
Let's set aside a possible mechanism for "water memory"for the moment.
How do water molecules know which ingredient to remember? Any water you use will have something other than just water molecules in it, even if it's only molecules dissolved into it form the surrounding air. How do the water molecules distinguish between these molecules already in there and the molecules the homoeopath decides to put in it?
Also, it will have had other types of molecules in it at other times in the past. How do the water molecules know that they have to switch off the memory of these other molecules and switch on the memory of the molecules that the homoeopath puts in it? How do the water molecules know which of these molecules were the ones the homoeopath put in?
Doesn't this make you question the whole idea of homoeopathy?

A suggested method of "erasing water memory" is simply boiling the water.

The very simple question homeopaths can't answer though, is: How do you know this?

Nobody ever tried it. Nobody ever tested it. It's just something that some homeopath pulled out of his :Dss one day, when a skeptic much like ourself walked up to him and said: "Water memory? Hang on ...".
For what it's worth, Hahnemann, the inventor of homeopathy, didn't start out using boiled water IIRC. And either way, it seems that whether water is boiled or not doesn't make much difference. It only became a problem after Avogadro showed up and water memory had to be invented to circumvent that little reality check.

There's further problems though, because it appears there's got to be some kind of sugar-memory too, since many homeopathic preparations are dripped onto sugar tablets, which are then dried and packaged.
How does the sugar know it has to copy the memories from the water? And which memories? Why not those from the water used to purify and clean the sugar? And the sugar can't be boiled, because then you'd have caramel.

With every offered answer, more questions pop up. With every scientific advance, more exits get blocked off. What ARE they going to come up with next time a hypothesis is shown to be impossible? It never ceases to amaze me ...
 
exarch said:
With every offered answer, more questions pop up. With every scientific advance, more exits get blocked off. What ARE they going to come up with next time a hypothesis is shown to be impossible? It never ceases to amaze me ...
That's why I don't even try to argue with people who just make up what they believe as they go along. No point. It's plain as day that they're just making stuff up.
If they're basically nice people who apparently have some *really deep psychological need* to believe nonsense, then I just leave them be.
I'm not a psychiatrist. I can't fix that.
 
At the moment it seems to be quantum entanglement.

:hb:

They don't seen to realise that quantum phenomena happen on the quantum scale.


Oh...hahaha...oh god...no freakin' way...BWaHahahaha...

The idea of quantum entanglement is borrowed from physics and developed into an algebraic argument to explain how double-blinding randomized controlled trials could lead to failure to provide unequivocal
evidence for the efficacy of homeopathy
, and inability to distinguish proving and placebo groups in homeopathic pathogenic trials. By analogy with the famous double-slit experiment of quantum physics, and more modern notions of quantum information processing, these failings are understood as blinding causing information loss resulting from a kind of quantum superposition between the remedy and placebo.

Oh dear god that is the funniest thing I've ever read in my life...
Quantum entanglement is messing up the placebo controlled trials...
 
Whatever happened to Rolfe?

Agreed.

You would have to show that this was not counter-productive to the above.

That's true; I wish I knew so that I could better reign in my own ranty side! But I don't think it's possible to quantify the psychology of persuasion in this context. I tend to believe that refutation is the main thing, the style of it is less important but should always begin[/] in a reasonable, pleasant way. The problem is, as with the 9/11 "denial" people, the sceptics and critics have already been there, many times, if not with the individual in question, then with countless others trotting out the same tired and lacking arguments. I think the refuters can be forgiven for "losing it" with dyed-in-the-wool woos sometimes.

But of course we should all try our best to remain civil and calm; the next woo might just be a sockpuppet for some hardcore pusher with an agenda, or it might be some teenager who's never come across counter-arguments before. A gentle approach may not yield instant retraction and contrition, but it's likely to start the intellectual ball rolling, if it's ever going to in that particular person. In the internet culture of "OMFG NOOB", maybe an aggressive response will actually work better; who can say? There are too many variables involved to second guess psychology online. I agree that those advocating the soft approach are probably correct that more lurkers (ie those who probably don't engage in online "smack talk" or even online discussion at all) will respond better to it than to an aggressive slapdown that at first glance may not appear very different to the sort of "I hope you die from your allopathy" rhetoric offered by some of the hpaths on the forums frequented by MRC_Hans and co.
 
If it ‘works’ because of a placebo effect, should that not be preferable to suffering – of whatever degree?

Placebo Effect != Medicinal Treatment

Honestly, this is one of the things I hate the most about this stuff. When people say, "Well, even if it IS the placebo effect, isn't that at least an effect? Shouldn't that be allowed?"

NO. The placebo effect could be brought about by any number of things. If a truly terminal patient is desperate, they would be better off going to a psychologist for counselling - this sort of situation could ALSO produce a placebo effect. As could going to a doctor who puts them on asprin, claiming an effect that hasn't ever been ascribed to asprin.

But claiming that people should be allowed to waste their hard-earned money on WATER (let's not be coy now, it's just water) is just wrong.

If they want water, find them a tap. If they want a treatment that doesn't exist or won't work, send them to a doctor who feels okay about prescribing something they know won't work (it has previously been mentioned that some doctors recommend asprin for some things because even though THEY know it won't work, the patient doesn't and so may receive a placebo effect).

And this completely overlooks the fact that the majority of people using homeopathy aren't terminally ill people. They are people who should genuinely be receiving medical treatment.

So whatever you do - do NOT invoke the placebo effect as a reason to allow homeopathy. It is not a valid position to take if one cares about the health of oneself and the population in general.


Okay, EVEN if it’s false hope – and I’m sorry to tell you I’m not sure of that – will you deny that so you can uphold your stance against what you see as propagating falsehood?

Yes. Because it is FALSE hope - you yourself have just hit the nail on the head. There's a light at the end of the tunnel, but in the case of homeopathy, the lights belong to a bullet train.

Now - you say you aren't sure that homeopathy is a false hope.

After reading this thread, what specifically do you believe about homeopathy, and why?
 
Excuse me, people, does it not occur to you that one might not be spending one’s entire life logging on?

No, it doesn't. If I'm here, then everyone should be here.

Right here, not running, not hiding behind skirts. Just behind computer.
Oops, didn’t know I was being nasty myself by telling you some of you often are – if I didn’t make that distinction, I apologize and correct myself.

It does raise an interesting question. If you think our attitude is off-putting, why did you adopt that same attitude to tell us that?

What, am I supposed to be a homeopath in hiding, insidiously out to defend homeopathy?

That's not what I was thinking. I was thinking it could be that you had already made up your mind that you weren't going to listen to what skeptics had to say. Claiming that it was because of our attitude was simply an excuse made up to fit the situation.

Are you maybe paranoid?

One (maybe the only :)) benefit of the Conspiracy Theory threads is that it provides The standard by which all paranoia can be measured.

Please let me clarify my reason for ‘un-lurking’. While there’s no reason anyone should give a damn what I think, my purpose was to inform you that you are putting off people with the attitude you sometimes display. And that should someone not immediately succumb to your reasoning, it should not brand him/her as unworthy of your courtesy or patience. SOLELY my OPINION. Feel free to ignore it, as I believe I am free to state it.

Please let me clarify my reason for protesting. You have not provided evidence in support of any of your assertions. You have not demonstrated that we put off people (i.e. people that come in willing to listen that leave with their minds closed against our words) as I am not convinced that you were not already prejudiced against listening to us before you started reading this thread. And you have not provided evidence of a lack of courtesy and patience in this thread.

I am in no way an anti-vaxxer nor am I supporting substituting homeopathy in any serious problem except in case of ‘last resort’. I just don’t see that IF people are duly informed about the unlikelihood of homeopathy working, and if they choose to try it nonetheless, where is the harm?

I outlined the various ways it could harm in my last post to you. And that was a very incomplete list.

If it ‘works’ because of a placebo effect, should that not be preferable to suffering – of whatever degree? Maybe because a lot of homeopaths spend TIME with their clients and let them unburden or whatever – there’s probably great value in letting someone talk about themselves. What about ‘last resort’ – someone has some disease that conventional medicine says cannot be cured. What if ayurveda or homeopathy offer some hope?

It's a waste of time, money, and effort when it does not alter what was already going to happen anyway. If the benefit of homeopathy comes from having someone to talk to and having attention paid to you, then all the window-dressing and mumbo-jumbo on top of that is unnecessarily wasteful.

Okay, EVEN if it’s false hope – and I’m sorry to tell you I’m not sure of that – will you deny that so you can uphold your stance against what you see as propagating falsehood?

Please explain to me why you see the propagation of false hope valuable when it comes at the expense of propagating real hope.

Oh dear – okay, since I said I would, if you would like me to, I shall go over the whole bally 20-odd pages again and offer bits I think indicate eye-rolling and sighing. Will take me time, so please don’t think I’ve vanished into dark night.
And thank you, BillyJoe.

Yeah, like you and BillyJoe aren't in collusion.

Linda
 
A suggested method of "erasing water memory" is simply boiling the water.

The very simple question homeopaths can't answer though, is: How do you know this?
Yes, I heard that on that tape that I couldn't reference above. The homoeopath did not attempt to provide an answer.
 
But of course we should all try our best to remain civil and calm; the next woo might just be a sockpuppet for some hardcore pusher with an agenda, or it might be some teenager who's never come across counter-arguments before. A gentle approach may not yield instant retraction and contrition, but it's likely to start the intellectual ball rolling, if it's ever going to in that particular person. In the internet culture of "OMFG NOOB", maybe an aggressive response will actually work better; who can say? There are too many variables involved to second guess psychology online. I agree that those advocating the soft approach are probably correct that more lurkers (ie those who probably don't engage in online "smack talk" or even online discussion at all) will respond better to it than to an aggressive slapdown that at first glance may not appear very different to the sort of "I hope you die from your allopathy" rhetoric offered by some of the hpaths on the forums frequented by MRC_Hans and co.
My sentiments entirely. And better put than I have, thanks.
 
Yeah, like you and BillyJoe aren't in collusion.
That sounds like a pretty serious accusation.
Or am I misreading you again, Linda.
Would you like to clearly explain what you mean by this.

BJ
 
That sounds like a pretty serious accusation.
Or am I misreading you again, Linda.

Probably, unless your delivery is even drier than mine.

Would you like to clearly explain what you mean by this.

Not really. No joke is ever improved by explanation.

Linda
 
But of course we should all try our best to remain civil and calm; the next woo might just be a sockpuppet for some hardcore pusher with an agenda, or it might be some teenager who's never come across counter-arguments before. A gentle approach may not yield instant retraction and contrition, but it's likely to start the intellectual ball rolling, if it's ever going to in that particular person. In the internet culture of "OMFG NOOB", maybe an aggressive response will actually work better; who can say? There are too many variables involved to second guess psychology online. I agree that those advocating the soft approach are probably correct that more lurkers (ie those who probably don't engage in online "smack talk" or even online discussion at all) will respond better to it than to an aggressive slapdown that at first glance may not appear very different to the sort of "I hope you die from your allopathy" rhetoric offered by some of the hpaths on the forums frequented by MRC_Hans and co.

I think that sums it up nicely. I also think it's a message that most people here already understand and generally follow.

Linda
 
I just don’t see that IF people are duly informed about the unlikelihood of homeopathy working, and if they choose to try it nonetheless, where is the harm? If it ‘works’ because of a placebo effect, should that not be preferable to suffering – of whatever degree? Maybe because a lot of homeopaths spend TIME with their clients and let them unburden or whatever – there’s probably great value in letting someone talk about themselves.
I read an article in a magazine some years ago about a medical doctor who used homoeopathy to great effect. However, he'd never actually bothered to go into the details about how it was supposed to work. When eventually he did that, he realised that homoeopathy could not possibly be helping his patients. But why were they getting better? He thought about this a great deal. Finally he decided it as the way he dealt with his patients. He spent time with them, letting them unburden just like the homoeopath in your story. When he continued to do this but dropped the homoeopathic treatments, he found he still got the same results. And he felt much better because he wasn't using something which he knew was totally and utterly useless.

What about ‘last resort’ – someone has some disease that conventional medicine says cannot be cured. What if ayurveda or homeopathy offer some hope? Okay, EVEN if it’s false hope – and I’m sorry to tell you I’m not sure of that – will you deny that so you can uphold your stance against what you see as propagating falsehood?
You say you are not sure about whether giving false hope is a good idea. Well, patients with terminal illness was part of what that medical doctor above was treating. It makes no difference if the person is psychologically unwell or terminally unwell. It's the care and attention that the person gets that makes the difference. There is no need to give useless treatments.

regards,
BillyJoe
 
My sentiments entirely. And better put than I have, thanks.

Ah, but, if the person in question isn't going to be persuaded, then I can see the (perhaps twisted) logic of resorting to ridicule in order to make an example of them. Of course we shouldn't resort to it unless the person has demonstrated an unwillingness to listen, but it's a tough thing to resist in the face of wilful ignorance, the potential for physical harm, and the actual taking of people's money under false pretenses. Those things make some people angry, and I understand and sympathise with that. We should always strive for reasoned, calm argument, but when you've tried that with various people until you're blue in the face, and then another person pops up giving the same old schtick and clearly failing to make the effort to look into the sceptical angle, or even listen to it laid-out for them, it's pretty tough and demoralising to go back to square one every time. Face-to-face, most of us are prepared to extend that courtesy, but it's somewhat different online. Comments made online are also persistent and viewable by millions, which means that not responding at all (if you can't say anything nice etc etc!) isn't an option for people wanting to stem the tide of ignorance. Just look the neverending circus that is the Conspiracy forum. It's like whack-a-mole out there.

And you have to realise that ridicule and mockery are widespread online; people are used to seeing nonsense posted, and to seeing it mocked as such. It's a powerful tool when preceded by a decent argument, and can really pull the rug from under people if deployed well, as it often is in these forums. Even RSLancastrs Sylvia Browne site employs it. Randi and Dawkins are well known for their aggressive stances, which are often simply formally presented scorn, derision, and mockery.

It's a valid approach in my opinion, but if you use it in the first instance, you've failed.
 
Last edited:
Thank You Randi Forum

A few months ago I did not know what homeopaths were. After watching some James Randi on Youtube and reading these postings, I saved myself from being swindled. Tonight my daughter was experiencing ear pain and I rushed over to the pharmacy to see what was available. I was looking at ear drops and could not find any for pain. Then I stumbled on one that claimed it cured pain, wax build up, and a couple of other things. As always I looked at the active ingredients and noticed that the percentages were written in this funny manner (parts per milion or billion). I continued to read more of the label and there it was, "Homeopathic Medicine." Knowing now that homeopaths are more than 99% water, I quickly put the label down in disgust, grabbed some childrens' Tylonol (for the pain) and will await her condition in the morning (possibly followed up by a doctor's visit). I can't help but to point out two red flags, which I hope will help others as they have helped me. First is the fact that it was the only medicine (so to speak) that had multiple healing effects, unlike all the others. The second is the quantities for the active ingredients were written in a different manner than all the other medications. I hope pharmacies don't start carrying multiple brands of homeopaths, this could make spotting red flags, like these, very difficult.
 
But I said "Didn't make sense to me", so, in order to decide whether the problem was my lack of understanding or you talking nonsense, I asked "for a clarification".

See, you're doing it again. I "talking nonsense" should not be considered one of the options. :)

Jesus, you have to be so careful what you write around here. :)

It could be worse. I "make allowances" when talking to you. That's a joke, btw.

You may be right. That means you have given up on people with biases? - just asking.

Nope. It's just a harder problem to solve and I am still working on it. I have some preliminary ideas that seem to make a difference.

Originally Posted by fls
I do not speak in what manner?

Well, you were making a point of differentiating between private and public conversation. I was wondering whether you say things differently in the broarder public sphere (compared to the relatively more private sphere here)

You didn't answer my question.

I recognise all that. But why does it have to be an eye for an eye (or even a cornea for an eye)? Mini obviously didn't have as much going for him/her as you, for example, but does it really hurt to make allowances for that.

I actually consider it a sign of disrespect to treat people as though they are weaker. I will concede that this perspective is not without its own problems, but at the moment I believe Symmetry is the Answer to the Question and it guides my thinking on this particular subject.

You want me to find a trial which shows which way is best?
If someone posts a negative impression of the posters on this thread, I can't see how providing further negativity could help.

That's because you are biased and are not examining your assumptions.

Well, yes, we haven't seen mini for a while, unfortunately. So, you are possibly (okay, probably) right. I would have liked to have heard more from him/her.

I was going to point out that it was too early to call it on Mini, even before she/he came back. I recognize that I have just used a classic woo technique and so I give you leave not to believe me. :)

Linda
 
Last edited:
Ah, but, if the person in question isn't going to be persuaded, then I can see the (perhaps twisted) logic of resorting to ridicule in order to make an example of them. Of course we shouldn't resort to it unless the person has demonstrated an unwillingness to listen, but it's a tough thing to resist in the face of wilful ignorance, the potential for physical harm, and the actual taking of people's money under false pretenses. Those things make some people angry, and I understand and sympathise with that. We should always strive for reasoned, calm argument, but when you've tried that with various people until you're blue in the face, and then another person pops up giving the same old schtick and clearly failing to make the effort to look into the sceptical angle, or even listen to it laid-out for them, it's pretty tough and demoralising to go back to square one every time. Face-to-face, most of us are prepared to extend that courtesy, but it's somewhat different online. Comments made online are also persistent and viewable by millions, which means that not responding at all (if you can't say anything nice etc etc!) isn't an option for people wanting to stem the tide of ignorance. Just look the neverending circus that is the Conspiracy forum. It's like whack-a-mole out there.

And you have to realise that ridicule and mockery are widespread online; people are used to seeing nonsense posted, and to seeing it mocked as such. It's a powerful tool when preceded by a decent argument, and can really pull the rug from under people if deployed well, as it often is in these forums. Even RSLancastrs Sylvia Browne site employs it. Randi and Dawkins are well known for their aggressive stances, which are often simply formally presented scorn, derision, and mockery.

It's a valid approach in my opinion, but if you use it in the first instance, you've failed.
Well, look, perhaps you might be right, I'll mull it over a bit and see what I think. My initial reaction is a little negative (especially when you mentioned Dawkins). Perhaps it's a matter of where you draw the line with your aggressive stance (I think Dawkins crosses it).

regards,
BillyJoe
 
A few months ago I did not know what homeopaths were. After watching some James Randi on Youtube and reading these postings, I saved myself from being swindled. Tonight my daughter was experiencing ear pain and I rushed over to the pharmacy to see what was available. I was looking at ear drops and could not find any for pain. Then I stumbled on one that claimed it cured pain, wax build up, and a couple of other things. As always I looked at the active ingredients and noticed that the percentages were written in this funny manner (parts per milion or billion). I continued to read more of the label and there it was, "Homeopathic Medicine." Knowing now that homeopaths are more than 99% water, I quickly put the label down in disgust, grabbed some childrens' Tylonol (for the pain) and will await her condition in the morning (possibly followed up by a doctor's visit). I can't help but to point out two red flags, which I hope will help others as they have helped me. First is the fact that it was the only medicine (so to speak) that had multiple healing effects, unlike all the others. The second is the quantities for the active ingredients were written in a different manner than all the other medications. I hope pharmacies don't start carrying multiple brands of homeopaths, this could make spotting red flags, like these, very difficult.

That's very much like the story I thought about telling in response to the OP.

I was looking for something OTC help my daughter's "swimmer's ear" pain and only found one medicine at the drug store (Walgren's) (in the Eye/Ear section), but the description seemed to be what I was looking for. It wasn't until I read the box more closely, while waiting for a prescription to be filled, that I saw that it was a homeopathic preparation. That really pissed me off. There was no clear separation between effective and not effective treatments in the store. There was no choice of an effective treatment provided. And the damn thing was expensive (I have eye-droppers at home already and I pay a fraction of the price for the water that comes out of my tap). I should have complained.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom