Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Okay, thanks. Now, with respect to OTC medicines in general, is there a different FDA approval standard for different products? For example, is the standard for cough medicine the same as for pain-relieving cream, or is there a higher hurdle for one or the other?

I'll tentatively say the standard is the same, but it could depend upon what you are getting at.

Linda
 
I'll tentatively say the standard is the same, but it could depend upon what you are getting at.

Linda
What I'm asking is whether the FDA has some objective standard that all OTC medicines must meet or whether judgments are involved. For example, are some medicine categories considered to be inherently riskier than others, and so additional testing is required?
 
Would you consider a medicine capable of causing these sort of symptoms to be risky?
...when he woke up he was covered with papules and pustules all over the body. The eruption followed the path of veins everywhere. It took 21 days to anti-dote it and restore health.
 
What I'm asking is whether the FDA has some objective standard that all OTC medicines must meet or whether judgments are involved. For example, are some medicine categories considered to be inherently riskier than others, and so additional testing is required?

The standard is that they have to work and be safe. Obviously this isn't the same for all medicines. A cough medicine will have to show that people report feeling a bit better than if they only have a placebo, which will be harder to show than, for example, a drug that cures broken bones in a day. And of course the safety criteria are different as well, a drug that cures 100% of a guaranteed fatal illness, but kills half the patients itself would probably be accepted, but a cough medicine that kills half the people who take it certainly wouldn't.

This is all simply common sense, and I get the distinct feeling that you are just looking for a way to try to excuse holding homeopathy to different standards from everything else. The point is, while the size of the effect required may vary depending on the condition, there always needs to be some effect shown, and the simple fact is that all homeopathic remedies have failed to do this.
 
What I'm asking is whether the FDA has some objective standard that all OTC medicines must meet or whether judgments are involved. For example, are some medicine categories considered to be inherently riskier than others, and so additional testing is required?

The standard is fairly objective and consistent. The amount and kind of testing to demonstrate "safe and effective" will vary. If a drug is suspected to be risky, then it requires more testing to detail the risk vs. benefit.

Linda
 
http://www.bbc.co.uk/science/horizon/2002/homeopathytrans.shtml

Don't know if anyone has linked that in this topic. Excellent program. Read the whole thing.

Indeed, an excellent program.

Seems to me that practitioners of homeopathy have a problem distinguishing cause and effect.

Half a trial cohort having "homeopathic" water, and the other half placebo seems too easy, IMO. I'd be interested to know the results of a third bunch of people -- with the same complaint -- who were just observed but given nothing for their condition.

My guess would be that some would get better and some wouldn't. :)

M.
 
My sentiments as well. On the "Is there a doctor in the house?" thread, the Opening Poster was all but crucified for having the audacity to report that Head On immediately cured her headache. But here, Moochie takes it as a given that his wife got better thanks to antibiotics and that her symptoms were relieved by an OTC cough medicine.


Sorry to dilute your bile, but I take no such thing.

My wife got better, fast. Proof? I can't produce any. But she, having been an erstwhile "flower child" of the 60s and 70s, and given to believe the drivel about "holistic" and "natural therapies," found through repeated self experimentation that they sucked, big time.

Yes, she's a late bloomer, and has only in the past decade begun to understand the difference between wishing and reality.

Chances are she would have got better in the same time frame regardless, but previous experience did not support that idea.

M.
 
Moochie,
(at the risk of a derail)

From http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/...Retrieve&dopt=abstractplus&list_uids=12212759

Community-acquired pneumonia, acute bacterial rhinosinusitis, and selected cases of acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis (50%) warrant antimicrobial therapy, whereas otitis media with effusion, acute bronchitis, and most rhinosinusitis are viral and do not require antibiotic therapy.
My guess:
Your wife had acute bacterial rhinosinusitis?

Basis of my guess:
Otitis media with effusion, acute bronchitis, and viral rhinosinusitis "do not require antibiotic therapy".
Community-acquired pneumonia, and acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis are lower RTI and you surely would not have allowed your lovely wife to have a cough mixture with a lower RTI.

:)
 
Seems to me that practitioners of homeopathy have a problem distinguishing cause and effect.

Half a trial cohort having "homeopathic" water, and the other half placebo seems too easy, IMO. I'd be interested to know the results of a third bunch of people -- with the same complaint -- who were just observed but given nothing for their condition.

What I would like to see is a trial with very sloppy blinding.
Get a whole bunch of homeopathy believers as a test group. Say it's for a proving for example.
Somehow, inadvertently, people in the homeopathy group have to find out they're in the homeopathy group, and the same with the placebo group.

Only afterwards is it then revealed that both groups were further split up, and half of each group got the real deal, and the other half placebo.

You know, a typical psychology experiment plot twist.

That should give you a good indication of the placebo power of homeopathy.
My guess is, all the placebo group people will have shown little to no effect, and all the homeopathy group people will have reported dramatic improvement, regardless of what they actually got.
 
Last edited:
Moochie,
(at the risk of a derail)

From http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/...Retrieve&dopt=abstractplus&list_uids=12212759


My guess:
Your wife had acute bacterial rhinosinusitis?

Basis of my guess:
Otitis media with effusion, acute bronchitis, and viral rhinosinusitis "do not require antibiotic therapy".
Community-acquired pneumonia, and acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis are lower RTI and you surely would not have allowed your lovely wife to have a cough mixture with a lower RTI.

:)

Sorry, mate, but I don't have a clue what you're on about.

I've had a cough/cold for several days now, and am treating it with hot toddies, Benadryl (Aussie cough syrup), and Codral. So far, so good, especially after the hot toddies :)

Cheers,

M.
 
Sorry, mate, but I don't have a clue what you're on about.
Evasion noted. :D

Anti-biotics are not needed in upper RTI. The exception is moderate to severe acute bacterial rhinosinusuitis (see the link). If your lovely wife was blowing green snot out of her nose or clearing green gobs out the back of her throat, she may have needed antibiotics. Also, cough mixtures are not contra-indicated in upper RTI, so she could have those as well.
On the other hand, antibiotics are generally useful in lower RTI (except in acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis - is your wife a smoker?). However, cough mixtures are contra-indicated in lower RTI because they suppress cough which is part of the body's defence mechanism.

It's hard being a sceptic isn't it Moochie? :(
 
Evasion noted. :D

Anti-biotics are not needed in upper RTI. The exception is moderate to severe acute bacterial rhinosinusuitis (see the link). If your lovely wife was blowing green snot out of her nose or clearing green gobs out the back of her throat, she may have needed antibiotics. Also, cough mixtures are not contra-indicated in upper RTI, so she could have those as well.
On the other hand, antibiotics are generally useful in lower RTI (except in acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis - is your wife a smoker?). However, cough mixtures are contra-indicated in lower RTI because they suppress cough which is part of the body's defence mechanism.

It's hard being a sceptic isn't it Moochie? :(

Derail noted.
 
Aw, come on, the thread is dead.



....and, correct me if I'm wrong, but this thread started with the state of Mrs. Moochie's health, so it's only fitting that it ends that way.


Well, she's well, and I'm not. :(

And, no, it's harder being a believer.

My wife does have a chronic bronchial condition -- has done so since childhood. She stopped smoking over 20 years ago.

M.
 
Well, cheers to Mrs. Moochie.
Commiserations to Mooch.
And happy christmas to everyone else.

:D
(actually, I'm really sorry you are sick, Moochie. We have a couple of sickies here as well - gastro, and definitely no treatments for that, homoeopathetic or otherwise)
 
Well, cheers to Mrs. Moochie.
Commiserations to Mooch.
And happy christmas to everyone else.

:D
(actually, I'm really sorry you are sick, Moochie. We have a couple of sickies here as well - gastro, and definitely no treatments for that, homoeopathetic or otherwise)

Thank you -- it's appreciated.

I'll recover -- I'm drinking tap water. No telling what sort of memories that has. :)

Just goes to show how totally silly the idea that water has memory is. Considering what water is, its memory must be vast, encompassing everything that's happened since time immemorial.

Unless, of course, our homeopathic friends have managed to create virgin water.

M.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom