Homeopathic Cough Medicine

I wasn't able to access all of the studies Linda linked to, but two of them were not completely negative to homeopathy. The first, an Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder study, concluded:

"There were no statistically significant differences between homeopathic remedy and placebo groups on the primary or secondary outcome variables. However, there were statistically and clinically significant improvements in both groups on many of the outcome measures.

That means: both the remedy group and the placebo group showed improvements, but both had about the same results. It then goes on:

"Conclusions: This pilot study provides no evidence to support a therapeutic effect of individually selected homeopathic remedies in children with ADHD.

It then goes on asking for more studies to be done, because perhaps homeopathy might still work, even if this study didn't show anything to that end.

The next one:

The second, an asthma study, concluded:

"Conclusion: Homoeopathic immunotherapy is not effective in the treatment of patients with asthma. The different patterns of change between homoeopathic immunotherapy and placebo over the course of the study are unexplained.

It says right there: not effective.

"What is already known on this topic:
Homoeopathic remedies probably have an effect that is greater than placebo.
Some of the better quality homoeopathic studies involve homoeopathic doses of allergens used to treat allergic disease.

which means the studies were of better quality, not the results.
And as fls said, only some of the studies were about homeopathy, the others didn't use homeopathic remedies but remedies wich had an actual active ingredient still present. That's not homeopathy, that's isopathy. It's been suggested for many years now that a way to reduce allergic reactions might be to get the body used to low doses of the allergy-causing substances.

"What this study adds:
In this study homoeopathic remedies were no better than placebo in the treatment of asthmatic patients who are allergic to house dust mite."

'nuff said.

I'm all in favor of more studies and would be pleased if the next major study tested OTC cough medicines -- both homeopathic and non-homeopathic -- against placebos.

We all think more research would be good. But before homeopathy goes up against the big boys (i.e. real medication), perhaps they should first show themselves to be able to deal with the little leage (i.e. placebo). And that easily fixes the all too often mentioned financial problem. Why should money meant for scientific research be wasted on homeopathy, when homeopathic remedy production companies like Boiron make more than enough money to do their own testing?

If you really want to see more scientific testing of homeopathy done, adjust the law so it can no longer be sold over the counter without first passing the same kind of testing procedures that a regular drug has to pass. Either positive tests and evidence of efficacy will start showing up, or homeopathy is never heard of again because it can no longer be legally sold.

A great quote I heard just yesterday:

Homeopathy: turning water into money since 1810 :)
 
If you really want to see more scientific testing of homeopathy done, adjust the law so it can no longer be sold over the counter without first passing the same kind of testing procedures that a regular drug has to pass.
You probably don't realize this, but I'm actually not yet in charge of adjusting all of the world's laws. However, with help from Randi Forum participants, that desirable outcome may be achieved in the not-too-distant future. ;) But I'm interested in hearing more about the testing procedures that "regular" OTC drugs pass -- in particular, "regular" OTC cough medicines.
 
But I'm interested in hearing more about the testing procedures that "regular" OTC drugs pass -- in particular, "regular" OTC cough medicines.
As far as the UK is concerned, the procedure for licensing medicines is governed by the MHRA:
you will notice that while "regular" medicines have to demonstrate efficacy in clinical trials, there are special schemes for homoeopathic medicines (and "traditional herbal medicines") that exempt them from this requirement.
 
Good quote :)

How many words could you substitute for "homeopathy"?

M.

Well if you change the date, and change the water to crap, alot. There are not that many woo scams that sell water, compaired to say herbs, or magic crystals or...
 
You probably don't realize this, but I'm actually not yet in charge of adjusting all of the world's laws. However, with help from Randi Forum participants, that desirable outcome may be achieved in the not-too-distant future. ;) But I'm interested in hearing more about the testing procedures that "regular" OTC drugs pass -- in particular, "regular" OTC cough medicines.

Rodney, I'm about done with your willful stupidity. All I can say at this point, after it has become painfully obvious that you don't give a hoot for any evidence but that which supports your apparently unshakable belief in quackery, is that you henceforth use homeopathy exclusively to treat any medical issue that arises in your life, or the lives of your loved ones.

Regarding the opening post, my wife got better, thanks to antibiotics. Her symptoms were relieved by an OTC cough medicine.

I eagerly await your triumphant post where you tell us how your illness was helped by ingestion of homeopathic substances.

M.
 
Last edited:
As far as the UK is concerned, the procedure for licensing medicines is governed by the MHRA:
you will notice that while "regular" medicines have to demonstrate efficacy in clinical trials, there are special schemes for homoeopathic medicines (and "traditional herbal medicines") that exempt them from this requirement.
The same is true here. When laws were being written to strengthen the FDA 70 years ago, a powerful senator (Royal Copeland) was a homeopath.
 
Thanks for the link, Linda. But I'm still unclear as to what procedures must be followed in the United States for a new OTC cough medicine to be introduced. For example, say a company wants to introduce a cough medicine that has the same active ingredients as an existing cough medicine, but the ingredients' proportions are slightly different than the existing cough medicine. What steps are required of the company?
 
Assumption, assumption, and anecdote.
Hmmm...
My sentiments as well. On the "Is there a doctor in the house?" thread, the Opening Poster was all but crucified for having the audacity to report that Head On immediately cured her headache. But here, Moochie takes it as a given that his wife got better thanks to antibiotics and that her symptoms were relieved by an OTC cough medicine.
 
Thanks for the link, Linda. But I'm still unclear as to what procedures must be followed in the United States for a new OTC cough medicine to be introduced. For example, say a company wants to introduce a cough medicine that has the same active ingredients as an existing cough medicine, but the ingredients' proportions are slightly different than the existing cough medicine. What steps are required of the company?

Basically they would demonstrate bioequivalence and then the data that was used to approve the pre-existing cough medicine could be used for the approval of the new cough medicine.

Linda
 
Basically they would demonstrate bioequivalence and then the data that was used to approve the pre-existing cough medicine could be used for the approval of the new cough medicine.

Linda
Okay, thanks. Now, with respect to OTC medicines in general, is there a different FDA approval standard for different products? For example, is the standard for cough medicine the same as for pain-relieving cream, or is there a higher hurdle for one or the other?
 
Okay, thanks. Now, with respect to OTC medicines in general, is there a different FDA approval standard for different products? For example, is the standard for cough medicine the same as for pain-relieving cream, or is there a higher hurdle for one or the other?

I would think that essentially, the hurdle is the exact same hurdle for every product. The fact that some products may have more difficulty jumping that hurdle (i.e. more trials needed before efficacy, safety, etc... can be shown, or different approaches/methods having to be used to get the evidence needed), does not actually change the hurdle they've got to pass.

And by different approaches I'm talking about differences in trial design depending on what kind of ailment you're trying to cure/alleviate. For cough medicine that would certainly be different than for pain relief medication, or ant-inflammation gel, etc...

Edit:
I suppose that in the end, it's still the FDA that approves products for sale, and they will also look at the risk/benefit. So it's not that the height of the hurdle changes, it's that some products may just have more additional "weight" to lift over the bar.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom