Homeopathic Cough Medicine

I trust you have some evidence for that. From what I've read, there's no cure for the common cold, but that the medicinal cough mixtures do suppress symptoms, and allow a person to have a night's sleep.
I gave you the Web MD link that discusses the non-efficacy of over-the-counter cough medicines. Here it is again -- http://www.webmd.com/content/article/18/1689_51929
Excerpt: "When a cold or flu hits, many people reach for over-the-counter cough medicines. But do they really work? A researcher has analyzed results of 15 trials, finding no real proof that they do anything."
 
What makes you think that the three professors of medicine who performed the analysis were biased? They weren't homeopaths.

If they where only looking at data, and not fine details of how the experiment was conducted they have no protection from the bias that the people running the experiment had.

Then there is also the potential for willfully corruption of data.

Homeopathy violates the principles that all of organic chemistry, and biochemistry and so on have learned about how things work. If it is true then a great many other things must be wrong. Chemotherapy must be the wrong approach because it goes against all homeopathic theory, if homeopathy is right.

Everything we know about how medicine, and every well conducted double blind experiment says homeopathy doesn't/can't work. And homeopathy's response is to say that double blind experiments are a bad tool for measuring the effectiveness of their product and you need to use techniques that are known to introduce bias and skew the results the way the people carrying out it want it to go.
 
I gave you the Web MD link that discusses the non-efficacy of over-the-counter cough medicines. Here it is again -- http://www.webmd.com/content/article/18/1689_51929
Excerpt: "When a cold or flu hits, many people reach for over-the-counter cough medicines. But do they really work? A researcher has analyzed results of 15 trials, finding no real proof that they do anything."

In reading the article as you seem to it would mean that, Antihistamines, Codine and so on do absolutely nothing. Is this your claim?
 
So are you in favor or decrimilalizing con games? If you are dumb enough to believe that you are being contacted to help someone in nigeria get their money out of swiss banks you desearve to lose your money?

How is the one so different from the other?
First, you assume that homeopathy is a scam or a con game. Do you have evidence that, not only does it not work, but that its proponents know that it does not work? Second, do you disagree that homeopathic medicines can have a placebo effect? Third, if the government bans homeopathic medicines on the grounds that their efficacy has not been demonstrated, do you want all products banned when their efficacy has not been demonstrated?
 
First, you assume that homeopathy is a scam or a con game.

I sell you something that can not possibly work, that seems to be a definition of con game to me, or at least a class of cons.
Do you have evidence that, not only does it not work, but that its proponents know that it does not work?
It violates everything known about chemistry, a 30x dilution is impossible you will not have any ingredient in the medicine you are buying. Even their most concentrated dilutions if possible to make would do nothing.

If I sell you a car that runs on water, in direct opposition to everything that is known about chemistry and thermodynamics in the same ways that homeopathy is in opposition to everything that is known about chemistry and biology, am I running a con?
Second, do you disagree that homeopathic medicines can have a placebo effect?

Horse[RULE8] Has a placebo effect, should I be able to mark manure as medicine and sell it in health food stores?
Third, if the government bans homeopathic medicines on the grounds that their efficacy has not been demonstrated, do you want all products banned when their efficacy has not been demonstrated?

YES. Any claims that have not been tested and shown to be valid should not be able to be made. These things cause people to die all the time because they believe people who are making money off of them and not seeing it for the con that it is.
 
These two statements probably are the gist of 99,9% of my personal encounters with people who use homeopathic stuff or talk about homeopathy as "alternative" medicine. :mad:
I've noticed that even some of the people who manufacture and sell "homeopathic" products don't seem to understand the term 'homeopathy'.

For instance...

http://www.sinusbuster.com/

A homeopathic line of natural nasal health sprays from the makers of "Sinus Buster Pepper Nasal Spray"

Homeopathic remedies are normally based on natural ingredients. Homeopathy works in harmony with your immune system, unlike some conventional medicines which suppress the immune system. Homeopathic remedies are not addictive. Homeopathy is holistic. It treats all the symptoms as one, which in practical terms means that it addresses the cause, not the symptoms.

Ingredients: Oleoresin Capsicum, Kava Kava extract, Marshmallow Root extract, Guarana Seed extract, Spearmint Oil, Grapefruit Seed Extract, Ascorbic Acid, Citric Acid, Vegetable Glycerin and Purified Water.

Sorry, Wayne... that ain't homeopathy. Yes, go ahead and hang your head in shame.

wayspray2.jpg
 
I've noticed that even some of the people who manufacture and sell "homeopathic" products don't seem to understand the term 'homeopathy'.

For instance...

Sadly, these folks don't really care. They just throw in some of the typical b*ll words, "holistic", "natural" blah blah and people will buy it. Herbal, homeopathic - doesn't matter to them.


Nice interpretation of the image from their site :D
 
I've noticed that even some of the people who manufacture and sell "homeopathic" products don't seem to understand the term 'homeopathy'.

For instance...

http://www.sinusbuster.com/



Sorry, Wayne... that ain't homeopathy. Yes, go ahead and hang your head in shame.

[qimg]http://sinusbuster.com/thestory/images/wayspray2.jpg[/qimg]

So this was a guy who decided pepper spray needed to be shot up his nose to fix his cold? And I can see how it might make you forget about a headache, if their concentration is of capsicum is anything close to what they are hinting at it would be hotter than any chili
 
So this was a guy who decided pepper spray needed to be shot up his nose to fix his cold? And I can see how it might make you forget about a headache, if their concentration is of capsicum is anything close to what they are hinting at it would be hotter than any chili

Actually... I'm in the process of developing a headache remedy along these same lines. I'm going to market it under the brand name...

Hammer to the Kneecap (patent pending)
 
The theoretical basis of homeopathy is absurd. Nothing in chemistry supports the "law of infinitesimals" and nothing supports the "law of similars".

To claim these "remedies" (sorry--you certainly cannot call them "medicines" because they aren't) will relieve any symptoms is an extraordinary claim. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof, and even you, Rodney, should agree that that sort of proof does not exist.

Rodney, many of these preparations are so dilute that it is virtually certain that not a single molecule of the active ingredient is left. (Someone calculated that a 30C preparation means you'd have one drop of ingredient in a volume of water the size of the solar system--or something similar.) Most of them are beyond the cleanliness and controls available in a common production plant. There's no science at all supporting the idea that water somehow "remembers" being in contact with the active ingredient (and if there were, then wouldn't water "remember" being in contact with all the other substances that it constantly cycles in and through?).
 
If consumers are dumb enough to pay $12.95 for 8 oz. of colored water, that's their problem -- not yours, mine, or the government's.

If some guy says he's going to fix your roof and then just messes around a bit up there, replaces a few shingles, then charges you $400 for it, having fixed nothing at all, that's your problem? Not the government's? Not mine? What if I'm his next customer? I don't want to pay some shyster $400 for doing a piss-poor job.

Your attitude sucks Rodney. You're basicvally condoning theft.
I someone steals your wallet or your car? Well, that's your problem isn't it?
Tell you what, next time it happens to you, tell the police to sod off and mind their own business why don't you?

Meanwhile, I'll be reporting the theft in the hopes that the criminals can be brought to justice. Whether they're stealing cars or selling quackery and snake-oils.
 
The jury is still out on the efficacy of homeopathy and even if it is ultimately proven not to be at all efficacious, that would not prove it's a scam.

Ehm, that's exactly what would prove it a scam actually.

And most research seems to have already convinced the jury that homeopathy is ultimately not efficacious. In other words, we pretty much know it doesn't work, research has shown it doesn't work better than placebo, but people are still selling it and saying it does work. That is, by definition, a scam. Plain and simple.

Anything else is just making excuses and being dishonest.
 
Sadly, these folks don't really care. They just throw in some of the typical b*ll words, "holistic", "natural" blah blah and people will buy it. Herbal, homeopathic - doesn't matter to them.

At least they didn't use "quantum"...
 
I sell you something that can not possibly work, that seems to be a definition of con game to me, or at least a class of cons.
It's a con only if you know it can't work.

It violates everything known about chemistry, a 30x dilution is impossible you will not have any ingredient in the medicine you are buying. Even their most concentrated dilutions if possible to make would do nothing.
That's the current conventional wisdom, but history tells us that the conventional wisdom often proves wrong.

If I sell you a car that runs on water, in direct opposition to everything that is known about chemistry and thermodynamics in the same ways that homeopathy is in opposition to everything that is known about chemistry and biology, am I running a con?
If you know that the car can't run on water, yes. But in that case, the con would be quickly exposed.

Horse[RULE8] Has a placebo effect, should I be able to mark manure as medicine and sell it in health food stores?
No, because it would likely cause harm.

YES. Any claims that have not been tested and shown to be valid should not be able to be made.
So do you prevent all products that have not been shown to be valid from being sold?

These things cause people to die all the time because they believe people who are making money off of them and not seeing it for the con that it is.
Homeopathic cough medicine causes "people to die all the time'?
 
That's the current conventional wisdom, but history tells us that the conventional wisdom often proves wrong.
Homeopathic cough medicine causes "people to die all the time'?

It's not 'conventional wisdom', it's MATH.

And dying people who take homeopathic medicine (not cough medicine) instead of real medicine will still die.
 
Instructions on how to learn homeopathy. Take a book on homeopathy and grind it up into little pieces. Do 30 serial dilutions of 1 to 100 (initially one part book to 100 parts water). Be very careful when taking the resulting liquid since it may make you so smart your brains might fall out of your head.
 
It's not 'conventional wisdom', it's MATH.
Math has been used to show that all kinds of things that we now know are true couldn't possibly happen; rogue waves, to name one. If a problem is specified incorrectly, math can't solve it.

And dying people who take homeopathic medicine (not cough medicine) instead of real medicine will still die.
I think you'll find that dying people who take "real medicine" will also still die. ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom