Homeopathic Cough Medicine

First, the evidence regarding the lack of efficacy of homeopathy is not as clear-cut as most people here seem to think. For example, according to -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy -- "In 1991, three professors of medicine from the Netherlands, none of them homeopaths, performed a meta-analysis of 25 years of clinical studies using homeopathic medicines and published their results in the British Medical Journal. This meta-analysis covered 107 controlled trials, of which 81 showed that homeopathic medicines were effective, 24 showed they were ineffective, and 2 were inconclusive."
Try looking at some more recent meta-analyses.
 
And are the manufacturers of non-homoeopathic cough medicines now claiming that DBPC tests are not an appropriate method of assessing their products?
I don't know, but how is that relevant? Either a cough medicine has been shown to be efficacious by objective testing or it has not been. The relevant question is whether homeopathic cough medicines that haven't shown to be efficacious by such testing should be treated differently than non-homeopathic cough medicines that haven't shown to be efficacious.
 
First, the evidence regarding the lack of efficacy of homeopathy is not as clear-cut as most people here seem to think. For example, according to -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy -- "In 1991, three professors of medicine from the Netherlands, none of them homeopaths, performed a meta-analysis of 25 years of clinical studies using homeopathic medicines and published their results in the British Medical Journal. This meta-analysis covered 107 controlled trials, of which 81 showed that homeopathic medicines were effective, 24 showed they were ineffective, and 2 were inconclusive."

Second, it is a well-established fact that a placebo effect exists with respect to many medicines. So why crusade against unproven, but otherwise harmless homeopathic medicines, while giving a free pass to unproven, but otherwise harmless non-homeopathic medicines?


Did these studies say anything about natural healing?

In regards to my OP, it did occur to me that the "efficacy" of the homeopathic cough medicine experienced by my wife's colleague may have been no more than her ailment having run its course.

In answer to your second point -- selling 8 oz of colored water for $12.95 is criminal.

We're not talking about "unproven, but otherwise harmless non-homeopathic medicines" here. If you have any evidence of same, start a thread.

M.
 
Rodney, it seems to me you are talking about something completely different here than what this thread was about. So, there are non-homeopathic remedies out there with questionable efficacy, you say. Now why should that be equally treated like the total scam that homeopathy is??
 
I don't know, but how is that relevant? Either a cough medicine has been shown to be efficacious by objective testing or it has not been. The relevant question is whether homeopathic cough medicines that haven't shown to be efficacious by such testing should be treated differently than non-homeopathic cough medicines that haven't shown to be efficacious.
The point I was making is that homoeopaths have taken to claiming that their remedies cannot be tested by DBPC trials. If conventional medicines are found not to work in properly controlled trials, then their manufacturers can't really argue about that. Homoeopaths, on the other hand, simply claim that any test methods that show that homoeopathy doesn't work are somehow not appropriate to testing homoeopathy, and go in for the sort of uncontrolled customer satisfaction survey published by a group from Bristol last year as evidence that homoeopathy works.
 
Did these studies say anything about natural healing?
I don't know, but what's the relevance?

In regards to my OP, it did occur to me that the "efficacy" of the homeopathic cough medicine experienced by my wife's colleague may have been no more than her ailment having run its course.
First, you don't know that for sure. Second, if it's true, how is that different from an M.D. prescribing a non-efficacious medicine, with the patient recovering because the ailment has run its course?

In answer to your second point -- selling 8 oz of colored water for $12.95 is criminal.
If consumers are dumb enough to pay $12.95 for 8 oz. of colored water, that's their problem -- not yours, mine, or the government's.

We're not talking about "unproven, but otherwise harmless non-homeopathic medicines" here. If you have any evidence of same, start a thread.M.
But you're singling out this "homeopathic" (who knows if it even is?) cough medicine for special condemnation, when no over the counter cough medicines have been proven to be efficacious. I don't have any interest in starting another thread because I don't mind that unproven, but otherwise harmless non-homeopathic medicines, are sold.
 
Rodney, it seems to me you are talking about something completely different here than what this thread was about. So, there are non-homeopathic remedies out there with questionable efficacy, you say. Now why should that be equally treated like the total scam that homeopathy is??
The jury is still out on the efficacy of homeopathy and even if it is ultimately proven not to be at all efficacious, that would not prove it's a scam.
 
The point I was making is that homoeopaths have taken to claiming that their remedies cannot be tested by DBPC trials. If conventional medicines are found not to work in properly controlled trials, then their manufacturers can't really argue about that. Homoeopaths, on the other hand, simply claim that any test methods that show that homoeopathy doesn't work are somehow not appropriate to testing homoeopathy, and go in for the sort of uncontrolled customer satisfaction survey published by a group from Bristol last year as evidence that homoeopathy works.
So why not let consumers evaluate the evidence and decide whether they want to purchase homeopathic medicines?
 
The jury is still out on the efficacy of homeopathy and even if it is ultimately proven not to be at all efficacious, that would not prove it's a scam.

This is not about a jury proving that homeopathy is _not_ efficacious. For me it would be good enough if homeopathy would prove it's efficaciousness (phew - is that actually a word??). It's their claim, not mine, that it works.
 
If the work colleague thinks she has been helped, what exactly is the problem? And is your solution to have the government ban the cough medicine?

The problem is obvious - maybe this colleague plans to vacation in Africa and now decides to take the Homeopathic "alternative" for malaria instead of getting properly vaccinated.

Then she gets a real disease that she is going to have a hard time wishing away by drinking distilled water.
 
I don't know, but what's the relevance?

It would tend to show the uselessness of the homeopathic "medicine."

First, you don't know that for sure. Second, if it's true, how is that different from an M.D. prescribing a non-efficacious medicine, with the patient recovering because the ailment has run its course?

We're talking about a specific homeopathic cough medicine here, for the second or third time.

If consumers are dumb enough to pay $12.95 for 8 oz. of colored water, that's their problem -- not yours, mine, or the government's.

That's where you and I differ.

But you're singling out this "homeopathic" (who knows if it even is?) cough medicine for special condemnation, when no over the counter cough medicines have been proven to be efficacious.

I trust you have some evidence for that. From what I've read, there's no cure for the common cold, but that the medicinal cough mixtures do suppress symptoms, and allow a person to have a night's sleep.

If OTC cough mixtures need research, then let it happen. The facts are already in for homeopathic "medicines" -- i.e., there are no detectable active ingredients present. In other words, it's water and/or sugar pills.

I don't have any interest in starting another thread because I don't mind that unproven, but otherwise harmless non-homeopathic medicines, are sold.

Fair enough, but I do care. Whether the label says "homeopathic" or anything else, if it's a scam, I want those responsible held to account.

M.
 
The problem is obvious - maybe this colleague plans to vacation in Africa and now decides to take the Homeopathic "alternative" for malaria instead of getting properly vaccinated.

Then she gets a real disease that she is going to have a hard time wishing away by drinking distilled water.

Excellent point. It is exactly at this juncture that the weasel words of the apologists, and those with vested interests, break down.

M.
 
First, the evidence regarding the lack of efficacy of homeopathy is not as clear-cut as most people here seem to think. For example, according to -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy -- "In 1991, three professors of medicine from the Netherlands, none of them homeopaths, performed a meta-analysis of 25 years of clinical studies using homeopathic medicines and published their results in the British Medical Journal. This meta-analysis covered 107 controlled trials, of which 81 showed that homeopathic medicines were effective, 24 showed they were ineffective, and 2 were inconclusive."

Sounds like a case of garbage in, garbage out. You can analyze the data all you want, if it is corrupted by bias it will always be worthless.
 
I have run across several products touting homeopathic preparation, but they list active ingredients at only 1, 2, or 5x. People still are aghast when I point out what homeopathic really means. That or they choose to ignore me and go with what their friend/relative/total stranger told them cured a friend of an acquaintance somewhere.

CT
 
The jury is still out on the efficacy of homeopathy and even if it is ultimately proven not to be at all efficacious, that would not prove it's a scam.

Good to know that the jury is still out on if modern chemistry has any basis in reality, I am sure Dupont is waiting with baited breath to know of they have spent the last 100 years doing pointless things like inventing nylon and Kevlar based on ideas that can not possibly work.
 
The jury is still out on the efficacy of homeopathy and even if it is ultimately proven not to be at all efficacious, that would not prove it's a scam.

poppycock.

There is no "jury still out". Homeopathy has not proven one damned thing in its entire existence.

Not one.

The only people who try and perpetuate the "jury still out" twaddle are homeos themselves.
 
If consumers are dumb enough to pay $12.95 for 8 oz. of colored water, that's their problem -- not yours, mine, or the government's.

So are you in favor or decrimilalizing con games? If you are dumb enough to believe that you are being contacted to help someone in nigeria get their money out of swiss banks you desearve to lose your money?

How is the one so different from the other?
 
The problem is obvious - maybe this colleague plans to vacation in Africa and now decides to take the Homeopathic "alternative" for malaria instead of getting properly vaccinated.

Then she gets a real disease that she is going to have a hard time wishing away by drinking distilled water.
A rather large leap from a homeopathic cough medicine to a homeopathic alternative for malaria. And who, exactly, is recommending the latter?
 
Sounds like a case of garbage in, garbage out. You can analyze the data all you want, if it is corrupted by bias it will always be worthless.
What makes you think that the three professors of medicine who performed the analysis were biased? They weren't homeopaths.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom