Homeopathic Cough Medicine

I have repeatedly made the point that non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines have been shown to have little or no benefit...
...despite having been shown studies showing that they have efficacy. Repeatedly asserting something does not make it true, especially in the face of contradictory evidence.
...and that homeopathic cough medicines haven't -- to my knowledge -- been tested.
Why not? It would certainly be to the homoeopathic medicines industry's advantage if these remedies could be shown to be effective, not least in the UK, where between 1971 and 1992 no new medicine could be marketed without proving efficacy. Apparently, no new homoeopathic medicines were introduced to the market during this period of 21 years.

Why hasn't the homoeopathic medicines industry carried out tests (or if they have, why can't you find the results published anywhere)?
Ideally, I would like to see a three-way test involving a non-homeopathic OTC cough medicine, a homeopathic cough medicine, and a placebo. Fair enough?
We already have tests showing that non-homoeopathic cough medicines have some efficacy. Why not just test the homoeopathic medicines against placebo?
 
OK, so OTC cough medicine may have been tested to have an effect, although I have bnever been prescribed something that worked.

But I do not see the connection between OTC cough medicine and homoeopathic cough medicine. Why is it important if OTC medicine has been tested or not? homoeopathic medicine does not suddenly become effective if OTC medicine was not effective.

I have often seen homoeopaths spending much time criticizing conventional medicine as if it somehow helps homoeopathy if conventional medicine did not work. Face the facts: homoeopathy sucks, and no failing, imagined or real, of conventional medicine can change that.
 
OK, so OTC cough medicine may have been tested to have an effect, although I have bnever been prescribed something that worked.

But I do not see the connection between OTC cough medicine and homoeopathic cough medicine. Why is it important if OTC medicine has been tested or not? homoeopathic medicine does not suddenly become effective if OTC medicine was not effective.

I have often seen homoeopaths spending much time criticizing conventional medicine as if it somehow helps homoeopathy if conventional medicine did not work. Face the facts: homoeopathy sucks, and no failing, imagined or real, of conventional medicine can change that.

Exactly. We have pointed this out several of times already in this thread alone. One medicine's effectiveness makes no difference to the effectiveness of others. Maybe if I write it slightly larger Rodney will actually notice.

One medicine's effectiveness makes no difference to the effectiveness of others.

Rodney, this thread is about homeopathic cough medicine. It doesn't matter how much you badmouth real medicine, no matter how bad, ineffective or downright dangerous a cough medicine might be, it still won't make any difference to the fact that homeopathic cough medicine does not work.

There is also no point trying to shift the burden of proof to anyone other than the promoters of homeopathy. Real drug comapnies already have medicines that work, and they work to develop new ones that they hope will work. Why would they spend their time and money researching someone else's product? If homeopathic cough medicines work, it is up to the people selling them to show this. More to the point, if they work, why do the most optimistic, published studies say that there is no evidence and more research is required? Considering that negative studies are hardly ever published, doesn't it seem at all odd to you that even the most positive ones can't actually say that homeopathy works at all?
 
Considering that negative studies are hardly ever published, doesn't it seem at all odd to you that even the most positive ones can't actually say that homeopathy works at all?

Negative studies do get published when researchers are trying to determine whether a line of inquiry is fruitless (as is the case with homeopathy). I provided links to most (I didn't link all of them as I was getting tired of the process and I knew they'd get ignored anyway) of the half-decent clinical trials of homeopathy that have been performed during the last 15 years (per Rodney's request) here. They are all negative.

Linda
 
If you put the topic in bold, at least get it right. homeopathic cough medicine.


But you didn't discuss homeopathic cough medicine in your reply. In fact, you didn't discuss homeopathic remedies at all.

I have repeatedly made the point that non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines have been shown to have little or no benefit,

No, you haven't. In fact the evidence comes down strongly against you.

and that homeopathic cough medicines haven't -- to my knowledge -- been tested. Ideally, I would like to see a three-way test involving a non-homeopathic OTC cough medicine, a homeopathic cough medicine, and a placebo. Fair enough?

No not fair enough.

As yet, there is no clinical trial that has shown an effect above that of placebo that cannot be explained by chance or bias for homeopathy.

There ARE clinical trials that have shown the OTC medicinal cough supressants show an effect above placebo if used in the correct dosage, for the correct cough.

So there is really no need to compare something with a KNOWN EFFECT (OTC CM) with something that has shown NO EFFECT (homeopathic remedies).

It would be very difficult to justify the cost of such a pointless trial.

First test whether homeopathy works (so far this does NOT seem to be the case).

Then, if it is found to work, there MAY be some justification in comparing it's effectiveness to that of an OTC medicine.
 
Rodney, you seem to not get this.

If you want to have anything to discuss, you need to find a recent homeo trial that is performed with proper controls and shows a positive results.

Next clue: At present time, no such trial exists. There is nothing to debate there. This is just the way things are.

That every attempt to created such a trial ends in (a) positive results with poor controls or (b) negative results with proper controls is a large clue to rational people that by very large odds, homeopathy is worthless.

However, if you can bring a well conducted positive results homeopathy study to the table, you'll get a decent discussion here rather than just a smackdown.
 
When? And what were the results?
Zep may correct me, but I believe he meant to say that homeopathic remedies have been tested and have been found to be ineffective (see any number of posts in this thread or the dozens of other homeopathy threads on this board).

As no medicine prepared using homeopathic methods has ever been shown to be efficacious, it is reasonable to conclude that specific homeopathic medicines for cough are also not efficacious.

This conclusion is provisional, of course, and needs only reliable, replicable studies demonstrating otherwise. Such studies (the initial ones at least) reasonably to be performed by, and reported openly by, homeopaths.

Further, as has been pointed out in this thread, as one of the selling points of homeopathy is the individualization of treatments, the mere fact that homeopaths push non-individualized treatments weighs heavily against the field.
 
Wow

I sat out of this thread for several hundred posts, and it is good to see that no progress has been made in improving Rodney's arguements or getting him to accept reason. It looks just like it did several hundred posts ago.
 
As no medicine prepared using homeopathic methods has ever been shown to be efficacious . . .
With the teensy, weensy exception of the 1991 British Medical Journal meta-analysis of 25 years of clinical studies, which showed that, of 107 controlled trials of homeopathic medicines, 81 showed an effect above placebo, including in 11 of the 15 best trials.
 
With the teensy, weensy exception of the 1991 British Medical Journal meta-analysis of 25 years of clinical studies, which showed that, of 107 controlled trials of homeopathic medicines, 81 showed an effect above placebo, including in 11 of the 15 best trials.
With the two teensy, weensy exceptions of:

1. The flaws, as demonstrated on this thread.

2. Even if not flawed, they might show an effect above placebo but do not show an effect attributable to homeopathy.


The teensy weensy ignoring of arguments that is your trait has much more of show than substance, Rodney, but I expect you know that.

Keep repeating the same tripe hoping to sway new lurkers; we'll keep pointing out your errors.
 
With the teensy, weensy exception of the 1991 British Medical Journal meta-analysis of 25 years of clinical studies, which showed that, of 107 controlled trials of homeopathic medicines, 81 showed an effect above placebo, including in 11 of the 15 best trials.

You are mischaracterizing the information. As I explained to you in this post, all we can say is that there were significant differences between the treated and the untreated group. We can only say that the difference between the two groups must be due to the effect of homeopathy if there are no other reasons for the groups to be different. However, in all cases, including the 11 out of 15 of the "best" trials, there were significant methodologic errors, making it likely that the groups would be different due to bias. That means that the trials were not tests of homeopathy, they were tests of homeopathy and bias. And in subsequent metanalyses where they removed the effect of bias, there wasn't anything left over to attribute to homeopathy.

Linda
 
With the teensy, weensy exception of the 1991 British Medical Journal meta-analysis of 25 years of clinical studies...
Why the obsession with a 15 year old study that found that the evidence from the studies carried out by that point was not of good enough quality to conclude that homoeopathy works? Is that the best evidence for homoeopathy you can come up with?

Why do you consistently fail to quote the conclusion of the paper?
At the moment the evidence of clinical trials is positive but not sufficient to draw definitive conclusions because most trials are of low methodological quality and because of the unknown role of publication bias. This indicates that there is a legitimate case for further evaluation of homoeopathy, but only by means of well performed trials.

Would you care to comment on the more recent meta-analysis papers that have been cited here, or the more recent and well performed trials (called for by your 1991 paper, remember?) that fls linked to?
 
Last edited:
You are mischaracterizing the information. As I explained to you in this post, all we can say is that there were significant differences between the treated and the untreated group. We can only say that the difference between the two groups must be due to the effect of homeopathy if there are no other reasons for the groups to be different. However, in all cases, including the 11 out of 15 of the "best" trials, there were significant methodologic errors, making it likely that the groups would be different due to bias. That means that the trials were not tests of homeopathy, they were tests of homeopathy and bias. And in subsequent metanalyses where they removed the effect of bias, there wasn't anything left over to attribute to homeopathy.
Out of respect to Linda's spine, I will ask everyone to leave this post alone.

That means you, Moochie! :mad:
 
Out of respect to Linda's spine, I will ask everyone to leave this post alone.

That means you, Moochie! :mad:


I respect every one of Linda's posts, both here and elsewhere.

We are free agents here -- no one has to read or post if they don't want to, including you, BJ! :D

M.
 
Would you care to comment on the more recent meta-analysis papers that have been cited here, or the more recent and well performed trials (called for by your 1991 paper, remember?) that fls linked to?
I did so in post #656.
 
I did so in post #656.
You commented on a single meta analysis there (or rather quoted what a prominent homoeopath had to say about it) and cited another meta-analysis that had nothing more positive to say than the 1991 one.

How about the ones I linked to in post 660?

And how about the dozen more recent trials fls linked to in post 706? You asked for them, remember?
 
You commented on a single meta analysis there (or rather quoted what a prominent homoeopath had to say about it) and cited another meta-analysis that had nothing more positive to say than the 1991 one.

How about the ones I linked to in post 660?

And how about the dozen more recent trials fls linked to in post 706? You asked for them, remember?

I wasn't able to access all of the studies Linda linked to, but two of them were not completely negative to homeopathy. The first, an Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder study, concluded:

"There were no statistically significant differences between homeopathic remedy and placebo groups on the primary or secondary outcome variables. However, there were statistically and clinically significant improvements in both groups on many of the outcome measures.

"Conclusions: This pilot study provides no evidence to support a therapeutic effect of individually selected homeopathic remedies in children with ADHD. A therapeutic effect of the homeopathic encounter is suggested and warrants further evaluation. Future studies should be carried out over a longer period of time and should include a control group that does not receive the homeopathic consultation. Comparison to conventional stimulant medication for ADHD also should be considered."

The second, an asthma study, concluded:

"Conclusion: Homoeopathic immunotherapy is not effective in the treatment of patients with asthma. The different patterns of change between homoeopathic immunotherapy and placebo over the course of the study are unexplained.

"What is already known on this topic:
Homoeopathic remedies probably have an effect that is greater than placebo.
Some of the better quality homoeopathic studies involve homoeopathic doses of allergens used to treat allergic disease.

"What this study adds:
In this study homoeopathic remedies were no better than placebo in the treatment of asthmatic patients who are allergic to house dust mite."

I'm all in favor of more studies and would be pleased if the next major study tested OTC cough medicines -- both homeopathic and non-homeopathic -- against placebos.
 
I wasn't able to access all of the studies Linda linked to, but two of them were not completely negative to homeopathy. The first, an Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder study, concluded:

"There were no statistically significant differences between homeopathic remedy and placebo groups on the primary or secondary outcome variables. However, there were statistically and clinically significant improvements in both groups on many of the outcome measures.

"Conclusions: This pilot study provides no evidence to support a therapeutic effect of individually selected homeopathic remedies in children with ADHD. A therapeutic effect of the homeopathic encounter is suggested and warrants further evaluation. Future studies should be carried out over a longer period of time and should include a control group that does not receive the homeopathic consultation. Comparison to conventional stimulant medication for ADHD also should be considered."

The study was negative. That the authors suggested further directions for study does not change that.

The second, an asthma study, concluded:

"Conclusion: Homoeopathic immunotherapy is not effective in the treatment of patients with asthma. The different patterns of change between homoeopathic immunotherapy and placebo over the course of the study are unexplained.

"What is already known on this topic:
Homoeopathic remedies probably have an effect that is greater than placebo.
Some of the better quality homoeopathic studies involve homoeopathic doses of allergens used to treat allergic disease.

"What this study adds:
In this study homoeopathic remedies were no better than placebo in the treatment of asthmatic patients who are allergic to house dust mite."

Even though this study mentions homeopathy, I shouldn't have included it as it is a test of Isopathy, which can work by conventional mechanisms depending upon the degree of dilution.

It was still negative, though.

Just because you can find authors that make concillatory statements in their conclusions, it doesn't change the actual results.

I'm all in favor of more studies and would be pleased if the next major study tested OTC cough medicines -- both homeopathic and non-homeopathic -- against placebos.

Really? When all indications are that it would be a colossal waste of time?

Linda
 
fls said:
Just because you can find authors that make concillatory statements in their conclusions, it doesn't change the actual results.

Rodney said:
I'm all in favor of more studies and would be pleased if the next major study tested OTC cough medicines -- both homeopathic and non-homeopathic -- against placebos.
Really? When all indications are that it would be a colossal waste of time?

Linda
Undoubtedly. These people have an insatiable apatite for research money. It seems there is a final form to fill-out at the conclusion for all studies funded by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. It is pre-printed at the bottom with "These studies, though negative, are inconclusive- more research is needed."
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom