Homeopathic Cough Medicine

It practices mnemonics? :) But seriously folks, the point you are missing is that, many times in history, the scientific establishment has not been able to account for something with current theory and has thus dismissed it as impossible. Eventually, though, when the evidence becomes irrefutable, the establishment is forced to concede that its theory was inadequate. Will that happen with homeopathy? Stay tuned.

Yes, and dear Sylvia will be proven to have genuine psychic powers. She had them all along, only we didn't know how to recognize them.

Yada yada yada...

M.
 
Been done. You would need to show some way to differentiate homeopathic treatment from a placebo in terms of chemistry.
Why? If a homeopathic treatment works better than a placebo to a high level of statistical certainty, the fact that chemists can't explain it means that our present knowledge of chemistry is deficient.
If you can reliably differentiate a homoeopathic remedy of higher potency than 12C/24X (that being the point at which our present knowledge of chemistry says there will be nothing left) from a placebo by any means, you can win a million Dollars.
 
That's her old man. :)
M.
A comparison between Cayce and Brown is like comparing day and night. Cayce went into a trance, Brown does not; Cayce's readings were carefully documented, Brown's are not (although Mr. Lancaster is doing his best to change that ;)); Cayce had a number of unambiguous successes, Brown does not; Cayce had a reputation as a humble person; Brown does not, etc.
 
Rodney, if you were given two bottles marked "homeopathic cough medicine", one of which contained homoeopathic cough medicine and the other of which contained all the ingredients of the homoeopathic medicine apart from those which arre present in homoeopathic potencies, do you think you could tell which was which?
 
Cayce had a number of unambiguous successes,
Which is more evidence that Rodney is targeting lurkers and not the regular posters here.

The "unambiguous successes" are highly ambiguous, as has been repeatededly demonstrated, on this forum, to Rodney. He pretends it didn't happen.

I'm not trying to derail this into a thread about Cayce, though. Just pointing out the tactics because he is doing the same thing with homeopathy.

In all this time, in a thread about homeopathic cough medicine, Rodney has answered zero questions relevant to the claims of homeopathic practicioners, has walked round and round the definitive explanations of people like fls, and keeps the focus everywhere but on the vacuity of homeopathy.
 
Rodney, if you were given two bottles marked "homeopathic cough medicine", one of which contained homoeopathic cough medicine and the other of which contained all the ingredients of the homoeopathic medicine apart from those which arre present in homoeopathic potencies, do you think you could tell which was which?
Oh, and if so, how?
 
Rodney, if you were given two bottles marked "homeopathic cough medicine", one of which contained homoeopathic cough medicine and the other of which contained all the ingredients of the homoeopathic medicine apart from those which arre present in homoeopathic potencies, do you think you could tell which was which?
No, but that's irrelevant to this discussion. The relevant question is whether the "homeopathic cough medicine" works better than a placebo.
 
No, but that's irrelevant to this discussion. The relevant question is whether the "homeopathic cough medicine" works better than a placebo.
Please offer evidence that it does. Evidence that is up to the standard of the evidence for conventional medicine, as explained by fls, please.
 
A comparison between Cayce and Brown is like comparing day and night. Cayce went into a trance, Brown does not; Cayce's readings were carefully documented, Brown's are not (although Mr. Lancaster is doing his best to change that ;)); Cayce had a number of unambiguous successes, Brown does not; Cayce had a reputation as a humble person; Brown does not, etc.

And, of course, there's ample evidence Cayce went in into a trance, isn't there?

Please...

M.
 
Rodney, if you were given two bottles marked "homeopathic cough medicine", one of which contained homoeopathic cough medicine and the other of which contained all the ingredients of the homoeopathic medicine apart from those which arre present in homoeopathic potencies, do you think you could tell which was which?
No, but that's irrelevant to this discussion. The relevant question is whether the "homeopathic cough medicine" works better than a placebo.
If homoeopathic cough medicine worked better than a placebo, it would be possible to tell them apart.

Can you provide any evidence that any homoeopathic cough medicine works better than a placebo?
 
I've had trouble getting and staying online all night and a reply I posted got lost in system somewhere. I don't even know it this one will get through, but it's late and I must be brief.

I am surprised at my old friend Exarch pitching darts.
I think he needs a double dose of cough mixture
...make that triple... or maybe quadru....

Linda, I don't get it.

Sorry to be sniping at you like that Billy, but here's why:

It depends on what kind of answers you're looking for.
If what you're looking for is proof that cough medicines work then, yes, tests have shown the ingredients in cough mixtures are effective in relieving cold symptoms like cough, congestion, etc...
If you're looking for a way to avoid malpractice lawsuits then, no, the effectiveness of cough medicine ingredients is not sufficient to take the risk, especially with children.

So why am I dismissing your comments this easily? Because they're giving Rodney an illigitimate excuse to ask questions again which we've already answered. He wanted medical trials showing the effectiveness of cough medicine, we've shown them. You show up with recommendations from reputable sources, and he considers that a free pass for homeopathy with its severe lack of any good evidence whatsoever.

It's not that you don't raise valid points, it's that we finally want to move the discussion onwards to homeopathy, and you've just set us back 6 pages :(
 
Last edited:
Which is more evidence that Rodney is targeting lurkers and not the regular posters here.

The "unambiguous successes" are highly ambiguous, as has been repeatededly demonstrated, on this forum, to Rodney. He pretends it didn't happen.

I'm not trying to derail this into a thread about Cayce, though. Just pointing out the tactics because he is doing the same thing with homeopathy.

In all this time, in a thread about homeopathic cough medicine, Rodney has answered zero questions relevant to the claims of homeopathic practicioners, has walked round and round the definitive explanations of people like fls, and keeps the focus everywhere but on the vacuity of homeopathy.

I think most sensible people have Rodney's measure by now. He betrays his apparent naivete again and again.

M.
 
No, but that's irrelevant to this discussion. The relevant question is whether the "homeopathic cough medicine" works better than a placebo.

Actually, if you go back to post #1, you'll see that I was making the point that quackery (such as homeopathy) was gaining credence because such products were being placed alongside other (perhaps more legitimate) products on pharmacy and health-food store shelves.

If you would care to read my post (#370) you would see that pharmacists in Australia have recently won a "prestigious" award for putting commerce ahead of ethics.

M.
 
Why? If a homeopathic treatment works better than a placebo to a high level of statistical certainty, the fact that chemists can't explain it means that our present knowledge of chemistry is deficient. Right, Linda? ;)

Yes, you're absolutely right.

The only problem is that all the serious trials done in this way show that homeopathy performs no better than placebo (and most scientists will probably agree that this result is to be expected when giving one group plain water/sugar and the other ... plain water/sugar ;))
 
No, but that's irrelevant to this discussion. The relevant question is whether the "homeopathic cough medicine" works better than a placebo.

And if you can't tell which one you have, doesn't that tell you something(well probably not, but it really should tell you something)
 
Getting a lollipop from the doctor afterwards might have a positive influence. Getting a pat on the back or a friendly smile too. But technically those last two aren't considered "placebo" according to the dictionary definition:

I meant an example of something the sCAM people drag in.

Since the dictionary definition focuses on "substances". The problem being that the placebo effect usually refers to more than just substances, as is obvious from looking at CAM (complementary and alternative medicine).

To get back to the drug trial: the placebo control side is subject to placebo effect + various other effects not included in placebo.
The remedy side includes the same placebo effect + various other side effects, but also the remedy's effect.

I think I see what you're getting at. The placebo effect is really only the psychological effect, but practically it isn't considered separately from the effects of special treatment, bias and time. And the psychological effect can apply equally as well to "attention and sympathy" as to a pill. When we are imprecise and focus on a substance, it means that we include effects under the label "placebo" that already have another name (e.g. regression) or we exclude effects with the same mechanism but a different trigger (e.g. friendly doctor).
(ETA: This is meant to make sure I understand what you're getting at.)

I never said an RDBPC was biased, I just said that not every "placebo" effect can be known, or even needs to be, in order to have an unbiased RDBPC. That's why I said it doesn't matter there.

I wasn't disagreeing with you. The details of the effects don't matter if the treatment is the same for both groups (i.e. controlled). I just wanted differentiate between bias (differences between groups) and effect (the change within a group).

But since there's no "control" in homeopathy, it's important to make people understand that there's far more to "placebo" effect than just the substance, and they're correct that the mere taking of the substance can't account for all the apparent improvement they're experiencing or noticing when taking their sCAM treatment. And this is a defense you'll often hear them make: "Are you saying that we're all crazy people who are getting better because we think we're getting better after taking medication?" Short answer: "Yes", but you can't say that because they'll just dismiss that. It's the long answer that's important, and that means having more to say than "placebo" ...

Okay, I agree. So the solution seems to be to move towards an inclusive definition of placebo that includes any contribution (not just substances) such as the one I suggested earlier - "any changes in subjective or objective outcomes during a course of treatment that are not due to the specific physiologic effects of the treatment" (you didn't comment on it before - yes? no? maybe?). Or to refer to only the psychological effects as the placebo effect. I think the former is already a shift that is happening by convention.

And just to elaborate on the "having more to say than 'placebo'"....regardless of which path you take, I think the key is talking about all the non-psychological effects specifically. Because the woos take "placebo" as though you are saying "it is all in your head", which is unbelievable. I think a description of regression and the take-home message of Bayes' Theorem (what do you expect to happen in the absence of treatment) would help explain how real changes aren't necessarily due to treatment.

Linda
 
Last edited:
That's because I am not looking for evidence. I am looking for practical advice form experts who deal with patients with respiratory infection about the use of cough mixtures.

Well, we're not. We were answering Rodney's query on whether or not cough medicines show effects above placebo. They do.
They may still not do a whole lot, but they do something, and that's what he assumed we wouldn't be able to say, based on a few not too accurate newspaper articles he read (just like you). This was also his whole defense for his argument to keep homeopathy on sale, since if "regular" medicine doesn't have good evidence supporting it, then why should homeopathy? We showed him that kite doesn't fly because regular medicine DOES have good evidence supporting its efficacy, while homeopathy still doesn't have any.

In the mean time, we're still waiting for Rodney to pick up where he left off, discussing homeopathy and putting cough medicine aside for now.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom