Homeopathic Cough Medicine

I meant an example of something the sCAM people drag in.

Sorry, I didn't understand what you were asking me.
I think the biggest problem is not the sCAM people dragging in things that we consider placebo effect, but rather the other way around, not realizing some things to have a placebo effect, and attributing the effect to the treatment they got/took.

Okay, I agree. So the solution seems to be to move towards an inclusive definition of placebo that includes any contribution (not just substances) such as the one I suggested earlier - "any changes in subjective or objective outcomes during a course of treatment that are not due to the specific physiologic effects of the treatment" (you didn't comment on it before - yes? no? maybe?). Or to refer to only the psychological effects as the placebo effect. I think the former is already a shift that is happening by convention.

Yes, I think your definition is definitely a step up.
The problem as I see it, is that "placebo" is a rather narrowly defined term (mostly referring to "inert substances" as people know it best, and sometimes also understood to mean "any non-effective actions" too). The "placebo effect" as used in conversation is a much more encompassing concept, which illogically enough, also seems to include some things that are not the effect of placebo :cool:

And just to elaborate on the "having more to say than 'placebo'"....regardless of which path you take, I think the key is talking about all the non-psychological effects specifically. Because the woos take "placebo" as though you are saying "it is all in your head", which is unbelievable. I think a description of regression and the take-home message of Bayes' Theorem (what do you expect to happen in the absence of treatment) would help explain how real changes aren't necessarily due to treatment.

Of course. But the short and easiest answer skeptics sometimes resort to is often to say that "it's only placebo", which is only half the story.
 
Yes, you're absolutely right.
I'm glad we agree on that -- most of the folks here don't seem to.

The only problem is that all the serious trials done in this way show that homeopathy performs no better than placebo (and most scientists will probably agree that this result is to be expected when giving one group plain water/sugar and the other ... plain water/sugar ;))
So none of the 81 (of 107) homeopathic trials discussed in the 1991 British Medical Journal article were "serious"?
 
But the short and easiest answer skeptics sometimes resort to is often to say that "it's only placebo", which is only half the story.

So your solution is to jump on skeptics so they stop doing that?

It might work. <grin>

Linda
 
I'm glad we agree on that -- most of the folks here don't seem to.

Oh no. You're wrong on that. Everyone will accept homeopathy if it's ever proven to be more than just wishful thinking. Most people just don't bother to make that particular distinction (there's no point really) and jump right ahead to the part where we ask you to provide proof for your assertion that homeopathy works.

So that's where we are now Rodney.
Answer this question please:
Why are you willing to dismiss the efficacy of cough medicine with as little proof as a couple of not all too accurate news paper articles, and in the face of good scientific evidence that they truly work better than placebo, while at the same time giving homeopathy a free pass, not requiring any proof at all to accept it works, and insisting it does when science and common sense says it can't work, and research confirms this?
 
Oh no. You're wrong on that. Everyone will accept homeopathy if it's ever proven to be more than just wishful thinking.
The history of science says otherwise.

Most people just don't bother to make that particular distinction (there's no point really) and jump right ahead to the part where we ask you to provide proof for your assertion that homeopathy works.
And where, exactly, did I assert that?

So that's where we are now Rodney.
Answer this question please:
Why are you willing to dismiss the efficacy of cough medicine with as little proof as a couple of not all too accurate news paper articles, and in the face of good scientific evidence that they truly work better than placebo, while at the same time giving homeopathy a free pass, not requiring any proof at all to accept it works, and insisting it does when science and common sense says it can't work, and research confirms this?
The "good scientific evidence" about OTC cough medicines does not seem to have convinced a lot of medical doctors, and I'm hardly giving homeopathy a free pass. I just don't see that it's been discredited.
 
Yes, but being told that and systematically discrediting the 81 positive trials are two very different things.

If I did it here, would you promise to stop supporting homeopathy?

Linda
 
Still having problem getting online

That information referred to the use of cough mixtures in children. I already explained that it means something like "since cough medicine does not influence the underlying cause and has a relatively high risk-benefit ratio in children, and we wish to be cautious in our recommendations, we recommed that cough mixtures not be used in children".
Fair enough, I can go with that.

ETA: The authors intend for the take-away message to be "don't bother with cough medicine in children". What I put in quotations in the previous paragraph is meant to be a summary of my explanation as to why the recommendations appear to be different from the evidence (or why statements like "no evidence for" get applied). It isn't meant to be an indication of what you are supposed to read into the simple statement of "cough mixtures play no role in the treatment of coughs".
Well, okay, it is becoming clearer to me where you are coming from. But, can I ask you whether, on the basis of the metanalysis, you agree with that bolded statement as a piece of good practical advice to parents.

You have not provided any evidence to counteract my demonstration by simply repeating the same one line summaries from different sources.
That's because I am not looking for evidence. I am looking for practical advice from experts, who actually manage patients with respiratory infection, about the use of cough mixtures.

Plus I provided a link to the complete summary of recommendations for the use of cough medicines in adults for all the different causes of cough made by the ACCP.
I missed that one. I will try to find it.

I prefer accuracy to simplification and the loss of accuracy. That this is my preference doesn't seem like an adequate justification for your derision.
Sorry, Linda, that was not intended. I really do appreciate your contribution to this thread. It was meant as a bit of levity in the face of my frustration with my internet connection continually breaking down.

Your understanding of lower RTI is incorrect. I am not going to provide a detailed explanation of LRTI as I think it has been amply demonstrated that this will not be productive.
All I am saying is that it is difficult to reliably distinguish an upper from lower RTI, meaning that you could be using that cough mixture on what you believe to be a upper RTI on a lower RTI. It was based on the following excerpt from that link:

"LRTI can be difficult to distinguish from upper respiratory tract infection"
"The distinction between cough due to an upper RTI and cough due to bronchitis (lower RTI) is not important, as both conditions are self limiting viral conditions"

regards,
BillyJoe
 
Well, okay, it is becoming clearer to me where you are coming from. But, can I ask you whether, on the basis of the metanalysis, you agree with that bolded statement as a piece of good practical advice to parents.

don't bother with cough medicine in children

What metanalysis?

It is not the advice that I would give, but I would agree that it is a piece of good practical advice to parents.

Linda
 
If I did it here, would you promise to stop supporting homeopathy?
Linda
I don't agree that I am "supporting" homeopathy -- I'm just not trashing it the way almost everyone else here is. But if you can discredit all of the trials finding that homeopathic treatments performed above placebo, I would certainly reevaluate my current neutral position on homeopathy.
 
I don't agree that I am "supporting" homeopathy -- I'm just not trashing it the way almost everyone else here is. But if you can discredit all of the trials finding that homeopathic treatments performed above placebo, I would certainly reevaluate my current neutral position on homeopathy.
We aren't trashing it because we are skeptics. We are trashing it because it's...well, trash!
 
What metanalysis?
The meta-analysis involved in collating all the trials that have been done, evaluating them and tehn coming to a conclusion about what they tell us about the effectiveness of cough mixtures. In other words, the thing you've been reporting on.

It is not the advice that I would give, but I would agree that it is a piece of good practical advice to parents.
And your advice to parents would be what?

BJ
 
The meta-analysis involved in collating all the trials that have been done, evaluating them and tehn coming to a conclusion about what they tell us about the effectiveness of cough mixtures. In other words, the thing you've been reporting on.

Ah. That would more properly be called a review. It's only a metanalysis if you are combining the data from several trials for a statistical analysis.

And your advice to parents would be what?

BJ

Hot rum toddies.

Linda
 
I don't agree that I am "supporting" homeopathy -- I'm just not trashing it the way almost everyone else here is. But if you can discredit all of the trials finding that homeopathic treatments performed above placebo, I would certainly reevaluate my current neutral position on homeopathy.

There are 437 posts in this thread as a result of you not supporting homeopathy?

Credulous is not the same as neutral.

We can calculate the positive-predictive value (the probability that a positive result is a true positive) using the model in this paper. Before we look at the trials, what level of positive-predictive value would you accept as reasonable support for your current position and what level would you consider so low that you would re-evaluate your current position on homeopathy?

Linda
 
Yes, but being told that and systematically discrediting the 81 positive trials are two very different things.
The meta-analysis you cited already discredited most of them: of the 81 positive trials, it found that most were flawed. In any case, the authors of that paper did not conclude that homoeopathy is effective.

The authors concluded: "At the moment the evidence of clinical trials is positive but not sufficient to draw definitive conclusions because most trials are of low methodological quality and because of the unknown role of publication bias. This indicates that there is a legitimate case for further evaluation of homoeopathy, but only by means of well performed trials." They did not find homoeopathy to be effective; they said, basically, that more good quality research was needed.

That was 15 years ago. More recent meta-analyses have not found homoeopathy to be effective; see, for example, the 2005 Lancet paper, or the 2002 systematic review of systematic reviews of homeopathy by Professor Edzard Ernst of the Department of Complementary Medicine at the University of Exeter, which concluded that "there was no condition which responds convincingly better to homeopathic treatment than to placebo or other control interventions. Similarly, there was no homeopathic remedy that was demonstrated to yield clinical effects that are convincingly different from placebo. It is concluded that the best clinical evidence for homeopathy available to date does not warrant positive recommendations for its use in clinical practice". No progress for homoeopathy in 15 years (hardly surprising in view of the fact that it hasn't made any progress in the last 200, I suppose).

You are basing your argument for homoeopathy on a 15 year old paper that did not actually conclude that it is effective. Can you find a more recent meta-analysis that shows that the further research that the authors of the 1991 paper said was necessary has actually been carried out, and has found homoeopathy to be effective?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom