Homeopathic Cough Medicine

So, Exarch's fundamental claim that "homeopathic cough medicines don't work" is supported by at least one study? Please supply a link to that study.

Why do you suggest a non-scientific or non-skeptical approach?

Linda
 
True, you would end up saying that. But you would also say that the remedy treatment includes the remedy plus other effects (including placebo).

The way that we figure out the treatment effect is by removing the effect seen with placebo. If you state it that way, you are placing the "other effects" into the treatment effect (i.e. you can't separate them quantitatively) and so I'm not sure what you are referring to as "other effects". You mentioned the effect of a friendly doctor, earlier. Usually that would be captured under the placebo effect (assuming the placebo treatment is equivalent to the active treatment (except for the drug) and both include a friendly doctor). If you are suggesting that the treatments are not equivalent (i.e. one includes a friendly doctor and one doesn't), then that would be considered bias.

These effect don't play a significant role in drug trails, other than needing to be controlled for. You don't need to quantify them for example. But they play a major role in alternative medicine. The problem is, the CAM-people start to weasel out when you simply dismiss it all as "placebo" (even though it is all psychology in action). They start dragging in things that you might consider to be included under the all encompassing working interpretation of "placebo", but which don't fit the dictionary definition of the term.

Can you give an example?

Either we need to redefine "placebo", or we need to find a new word for the large umbrella-definition of "any apparent healing effects that show up during treatment that are not due to the medication".

I use something like "any changes in subjective or objective outcomes during a course of treatment that are not due to the specific physiologic effects of the treatment".

I wouldn't emphasis "apparent healing effects". It gives the impression that healing took place because a placebo was given, when in reality we just happened to keep track of the healing that was going to happen anyway.

Linda
 
Either we need to redefine "placebo", or we need to find a new word for the large umbrella-definition of "any apparent healing effects that show up during treatment that are not due to the medication".

We call it placebo. In a trial there are two things that affect the results - the treatment and placebo. The first is an actual physiological effect, while the term "placebo" covers everything that causes the patient to appear improved, to themselves or to other people, that does not have an actual physical cause. Your statement that
These effect don't play a significant role in drug trails, other than needing to be controlled for.
simply makes no sense. If they didn't play a significant role they wouldn't need to be controlled for. The fact is, if someone is given a sugar pill and feels better, that is placebo. If someone buys a sugar pill themselves with no-one else involved and feels better, that is placebo. If someone talks to a doctor and feels better even though not given any treatment, that is placebo. Anything that makes the patient feel better without actually having a physical effect is placebo. This is why we have placebo controlled trials. One group is given active treatment, the other is treated identically in all respects except the drug is not active. Any improvement that occurs in both groups is due to placebo and can be ignored. Of course, there are a few other effects such as spontaneous recovery and regression to the mean, but these are not relevant to this discussion.
 
I've had trouble getting and staying online all night and a reply I posted got lost in system somewhere. I don't even know it this one will get through, but it's late and I must be brief.

I am surprised at my old friend Exarch pitching darts.
I think he needs a double dose of cough mixture
...make that triple... or maybe quadru....

Linda, I don't get it.

I know you have presented the metanalysis the trials involving cough mixtures. I am not impressed by what they tell us, but I am no expert in this field as you seem to be. I am more interested in the practical application of this knowledge. If I can't trust the RCH website, whp can I trust to supply this information? This is what they say:

It's on the last page and I am too frightened to click back in case I lose you. Anyway something like:

Cough mixtures play no role in the treatment of coughs

A straight forward, succinct answer I would have thought but, no, they mean something else entirely. Goddamn! They don't mean forget about the cough mixture, they mean cough mixtures don't fight the virus, but they relieve symptoms so go ahead and use it. Stupid me!
And WE are talking about cough mixtures for adults anyway.
So here is one about adult respiratory infection:

There is no role for cough mixtures.

Or something like that because I can't be bothered clicking waiting and hoping. But no. This is about LOWER respiratory tract infection. Well excuse me! Perhaps one of you can tell me the last time one of you clearly suffered from an upper as opposed to a lower respiratory tract infection. What criteria did you use to reach this decision. And where you careful to use cough mixtures in the upper RTIs only.
Give me a break.

Most Lower RTI are treated in the community. Most do not even see a doctor. Doctors have great difficulty distinguishing one from the other most of the time (except those that clearly need hospitalisation). This is form the link and from memory because the internet is against me as well.

Okay I'll try posting.
It is bedtime and I'm not checking for errors so, if you find some, stick it up your nose exarch.....my OLD friend.

:D

BillyJoe
 
Last edited:
BillyJoe, I'm a little confused by your arguments. The quotes you have posted very much support what Linda has been saying.

However, some cough medicines may make children feel a bit sleepy, and help them have a more settled night’s sleep.

Over-the-counter cold medications. Nonprescription decongestants and pain relievers offer some symptom relief, but they won't prevent a cold or shorten its duration,

But the American College of Chest Physicians strongly discourages the use of these medications because they're not effective at treating the underlying cause of cough due to colds. Some contain ingredients that may alleviate coughing, but the amounts are too small to do much good and may actually be harmful for children. In fact, the college has strongly recommended against using OTC cough syrups or cold medicines for any child younger than 14.

(bolding mine)

The first quote says that cough medicine doesn't do anything, but then goes on to say that it helps children sleep. Since lack of sleep can be seen as one of the symptoms of a cough, obviously this is doing something, and no-one can argue that ensuring an ill child gets enough sleep is a bad thing. The second quote simply says that cough medicine doesn't cure anything but relieves symptoms, which is the whole point. The third one says that they don't do enough to be worth the risk in young children.

So basically, cough medicine helps relieve symptoms but does not actually cure colds, and some may not be safe for children. Exactly as Linda has said.
 
I know you have presented the metanalysis the trials involving cough mixtures. I am not impressed by what they tell us, but I am no expert in this field as you seem to be. I am more interested in the practical application of this knowledge. If I can't trust the RCH website, whp can I trust to supply this information? This is what they say:

It's on the last page and I am too frightened to click back in case I lose you. Anyway something like:

Cough mixtures play no role in the treatment of coughs

A straight forward, succinct answer I would have thought but, no, they mean something else entirely. Goddamn! They don't mean forget about the cough mixture, they mean cough mixtures don't fight the virus, but they relieve symptoms so go ahead and use it. Stupid me!

To start with, as has been pointed out, they are talking about children, who are very different from adults. However, I would agree with you that they appeared to be talking about any use for cough mixture, not just actual treatment. This does not alter the fact that all they are saying is that they don't recommend use of cough mixture in young children because the risk outweighs the benefit. They do not say there is no effect, they say that it is not big enough compared to the potential side effects in children. This is a thread about whether cough mixture has any effect at all, not a risk-benefit analysis.

And WE are talking about cough mixtures for adults anyway.
So here is one about adult respiratory infection:

There is no role for cough mixtures.

Or something like that because I can't be bothered clicking waiting and hoping. But no. This is about LOWER respiratory tract infection. Well excuse me! Perhaps one of you can tell me the last time one of you clearly suffered from an upper as opposed to a lower respiratory tract infection. What criteria did you use to reach this decision. And where you careful to use cough mixtures in the upper RTIs only.
Give me a break.

I don't know where you got all this from. Virtually all coughs are upper respiratory tract infections. An infection of the lower respiratory tract is usually extremely serious, the most common being pneumonia and bronchitis. If you have one of these, the effectiveness of cough medicine is the least of your worries. Unsurprisingly, cough medicine does not help a problem in your lungs, so why do you think this is in any way related to the effectiveness of cough medicine for common colds?

To answer your other question, the last time I had an upper RTI was last week, the last time I had a lower RTI was never, and the same is true for most people (execpt the last week bit). I would also say that Linda has given very detailed information and you clearly know very little about this area, so your attitude is rather uncalled for.
 
fls said:
What makes you think they haven't already been asked and answered numerous times?
I'm certain they have, but not on this thread. It is a shame that the same arguments must be rehashed and rehashed, but they must. And the new lurkers out there are not aware of past arguments. This is what folks like Rodney count on. He, T'ai Chi, and some others who post regularly here really do not have the active skeptics on this board as their audience. They are targeting the lurkers with less experience and less information. It doesn't matter if you are right, fls. If Rodney can make it appear that there are issues you haven't addressed and holes in your position, then he wins, and he knows it. Regardless of fact.

And while I am aware of this, I am also aware that I am neither expert enough nor articulate enough to adequately express those things that an uninformed lurker might find persuasive. You, exarch, and some others here are. So I asked the questions.

I say this as a long-time former believer. Not in homeopathy, but in lots of other things lacking evidence. So I have a fair amount of experience in how at least some believers think and how they might view arguments.

So, to you, Exarch, and Zep: Thanks for the responses to my bit of devil's advocacy. I think it helped.
 
So, Exarch's fundamental claim that "homeopathic cough medicines don't work" is supported by at least one study? Please supply a link to that study.

Wrong, the general claim is that "Homeopathy can't work"

Why do you assume function on homeopathy but what evidence that real medicine is safe and effective?
 
Linda, I don't get it.

I know you have presented the metanalysis the trials involving cough mixtures. I am not impressed by what they tell us, but I am no expert in this field as you seem to be. I am more interested in the practical application of this knowledge. If I can't trust the RCH website, whp can I trust to supply this information? This is what they say:

It's on the last page and I am too frightened to click back in case I lose you. Anyway something like:

Cough mixtures play no role in the treatment of coughs

A straight forward, succinct answer I would have thought but, no, they mean something else entirely. Goddamn! They don't mean forget about the cough mixture, they mean cough mixtures don't fight the virus, but they relieve symptoms so go ahead and use it. Stupid me!

That information referred to the use of cough mixtures in children. I already explained that it means something like "since cough medicine does not influence the underlying cause and has a relatively high risk-benefit ratio in children, and we wish to be cautious in our recommendations, we recommed that cough mixtures not be used in children".

ETA: The authors intend for the take-away message to be "don't bother with cough medicine in children". What I put in quotations in the previous paragraph is meant to be a summary of my explanation as to why the recommendations appear to be different from the evidence (or why statements like "no evidence for" get applied). It isn't meant to be an indication of what you are supposed to read into the simple statement of "cough mixtures play no role in the treatment of coughs".

And WE are talking about cough mixtures for adults anyway.
So here is one about adult respiratory infection:

There is no role for cough mixtures.

Or something like that because I can't be bothered clicking waiting and hoping. But no. This is about LOWER respiratory tract infection. Well excuse me! Perhaps one of you can tell me the last time one of you clearly suffered from an upper as opposed to a lower respiratory tract infection. What criteria did you use to reach this decision. And where you careful to use cough mixtures in the upper RTIs only.
Give me a break.

It is not my fault that the information and recommendations with respect to a heterogeneous group of medications for a hetergeneous group of conditions in a heterogeneous group of people cannot be summarized accurately with a single sentence.

You continue to insist that it can be by providing examples of one line summaries. I have demonstrated that those summaries are incorrect if applied to cough medicines generally. You have not provided any evidence to counteract my demonstration by simply repeating the same one line summaries from different sources. I have provided multiple links that demonstrate that certain cough medicines are effective in certain situations, which includes the indications for which the bulk of OTC cough medicine is used (excluding children). Plus I provided a link to the complete summary of recommendations for the use of cough medicines in adults for all the different causes of cough made by the ACCP.

I prefer accuracy to simplification and the loss of accuracy. That this is my preference doesn't seem like an adequate justification for your derision.

Most Lower RTI are treated in the community. Most do not even see a doctor. Doctors have great difficulty distinguishing one from the other most of the time (except those that clearly need hospitalisation). This is form the link and from memory because the internet is against me as well.

Your understanding of lower RTI is incorrect. I am not going to provide a detailed explanation of LRTI as I think it has been amply demonstrated that this will not be productive.

Linda
 
Last edited:
'The Bent Spoon Award is "presented to the perpetrator of the most preposterous piece of paranormal or pseudoscientific piffle" and this year went collectively to the retail pharmacists of Australia for their practice of overcoming both their professional training and cognitive dissonance to sell homeopathy and other nonsense alongside real medicine.'

http://www.ratbags.com/rsoles/

Couldn't happen to a finer bunch of ning-nongs :)

M.
 
Why do you suggest a non-scientific or non-skeptical approach?
Linda
It's non-scientific or non-skeptical to ask someone here to cite a study demonstrating the non-efficacy of a homeopathic cough medicine?
 
It's non-scientific or non-skeptical to ask someone here to cite a study demonstrating the non-efficacy of a homeopathic cough medicine?

Yes. The scientific approach is to first look for a demonstration of the presence of something. The skeptical approach is to doubt the presence of something until evidence is offered.

Linda
 
Wrong, the general claim is that "Homeopathy can't work"
In post # 345 of this thread, Exarch wrote: "Us: homeopathic cough medicines don't work."

Why do you assume function on homeopathy but what evidence that real medicine is safe and effective?
I'm not assuming anything about homeopathy; I've simply noted that the evidence regarding its efficacy is mixed. I take the same approach with respect to "real [OTC cough] medicine", but, as BillyJoe notes, it's difficult to find ringing endorsements for its use.
 
I'm not assuming anything about homeopathy; I've simply noted that the evidence regarding its efficacy is mixed.

You've stated your opinion that evidence regarding the efficacy of homeopathy is mixed.

M.
 
Last edited:
Yes. The scientific approach is to first look for a demonstration of the presence of something. The skeptical approach is to doubt the presence of something until evidence is offered.
Linda
But since millions of people worldwide use homeopathic medicines and since at least one homeopathic OTC cough medicine apparently exists (I say "apparently" because it would need to be tested to make sure it is, in fact, homeopathic), don't you think it would be desirable to have a controlled study of homeopathic vs. non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines?
 
But since millions of people worldwide use homeopathic medicines and since at least one homeopathic OTC cough medicine apparently exists (I say "apparently" because it would need to be tested to make sure it is, in fact, homeopathic), don't you think it would be desirable to have a controlled study of homeopathic vs. non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines?
We already have some controlled trials of non-homoeopathic OTC cough medicines referenced in this thread. How about a controlled trial of a homoeopathic one?
 
Rodney, it's about time you answered a question:

Explain for us, if you can, the homeopathic principle of how water has a "memory."

The question is germane because the homeopathic principle of water having a "memory" is one of the most obvious quack notions in homeopathy -- a debunked quackery which you have chosen to defend.

M.
 
Last edited:
I'm not assuming anything about homeopathy; I've simply noted that the evidence regarding its efficacy is mixed.

You tried that argument already and it was pointed out to you that the evidence is not mixed. By the rules of engagement, you are not allowed to re-use this argument unless you make an attempt to refute the response.

I take the same approach with respect to "real [OTC cough] medicine", but, as BillyJoe notes, it's difficult to find ringing endorsements for its use.

You tried that argument already and it was pointed out to you that the comparison is not valid. By the rules of engagement, you are not allowed to re-use this argument unless you make an attempt to refute the response.

<grin>

What you have established is that you don't think it's necessary to be skeptical or scientific in your approach to homeopathy. What you have not established is why that would be a reasonable approach.

Linda
 
Failing that, Rodney, would you care to venture an opinion on whether the notion of water having a memory is quackery?

M.
 
But since millions of people worldwide use homeopathic medicines and since at least one homeopathic OTC cough medicine apparently exists (I say "apparently" because it would need to be tested to make sure it is, in fact, homeopathic), don't you think it would be desirable to have a controlled study of homeopathic vs. non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines?

As long as it isn't my time and money, sure. And until that study is done, the evidence shows that it can be assumed to be ineffective.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom