Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Incidentally, Rodney, the medicines licensing regime in the UK provides some powerful circumstantial evidence.

In 1971 the Medicines Act 1968 was implemented. One of its provisions was that no new medicinal product could be licensed for sale unless efficacy was demonstrated. Between 1971 and 1992, according to the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (the government agency responsible for enforcing the law relating to medicines in the UK), "attempts to acquire marketing authorisations for new homoeopathic medicines were unsuccessful owing to difficulties in proving efficacy in conventional clinical trials." Therefore, in 1992 a new scheme was introduced whereby homoeopathic medicines could be registered without having to prove efficacy.

So we have a period of over 20 years during which the manufacturers of homoeopathic medicines had an extremely powerful incentive to demonstrate the efficacy of their products, during which it appears that they completely failed to do so. Do you think this tells us anything about homoeopathic medicines?
 
The "good scientific evidence" about OTC cough medicines does not seem to have convinced a lot of medical doctors, and I'm hardly giving homeopathy a free pass. I just don't see that it's been discredited.

And where did you get this idea? As we have spent most of this thread pointing out, cough medicine has an effect. Whether it has enough of an effect to be worth the cost, both monetary and in side effects, is a different matter. Trying to claim that doctors are not convinced simply because they don't think the benefit outweighs the risk looks like willful ignorance in the face of everything you have been told here.

I don't agree that I am "supporting" homeopathy -- I'm just not trashing it the way almost everyone else here is. But if you can discredit all of the trials finding that homeopathic treatments performed above placebo, I would certainly reevaluate my current neutral position on homeopathy.

At the very best, we could say that the evidence for homeopathy is inconclusive and much more research is needed. You have argued that homeopathic remdies should be allowed to sold simply because of this. No other treatment can be sold without substantial evidence that it works. You are not neutral.
 
At the very best, we could say that the evidence for homeopathy is inconclusive and much more research is needed. You have argued that homeopathic remdies should be allowed to sold simply because of this. No other treatment can be sold without substantial evidence that it works.
This is not quite the case in the UK now. A recent change in the rules also allows herbal medicines to be sold, with indications as to what conditions they are purported to treat, without evidence of efficacy. See this MHRA press release.
 
This is not quite the case in the UK now. A recent change in the rules also allows herbal medicines to be sold, with indications as to what conditions they are purported to treat, without evidence of efficacy. See this MHRA press release.

True. I wonder if Rodney supports this as well?
 
Well I'm sure Kumar would, as they only seem to be asking for evidence that they are mass existing in well distributed people since long with least adversities of traditional usage and safety.
 
I don't agree that I am "supporting" homeopathy -- I'm just not trashing it the way almost everyone else here is. But if you can discredit all of the trials finding that homeopathic treatments performed above placebo, I would certainly reevaluate my current neutral position on homeopathy.

Also, I want to sure I understand what you are getting at here.

During this thread, we have mostly talked about the collective effect of the homeopathic studies - even though individual studies are testing individual treatments, the studies are united by the idea of homeopathy. If the studies are analyzed collectively (i.e. analyzed as though the thing being tested is "homeopathy" rather than "oscillococcimum, arnica, drosera rotundifolia, etc.") we see that the evidence for the idea of homeopathy has progressively become weaker until it has essentially disappeared.

Now you have shifted your attention to the studies of individual treatments. If the test of an individual homeopathic treatment is positive, that means that there is evidence of a true effect. And if there are numerous individual treatments that show evidence of a true effect, and the only idea that combines these effects into a unifying hypothesis is homeopathy, the positive individual trials suggest that there is evidence for homeopathy. Homeopathy serves as a way to explain an effect that otherwise would have no explanation.

Does that last paragraph serve as a reasonable summary of what you are thinking of?

Linda
 
I don't agree that I am "supporting" homeopathy -- I'm just not trashing it the way almost everyone else here is. But if you can discredit all of the trials finding that homeopathic treatments performed above placebo, I would certainly reevaluate my current neutral position on homeopathy.

Well Rodney, I'd say your stance on OTC cough medicines is more "neutral", and most people here would say that your reaction towards them is actually more similar to our reaction towards homeopathy. And OTC cough medicines have actually shown their efficacy in scientific random double blind placebo controlled drug trials.

Your reaction to homeopathy is not neutral, it's very credulous (as others have pointed out).

You're not actually saying it out loud, but you're basically using the "you're not being open-minded" defense, pretending that you are open-minded because you haven't dismissed homeopathy yet as the nonsense it is. Well, consider this: the evidence in favor of homeopathy is a lot worse than that in favor of OTC cough medicines. But somehow, you're more receptive to homeopathy than OTC cough medicines being effective.

The only explanation is that you're being less critical of homeopathy than you are of scientifically proven conventional medication (why, I don't know), while we are not. You may think we're not being neutral, but we don't see homeopathy as finding itself in a neutral position at all. We see homeopathy as being thoroughly debunked. The proposed mechanism of action is bollocks and goes against all our current scientific understanding, and further more there's no evidence it does anything at all. Why would we need to keep assuming that there's something there, when it's been duly shown to be nothing more than a placebo? Which is by the way also the logical explanation considering it can't possibly work?

The simple fact is that we have a scientifically credible explanation as to how homeopathy works: various placebo effects and other psychological influences and biases. It's sufficient to explain all the reported effects, and it doesn't violate the laws of physics. Why are you being so close minded to this explanation? Why do you insist on rejecting it in favor of a completely unbelievable and unreasonable hypothesis? Or at least keep suggesting that both explanations are equally valid, when they clearly are not?

The jury has come in on homeopathy a long time ago, and the verdict was: it's quackery.
 
Favour

Can I ask y'all a favour?

Well, too bad, I'm going to anyway. <g>

I have something important to talk about, but it's complicated. And I need Rodney to be able to pay attention and to answer my questions.

So I'm asking, can you keep the distractions to a minimum? Pretty please?

Linda
 
I don't agree that I am "supporting" homeopathy -- I'm just not trashing it the way almost everyone else here is. But if you can discredit all of the trials finding that homeopathic treatments performed above placebo, I would certainly reevaluate my current neutral position on homeopathy.

Why aren't you trashing it, Rodney? It is based on spurious principles that no one has ever managed to validate -- not even you.

I mean, you can make your own homeopathic preparations right in the comfort of your own home. Next time you have a life-threatening illness, I suggest you do just that. Then come back to us and tell us how homeopathy saved you.

M.
 
Ah. That would more properly be called a review. It's only a metanalysis if you are combining the data from several trials for a statistical analysis.



Hot rum toddies.

Linda

They've worked for me, on occasion :)

M.
 
Also, I want to sure I understand what you are getting at here.

During this thread, we have mostly talked about the collective effect of the homeopathic studies - even though individual studies are testing individual treatments, the studies are united by the idea of homeopathy. If the studies are analyzed collectively (i.e. analyzed as though the thing being tested is "homeopathy" rather than "oscillococcimum, arnica, drosera rotundifolia, etc.") we see that the evidence for the idea of homeopathy has progressively become weaker until it has essentially disappeared.

Now you have shifted your attention to the studies of individual treatments. If the test of an individual homeopathic treatment is positive, that means that there is evidence of a true effect. And if there are numerous individual treatments that show evidence of a true effect, and the only idea that combines these effects into a unifying hypothesis is homeopathy, the positive individual trials suggest that there is evidence for homeopathy. Homeopathy serves as a way to explain an effect that otherwise would have no explanation.

Does that last paragraph serve as a reasonable summary of what you are thinking of?

Linda

Assuming that you mean an effect above placebo, yes.
 
True. I wonder if Rodney supports this as well?

I support permitting any non-harmful product to be sold with a disclaimer on the product's label, if warranted, that the product has not been demonstrated to be effective.
 
Can I ask y'all a favour?

Well, too bad, I'm going to anyway. <g>

I have something important to talk about, but it's complicated. And I need Rodney to be able to pay attention and to answer my questions.

So I'm asking, can you keep the distractions to a minimum? Pretty please?

Linda

Sorry Linda, I posted before I saw your most recent posts.

I await your erudition with pleasure.

M.
 
I support permitting any non-harmful product to be sold with a disclaimer on the product's label, if warranted, that the product has not been demonstrated to be effective.

So unless something is demonstrated to be harmful it should be able to be sold then? Homeopathy has not been demonstrated to be non-harmful if it is not effective. If the jury is out on one why isn't the jury out on the other?

Sorry Linda I couldn't help myself.
 
Last edited:
If the test of an individual homeopathic treatment is positive, that means that there is evidence of a true effect. And if there are numerous individual treatments that show evidence of a true effect, and the only idea that combines these effects into a unifying hypothesis is homeopathy, the positive individual trials suggest that there is evidence for homeopathy. Homeopathy serves as a way to explain an effect that otherwise would have no explanation.

Does that last paragraph serve as a reasonable summary of what you are thinking of?
Assuming that you mean an effect above placebo, yes.

So if there's no effect above placebo, there's no need for an explanation. Right?
So why insist on continuing this explanation anyway, when to this day, no effect above placebo has been demonstrated?

In fact, why start with an explanation for an effect you don't know exists? And which scientific testing seems to indicate isn't there? What does that say about the explanation?

Exactly ...
 
Wouldn't it be better...

Thanks for the tip. The point I'm making, however, is that it's not enough to assume that ingredients that have been shown to be marginally effective in treating a cough will combine to produce an efficacious cough medicine. The only way to demonstrate whether a cough medicine is efficacious is to do a controlled test of it versus a placebo.

Wouldn't it be better if you did a controlled test of the cough medicine against a homeopathic remedy instead of a placebo.....

Ohhh wait a second, they're the same thing.

I loved the pancake syrup analogy by the way, seems you hit upon the idea that if you leave out important ingredients you don't get the effect you want. I don't quite understand how given this flash of inspiration you still cheer on homeopathy since, after all, it's the remedy that leaves ALL of the ingrediants out.
 
I love it

However, is Vicks Medinite an over-the-counter medicine? I never recall seeing it on any shelves in U.S. drugstores.

Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha

"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
etc etc etc etc

Followed by,
"Well I'VE never seen it for sale!"

Frakking hilarious.
 
Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha

"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
etc etc etc etc

Followed by,
"Well I'VE never seen it for sale!"

Frakking hilarious.

Now now, IW, mustn't ridicule the impaired...

M.
 
Linda-
Please continue with your important information. Some of us are waiting patiently.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom