Homeopathic Cough Medicine

It's non-scientific or non-skeptical to ask someone here to cite a study demonstrating the non-efficacy of a homeopathic cough medicine?

Yes, it is up to the person trying to say it is effective to show real studies and not just cite wikipedia, not the people saying that it can not possibly work and showing all the reasons why it violates everything we know about chemistry and all that.
 
But since millions of people worldwide use homeopathic medicines and since at least one homeopathic OTC cough medicine apparently exists (I say "apparently" because it would need to be tested to make sure it is, in fact, homeopathic), don't you think it would be desirable to have a controlled study of homeopathic vs. non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines?

Been done. You would need to show some way to differentiate homeopathic treatment from a placebo in terms of chemistry.
 
Been done. You would need to show some way to differentiate homeopathic treatment from a placebo in terms of chemistry.
Why? If a homeopathic treatment works better than a placebo to a high level of statistical certainty, the fact that chemists can't explain it means that our present knowledge of chemistry is deficient. Right, Linda? ;)
 
Why? If a homeopathic treatment works better than a placebo to a high level of statistical certainty, the fact that chemists can't explain it means that our present knowledge of chemistry is deficient. Right, Linda? ;)

That's a rather pointless and, frankly, stupid reply.

Does anyone still believe that Rodney is seriously looking for answers or exploring issues?
 
That's a rather pointless and, frankly, stupid reply.

Does anyone still believe that Rodney is seriously looking for answers or exploring issues?
Not I. He's targeting the lurking fence-sitters, not us.

As such, replies are still necessary.
 
I don't know where you got all this from. Virtually all coughs are upper respiratory tract infections. An infection of the lower respiratory tract is usually extremely serious, the most common being pneumonia and bronchitis. If you have one of these, the effectiveness of cough medicine is the least of your worries. Unsurprisingly, cough medicine does not help a problem in your lungs, so why do you think this is in any way related to the effectiveness of cough medicine for common colds?

To answer your other question, the last time I had an upper RTI was last week, the last time I had a lower RTI was never, and the same is true for most people (execpt the last week bit). I would also say that Linda has given very detailed information and you clearly know very little about this area, so your attitude is rather uncalled for.

Here's the link again: http://www.sign.ac.uk/pdf/sign59.pdf

On page 5 there is a pyramid. Study that for a minute or two.
On page 1 read the second paragraph of 1.1.

Any infection that spreads below the larynx is a lower RTI. See diagram:

respiratory_tract.jpg



You lucky never to have had an infection that has spread into the trachea or bronchial tubes. :)
You are also lucky never to have had the 'flu' :) :)

The common unifying symtom of a lower RTI is cough.

BJ
 
Not I. He's targeting the lurking fence-sitters, not us.

As such, replies are still necessary.

I see. So it looks like he's engaging in debate which may impress people who are less used to fallacious reasoning than we are. Point taken.

I have been away for a few days and was surprised to see things still going around in circles in this thread. :D
 
Why? If a homeopathic treatment works better than a placebo to a high level of statistical certainty, the fact that chemists can't explain it means that our present knowledge of chemistry is deficient. Right, Linda? ;)

So water does have a memory then. Thank you for finally answering that question.
 
See my above response to ponderingturtle.

Bulldust, mate. In quote #151 you answered thus:

"I don't know if water has a memory, but that question is irrelevant to this discussion."

i.e., you avoided answering a question that goes to the heart of homeopathy.

You're busily defending homeopathy here, so the question is to the point, so answer it:

Explain for us, if you can, the homeopathic principle of how water has a "memory."


M.
 
Bulldust, mate. In quote #151 you answered thus:

"I don't know if water has a memory, but that question is irrelevant to this discussion."

i.e., you avoided answering a question that goes to the heart of homeopathy.

You're busily defending homeopathy here, so the question is to the point, so answer it:

Explain for us, if you can, the homeopathic principle of how water has a "memory."


M.
It practices mnemonics? :) But seriously folks, the point you are missing is that, many times in history, the scientific establishment has not been able to account for something with current theory and has thus dismissed it as impossible. Eventually, though, when the evidence becomes irrefutable, the establishment is forced to concede that its theory was inadequate. Will that happen with homeopathy? Stay tuned.
 
It practices mnemonics? :) But seriously folks, the point you are missing is that, many times in history, the scientific establishment has not been able to account for something with current theory and has thus dismissed it as impossible. Eventually, though, when the evidence becomes irrefutable, the establishment is forced to concede that its theory was inadequate. Will that happen with homeopathy? Stay tuned.

And that is one of the poorest rationals that cranks always roll out. Most of those where not well measured and did not have all that much really good evidence supporting them. Chemistry and the idea of how many atoms are in a certain amount do not qualify as being so poorly supported by real data.

So while accepted rationals have often been very wrong those are not well tested explanations, or if you can find some that come anywhere near the level of validation that modern chemistry has being overturned I would like to see it.

Remember to wear the mantle of Galileo you need to be persecuted and most importantly right. just being rejected by the establishment is not enough.
 
It practices mnemonics? :) But seriously folks, the point you are missing is that, many times in history, the scientific establishment has not been able to account for something with current theory and has thus dismissed it as impossible. Eventually, though, when the evidence becomes irrefutable, the establishment is forced to concede that its theory was inadequate. Will that happen with homeopathy? Stay tuned.

The evidence for homeopathy is moving in the wrong direction. The evidence is becoming more and more refutable, rather than irrefutable.

"Now, another example of a test of truth, so to speak, that works in the sciences that would probably work in other fields to some extent is that if something is true, really so, if you continue observations and improve the effectiveness of the observations, the effects stand out more obviously. Not less obviously." - Richard Feynman, The Meaning of It All

Linda
 
Why? If a homeopathic treatment works better than a placebo to a high level of statistical certainty, the fact that chemists can't explain it means that our present knowledge of chemistry is deficient.
Do you have evidence that a homoeopathic cough medicine works better than placebo?
 
That information referred to the use of cough mixtures in children. I already explained that it means something like "since cough medicine does not influence the underlying cause and has a relatively high risk-benefit ratio in children, and we wish to be cautious in our recommendations, we recommed that cough mixtures not be used in children".
Fair enough.

ETA: The authors intend for the take-away message to be "don't bother with cough medicine in children". What I put in quotations in the previous paragraph is meant to be a summary of my explanation as to why the recommendations appear to be different from the evidence (or why statements like "no evidence for" get applied). It isn't meant to be an indication of what you are supposed to read into the simple statement of "cough mixtures play no role in the treatment of coughs".
Well, okay, it is becoming clearer to me where you are coming from. But, can I ask you whether, on the basis of the metanalysis, you agree with that bolded statement as a piece of good practical advice to parents.

You have not provided any evidence to counteract my demonstration by simply repeating the same one line summaries from different sources.
That's because I am not looking for evidence. I am looking for practical advice form experts who deal with patients with respiratory infection about the use of cough mixtures.

Plus I provided a link to the complete summary of recommendations for the use of cough medicines in adults for all the different causes of cough made by the ACCP.
Sorry I really did miss that one. I will try to find it.

I prefer accuracy to simplification and the loss of accuracy. That this is my preference doesn't seem like an adequate justification for your derision.
:( Sorry, Linda, that was not intended. I really do appreciate your contribution to this thread. It was meant as a bit of levity in the face of my frustration with my internet connection continually breaking down.

Your understanding of lower RTI is incorrect. I am not going to provide a detailed explanation of LRTI as I think it has been amply demonstrated that this will not be productive.
All I was saying is that it is difficult to reliably distinguish an upper from lower RTI, meaning that you could be using that cough mixture on what you believe to be a upper RTI on a lower RTI. It was based on the following excerpt from that link:

"LRTI can be difficult to distinguish from upper respiratory tract infection"
"The distinction between cough due to an upper RTI and cough due to bronchitis (lower RTI) is not important, as both conditions are self limiting viral conditions"

regards,
BillyJoe
 
Here's the link again: http://www.sign.ac.uk/pdf/sign59.pdf

On page 5 there is a pyramid. Study that for a minute or two.
On page 1 read the second paragraph of 1.1.

Any infection that spreads below the larynx is a lower RTI. See diagram:

You lucky never to have had an infection that has spread into the trachea or bronchial tubes. :)
You are also lucky never to have had the 'flu' :) :)

The common unifying symtom of a lower RTI is cough.

BJ

And your point is? As I said before, almost all coughs are upper RTIs, lower RTIs are usually much more serious, the most common being pneumonia and bronchitis. I don't see why you state that the unifying symptom of a LRTI is a cough, since the symptom of almost any RTI is a cough. The Patient UK site says this about URTIs (Patient UK is information provided by GPs to their patients). Their reading topics for LRTIs are here.

None of this alters the fact that cough medicines are meant for the upper respiratory tract, so your complaint about Linda dismissing a study on the lower respiratory tract is, and always will be, erroneous. Yes, it can be difficult to tell the difference between upper and lower infections, but that is not the issue at hand.
 
Can you give an example?

Getting a lollipop from the doctor afterwards might have a positive influence. Getting a pat on the back or a friendly smile too. But technically those last two aren't considered "placebo" according to the dictionary definition:
a : a usually pharmacologically inert preparation prescribed more for the mental relief of the patient than for its actual effect on a disorder b : an inert or innocuous substance used especially in controlled experiments testing the efficacy of another substance (as a drug)
Since the dictionary definition focuses on "substances". The problem being that the placebo effect usually refers to more than just substances, as is obvious from looking at CAM (complementary and alternative medicine).

To get back to the drug trial: the placebo control side is subject to placebo effect + various other effects not included in placebo.
The remedy side includes the same placebo effect + various other side effects, but also the remedy's effect.

I never said an RDBPC was biased, I just said that not every "placebo" effect can be known, or even needs to be, in order to have an unbiased RDBPC. That's why I said it doesn't matter there.

But since there's no "control" in homeopathy, it's important to make people understand that there's far more to "placebo" effect than just the substance, and they're correct that the mere taking of the substance can't account for all the apparent improvement they're experiencing or noticing when taking their sCAM treatment. And this is a defense you'll often hear them make: "Are you saying that we're all crazy people who are getting better because we think we're getting better after taking medication?" Short answer: "Yes", but you can't say that because they'll just dismiss that. It's the long answer that's important, and that means having more to say than "placebo" ...
 
We call it placebo. In a trial there are two things that affect the results - the treatment and placebo. The first is an actual physiological effect, while the term "placebo" covers everything that causes the patient to appear improved, to themselves or to other people, that does not have an actual physical cause. Your statement that
These effect don't play a significant role in drug trails, other than needing to be controlled for.
simply makes no sense. If they didn't play a significant role they wouldn't need to be controlled for.

They don't play a significant role because the placebo effect and all related effects are present in both the control and the remedy section of the trial. If they are controlled for (i.e. present in both the control and the remedy section) then the trial is unbiased and they are of no further relevance.

They play a huge role in real life though, where people who swear by homeopathy are staking their life on it precisely because these effects play such a huge part in the apparent effectiveness of the treatment.
 
Anything that makes the patient feel better without actually having a physical effect is placebo. This is why we have placebo controlled trials. One group is given active treatment, the other is treated identically in all respects except the drug is not active. Any improvement that occurs in both groups is due to placebo and can be ignored. Of course, there are a few other effects such as spontaneous recovery and regression to the mean, but these are not relevant to this discussion.

They are in fact precisely what I am getting at. Your indiscriminate use of the word "placebo" instead of the more correct term "placebo effect" for starters is already a big part of the problem.
Beyond that, there's things like the desease running its course that are not by any definition a "placebo effect", since they occur regardless of taking medication or not.

It's important to realize that there's people out there who'll jump at discrepancies like this just to be able to claim that "skeptics" can't explain why homeopathy seems to work, even though we can.

While this conflation of terms is not a big problem when the aim is to figure out the specific effect of a remedy, it is a big problem when discussing with woos about their particular brand of sCAM. Like Rodney for example ...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom