Homeopathic Cough Medicine

It falls on Rodney's and others' deaf ears, fls.

Are you calling my ears deaf Moochie?
I may not disagree with fls, but I definitely don't mind her posting all that stuff, because it's interesting no matter how much or little you already know about double blind placebo controlled drug trials.
 
Thanks for your continuing educational efforts, Linda. Still, I wonder why I keep finding articles like this one from only a month ago:

[...]

"The study suggests over-the-counter syrups contain medications in such low doses that they are ineffective, or contain a combination of active and inactive ingredients that are not proven to control cold-related coughs. The American Thoracic Society and the Canadian Thoracic Society are two other professional organizations that support ACCP's conclusion.

"One popular brand's combination of codeine and dextromethorphan has been approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), however the ACCP study authors suggest their doses are too small to produce the relief many cold sufferers seek.

[...]

These two paragraphs illustrate exactly what the problem is. A problem homeopathy isn't bothered by because it has the same status as a bottle of soda or a box of smarties:
FDA regulation.

These regulations can be so strict that a medicine cannot be sold OTC (that's "over the counter", i.e. the opposite of "by prescription") if it contains too much of a good thing. The problem is therefore not in the efficacy of a product or its ingredients, but in the law setting a limit to what can be sold OTC.

If the law were to say you can no longer sell more than 5 matches at a time, then it's not the match-making industry's fault if one book of matches is no longer sufficient to light all the cigarettes in a pack. We know matches are capable of lighting a cigarette, and tests have conclusively proven this.

The problem in this case is drug manufacturers adjusting their product for OTC sale to a point where it's no longer working to its full potential.
 
These two paragraphs illustrate exactly what the problem is. A problem homeopathy isn't bothered by because it has the same status as a bottle of soda or a box of smarties:
FDA regulation.

These regulations can be so strict that a medicine cannot be sold OTC (that's "over the counter", i.e. the opposite of "by prescription") if it contains too much of a good thing. The problem is therefore not in the efficacy of a product or its ingredients, but in the law setting a limit to what can be sold OTC.

If the law were to say you can no longer sell more than 5 matches at a time, then it's not the match-making industry's fault if one book of matches is no longer sufficient to light all the cigarettes in a pack. We know matches are capable of lighting a cigarette, and tests have conclusively proven this.

The problem in this case is drug manufacturers adjusting their product for OTC sale to a point where it's no longer working to its full potential.
To play devil's advocate a bit:

It doesn't matter the reason for the inefficacy of the OTC stuff. If it does not do what it claims, and the companies know this, should they not (a) stop selling it or (b) relabel it?

Additionally, if skeptics on this board know that the OTC stuff does not do what it claims, why do we single homeopathy out above the OTC stuff?

I happen to think there are legitimate answers to both questions, but I also think they need to be asked. And I also think it's what Rodney may be getting at.
 
I'm not trying to discredit you, but I still don't agree with your logic regarding homeopathy studies. Yes, the 2005 Lancet study is the latest, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's the greatest. It seems to me that, to begin to fully discredit homeopathy, someone needs to methodically review the 81 of 107 studies in the 1991 British Medical Journal study and discredit the great majority of the 81. (I understand and accept your argument that some studies would produce positive results just by chance, but 81 out of 107?)

I did not state that the 2005 Lancet study is the greatest study because it is the latest. It is considered a better study because it tested homeopathy in a different manner and was more rigorous in its approach. I did not suggest that the 81 positive studies mentioned in the BMJ review were positive due to chance. Most of those are probably positive due to poor design and execution (more later). I was talking about the less than a dozen studies that are similar in methodologic quality to the average convential drug trial that showed small differences in subjective outcomes and no differences in objective outcomes. I was suggesting that these studies could easily reflect a bias towards publishing studies that showed a p<0.05 in any of multiple comparisons. Once you take multiple comparisons into account, you'd only need to perform 20 or 30 studies to come up with 10 that showed at least one significant difference due to chance.

Going back to the homeopathic studies that showed effect in the BMJ review. They were methodically reviewed (there have been six published re-analyses of the data). As I mentioned before, the majority of the positive results were in studies that were poorly designed and executed (and poorly analyzed). This means that there were several reasons that the groups were different, not just whether or not a homeopathic preparation was being taken. When the studies are rated for quality based on objective criteria, the positive results are found in low quality studies and the negative results are found in high quality studies. High quality studies that are published in conventional peer-reviewed journals have been negative. Why do you think homeopaths complain the standard double-blind RCT is not the appropriate tool by which to assess homeopathic therapies? Because they can't get positive results by that method. Most of the so-called double-blind randomized controlled trials that homeopaths use to claim effect can't get published in conventional medical journals because of signficant methodologic and analytic flaws.

I am not trying to convince you of anything. I am trying to provide information in an understandable manner as to why objective experts do not consider homeopathy a valid therapy. And why they consider the evidence to date adequate to come to this conclusion.

Linda
 
Linda,

After reading the whole thread, it seemed obvious to me that there are really only two people who are patiently trying to discus this thing in a reasonable manner. Yourself and Rodney. Yes, Rodney has been very patient considering the amount of attention he has been receiving. Of course he has a very unsceptical view of homoeopathy. However, he is willing to listen to alternative views and has conceded a few points along the way. This makes him a winner in my book, in the sense that he is getting something out of this thread, whereas other are just confirming their prejudices and learning nothing.

Bollocks. Rodney has been shown to be wrong time and again, and he just keeps rephrasing the question to give the impression that he either misunderstood or to pretend he was claiming something else entirely. Perhaps the biggest difference between fls and the rest of the posters on this thread is the fact that she hasn't debated Rodney before in other threads about homeopathy. He does this all the time, and it wouldn't be so bad if he was actually interested in learning something new, but he's not.

Go read Rodney's posts Billy, and you'll see how he keeps moving the goalposts around. Try showing him why he's wrong, and he just switches the subject, or suddenly claims something different.

But the most obvious tactic so far, is the fact that for 9 pages now, Rodney has managed to avoid the subject of the opening post: homeopathic cough medicines from being discussed. Every time we try to get him to address that point, he throws up another hurdle about regular medicine for us to jump over.
Us: homeopathic cough medicines don't work.
Rodney: Well, research has shown that regular cough medicines don't work either.
Us: Here's the research that says they do.
Rodney: But those are just the ingredients, not the specific cough medicines.
Us: But the specific cough medicines contain these ingredients.
Rodney: But the specific brands aren't tested.
Us: But the specific brands contain these ingredients.
Rodney: But the specific brands aren't tested.
Us: Actually, they are.
Rodney: But this journalist still says they don't work
Us: Well, that journalist is wrong, because the research says they do. Now how about some research on homeopathic cough medicines? (we know those don't exist)
Rodney: Wow, interesting essay on cough medicine research fls. I'd like to talk about that some more.
Us: Sure, this is how it works. Here are some examples. Now how about homeopathy's track record?
Rodney: Lots of homeopathic studies are positive.
Us: No, they're not, didn't you just read that wonderful essay and see those great examples? Homeopathy's not like that. Care to discuss the OP at last?
Rodney: But the OP wasn't about homeopathy, it was about cough medicines.
Us: No, the OP was about homeopathic cough medicines. We've already discussed cough medicines, time to move on to homeopathy.
BillyJoe: Here's a few newspaper articles and recommendations about children's cough medicine.
Us: *facepalm* Uhm, Billy, 1) we weren't talking about kids, 2) we already covered that bit about newspaper exerpts, and 3) we also covered the difference between curing colds, and alleviating cold symptoms. And finally 4) We were discussing the effectiveness of of OTC cough medicines as a side track initiated by Rodney. I think we've proven our point, we want to move on to homeopathic cough medicines and their ineffectiveness, not the side effects of OTC cough medicines.

Perhaps it's not a bad idea for you to re-read this thread a bit more carefully?
 
I agree with exarch. I'll quote myself from Post #161 at the top of page 5 of this thread:

Garrette said:
I have to commend you, Rodney. You've done an admirable job of turning this thread from a discussion of bs homeopathic remedies to a labeling issue about cough medicines. Even when people agree with some of your points, you keep the discussion away from homeopathy.

Why do you feel the need to avoid discussing homeopathic remedies?
 
As such, it's not me who's misusing "placebo" wrongly, it's you who's using it to cover every form of bias that shows up during the healing process. As such, the woos are right to point out that a friendly doctor is not part of the placebo effect, although (s)he is part of the healing illusion.
It's important to make this distinction. Placebo is any apparent healing that occurs after receiving a therapy or ingesting medication that is only the result of going through the procedure of doing so, and not of the therapeutic effect of the therapy or the influence of the chemicals in the medicine specifically.

Of course, I may be wrong ...

And the apparent healing that occurs after receiving a therapy may not even have anything to do with going through the procedure of doing so.

If the placebo effect represents a hodge podge of various effects, I'm not sure that there's much benefit in insisting that it cover a slightly smaller vs. a slightly larger collection. I see the benefit in recognizing just what these effects are - regression, psychological, etc. But in any given study we don't really know the relative contribution of each, just the total. And since that total necessarily includes the stuff you want to exclude (the effect of a friendly doctor), I'm not sure what you've accomplished.

You end up saying something like, "the effect of the placebo treatment includes placebo effects and other effects".

Linda
 
Your argument about the ingredients reminds me of something that happened when I was on a camping trip with a group of boys when I was 14 years old. Our counselor made us pancakes for breakfast one morning and then informed us that, while he did not have any pancake syrup, he was going to make his own syrup with sugar and water. He was adamant that "syrup is just sugar and water." I still remember how his blend of sugar and water ruined the pancakes.

I do so hate coming late to these parties, but at any rate:

Clearly your counselor's mistake was in using too much water and not enough sugar. In other words, your pancakes were ruined by HOMEOPATHIC SYRUP.
 
Regarding homeopathy, I still don't see the hard evidence refuting it. I will grant you that it's hardly proven, but that's different than refuting it. And, as far as I know, no homeopathic cough medicine has ever been subjected to controlled testing.

And yet, there is much, much more testing done regarding conventional OTC cough medicine, and you're willing to dismiss that verbatim based on a few newspaper clippings. On the other hand, homeopathy, despite lacking a sensible means of functioning, evidence of it actually working, and many, many trials showing no effects above placebo, receives no such cold shoulder.

And then this ...

You are a very articulate spokesperson for the manufacturers of OTC cough medicines, Linda. You don't have to answer this question if you would rather not, but do you work for one of them or an industry group representing them?

Wow. Just wow. You finally find someone who knows enough to plug any holes you're hoping to find in this particular bit of conventional medicine, and you immediately assume she must be working for "big evil pharma".

See my custom title there Rodney? It's there for exactly this reason: to ridicule this type of dishonest debate. You don't like hearing some of the things someone is saying? Accuse them of working for "the enemy" and parroting the political party line, having vested interests.

And the sad fact is that it's usually the other way around, with homeopaths with vested interests in homeopathy assuming that anyone who's defending conventional medicine and actively refuting their claims must be working for the pharmaceutical industry.

We're not all like that. In fact, it seems it's primarily the woos who do that. We're just arguing against homeopathy because we've seen the evidence, found it severly wanting, and think it's unethical for people to continue making money ripping unaware consumers off like that.
 
To play devil's advocate a bit:

It doesn't matter the reason for the inefficacy of the OTC stuff. If it does not do what it claims, and the companies know this, should they not (a) stop selling it or (b) relabel it?

Medication gets licensed for specific indications, but once it's licensed there's no limitation to its use (with some exceptions). Prescription medication tends to get subscribed for indications that have good evidence, so it doesn't matter so much if the evidence changes as that's what physicians tend to follow. OTC medications are somewhat different, as there is no real incentive for the companies to withdraw indications. I don't know what it would take for the FDA to force change - certainly not a single weak negative effectiveness study in the setting of a dozen positive efficacy studies, though. If the FDA withdraws a drug it's usually because of safety issues, not effectiveness issues.

And technically, if you are talking about OTC cough medicines, the companies do not know that they do not do what they claim. The level of evidence provided by the negative studies is too low to meet any reasonable standards of proof. They simply insert a big question mark. It may be enough for physicians to qualify their recommendations, but it isn't proof of anything.

Additionally, if skeptics on this board know that the OTC stuff does not do what it claims, why do we single homeopathy out above the OTC stuff?

The evidence available for both is dramatically different, though. In one case we have strong evidence for efficacy, moderate evidence for effectiveness in specific circumstances and weak evidence against effectiveness in specific circumstances. And in the other case, we have no evidence for efficacy, no evidence for effectiveness and a silly idea. A simple objective weighing of the evidence seems adequate to guide us with respect to what we should single out.

I happen to think there are legitimate answers to both questions, but I also think they need to be asked. And I also think it's what Rodney may be getting at.

What makes you think they haven't already been asked and answered numerous times?

Linda
 
Some support but not an ringing endorsement, IMO...a single positive trail (and the next trial might be positive or negative)....a couple of trials, one positive, the other negative....a few positive trials "showing effect above placebo" (unquantified)

Um ... Billy, this is a trial testing if there's anything there at all. This is putting the bar really, really, really high. And they still show effect above placebo, if only a little.
And the ones not passing, well, in a way that might just be like saying the team didn't win because they didn't beat the opposition with a high enough difference in score. They might have an effect, we just can't detect it.
On the other hand, the trials that DO show an effect, even if a previous trial failed to show any effect, is considered successful, precisely because the bar is put that high. One win is enough to exclude false positives, and to realize the previous fail was a false negative.
 
Sorry Billy, I keep refuting you because it's just so goddamned easy ...

"There are a number of experimental studies where the severity of pharmacologically induced cough is reduced by dextromethorphan and codeine (but these tend to be small studies of around 20 patients) and there is conflicting evidence for the therapeutic effect of dextromethorphan and codeine and pholcodeine in patients with chronic cough."
 
Thus, the experiment seems to show that the placebo effect may --at least in some instances -- involve a complex interaction between the physiological and psychological.

Which, if I understand correctly, was exactly what the study was meant to find out? What is your point though?
What's more, how does any of this support homeopathy?

I'm not trying to discredit you, but I still don't agree with your logic regarding homeopathy studies. Yes, the 2005 Lancet study is the latest, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's the greatest. It seems to me that, to begin to fully discredit homeopathy, someone needs to methodically review the 81 of 107 studies in the 1991 British Medical Journal study and discredit the great majority of the 81. (I understand and accept your argument that some studies would produce positive results just by chance, but 81 out of 107?)

I wonder what the odds are that the 2005 Lancet study actually also included most (if not all) of those 81 studies from the 1991 BMJ study. Perhaps even all 107 of them ...

Edit: and rejected the majority of them from their results because they were poorly designed or had other flaws the 1991 study didn't consider.
 
Last edited:
To play devil's advocate a bit:

It doesn't matter the reason for the inefficacy of the OTC stuff. If it does not do what it claims, and the companies know this, should they not (a) stop selling it or (b) relabel it?

Additionally, if skeptics on this board know that the OTC stuff does not do what it claims, why do we single homeopathy out above the OTC stuff?

I happen to think there are legitimate answers to both questions, but I also think they need to be asked. And I also think it's what Rodney may be getting at.

Of course, if the product is ineffective because they had to remove part of the ingredients, or because they had to reduce them to the point where taking one tablet doesn't work, but taking two does, then they might be violating the rules somehow. But the thing is, they've only diluted them, they still work if taken in high enough quantities.

On the other hand, if you have a physician like mine, who'll advise you not to buy that cough syrup you used to buy a decade ago, because they've removed the codeine from it to be able to sell it OTC, and give you a prescription for one that still does contain it, or who tells you that a particular brand of ibuprofen 400mg contains only half or a third as much active ingredient as the prescription variants (and that you should therefor take two or three to get the same effect), then what's the problem?

If I want something against my cough, I buy the brand from a decade ago. If I need a decongestant, I'll go to the doctor to prescribe me the good stuff. If I have a serious headache, I know one tablet isn't going to cut it, while it will for a light one.

While it might seem like manufacturers of OTC remedies are selling out just to make a buck, they're just making a product with a built in safety in case people do crazy things like taking too much, or giving it to their kids when it's indicated to only be for adults.

I suppose this is the result of decades of class action suits and frivolous lawsuits by greedy idiots.
 
If the placebo effect represents a hodge podge of various effects, I'm not sure that there's much benefit in insisting that it cover a slightly smaller vs. a slightly larger collection. I see the benefit in recognizing just what these effects are - regression, psychological, etc. But in any given study we don't really know the relative contribution of each, just the total. And since that total necessarily includes the stuff you want to exclude (the effect of a friendly doctor), I'm not sure what you've accomplished.

You end up saying something like, "the effect of the placebo treatment includes placebo effects and other effects".

True, you would end up saying that. But you would also say that the remedy treatment includes the remedy plus other effects (including placebo).

These effect don't play a significant role in drug trails, other than needing to be controlled for. You don't need to quantify them for example. But they play a major role in alternative medicine. The problem is, the CAM-people start to weasel out when you simply dismiss it all as "placebo" (even though it is all psychology in action). They start dragging in things that you might consider to be included under the all encompassing working interpretation of "placebo", but which don't fit the dictionary definition of the term.

Either we need to redefine "placebo", or we need to find a new word for the large umbrella-definition of "any apparent healing effects that show up during treatment that are not due to the medication".
 
Last edited:
To play devil's advocate a bit:

It doesn't matter the reason for the inefficacy of the OTC stuff. If it does not do what it claims, and the companies know this, should they not (a) stop selling it or (b) relabel it?

Additionally, if skeptics on this board know that the OTC stuff does not do what it claims, why do we single homeopathy out above the OTC stuff?

I happen to think there are legitimate answers to both questions, but I also think they need to be asked. And I also think it's what Rodney may be getting at.
I agree with your notion here. It's just that homeopathy is far more obviously and demonstrably ineffective than various OTC medications that do not work as per the label. However homeopathy was Rodney's specific topic on this thread.

Of course you can group with homeopathy quite a few other remedies and procedures that similarly have demonstrated no effect beyond placebo (and they are based on obviously wonky thinking anyway): reflexology, iridology, numerology, ayervedic, "light touch" and "no touch" massage therapies, etc.

Some "alternative medicines" MAY have some medical benefit sometimes (albeit very slight to negligible in most cases), although usually not for the reasons being touted by their proponents: most relaxation massage-based therapies, acupuncture, "low dilution" homeopathy (basically weak herbal teas), etc.

And some seem worth pursuing medically because they have a rational basis with demonstrable effect, but this needs to be in a much more controlled fashion than currently: undiluted herbal products, diet control, relaxation techniques, various exercises, sports and orthopedic massage, etc.
 
To play devil's advocate a bit:

It doesn't matter the reason for the inefficacy of the OTC stuff. If it does not do what it claims, and the companies know this, should they not (a) stop selling it or (b) relabel it?

Additionally, if skeptics on this board know that the OTC stuff does not do what it claims, why do we single homeopathy out above the OTC stuff?

I happen to think there are legitimate answers to both questions, but I also think they need to be asked. And I also think it's what Rodney may be getting at.

C have people talk to their doctor and take more of the OTC so you get an effective dose.
 
Bollocks. Rodney has been shown to be wrong time and again, and he just keeps rephrasing the question to give the impression that he either misunderstood or to pretend he was claiming something else entirely. Perhaps the biggest difference between fls and the rest of the posters on this thread is the fact that she hasn't debated Rodney before in other threads about homeopathy. He does this all the time, and it wouldn't be so bad if he was actually interested in learning something new, but he's not.

Go read Rodney's posts Billy, and you'll see how he keeps moving the goalposts around. Try showing him why he's wrong, and he just switches the subject, or suddenly claims something different.

But the most obvious tactic so far, is the fact that for 9 pages now, Rodney has managed to avoid the subject of the opening post: homeopathic cough medicines from being discussed. Every time we try to get him to address that point, he throws up another hurdle about regular medicine for us to jump over.
Us: homeopathic cough medicines don't work.
Rodney: Well, research has shown that regular cough medicines don't work either.
Us: Here's the research that says they do.
Rodney: But those are just the ingredients, not the specific cough medicines.
Us: But the specific cough medicines contain these ingredients.
Rodney: But the specific brands aren't tested.
Us: But the specific brands contain these ingredients.
Rodney: But the specific brands aren't tested.
Us: Actually, they are.
Rodney: But this journalist still says they don't work
Us: Well, that journalist is wrong, because the research says they do. Now how about some research on homeopathic cough medicines? (we know those don't exist)
Rodney: Wow, interesting essay on cough medicine research fls. I'd like to talk about that some more.
Us: Sure, this is how it works. Here are some examples. Now how about homeopathy's track record?
Rodney: Lots of homeopathic studies are positive.
Us: No, they're not, didn't you just read that wonderful essay and see those great examples? Homeopathy's not like that. Care to discuss the OP at last?
Rodney: But the OP wasn't about homeopathy, it was about cough medicines.
Us: No, the OP was about homeopathic cough medicines. We've already discussed cough medicines, time to move on to homeopathy.
BillyJoe: Here's a few newspaper articles and recommendations about children's cough medicine.
Us: *facepalm* Uhm, Billy, 1) we weren't talking about kids, 2) we already covered that bit about newspaper exerpts, and 3) we also covered the difference between curing colds, and alleviating cold symptoms. And finally 4) We were discussing the effectiveness of of OTC cough medicines as a side track initiated by Rodney. I think we've proven our point, we want to move on to homeopathic cough medicines and their ineffectiveness, not the side effects of OTC cough medicines.

Perhaps it's not a bad idea for you to re-read this thread a bit more carefully?

Wow that is the best summary of a several hundred post debate I have seen. Way to go.
 
Wow that is the best summary of a several hundred post debate I have seen. Way to go.
So, Exarch's fundamental claim that "homeopathic cough medicines don't work" is supported by at least one study? Please supply a link to that study.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom