Linda,
After reading the whole thread, it seemed obvious to me that there are really only two people who are patiently trying to discus this thing in a reasonable manner. Yourself and Rodney. Yes, Rodney has been very patient considering the amount of attention he has been receiving. Of course he has a very unsceptical view of homoeopathy. However, he is willing to listen to alternative views and has conceded a few points along the way. This makes him a winner in my book, in the sense that he is getting something out of this thread, whereas other are just confirming their prejudices and learning nothing.
Bollocks. Rodney has been shown to be wrong time and again, and he just keeps rephrasing the question to give the impression that he either misunderstood or to pretend he was claiming something else entirely. Perhaps the biggest difference between fls and the rest of the posters on this thread is the fact that she hasn't debated Rodney before in other threads about homeopathy. He does this all the time, and it wouldn't be so bad if he was actually interested in learning something new, but he's not.
Go read Rodney's posts Billy, and you'll see how he keeps moving the goalposts around. Try showing him why he's wrong, and he just switches the subject, or suddenly claims something different.
But the most obvious tactic so far, is the fact that for 9 pages now, Rodney has managed to avoid the subject of the opening post:
homeopathic cough medicines from being discussed. Every time we try to get him to address that point, he throws up another hurdle about regular medicine for us to jump over.
Us: homeopathic cough medicines don't work.
Rodney: Well, research has shown that regular cough medicines don't work either.
Us: Here's the research that says they do.
Rodney: But those are just the ingredients, not the specific cough medicines.
Us: But the specific cough medicines
contain these ingredients.
Rodney: But the specific brands aren't tested.
Us: But the specific brands
contain these ingredients.
Rodney: But the specific brands aren't tested.
Us: Actually, they are.
Rodney: But this journalist still says they don't work
Us: Well, that journalist is wrong, because the research says they do. Now how about some research on homeopathic cough medicines? (we know those don't exist)
Rodney: Wow, interesting essay on cough medicine research fls. I'd like to talk about that some more.
Us: Sure, this is how it works. Here are some examples. Now how about homeopathy's track record?
Rodney: Lots of homeopathic studies are positive.
Us: No, they're not, didn't you just read that wonderful essay and see those great examples? Homeopathy's not like that. Care to discuss the OP at last?
Rodney: But the OP wasn't about homeopathy, it was about cough medicines.
Us: No, the OP was about homeopathic cough medicines. We've already discussed cough medicines, time to move on to homeopathy.
BillyJoe: Here's a few newspaper articles and recommendations about children's cough medicine.
Us: *facepalm* Uhm, Billy, 1) we weren't talking about kids, 2) we already covered that bit about newspaper exerpts, and 3) we also covered the difference between curing colds, and alleviating cold symptoms. And finally 4) We were discussing the effectiveness of of OTC cough medicines as a side track initiated by Rodney. I think we've proven our point, we want to move on to
homeopathic cough medicines and their
ineffectiveness, not the
side effects of OTC cough medicines.
Perhaps it's not a bad idea for you to re-read this thread a bit more carefully?