Homeopathic Cough Medicine

I would like you to state your point succinctly, Rodney. Do you believe that homeopathy works beyond placebo, and if so, on what evidence do you base this? Also, do you believe a "meta-analysis" of previous trials/experiments to be scientifically valid?

M.
 
Two sets of questions:

(1) Even if "[j]ournalists always make mistakes when reporting on scientific research", why is it that they seem to consistently come down against the efficacy of OTC cough medicines? Are they out to get manufacturers of those medicines? If so, why?

"Common Medicine Works" is not much of a story, "Common Medicine Doesn't Work" is a much better story. It is like Dog bites Man, vs Man Bites Dog. So of course they will be weighted to negative results.
(2) How do you explain these quotes from MDs? --

Just because someone is a doctor doesn't mean they are not an idiot about something.
 
Linda has not lost me, but you're raising some valid points. I don't think either you or me has been cherry-picking the quotes -- it's just that most of them are negative toward OTC cough medicines.

I think BillyJoe was most definitely cherry picking quotes as they where all about children or families, and not at all about adults. Well most medicine is poorly tested on children for ethical reasons. And designing a test for something that is not a real threat to health and the medicine does not improve the overall outcome is not going to be very easy. So how effective and how risky these things are in children is like with most medication an open question because we test on adults.
 
It would seem a reasonable extrapolation, don't you think?

(In response to extrapolating information from children to adults and vice versa.)

I might if it wasn't contradicted by the evidence. Scientific research has demonstrated that children can be quite different from adults in how they metabolize drugs, and in how they are affected by drugs. To use a relevant example, it requires a larger dose relative to weight for DM to relieve cough in children, and they are more susceptible to the side-effects. So some children may get a little loopy if they receive 1 or 2 extra doses of DM, whereas it may take 5 or 6 extra doses for an adult to get a little loopy.

And as a society we tend to be more cautious of children; prohibiting them from stuff that's potentially harmful while placing no restrictions on adults (e.g. age-limits for alcohol consumption).

When we make blanket recommendations, we aim at the lowest common denominator rather than the average. So even if cough medicines are moderately effective in children, if there's a small chance that the expected amount of mis-use could lead to harm, the overall assessment is that they are not useful (i.e. the benefit does not sufficiently compensate for the possible harm). On the other hand, if you are dealing with an individual, you have a much clearer idea of the circumstances for which the medicine will be used, whether they are capable of using it properly, and whether they are more likely to be susceptible to side-effects. And there is an opportunity for individualized instruction. So you may go ahead and recommend the use of a cough medicine based on evidence in an individual even though it gives the appearance of going against blanket recommendations. That is why you often see "consult your physician" as a qualifier to these statements.

"Cough medicines are not useful in treating cough in children"
"There is no evidence that cough medicines, decongestants, antihistamines or antibiotics have a role in treatment."

Firstly, there is a specific statement that there is "no evidence" for a role of cough mixtures in treatment. So, I think your assumption (see below)that the advice was based on evidence is probably correct. ;)
Secondly, your distinction between treating and relieving doesn't seem to apply here. I agree thay can mean different things in certain contexts. But in this context I can't see a difference in meaning. Can you, really? They are clearly talking about treating symptoms, not treating the underlying cause. Their statements would otherwise make no sense to their target audience.

Because the list includes antibiotics, they are clearly talking about treating the underlying cause. While the idea of treating symptoms could be applied to the other drugs, it cannot be applied to the use of antibiotics.

I think you have put your finger on a major source of mis-interpretation, though. Many terms have a specific meaning in the field of medicine. And this is the meaning that physicians usually have in mind when they write something. But it may be a word that gets used in a broader sense in casual use, and the reader often interprets it as it is used casually rather than professionally. It is up to the writer to try and prevent this, but when you are used to using a word in a particular way, it is easy to forget that others use it differently.

Some support but not an ringing endorsement, IMO...a single positive trail (and the next trial might be positive or negative)....a couple of trials, one positive, the other negative....a few positive trials "showing effect above placebo" (unquantified)

I gave you the link to the review so that the information would be available to you. The effects above placebo were not unquantified; they were quantified in the review. I did not repeat that information in my summary because that would have made it unreadable.

Seems to me that reduces the difference the cough mixture makes.

(This was in reference to my statement that there is a large placebo effect with cough.)

When we talk about the difference cough mixtures make, the effect of placebo is taken into account - i.e. it doesn't reduce the difference again.

It reminds me of the following story:
A couple of years ago, a family physician who used homoeopathic "treatments" with impressive effects, had it bought to his attention how ridiculous the idea of homoeopathy really was. He then realised that the effect he was acheiving was purely placebo - produced by the care and attention he was providing his patients. He therefore continued his care and attention and dispensed with the homoeopathy.

Hasn't that been my point all along? That even though all trials of cough medicine show that it is effective, one needs to look at the effect in addition to the effect of placebo. So instead of stating that all trials show that cough medicine is effective, I and other experts have provided a more honest and conservative assessment by pointing out that in some studies, the effect is only marginally greater than the placebo effect.

If this is a correct summary of the clinical trials, I guess, on balance, there is likely to be some beneficial effect of cough mixtures on symptoms. I'm still not kicking up my heels with excitement though.

I was going for an objective, rather than subjective, approach.

Fair enough, but I wonder why the RCH, presumably using the same evidence base, conclude otherwise.

It is unlikely that the RCH used the same evidence base, since they are talking about children. Their conclusion does not seem to different from mine (please be specific if you think otherwise).

Except that one of those statements include the phrase "there is no evidence for". And it addressed the situation of a mother or family physician faced with a child with a cough.

Can you show me what part you are referring to from your references?

And, of course, you know that what consumer's do is always rational. ;)
They also demand antibiotics for viral infections because they know it helped last time.

My qualification of my statement (which you snipped) was meant make it clear that I wasn't referring to irrational assumptions.

"(i.e. people are willing to spend a little money on relief of symptoms (not knowing how many are confused about the relief/treatment issue))"

I wasn't talking about whether people are mistaken as to what helps treat their cough. I was talking about the idea of taking a medication to relieve a symptom, even though you know that the medication does not treat the underlying cause. Most people know that there isn't a cure for the common cold, so they know that taking cough medicine is really about reducing a particular symptom rather than attacking the cold virus. I think people are capable of deciding whether or not they want to bother treating a symptom while they get better on their own.

What the RCH is saying to parents is: over and above looking after your child, the addition of cough mixtures play very little, if any, role.
So far, my own experience with my children would back up that advice. :)

regards,
BillyJoe

Yeah, it always seems to come down to that. Subjective personal opinion wins out over the consideration of objective information. We need to recognize that we use stories to make things real and incorporate that into our presentation, somehow.

Anyway, I think we've derailed this thread enough.
I'm still keen to hear from Rodney about whether he has any further thoughts about homoeopathy.

Why?

Linda
 
I would like you to state your point succinctly, Rodney. Do you believe that homeopathy works beyond placebo, and if so, on what evidence do you base this? Also, do you believe a "meta-analysis" of previous trials/experiments to be scientifically valid?
M.
For the umpteenth time, I think the jury is still out on homeopathy. As far as the valididy of meta-analyses, it depends how they're done. However, if you don't believe in them at all, you must discount the August 2005 Lancet study.
 
But that's not what the Benedetti study found. Rather, it found that naloxone blocks the pain-relieving effect of saline solution, just as it blocks the pain-relieving effect of morphine.

Saline does not relieve pain. What they where was convinced that the pain would be reduced and their body produced that effect. The naloxone blocked the psychosomatic response. Which is interesting, but Linda has explained the physiological rational for that much better than I can already.

I was addressing the feeling better/worse issue based on prior experiance and expectation and not the physiological reasons for it.
 
For the umpteenth time, I think the jury is still out on homeopathy. As far as the valididy of meta-analyses, it depends how they're done. However, if you don't believe in them at all, you must discount the August 2005 Lancet study.

Then provide a mechanism that says it can work, with what we know about biology and chemistry? You keep ignoreing the question of water memory and all of that.

The theories of homeopathy run counter to all of modern understanding of physiology and chemistry. Please resolve this contradition.

So following science the jury is not out on anything unless there is strong evidence one in favor of it
 
Community Management of Lower Respiratory Tract Infection in Adults
A national clinical guideline

What is your point? OTC cough medicines are not claimed to be effective for lower respiratory tract infection in adults.

That you have yet to provide a link that is relevant to what I have been talking about is giving me the impression that you don't understand what I'm talking about.

Linda
 
For the umpteenth time, I think the jury is still out on homeopathy. As far as the valididy of meta-analyses, it depends how they're done. However, if you don't believe in them at all, you must discount the August 2005 Lancet study.

Fair enough, then. Some of us think there's ample evidence. One doesn't even need to be a scientist or statistician to figure out that, when prepared in the "homeopathic method," homeopathic preparations are little more than water.

Hence, for such a preparation to appear to work, it cannot be anything other than the placebo effect.

As for meta-analyses, "A good meta-analysis of badly designed studies will still result in bad statistics." -- Wikipedia.

M.
 
Saline does not relieve pain. What they where was convinced that the pain would be reduced and their body produced that effect. The naloxone blocked the psychosomatic response. Which is interesting, but Linda has explained the physiological rational for that much better than I can already.

I was addressing the feeling better/worse issue based on prior experiance and expectation and not the physiological reasons for it.
But the patient did not know the naloxone was being administered, correct? So, the patient was expecting pain relief both when it was being administered and when it was not. Thus, the experiment seems to show that the placebo effect may --at least in some instances -- involve a complex interaction between the physiological and psychological.
 
For the umpteenth time, I think the jury is still out on homeopathy. As far as the valididy of meta-analyses, it depends how they're done. However, if you don't believe in them at all, you must discount the August 2005 Lancet study.

From a scientific perspective, the jury is not out on homeopathy. As I detailed previously, since homeopathy is based on an unbelievable and implausible idea, it has no independent support. Therefore, in order to be given any serious consideration, there needs to be compelling objective evidence that there is something going on that can only be attributed to the effects of homeopathic preparations. Since the "evidence" is weak, and can be easily attributed to chance and the effects of other processes, it fails to provide any support for itself.

I see that you did not understand the detailed explanations that I provided. I'm not sure that I can do anything about that. It's a complicated topic.

Linda
 
But the patient did not know the naloxone was being administered, correct? So, the patient was expecting pain relief both when it was being administered and when it was not. Thus, the experiment seems to show that the placebo effect may --at least in some instances -- involve a complex interaction between the physiological and psychological.

The patient was experianceing what was strongly expected with the saline, just like the smell of some food can make people feel ill if they have a strong connection of illness to their experiance with the food.

So their mind was tricking itself by produceing a painkiller to block the pain, instead of mearly convicing them that it did not hurt. That is what is interesting about the effect.
 
Linda, Linda, Linda! Are you actually my old dear friend Ursula? ;)

Why are you looking for a way to discredit the person instead of the argument? Can't you just ignore me if I'm saying things that you don't want to hear?

And just to be clear, I am not Ursula (I get the distinct impression that she was not your friend <g>).

Linda
 
The patient was experianceing what was strongly expected with the saline, just like the smell of some food can make people feel ill if they have a strong connection of illness to their experiance with the food.

So their mind was tricking itself by produceing a painkiller to block the pain, instead of mearly convicing them that it did not hurt. That is what is interesting about the effect.

Yes, but evidently the psychological placebo effect goes only so far because of physiological constraints.
 
Why are you looking for a way to discredit the person instead of the argument? Can't you just ignore me if I'm saying things that you don't want to hear?
I'm not trying to discredit you, but I still don't agree with your logic regarding homeopathy studies. Yes, the 2005 Lancet study is the latest, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's the greatest. It seems to me that, to begin to fully discredit homeopathy, someone needs to methodically review the 81 of 107 studies in the 1991 British Medical Journal study and discredit the great majority of the 81. (I understand and accept your argument that some studies would produce positive results just by chance, but 81 out of 107?)

And just to be clear, I am not Ursula (I get the distinct impression that she was not your friend <g>).
Linda
I actually knew that you weren't Ursula because your writing styles are different. She used to make sarcastic remarks about almost everything I posted, until one day she abruptly stopped posting. I just can't fathom why people would make sarcastic remarks -- I would never do such a thing. ;)
 
I'm not trying to discredit you, but I still don't agree with your logic regarding homeopathy studies. Yes, the 2005 Lancet study is the latest, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's the greatest. It seems to me that, to begin to fully discredit homeopathy, someone needs to methodically review the 81 of 107 studies in the 1991 British Medical Journal study and discredit the great majority of the 81. (I understand and accept your argument that some studies would produce positive results just by chance, but 81 out of 107?)
Let's see what Professor Edzard Ernst, of the Department of Complementary Medicine at the University of Exeter, concluded when he investigated systematic reviews and meta-analysis of homoeopathy in 2002: Ernst, E: A systematic review of systematic reviews of homeopathy, Br J Clin Pharmacol. 2002 Dec;54(6):577-82:
Collectively they failed to provide strong evidence in favour of homeopathy. In particular, there was no condition which responds convincingly better to homeopathic treatment than to placebo or other control interventions. Similarly, there was no homeopathic remedy that was demonstrated to yield clinical effects that are convincingly different from placebo. It is concluded that the best clinical evidence for homeopathy available to date does not warrant positive recommendations for its use in clinical practice.
 
Edit : In fact, this is the whole problem. Many people think, as you do, that the placebo effect is just one specific thing, when it is actually a term that covers basically any bias. This is why some people claim homeopathy, for example, works above placebo because the practioner is more friendly, when in fact a friendly practioner is a placebo.

Then I must be misremembering the specific article I'm thinking of, which I thought had made a specific listing of "placebo" as one of 7 effects taking place. Maybe it was indeed a list of 7 things that are generally grouped under the term "placebo" instead?
I think this thing would be a lot simpler to discuss if I actually had a link to the article I'm thinking of. I think it was on Quackwatch ...

Okay, found it: Ay first I thought I was perhaps confusing this article about alternative therapies with this article covering the same subject, but adding a further three effects. They also have an article on placebo specifically, but that doesn't really go into specifics, and includes some effects that the other two articles list separately alongside the placebo effect.

I fear the problem with the term "placebo effect" has become that some people are using it thinking it means something it doesn't. Since placebo works whether you got your medication from a practitioner or whether you pulled it out of a vending machine, it makes sense to conclude that the practitioner isn't actually part of the placebo's effect, but a separate (although not a negligable) influence.

As such, it's not me who's misusing "placebo" wrongly, it's you who's using it to cover every form of bias that shows up during the healing process. As such, the woos are right to point out that a friendly doctor is not part of the placebo effect, although (s)he is part of the healing illusion.
It's important to make this distinction. Placebo is any apparent healing that occurs after receiving a therapy or ingesting medication that is only the result of going through the procedure of doing so, and not of the therapeutic effect of the therapy or the influence of the chemicals in the medicine specifically.

Of course, I may be wrong ...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom