Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Look, Rodney, it is up to the proponents of homoeopathy to demonstrate that it works. Off you go.
 
Would this be the psychological effect where the subject believes they are better (or worse) despite the actual efficacy (or non-efficacy) of the treatment? If so, perhaps the placebo (or nocebo) effect can be defined as the difference between what the subject/patient thinks they feel and what their true physical condition actually is?

I think that's what it boils down to. But it is difficult to tease that out from regression in many types of studies. Normally, it wouldn't really matter, since all we usually want to know is "what is the specific effect of the drug above and beyond these other effects that are not specific to the drug". It becomes an issue when you see claims made that the placebo effect represents some sort of special healing power of the mind. And I think the use of the word "effect" makes it easier for people to frame it that way.

Linda
 
Definitely. And I should have stated it differently in order to make it clear that both positive and negative studies have to be included when looking at the overall pattern. You need to take into consideration that most studies are powered so that there is a greater chance of missing a positive effect (false negative) than there is of missing a negative effect (false positive). It would be unusual and maybe even suspicious if there were no negative studies when looking at all the published studies. A statistical analysis helps you figure out what positive results you expect due to chance and what negative results you expect due to chance.

Linda
So you've done such a statistical analysis for OTC cough medicine studies? If so, at what percentage level were the composite results significant?
 
I think that's what it boils down to. But it is difficult to tease that out from regression in many types of studies. Normally, it wouldn't really matter, since all we usually want to know is "what is the specific effect of the drug above and beyond these other effects that are not specific to the drug". It becomes an issue when you see claims made that the placebo effect represents some sort of special healing power of the mind. And I think the use of the word "effect" makes it easier for people to frame it that way.

Linda
That does seem to gel with the homeopaths' claims of actual "cure", versus the reality of no effect at all. It also suggests that science and homeopaths are comparing apples and oranges: Homeopaths are taking their results from what the patients tell them they feel, whereas science uses objective gathering of medical facts. Hence the discrepancy, and thus the differences of opinion.
 
Thanks for the explanation, Linda. If I understand you correctly, the medical community now believes that the saline solution works to reduce pain either partly or entirely because it causes the production and release of opioids by the body. However, until the Benedetti study, was this the medical consensus, or was the consensus rather that the patient experienced less pain entirely because (s)he thought morphine -- and not a saline solution -- was being administered?

The research indicating that endogenous opioids were involved pre-dated Benedetti's studies (by decades). Ongoing study - including Benedetti's - serves to clarify the mechanisms. Rather than a shift in consensus, it was probably more like a gradual change from low to high consensus.

Linda
 
So you've done such a statistical analysis for OTC cough medicine studies? If so, at what percentage level were the composite results significant?

What do you mean when you say "composite results"? Are you talking about a metanalysis? Because the studies are not suitable for metanalysis - at least not for the question being asked. If you are talking about something else can you clarify your question?

Linda
 
I'd like to see the placebo effect renamed. It suggests that there is an actual physiologic effect, leading to healing independent of the usual processes. And we have no evidence that that is the case. Studies suggest that the placebo "effect" has nothing to do with healing and everything to do with a statistical artifact, plus some people fooling themselves while they get better on their own. In studies designed to look at this issue, people on placebo do not heal any faster than people that are not on placebo.
Linda, I thank you for this series of posts, in name of the rest of the lurkers. Don't worry if the original recipient doesn't appreciate them.

I was always bothered by the placebo effect, but your explanation makes perfect sense.
 
What do you mean when you say "composite results"? Are you talking about a metanalysis? Because the studies are not suitable for metanalysis - at least not for the question being asked. If you are talking about something else can you clarify your question?
Linda
I'm simply trying to figure out on what basis you have concluded that studies of the efficacy of OTC cough medicines "show a distribution that is significantly different from that expected due to chance."
 
The fact that some ingredients of OTC cough medicines appear to be slightly useful does not necessarily mean that any specific OTC cough medicine is efficacious.

I say we can easily conclude that any OTC cough medicine which contains any of the ingredients that have shown to have some useful effects can be considered useful themselves. Perhaps that doesn't mean they will be useful for all of the people all of the time, but at least they've shown themselves to have at least a smidgen of scientific backing for their claims.

So Rodney, how about you giving us an example of an OTC cough medicine that hasn't got any studies to back any of its ingredients?

(Assuming of course that you haven't done this yet during the now apparently 7 pages of this thread so far. But I bet you haven't)
 
I disagree because consumers purchase a bottle of cough medicine, not a bottle of cough medicine ingredients. To my knowledge, not a single brand (including generic brands) of cough medicine has been proven to be efficacious in a controlled study. If I'm wrong, please cite the study.

Skeptic: Fuel burns?
Rodney: Which fuel?
Skeptic: any petroleum derived fuel really.
Rodney: No, name me one particular brand of fuel that burns.
Skeptic: Ehm? 98 octane? Kerosene? Diesel? ...
Rodney: No, I mean a specific brand.
Skeptic: Shell? Exxon? BP?
Rodney: exactly, you say diesel burns, but have you actually tried burning Exxon diesel specifically?
Skeptic: But Diesel burns, we know this. Do you realize why that is a dumb thing to ask?
Rodney: No.
 
Rereading your posts, I realize I wasn't following this thread as well as I thought.

I missed that Rodney is arguing that psuedoephedrine performs differently depending upon the graphics on the outside of the bottle.

Seeing how ephedrine and pseudoephedrine are controlled substances (being an ingredient for meth) I bet you could even trace the origin of the pseudoephedrine in your cough medicine back to a specific manufacturer, and come to the conclusion that the specific batch of pseudoephedrine is exactly the same as that used in a number of commercial OTC products.

Basically, this is Rodney saying "Yes, you've shown that ice can cool a drink, and you've shown me scientific studies that back this assertion. Now show me a study that says that this particular ice that I've just made in my freezer last night will also cool my drink".

Ice is ice Rodney, pseudoephedrine is pseudoephedrine, sugar is sugar, butter is butter. In the end, they may taste a little different, but chemically, they're the same stuff.
 
The problem is your magical thinking. The names of the products are meaningless. Read the studies and read the ingredients levels. That's all that matter -- specific ingredients and specific quantities of those ingredients. They don't change simply because you use more blue dye in one brand and more yellow die in another. And it doesn't matter how many times you shake the bottle.

You know, seeing how he believes homeopathy is real, and how water can retain a memory of products it's been in contact with (don't claim you don't believe this Rodney, because you have to in order to believe homeopathy works), I can see how he would think that the colour of the cough syrup would make a difference to its effects.

Of course, despite his requests for absurd amounts of testing of real medication, he'll swallow that homeopathic cr:Dp without even blinking. Perhaps he's unaware of the fact that homeopathic concoctions are hardly tested at all. And even if they are tested at, say, 30C, they are then just randomly diluted even further to 200c without any further testing, despite his earlier insistence that even the slightest change in the formula can have devastating effects on the efficacy of a product.

Go figure ...
 
No. The meta-analysis on homeopathy concluded, "At the moment the evidence of clinical trials is positive but not sufficient to draw definitive conclusions because most trials are of low methodological quality and because of the unknown role of publication bias. This indicates that there is a legitimate case for further evaluation of homoeopathy, but only by means of well performed trials."

What do you think "low methodological quality" means?

Do you know what publication bias is? Do you understand how it could account for apparently having 15 successful studies that might actually only be the best looking ones from a whole string of studies?
As in, "we tried it 20 times, and in one of those 20 tries, we got a chance result that looked like it might be doing something, so that's the one we published".
As in: there's another 19 that didn't look so good, and of those 19 probably one that makes it seem as though homeopathy is in fact worse than placebo. But we've hidden that one in the bottom of the drawer hoping no one ever sees it.
 
I'm simply trying to figure out on what basis you have concluded that studies of the efficacy of OTC cough medicines "show a distribution that is significantly different from that expected due to chance."

If you look at the studies on OTC cough medicines (both positive and negative), the majority are positive. By the conventional standard (p<0.05), you would only expect 5 percent to be positive due to chance.

The studies that are negative have a low power - that is, the chance of a Type 2 error (false negative) is high. If the medication was ineffective, high powered studies would also be negative.

Linda
 
Thank you for summarizing my position; ;) however: Moochie started this thread because he is exercised that someone thinks a "homeopathic" OTC cough medicine works. He absolutely, incontrovertibly knows it can't work because it claims to be homeopathic. Of course, Moochie -- like me, Garrette, and everyone else here -- has no idea if the cough medicine actually even is homeopathic, let alone knowing if it works. I then noted that there is significant doubt whether non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines are efficacious. Linda pointed out that there is some evidence that they are, but it still does not seem that there is a significant benefit in taking non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines over placebos.

Wrong, there IS evidence they do better than placebo, there is just caution taken in the conclusions of the study: while these OTC cough medicines may be effective in most cases of the common cold, they have not been tested on cases of accute cough (IIRC), and may not be as effective against those.

I then noted that the evidence regarding the lack of efficacy of homeopathy in general is not quite as unequivocal as most here seem to believe, and that how homeopathy works is irrelevant to this thread.

A lack of efficacy of homeopathy in general seems, thus far, the only conclusion we can come to after 200 years of research. So what makes you still doubt?
And how homeopathy works is relevant to showing that absence of evidence may be due to absence of a possible modus operandus, which supports the absence of existence.
In any event, it's clear that the modus operandus suggested by Samuel Hahneman has been shown to be wrong when Avogadro came onto the scene.
 
So why doesn't the above logic apply to the few tests that have shown that some OTC cough medicines are efficacious?

Replicability.

Nobody has ever tried successful homeopathic tests again. and if they have, they've kept it very very silent (probably because any follow-up study forced them to conclude that homeopathy IS a placebo and nothing more, so they decided not to publish).

In fact, in homeopathy, you'll find quite a few examples of studies saying "you know, perhaps there's something there, but we need more studies to determine if the result was just statistics or an actual effect". You never hear anything about follow up studies. Some of these are over 25 years old. You'd think some homeopath somewhere might have tried to replicate the study? And yet ... nothing?
I think the reason is obvious ...
 
I'd like to see the placebo effect renamed. It suggests that there is an actual physiologic effect, leading to healing independent of the usual processes. And we have no evidence that that is the case. Studies suggest that the placebo "effect" has nothing to do with healing and everything to do with a statistical artifact, plus some people fooling themselves while they get better on their own. In studies designed to look at this issue, people on placebo do not heal any faster than people that are not on placebo.

Didn't quackwatch have an article somewhere detailing at least 7 (IIRC) different (mostly psychological) effects that are generally collected under the term "placebo" in common language but are not actually placebo at all?
It included things like bedside manners, pampering the sick person, etc... all factors that contributed to the subjective "feeling better" of the patient without actually having any curative effect whatsoever. In other words the person was still just as sick, they just feel better because the doctor had a look at them, their mom made them chicken soup and they're relaxing on the couch watching TV. You're still sick, but you feel much better than if you were still stuck in the office feeling miserable and having your boss totally oblivious to the fact you feel like s:cool:t and pile some more work on your desk.
 
The question does not necessarily have anything to do with homeopathic cough medicines, but I'm trying to learn more about the placebo effect, which could be related to homeopathy.
Please note that placebo is much more than specific healing. Placebo covers those cases where the patient would have healed anyway. Many peopla stop coughing without taking any drugs. If they had been taking drugs, you could have thought that the drug was responsible, but these cases would be covered by the placebo effect.

The placebo effect also covers misdiagnosis (where the patient suffers from a less serious ailment than diagnosed), and it covers the cases where no healing is taking place at all, but the doctor (and sometimes the patient) declares the patient "healed".

This is why the placebo effect is quite strong with animals: It does not matter that they do not know what medicine they are taking, because the owners and the vet knows, and they interpret the symptoms according to their own expectations.
 
Actually, if I remember correctly, placebo effect only specifically covers taking a non-active medical product or procedure, and getting better anyway. As such, it's only one of the several phenomena that make it seem as though a person is being helped when no actual healing is taking place. Including misdiagnosis, and several biases by the patient themselves, the physician, subjective interpretations, touchy-feely stuff, etc...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom