Homeopathic Cough Medicine

What's this got to do with whether homoeopathic cough medicines have any effect above placebo? Has a similar experiment been performed with a homoeopathic remedy, a placebo and something that blocks the effect of the homoeopathic remedy (NB: you'd have to prove the homoeopathic remedy had any effect first, of course)?
The question does not necessarily have anything to do with homeopathic cough medicines, but I'm trying to learn more about the placebo effect, which could be related to homeopathy.
 
Do the results of studies of non-homeopathic cough medicines follow approximately the same normal distribution as studies of homeopathic medicines?

No. They show a distribution that is significantly different from that expected due to chance.

Linda
 
Since most of us here are not doctors, an explanation of why the saline solution works to block pain when the naloxone is not added to it, but fails to work to block pain when the naloxone is added to it, would be appreciated.

Our body contains opioid receptors. Chemicals produced by the body (endogenous) and chemicals taken from an external source (like pharmaceuticals) (exogenous) will bind to the receptors and lead to relief of pain. There are a variety of conditions/situations that lead to the production and release of opioids by the body. Examples of opioids are endorphin (endo) and morphine (exo). Naloxone blocks the opioid receptor. If the application of a placebo was leading to pain relief which was blocked by naloxone, that suggests that at least part of the pain relief from placebo was due to the endogenous release of opioids.

Linda
 
Linda,

You are doing a marvellous job here. I'd like you to know that I really appreciate it.



eta: I've nominated your posts. :)
 
Last edited:
I second that. And, Linda, I might add you are incredibly patient and thorough. You must be one heck of a doctor!
 
Doesn't "they" include most major drug manufacturers? I would think, if companies such as Procter & Gamble (manufacturer of Vicks) are confident that non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines are superior to homeopathic ones, they would want to see that fact proven in controlled tests.

Clinical trials cost money and time. Procter & Gamble already has demonstrated that their medicines are superior to homeopathic medicines by virtue of FDA approval. They already can say "this medicine has been proven to be safe and effective, and that of a rival has not been proven to be safe and effective". They're better off spending the money on marketing.

Linda
 
The question does not necessarily have anything to do with homeopathic cough medicines, but I'm trying to learn more about the placebo effect, which could be related to homeopathy.

I'd like to see the placebo effect renamed. It suggests that there is an actual physiologic effect, leading to healing independent of the usual processes. And we have no evidence that that is the case. Studies suggest that the placebo "effect" has nothing to do with healing and everything to do with a statistical artifact, plus some people fooling themselves while they get better on their own. In studies designed to look at this issue, people on placebo do not heal any faster than people that are not on placebo.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/...Retrieve&dopt=abstractplus&list_uids=11372012
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=6369471&dopt=Citation

Linda
 

I forgot that I wanted to complain about this particular article. I've seen it referenced here a few times and find it annoying. This is what I said about it on another forum when it first came out.

"That was another fine demonstration of a journalist doing a crappy job at reporting scientific information. I think he got all the usual mistakes in there - factual errors, exaggerated importance of a single finding, miss where the real controversies lie and manufacture controversies that aren't present, present bizarre explanations/solutions while downplaying reasonable explanations/solutions, etc."

Linda
 
Last edited:
No. They show a distribution that is significantly different from that expected due to chance.
Linda
I'm not sure what you're basing that statement upon. Have you undertaken a statistical analysis of all studies of the efficacy of OTC cough medicines?
 
I'm not sure what you're basing that statement upon. Have you undertaken a statistical analysis of all studies of the efficacy of OTC cough medicines?

I reviewed the studies on cough medicines in the past so I was already familiar with the literature, and I looked at them again for this thread to refresh my memory. One expects to find a particular pattern to the results depending upon whether positive results are due to chance or due to specific effects. The pattern of results for studies of non-homeopathic cough medicines fits that due to specific effects.

Linda
 
Our body contains opioid receptors. Chemicals produced by the body (endogenous) and chemicals taken from an external source (like pharmaceuticals) (exogenous) will bind to the receptors and lead to relief of pain. There are a variety of conditions/situations that lead to the production and release of opioids by the body. Examples of opioids are endorphin (endo) and morphine (exo). Naloxone blocks the opioid receptor. If the application of a placebo was leading to pain relief which was blocked by naloxone, that suggests that at least part of the pain relief from placebo was due to the endogenous release of opioids.
Linda
Thanks for the explanation, Linda. If I understand you correctly, the medical community now believes that the saline solution works to reduce pain either partly or entirely because it causes the production and release of opioids by the body. However, until the Benedetti study, was this the medical consensus, or was the consensus rather that the patient experienced less pain entirely because (s)he thought morphine -- and not a saline solution -- was being administered?
 
I reviewed the studies on cough medicines in the past so I was already familiar with the literature, and I looked at them again for this thread to refresh my memory. One expects to find a particular pattern to the results depending upon whether positive results are due to chance or due to specific effects. The pattern of results for studies of non-homeopathic cough medicines fits that due to specific effects.

Linda
But have not a number of studies shown that OTC cough medicines performed no better than placebos? If so, don't you need to undertake an overall statistical analysis of all studies of OTC cough medicines to determine whether the composite results are significantly above chance?
 
I'd like to see the placebo effect renamed. It suggests that there is an actual physiologic effect, leading to healing independent of the usual processes. And we have no evidence that that is the case. Studies suggest that the placebo "effect" has nothing to do with healing and everything to do with a statistical artifact, plus some people fooling themselves while they get better on their own. In studies designed to look at this issue, people on placebo do not heal any faster than people that are not on placebo.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/...Retrieve&dopt=abstractplus&list_uids=11372012
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=6369471&dopt=Citation

Linda
Would this be the psychological effect where the subject believes they are better (or worse) despite the actual efficacy (or non-efficacy) of the treatment? If so, perhaps the placebo (or nocebo) effect can be defined as the difference between what the subject/patient thinks they feel and what their true physical condition actually is?
 
But have not a number of studies shown that OTC cough medicines performed no better than placebos?
(1) Which studies?

(2) Define "OTC cough medicines".

(3) What were their actual medical claims?

(3) Quantify what the "performance" measurement was.

For a start...
 
Have you?

Absolutely. I have burned the midnight oil on countless evenings undertaking a statistical analysis of all studies of the efficacy of OTC cough medicines. I just want to make sure Linda has obtained the same results as me. ;)
 
Absolutely. I have burned the midnight oil on countless evenings undertaking a statistical analysis of all studies of the efficacy of OTC cough medicines. I just want to make sure Linda has obtained the same results as me. ;)
So publish.

Here.

Now.

OK?
 
But have not a number of studies shown that OTC cough medicines performed no better than placebos? If so, don't you need to undertake an overall statistical analysis of all studies of OTC cough medicines to determine whether the composite results are significantly above chance?

Definitely. And I should have stated it differently in order to make it clear that both positive and negative studies have to be included when looking at the overall pattern. You need to take into consideration that most studies are powered so that there is a greater chance of missing a positive effect (false negative) than there is of missing a negative effect (false positive). It would be unusual and maybe even suspicious if there were no negative studies when looking at all the published studies. A statistical analysis helps you figure out what positive results you expect due to chance and what negative results you expect due to chance.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom