Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

I have a confession to make.

My real name is not johnny karate.

*waits for the Feds to kick his door in*


I may have bigger problems, I just remembered the fake phone numbers.

OMG THE PHONE COPS ARE COMING
:eek: :eek: :eek:
 
Last edited:
I hope you're right, but the circumstances around that doc stink. I don't share your confidence.

If in fact he has identified himself and claimed the document, and if in fact he forged it, then he has opened himself to charges of libel and disparagement of trade at the least, and I would expect him to be in court in short order.
 
So it didn't mater to you that the details he was "missing" were relevant, as long as there was something he didn't put in his post that's enough to question what he says?

We agree here. The details he was missing were quite relevant.

As to the law, just like with the Heartland Institute's non-profit status, we shall have to wait and see. Personally I would not be surprised it some laws were broken. Contacting an organization pretending to be a board member and obtaining documents under that false premise may or may not be illegal. But it is certainly quite different from what Ben described.
 
We agree here. The details he was missing were quite relevant.


How? we've already established there is nothing illegal or even unethical about giving a false name. It wasn't even new information as we already knew how the documents were obtained.
 
Well, it's not just HI saying this. There's plenty of circumstantial evidence that it's a fake. Not that that changes the facts in the other undisputed documents.
What circumstantial evidence? I have not seen any that is worth the electrons that put it on the web.
 
How? we've already established there is nothing illegal or even unethical about giving a false name. It wasn't even new information as we already knew how the documents were obtained.

"Established" how? By a couple posts by non-lawyers on an internet forum? You'll pardon me if I'm just a little skeptical.

Not unethical? Gleick himself disagrees with that part:
In an effort to do so, and in a serious lapse of my own and professional judgment and ethics, I solicited and received additional materials directly from the Heartland Institute under someone else's name.
Bold added for emphasis.
 
By a couple posts by non-lawyers on an internet forum? You'll pardon me if I'm just a little skeptical.
It was your claim, so no one is obliged to prove it false it was for you to prove it true. The fact that people agree it is false didn't change that
 
No, but the documents reveal that the heartland institute is funded by the fossil fuel industry. I don't expect people to work for free either, but if my doctor tells me to try these shiny new pills when the science says they're rubbish, oh and by the way the shiny pill company pays his wages, to me that is an issue.
Quantifiers matter. Heartland gets some of its funding from pertoleum-related industries. Seems to me, "the science" does not say the arguments of opponents of the "AGW is real and urgent" position are "rubbish". I cannot assess the science, so I have to take people's words for it. Many of the people who oppose the "AGW is real and urgent" position are highly credentialed in relevant fields. I suggest you start here. Also here.

Anyway, while I cannot assess the science, I can assess the behavior. The withholding of data, the selective presentation of data, the adjustment of raw data, perversion of peer review, and the calumnation of skeptics suggest to me that many advocates for the "AGW is real and urgent" position lack confidence that they can win with an honest argument.

you might want to ask yourself if you've become blinded by ideology./QUOTE]
 
This is crappola of a high order eminating from doofuses who are not climate scientists. How very apropos in a Heartland thread.
Arguments in that style discredit the voice of advocates for the "AGW is real and urgent" position, in my opinion. "Climate science" encompasses a wide range of science: astrophysics, thermodynamics, celestial mechanics, geology, plant physiology, computer modeling, statistics.
Did not like those las two? Here's another.
 
This is getting more and more interesting by the hour. I suspect that Heartland Institute is in full damage-control mode right now, and they are attempting to cloud the issue. But I will fully admit that is mostly my bias talking.

As with so-called Climategate, I am perfectly content to sit back and see what the inevitable investigations reveal. But I do find their (HI's) reaction to people blogging about it to be very revealing and quite hypocritical.

[puts blog post on hold for a bit in an effort to refine it]

:popcorn1
 
Corbyn!? Strike three.
No. From the link:...
Claude Allegre, former director of the Institute for the Study of the Earth, University of Paris
J. Scott Armstrong, cofounder of the Journal of Forecasting and the International Journal of Forecasting
Jan Breslow, head of the Laboratory of Biochemical Genetics and Metabolism, Rockefeller University
Roger Cohen, fellow, American Physical Society
Edward David, member, National Academy of Engineering and National Academy of Sciences
William Happer, professor of physics, Princeton
Michael Kelly, professor of technology, University of Cambridge, U.K.
William Kininmonth, former head of climate research at the Australian Bureau of Meteorology
Richard Lindzen, professor of atmospheric sciences, MIT
James McGrath, professor of chemistry, Virginia Technical University
Rodney Nichols, former president and CEO of the New York Academy of Sciences
Burt Rutan, aerospace engineer, designer of Voyager and SpaceShipOne
Harrison H. Schmitt, Apollo 17 astronaut and former U.S. senator
Nir Shaviv, professor of astrophysics, Hebrew University, Jerusalem
Henk Tennekes, former director, Royal Dutch Meteorological Service
Antoninio Zichichi, president of the World Federation of Scientists, Geneva
BTW, Charles Darwin was not a biologist (on paper).
 
It was your claim, so no one is obliged to prove it false it was for you to prove it true. The fact that people agree it is false didn't change that

No, you said it was "established" that it was not illegal and not unethical. I said that I was not a lawyer. So you have made the unsubstantiated claim, not I.
 
What circumstantial evidence? I have not seen any that is worth the electrons that put it on the web.

The Atlantic article that Brainster linked to makes a pretty compelling case against its authenticity:

Megan McCardle has a pretty good article on the faked document that should give real skeptics reason to doubt its veracity:

Which, again, is not to say that I think the remaining documents aren't real. But it's important that we get this right; if one of "our own" ends up having feet of clay (which I suspect may be the case) we have to be honest about it, regardless of how the deniers might crow.
 
No. From the link:...BTW, Charles Darwin was not a biologist (on paper).


The signatories of this newest letter are also worth noting for their lack of noteworthiness. Although the climate denialist blogs have labeled them "luminaries" and "prominent scientists", the list is actually quite underwhelming. In fact, it only includes four scientists who have actually published climate research in peer-reviewed journals, and only two who have published climate research in the past three decades. Nearly half of the list (at least 7 of 16) have received fossil fuel industry funding, and the list also includes an economist, a physician, a chemist, an aerospace engineer, and an astronaut/politician.

http://www.skepticalscience.com/print.php?n=1250
 
No. From the link:...BTW, Charles Darwin was not a biologist (on paper).


BTW would you take medical advice from....me? Im well read and have a decent amount of knowledge of many subjects but I dont know much about the medical field. How about letting my Secretary fix your Porsche?
You think Microsoft would let me write the programming for Windows 8 with no experience in the field?
 
BTW would you take medical advice from....me? Im well read and have a decent amount of knowledge of many subjects but I dont know much about the medical field. How about letting my Secretary fix your Porsche?
You think Microsoft would let me write the programming for Windows 8 with no experience in the field?
The problem is "the field". The "AGW is real and urgent" argument depends on many threads of evidence. Plant physiologists may assess the science behind some of the dendroclimatologists' assumptions about the relation between temperature and tree ring width, for example. Statisticians may assess the treatment of raw data. Physicists may assess assumptions about the behavior of fluid heat sinks, etc. One need not have published in their journals to assess the science.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom