Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

So your line of reasoning is that theres a big government conspiracy and somehow only the guys who have an obvious agenda have noticed and are now calling it while the rest of the world blindly plays along with the AGW hoax?
My position is: people pay advocates (Gleick has hired a lawyer). Government is not society. Scientists on the government payroll (indirectly, in the case of private universities) are no more or less immune to institutional incentives and careerist ambition than are scientists in industry or the average citizen. If Mobil or BP pays me to engage in discussions on the internet and I say "2+2=4", that does not make two plus two equal to something other than four. If "Mobil gave Heartland money, and Heartland paid for his (fill in the blank) research" is a reason to suspect the research, then "some government paid for his research" is just as much a reason to suspect the research. Motives are relevant, but that consideration applies to all.

Generally, if a decision process arrives at a conclusion with which we agree, we do not ask: "how did it arrive at that result". Consider a calculator. If my calculator ouitputs "2+2=4", no one asks "Why did it say that?" If it outputs "2+2=7 2/3", we suspect a flaw. We generally only question motives when someone disagrees with our beliefs.
 
We have to trade recommendations, right? You want me to read eight large documents. When I'm done, I'll name eight Climate Audit posts. I'm not putting any burden on you yet.

Yes, I want you to read the eight independent investigatios that you've been spreading misinformation about. You can send your eight ClimateAudit posts any time you want.

Note, this is how far we got in the last thread. Then you ran away.
 
Were you dropped on your head as an infant?

Acting childish is not going to get you anywhere.
I did not claim it was illegal. I pointed out that the HI says it is illegal and then that I am not a lawyer and thus not in a position to judge their statement.

So you were just repeating it, insisting Ben needed to put a disclaimer in his post about it but were never claiming it was true or relevant?

This is Intellectual dishonest, but seeing as you are not prepared to either support the claim or accept responsibility for making it I think we can put this to bed and dismiss it since there isn’t much more to talk about unless you are going to bring something to the table and stand behind it instead of aguing by “just saying...”
 
Yes, I want you to read the eight independent investigatios that you've been spreading misinformation about. You can send your eight ClimateAudit posts any time you want.

Note, this is how far we got in the last thread. Then you ran away.
I got bored with the partisan name calling and "AGW is real and urgent" partisans' refusal to read Steve McIntyre's Climate Audit blog (which is central, since it was McIntyre's requests for data that Jones and Mann refused).
"Ran away" is just more of that partsan name calling, coward.
 
I got bored with the partisan name calling and "AGW is real and urgent" partisans' refusal to read Steve McIntyre's Climate Audit blog (which is central, since it was McIntyre's requests for data that Jones and Mann refused).
"Ran away" is just more of that partsan name calling, coward.

So, are you going to send me the eight ClimateAudit posts any time soon? I've already given you the link to where you can find the eight independent investigations, so you'd best get crackin'.
 
We have to trade recommendations, right? You want me to read eight large documents. When I'm done, I'll name eight Climate Audit posts. I'm not putting any burden on you yet.
Oh, they won't play that game. It's like asking (not the Priests) but the docile sheeple of the congregation to read the Marquis de Sade...

Nooooooooo.......
 
Oh, they won't play that game. It's like asking (not the Priests) but the docile sheeple of the congregation to read the Marquis de Sade...

Nooooooooo.......

I am trying to play the game, but Malcolm seems reluctant.
 
I'd suggest some of the classic theoretical expositions of McIntyre, but I'm butting in here and don't intend or mean to derail the discussion.
 
I'd suggest some of the classic theoretical expositions of McIntyre, but I'm butting in here and don't intend or mean to derail the discussion.

I don't mind. You can collaborate with Malcolm on what McIntyre posts he should submit to me if you want. All I ask in return is that Malcolm reads the eight independent investigations exhonerating the climate scientists, and after reading and understanding them, that he stops misrepresenting the investigations.
 
Arguments in that style discredit the voice of advocates for the "AGW is real and urgent" position, in my opinion. "Climate science" encompasses a wide range of science: astrophysics, thermodynamics, celestial mechanics, geology, plant physiology, computer modeling, statistics.
Did not like those las two? Here's another.
AGW deniers are kind of like twoofers. They think that ecconomists have a right to a spot at the table.
 
Using a false name is one thing but to use the name of a board member to obtain documents? Folks really think that's okay?
I assume, then, that you would like to see the sludge monster Breitbart and his pet pimp up on charges for what they did to ACORN, right?
 
I assume, then, that you would like to see the sludge monster Breitbart and his pet pimp up on charges for what they did to ACORN, right?

I'm not sure about this.

Here's why.

We KNOW the cesspool hero of the Anti-Heartland morons wasn't a Board Member like he said.

But how do you KNOW that Breitbart's pet pimp was a pimp not?
 
The problem is "the field". The "AGW is real and urgent" argument depends on many threads of evidence. Plant physiologists may assess the science behind some of the dendroclimatologists' assumptions about the relation between temperature and tree ring width, for example. Statisticians may assess the treatment of raw data. Physicists may assess assumptions about the behavior of fluid heat sinks, etc. One need not have published in their journals to assess the science.

This is weak. Show that a majority of experts in each of these individual subjects who are actively publishing material related to climate science do not agree with the consensus. Wikipedia lists institutions from several fields and their statements on climate change - can you guess which way they align themselves? We already know that 97% of climate scientists believe AGW to be real and that on average, climate scientists believing AGW to be true are better qualified than those who believe it to be false. On top of that, there isn't a single major scientific institution in the world that holds a stance against AGW being real.

You've also failed to show evidence of a conspiracy by governments to falsify evidence or mislead the public. Here is an article by Monbiot showing examples of the fossil fuel industry seeking to mislead the public. On top of that, you've failed to explain why governments that would clearly benefit from climate change not being true (such as the australian government) haven't managed to convince their scientists to argue against it.

You're clutching at straws. Plenty of more detailed evidence is available in the main climate change thread.
 
This is weak. Show that a majority of experts in each of these individual subjects who are actively publishing material related to climate science do not agree with the consensus. Wikipedia lists institutions from several fields and their statements on climate change - can you guess which way they align themselves? We already know that 97% of climate scientists believe AGW to be real and that on average, climate scientists believing AGW to be true are better qualified than those who believe it to be false. On top of that, there isn't a single major scientific institution in the world that holds a stance against AGW being real.

You've also failed to show evidence of a conspiracy by governments to falsify evidence or mislead the public. Here is an article by Monbiot showing.....
Leaving aside the all knowing, keenly intelligent, progressive and elite presentation of the narrow group of selected supportive facts and opinions to buttress poorly defined premises, we have to consider the veracity of the entire summation, when the name Monbiot comes in.

Now you know when Monbiot the Moonbat's name comes up, that we've hit new lows in the lowest of low places.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KXN7esF7THs&feature=related
 
But how do you KNOW that Breitbart's pet pimp was a pimp not?
The sludge monster and Buzzard-beak both meet one of the definitions of a "pimp." Worthless slime getting paid for nothing productive and leaching off of society.

They acted with totally criminal intent to create an entirely flase impression of legitimate public service organizations. People have wrongly suffered real harm.
 
Leaving aside the all knowing, keenly intelligent, progressive and elite presentation of the narrow group of selected supportive facts and opinions to buttress poorly defined premises, we have to consider the veracity of the entire summation, when the name Monbiot comes in.

Now you know when Monbiot the Moonbat's name comes up, that we've hit new lows in the lowest of low places.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KXN7esF7THs&feature=related

Oh wow. I click "unhide post" to see if you've decided to actually contribute to the discussion for once, but nope - instead you're dismissing the opinions of the entire developed world's collection of major scientific institutions off-hand because they don't agree with your ideologically formed position, and you're summing it up with a completely unsupported ad-hominem. That is top grade conspiracy theorist thinking there, good effort.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom