Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

BTW, it appears he simply convinced them to send him the stuff, so no crime was committed whatsoever.

Heartland, however, may be in serious legal jeopardy because of the disclosures; Seems that they might actually be for-profit and so in violation of the tax laws...
I expect we will see both of these claims disproved. Dr Gleick (PhD, Berkeley, Resources and Energy) obtained the real Heartland documents through fraud (false identity) and likely fabricated the one false document. The real documents do not establish anything that puts Heartland in legal jeopardy. The false document would, if it were true put their tax-exempt status at risk. That enhances Glieck's legal jeopardy, since he's fabricating false "evidence" of a crime (if he indeed fabricated the one false document). We'll just have to wait.
 
I expect we will see both of these claims disproved. Dr Gleick (PhD, Berkeley, Resources and Energy) obtained the real Heartland documents through fraud (false identity) and likely fabricated the one false document.

Sorry, just HI's word does not constitute evidence that it was false. They are going to need evidence. As far as I can see, it is consistant with the mission of HI and similar right wing stink tanks.
 
I expect we will see both of these claims disproved. Dr Gleick (PhD, Berkeley, Resources and Energy) obtained the real Heartland documents through fraud (false identity) and likely fabricated the one false document. The real documents do not establish anything that puts Heartland in legal jeopardy. The false document would, if it were true put their tax-exempt status at risk. That enhances Glieck's legal jeopardy, since he's fabricating false "evidence" of a crime (if he indeed fabricated the one false document). We'll just have to wait.

Whats your opinion on the definitely real documents showing that "climate skeptics" such as fred singer were being funded by the fossil fuel industry, despite denying this in the past?
 
Whats your opinion on the definitely real documents showing that "climate skeptics" such as fred singer were being funded by the fossil fuel industry, despite denying this in the past?
a) Heartland is not "the fossil fuel industry".
b) I don't expect people to work for free.
c)
If Mobil or BP pays me to say "2+2=4", does that make two plus two equal something else? If funding is an issue, why is not the support that university professors receive from governments an issue?
 
Sorry, just HI's word does not constitute evidence that it was false. They are going to need evidence. As far as I can see, it is consistant with the mission of HI and similar right wing stink tanks.

Well, it's not just HI saying this. There's plenty of circumstantial evidence that it's a fake. Not that that changes the facts in the other undisputed documents.
 
BTW, it appears he simply convinced them to send him the stuff, so no crime was committed whatsoever.

Remember this part of his confession?

Given the potential impact however, I attempted to confirm the accuracy of the information in this document. In an effort to do so, and in a serious lapse of my own and professional judgment and ethics, I solicited and received additional materials directly from the Heartland Institute under someone else's name.

Bolding added for emphasis. According to Heartland:

How did this happen? The stolen documents were obtained by an unknown person who fraudulently assumed the identity of a Heartland board member and persuaded a staff member here to “re-send” board materials to a new email address. Identity theft and computer fraud are criminal offenses subject to imprisonment. We intend to find this person and see him or her put in prison for these crimes.

IANAL, but it is clear that he did not simply "convince" them to send him the stuff; more like he simply "conned" them.

Heartland, however, may be in serious legal jeopardy because of the disclosures; Seems that they might actually be for-profit and so in violation of the tax laws...

We shall see.
 
a) Heartland is not "the fossil fuel industry".
b) I don't expect people to work for free.
c)

No, but the documents reveal that the heartland institute is funded by the fossil fuel industry. I don't expect people to work for free either, but if my doctor tells me to try these shiny new pills when the science says they're rubbish, oh and by the way the shiny pill company pays his wages, to me that is an issue. If it's not an issue to you, you might want to ask yourself if you've become blinded by ideology.
 
False all around. The author of the Common room is no kook.

then prove to us that he has credentials relevant to the case in questions. So far all you've done is link to random sites on the internet and say "this guy says it so it must be true!!!"


Jones conspired to delete emails to evade FOI and rejected FOI on false grounds.
The investigation (s) didn't substantiate this accusation. Unlike the Heartland papers this accusation is false.

BTW deleting old e-mail is a perfectly acceptable and indeed recommended record keeping practice.


One investigation determined that Jones improperly rejected requests

Jones doesn't process FoI requests, there will be an FoI officer for that. Nor would any form of stature of limitations apply.

Perhaps your kook web site is simply confusing stature of limitations with time an FoI officer will keep a request open when the requester doesn't respond to their correspondence. (Something that did happen here probably because the requester was more intent of filing as many vexatious requests as possible rather than obtaining information. In fact McIntyre once posted a request on his web site that his readers file so many requests the entire CRU would have to stop it's research to respond to them)


All this is of course beside the real point which is your hypocrisy in saying the perfectly legal methods used in obtaining the heartland documents were some form if illegal search and seizure while insisting illegal hacking the University if East Anglia is ok.
 
Last edited:
Hey Malcolm...

You ran from our deal in the other thread. You promised you'd read the eight independent investigations exhonerating the climate scientists in exchange for me reading eight blog posts by McIntyre. As it seems you're still going around spreading false information about the investigations you admit you haven't read, how about we do this now?

Send me eight blog posts by McIntyre you feel are especially convincing and I'll read them. In return, you read the eight investigations. They are all available from this wiki page.
 
I have a confession to make.

My real name is not johnny karate.

*waits for the Feds to kick his door in*
 
I am finding this 8 kinds of hilarious, BTW.

Not only do we now know within reasonable doubt that all of the documents are real, but likely know the name of the Big Fish donor. I will be calling my Senators' offices tomorrow demanding an audit of Heartland's taxes, and the taxes of all of their donors.

But the egg on the face of the Conspiracy Theorists who were trying to make this all out as a hoax is worth the price of admission.
 
If Mobil or BP pays me to say "2+2=4", does that make two plus two equal something else? If funding is an issue, why is not the support that university professors receive from governments an issue?

One does actual peer-reviewed research, and the other shills for the industry. If you can't see the difference, I don't what to tell you. Some people just don't have any sense of proportion, I guess.
 
Are you really suggesting that it's illegal to use a false name?

Are you really unable to figure out what IANAL means? All I was pointing out was that Ben's description of how Gleick got the documents was missing a few details.
 
I hope you're right, but the circumstances around that doc stink. I don't share your confidence.

If in fact he has identified himself and claimed the document, and if in fact he forged it, then he has opened himself to charges of libel and disparagement of trade at the least, and I would expect him to be in court in short order.
 
All I was pointing out was that Ben's description of how Gleick got the documents was missing a few details.

So it didn't mater to you that the details he was "missing" were relevant, as long as there was something he didn't put in his post that's enough to question what he says?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom