Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

As you might imagine, Heartland was on top of "climategate" like white on rice.

Joseph Bast said:
The release of these documents creates an opportunity for reporters, academics, politicians, and others who relied on the IPCC to form their opinions about global warming to stop and reconsider their position. The experts they trusted and quoted in the past have been caught red-handed plotting to conceal data, hide temperature trends that contradict their predictions, and keep critics from appearing in peer-reviewed journals. This is new and real evidence that they should examine and then comment on publicly.
 
Heartland serves all humankind by countering climate change brainwash with the truth.

Heartland, my Heartland!
You land that gave us life.
Too long forgotten
Through years of storm and strife.

Proudly the children,
Turn homeward as before,
Weary and yearning
For dignity once more.

All for one in brotherhood,
Secure the common worth.
Guarantee the greater good
For every soul on Earth.

...
 
And why is Microsoft interfering with the public good?

I think that is a serious question they need to be asked.

It's my understanding that Heartland also lobbies for things other than climate denial and Microsoft supports them for those efforts. I just can't find the list I saw right now.
 
It's my understanding that Heartland also lobbies for things other than climate denial and Microsoft supports them for those efforts. I just can't find the list I saw right now.
That's the sort of outrageous BS that Microsoft foisted about their contributions to The Discovery Institute, as they hand money to the beards of these anti-science organizations.
 
The only other thing I can find right now is Heartland receives funding from Philip Morris's parent company to fight anti-smoking legislation.
 
I read this hours ago but just now stopped laughing long enough to post my reply.
 
Fixed for accuracy:

Megan McCardle has a pretty good article on the faked document that should give real skeptics reason to doubt its veracity:

1. All of the documents are high-quality PDFs generated from original electronic files . . . except for the "Climate Strategy" memo. (Hereinafter, "the memo"). That appears to have been printed out and scanned, though it may also have been faxed.

5. The worldview is different. In my experience, climate skeptics see themselves as a beleaguered minority fighting for truth and justice against the powerful, and nearly monolithic, forces of the establishment. They are David, to the climate scientists' Goliaths. This is basically what the authenticated documents sound like.

The memo, by contrast, uses more negative language about the efforts it's describing, while trying to sound like they think it's positive. It's like the opposition political manifestos found in novels written by stolid ideologues; they can never quite bear (or lack the imagination) to let the villains have a good argument. Switch the names, and the memo could have been a page ripped out of State of Fear or Atlas Shrugged.
 
I don't know about suing, but if the veracity of the document is in question of course it is legitimate to stop people from spreading it, as it might be libelious. I mean, if I posted on the internet a fake document that pretends to show Mr. X is a pedophile, I don't get a protection from libel just by saying, "Well, it's just purportedly fake, according to Mr. X". The "climategate" documents, on the other hand, are surely real, and nobody denied it.
 
The "climategate" documents, on the other hand, are surely real, and nobody denied it.

The context, however, was such that the papers were worthless as evidence for the position that the shrieking monkey right wanted to support by revealing them.
 
Confession of the person who illegally obtained the documents, leaves murky the issue of the allegedly phony memo:

At the beginning of 2012, I received an anonymous document in the mail describing what appeared to be details of the Heartland Institute's climate program strategy. It contained information about their funders and the Institute's apparent efforts to muddy public understanding about climate science and policy. I do not know the source of that original document but assumed it was sent to me because of my past exchanges with Heartland and because I was named in it.

Given the potential impact however, I attempted to confirm the accuracy of the information in this document. In an effort to do so, and in a serious lapse of my own and professional judgment and ethics, I solicited and received additional materials directly from the Heartland Institute under someone else's name. The materials the Heartland Institute sent to me confirmed many of the facts in the original document, including especially their 2012 fundraising strategy and budget. I forwarded, anonymously, the documents I had received to a set of journalists and experts working on climate issues. I can explicitly confirm, as can the Heartland Institute, that the documents they emailed to me are identical to the documents that have been made public. I made no changes or alterations of any kind to any of the Heartland Institute documents or to the original anonymous communication.

Heartland continues to insist the one document is phony:

An additional document Gleick represented as coming from The Heartland Institute, a forged memo purporting to set out our strategies on global warming, has been extensively cited by newspapers and in news releases and articles posted on Web sites and blogs around the world. It has caused major and permanent damage to the reputations of The Heartland Institute and many of the scientists, policy experts, and organizations we work with.

So it appears that the initial email contained the allegedly bogus document, but of course this creates some interesting questions given what McCardle wrote:

2. The date on the memo file is different from the other documents. And indeed, when you look at the information on the PDFs that Heartland acknowledges, almost all of them were created by printing to PDF on January 16th, the day before Heartland's board meeting. There is a Board Directory that was created on the 25th of January, also by printing to PDF. And then there is the memo, which was created via an Epson scanner at 3:41 PM on February 13th.

Did Gleick scan in the document from his email in an attempt to disguise the identity of his original source? He has to know that his email records will be subpoenaed in the trials that will undoubtedly follow.

ETA: Things look bad for Gleick. Apparently suspicion was already centering on him, based on similarity in writing style between things he has written and the bogus memo:

Steven Mosher first noticed language similarities, and language analysis is what led many of us studying the event to conclude Dr. Gleick was the main person of interest. Comparisons of his writing style from language specialists as well as software show strong similarities to the faked document and strongly suggest that he authored it.
 
Last edited:
ETA: Things look bad for Gleick. Apparently suspicion was already centering on him, based on similarity in writing style between things he has written and the bogus memo:
Is that the best those nitwits can offer?

Do they think it will go over any better than that crap some dirtbag tried to use as evidence that Obama's books were ghost-written? Srsly?

:dl:
 
Εr, LeftySergeant -- not arguing about the content of your posts, only noting that when every single post of yours uses crude, often explcit, expressions against people you disagree with, it's a big turn-off.
 
Is that the best those nitwits can offer?

Do they think it will go over any better than that crap some dirtbag tried to use as evidence that Obama's books were ghost-written? Srsly?

This will no doubt be the fallback party line. For now, they're sticking to "the other memo wasn't a fake!" wheeze. PZ Myers, who should know better:
How about if we focus on the content of the leaked documents instead? They do reveal a deep truth: that the Heartland Institute is a propaganda organization with great support from right-wing political organizations and individuals, and that their mission is to parcel out money to disinformation agents like Anthony Watts and Fred Singer, who sow unfounded doubt and confusion about real science. And they plan to poison American education.
He goes on to quote the most obviously bogus passage:
His effort will focus on providing curriculum that shows that the topic of climate change is controversial and uncertain- two key points that are effective at dissuading teachers from teaching science.
Cue menacing music and twisting of mustache by evil villain.
The Heartland Institute's position makes no sense if the memo was part of the package sent to Gleick. Hence it must either be in the earlier email he claims to have received, or composed by Gleick himself.

Unfortunately for Gleick, the media are not missing out on the real story. Time's EcoCentric blog:
You can read the rest here. The major question now — beyond the legal ramifications for Gleick and the Heartland Institute — is whether the original document Gleick says he received, the strategy memo, is real or whether it’s a falsification as the Heartland Institute maintains. The problem for climate advocates, of course, is that suspicion will only grow that Gleick falsified the original document now that he has admitted using deception to get the additional memos. (And just so we’re clear, this is deception — no reputable investigative reporter would be permitted to do what Gleick did. It’s almost certainly a firing offense.)
And the NY Times' Dot Earth:
Another question, of course, is who wrote the climate strategy document that Gleick now says was mailed to him. His admitted acts of deception in acquiring the cache of authentic Heartland documents surely will sustain suspicion that he created the summary, which Heartland’s leadership insists is fake.

One way or the other, Gleick’s use of deception in pursuit of his cause after years of calling out climate deception has destroyed his credibility and harmed others. (Some of the released documents contain information about Heartland employees that has no bearing on the climate fight.) That is his personal tragedy and shame (and I’m sure devastating for his colleagues, friends and family).
 
Why is it wrong to use deception to obtain documents as long as the documents are genuine and not edited (ala Breitbart)?
 
Why is it when I see an entity calling itself "the Heartland Institute" I automatically assume it's incorporated in the Netherlands Antilles for tax purposes?
 
Brainster, thanks, the points you make about the (in?)authenticity of the memo are compelling.
 
And why is Microsoft interfering with the public good?

I think that is a serious question they need to be asked.

IIRC they made a public statement as soon as the documents were leaked to the effect that they had donated no money to heartland, and that the number reflects the value of software provided under a program where non-profits can get MS software free of charge.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom