Checkmite
Skepticifimisticalationist
No. From the link:...BTW, Charles Darwin was not a biologist (on paper).
Important distinction - Charles Darwin was right.
No. From the link:...BTW, Charles Darwin was not a biologist (on paper).
The problem is "the field". The "AGW is real and urgent" argument depends on many threads of evidence. Plant physiologists may assess the science behind some of the dendroclimatologists' assumptions about the relation between temperature and tree ring width, for example. Statisticians may assess the treatment of raw data. Physicists may assess assumptions about the behavior of fluid heat sinks, etc. One need not have published in their journals to assess the science.
Which, again, is not to say that I think the remaining documents aren't real. But it's important that we get this right; if one of "our own" ends up having feet of clay (which I suspect may be the case) we have to be honest about it, regardless of how the deniers might crow.
I was about to ask whether you meant to post this to 9/11 Conspiracy Theories.The signatories of this newest letter are also worth noting for their lack of noteworthiness. Although the climate denialist blogs have labeled them "luminaries" and "prominent scientists", the list is actually quite underwhelming. In fact, it only includes four scientists who have actually published climate research in peer-reviewed journals, and only two who have published climate research in the past three decades. Nearly half of the list (at least 7 of 16) have received fossil fuel industry funding, and the list also includes an economist, a physician, a chemist, an aerospace engineer, and an astronaut/politician.
http://www.skepticalscience.com/print.php?n=1250
No, you said it was "established" that it was not illegal and not unethical. I said that I was not a lawyer. So you have made the unsubstantiated claim, not I.
Economist? Obvious. Policy choices depend on cost/benefit analysis. Also, usually, considerable statistical expertise. Chemist? Obvious, again. Retention of CO2 in the atmosphere depends on chemical reactions with soil, living things, and oceans. Engineer? Computer modeling expertise. General intelligence. Astronaut/politician?Nearly half of the list (at least 7 of 16) have received fossil fuel industry funding, and the list also includes an economist, a physician, a chemist, an aerospace engineer, and an astronaut/politician.
Of those last 5 tell me which ones have relevant expertise.........or you can pay my secretary to fix your Porsche im sure she will do a great job
Harrison H. Schmitt (Ph.D.)
NASA Astronaut (former)
PERSONAL DATA: Born July 3, 1935, in Santa Rita, New Mexico. Married to Teresa Fitzgibbon. Recreational interests writing, skiing, fishing, carpentry, hiking, handball, squash, and running.
EDUCATION: Graduated from Western High School, Silver City, New Mexico; received a bachelor of science degree in science from the California Institute of Technology in 1957; studied at the University of Oslo in Norway during 1957-1958; received doctorate in geology from Harvard University in 1964.
Nearly all professional climate scientists receive government funding.Nearly half of the list (at least 7 of 16) have received fossil fuel industry funding...
So? They are not paid to lie.Nearly all professional climate scientists receive government funding.
Using a false name is one thing but to use the name of a board member to obtain documents? Folks really think that's okay?
You brought up the claim starting in post #66, it was not being argued prior to that. You started down this line and it's yours to support. The fact that everyone else agrees your claim is wrong means you are unlikely to be able to support you contention that it's illegal to use a false name, but this doesn't chance your burden of proof.
Now are you going to retract your claim that using a false name is illegal or not?
Were you dropped on your head as an infant? Perhaps you turned blue while holding your breath in a tantrum once too often?
I did not claim it was illegal. I pointed out that the HI says it is illegal and then that I am not a lawyer and thus not in a position to judge their statement. Against which I have unsupported claims by junior prosecutors like yourself, Johnny Karate and Ben Burch that it is obviously not illegal. Personally I shall wait until we hear from Mr District Attorney himself.
McCardle is weak. She can't "think like the wolf."
So what if the memo is not in the official corporate style? This is not the kind of thing you keep in your desk drawer and haul out whern you brief a new hire. It is not part of their corporate dogma.
Assume for a moment that it is, indeed, part of their corporate dogma, and that they will lose a major investor if it leaks out. Do you think they want it to sound like something they wrote? I wouldn't.
And, if it is potentially damaging to your operation if it is found and documented on your hard drive, would you really want to do a PDF in the same format as others in a related batch of documents, or would you want to do it on a whole different comuter that you can utterly wipe and wehich may never be found or even thought of in the same context with your main server?
So, we have here documents that may have been created by an enemy to make HI look like a bunch of sneaky lying bastards, or we may have actual proof that HI are sneaky lying bastards.
My take? Hey! They're republicons. Whadda ya expect?
Gleick insists he did not alter any of the documents he got from the Chicago institute, but he could nevertheless be in legal jeopardy, according to Rory Little, professor of law at UC Hastings College of the Law and a former federal prosecutor.
"Most states have offenses for deceit if you can show there was intent to defraud," Little said. "At the very least, it's civil unlawfulness, and in many states it could be a criminal offense, depending on the elements of their common law."
Hey Malcolm...
You ran from our deal in the other thread. You promised you'd read the eight independent investigations exhonerating the climate scientists in exchange for me reading eight blog posts by McIntyre. As it seems you're still going around spreading false information about the investigations you admit you haven't read, how about we do this now?
Send me eight blog posts by McIntyre you feel are especially convincing and I'll read them. In return, you read the eight investigations. They are all available from this wiki page.
I read slowly.*clears throat*
Nearly all professional climate scientists receive government funding.
I wondered about this, too. Perhaps it makes a difference if the victim of the deception would have provided the information to a generic human or not. Intent also makes a difference, and the forgery provides evidence of an intent to harm Heartland, seems to me. Perhaps Gleick's action would have been legal against the Gambino syndicate, or an industry illegally pumping toxic waste into the ground, or a Madoff-style ponzi scheme. If that is the case, the defense has the burden of proof.If pretending to be someone you're not in order to gain information about a non-profit is illegal, then why isn't James O'keefe in prison? Can you not remember tens or hundreds of these kinds of actions on your own without waiting for a prosecutor? It's illegal to give a false name when asking a question? How's Jeff Gannon doing these days, eh?