Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

Megan McCardle has a pretty good article on the faked document that should give real skeptics reason to doubt its veracity:

That article is quite compelling. I'm going to remain skeptical over whether that memo is real and hope more information comes to light. The real story does appear to be that "climate skeptics" who have denied being funded by the fossil fuel industry have in fact been funded by the fossil fuel industry, though.

Monbiot's take.
 
Why is it wrong to use deception to obtain documents as long as the documents are genuine and not edited (ala Breitbart)?
Okay. Why do the police need a warrant to search your "person, property, papers, and effects"? Can we see your medical records and last five years of tax returns?

What's surprising that some allies fund Heartland and that Heartland funds some allies? If Mobil or BP pays me to say "2+2=4", does that make two plus two equal something else? If funding is an issue, why is not the support that university professors receive from governments an issue?

I predict that by the time Heartland is through with Gleick, he will have confessed to fabricating the summary document.

There are lies, damned lies, and Higher Truth.
I would like to sympathize, but given the mendacity and malice of so many people who take the "it's real and urgent" position on the AGW discussion, it's sweet to see an ostentatiously credentialed liar go down.
Here's BWoods: (read the whole thing)
So this is where Peter has infuriated me, for someone in his position, his refusal to substantiate PUBLIC statement, when he is asked to back up his statement.. ie pg number, url, ref, and reasoning, as it seems to be a worrying attitude that appear to frequently expressed within ‘climate change science’

To be willing to substantiate something is something ANY student would expect of their teacher, or public figure, and Peter is both.
 
IIRC they made a public statement as soon as the documents were leaked to the effect that they had donated no money to heartland, and that the number reflects the value of software provided under a program where non-profits can get MS software free of charge.
Hmm, it makes sense because I don't see their motivation. I've been PO'ed ever since I learned about Microsoft donations to Discovery, and I was informed by a PR person (don't recall if it was an MS employee or an employee of their agency) that the contributions were for a Discovery initiative having to do with transportation, which impressed me as BS in some respect or another.

I'm going to try to confirm the nature of the Heartland and Discovery donations. Here's MS licensing policy. Non-profits don't get software for free, but they do get a deep discount.
 
We have no proof one way or the other.

Since the other documents are of undoubted veracity, I side with the remaining document being real too.

Not necessarily. It's not uncomon for fake documents to be planted with genuine ones precisely so as to have them gain crediblity this way. I agree we don't really known, though.
 
Okay. Why do the police need a warrant to search your "person, property, papers, and effects"? Can we see your medical records and last five years of tax returns?


It’s hypocritical to make such a statement despite the fact that just over a month you were appealing to the authority of bloggers posting cherry picked excerpts from stolen documents.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7936701#post7936701

Actually, on review we don’t even need to go back to see your hypocrisy. Because in the very same post where you linked to a site dedicated to spreading misleading excepts from stolen documents.

 
Okay. Why do the police need a warrant to search your "person, property, papers, and effects"?

First, a journalist is not the police. Second, the police can lie to you if they're trying to catch you in a crime.

Again, the question is whether or not the documents are real. And HI confirms that they are, except for one memo which they claim is a forgery.

The more important thing is that they claimed for years to have no ties to oil companies or lobbyists, but yet here they are taking millions from oil companies and a secret, special person whose identity is hidden.

I wonder if that person will turn out to be an oil guy?
 
Εr, LeftySergeant -- not arguing about the content of your posts, only noting that when every single post of yours uses crude, often explcit, expressions against people you disagree with, it's a big turn-off.
When I am dealing with criminal elements pretending to be a legitimate political association, I will refer to them as I would a criminal organization.

I am hearing "Be polite when you talk about Mr Schickelgruber."
 
(Unabogie): "Why is it wrong to use deception to obtain documents as long as the documents are genuine and not edited1 (ala Breitbart)?"
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "Okay. Why do the police need a warrant to search your "person, property, papers, and effects"? Can we see your medical records and last five years of tax returns?"
(lomiller): "It’s hypocritical to make such a statement2. despite the fact that just over a month you were appealing to the authority of bloggers posting cherry picked3 excerpts from stolen documents4".http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7936701#post7936701
Actually, on review we don’t even need to go back to see your hypocrisy. Because in the very same post where you linked to a site dedicated to spreading misleading excepts5 from stolen documents.
(Malcolm): Bwoods
1. Does "unabogie" refer to Shirley Sherrod? Breitbart says he relayed the entire clip that came to him; that he edited nothing. The clip he posted actually put Sherrod in a positive light, rather courageously telling a story against herself. It was the approving reaction of the NAACP audience, halfway through the story (that is, the part she regretted), that was Breitbart's target, not Sherrod.
2. There's no "statement" here. I asked a question. There is an implied statement: for whatever reason illegal searches are illegal, it's illegal to obtain "papers and effects" by fraud (identity theft).
3. "Cherry picked" implies an unrepresentative sample. If someone murders a spouse, is it "cherry picking" his interactions with other people for the prosecutor to ignore, in making his case, all the other non-lethal interactions the accused has had?
4. Dunno 'bout "stolen". We wander into a grey area here. The UEA emails were apparently leaked by an insider. Someone apparently had authorized access but not authorization to distribute the emails.
5. What's "misleading"? Can you point to a falsehood in any of the posts of that blog?
(Unabogie): "First, a journalist is not the police1. Second, the police can lie to you if they're trying to catch you in a crime2.
Again, the question is whether or not the documents are real. And HI confirms that they are, except for one memo which they claim is a forgery.
The more important thing is that they claimed for years to have no ties to oil companies or lobbyists, but yet here they are taking millions3 from oil companies and a secret, special person whose identity is hidden.
I wonder if that person will turn out to be an oil guy?
"

1. We agree. My point still stands. The authors of the US Constitution evidently thought that privacy deserved respect. That's an answer to: "Why is it wrong to use deception to obtain documents as long as the documents are genuine..."
2. Under some circumstances. They have to have reason to suspect you of a crime. They cannot legally obtain a citizen's private papers simply to look for some unspecified crime. What crime has Heartland committed?
People might be less enthusiastic about making such allegations if they used their names in these discussions.
3. Oh? Heartland reports total donations of $3,293,371 from all donors giving more than $10,000. Where do you get this "millions from oil companies"?
 
1. Does "unabogie" refer to Shirley Sherrod? Breitbart says he relayed the entire clip that came to him; that he edited nothing. The clip he posted actually put Sherrod in a positive light, rather courageously telling a story against herself. It was the approving reaction of the NAACP audience, halfway through the story (that is, the part she regretted), that was Breitbart's target, not Sherrod.
That the sludge monster tried to smear NAACP is the least of his crimes.
2. There's no "statement" here. I asked a question. There is an implied statement: for whatever reason illegal searches are illegal, it's illegal to obtain "papers and effects" by fraud (identity theft).
So HI cannopt be brought up on criminal charges. The sludge monster and his pimp, by contrast, tried to have ACORN criminally prosecuted. Nobody is trying to have HI criminally prosecuted. They are just being subjected to public scrutiny because some insider decided that they would no longer assist in the unethical activities of HI.
 
From The Common Room:...
It's instructive to consider the difference between this and the ClimateGate emails.
With Climate Gate the skeptical blogosphere took time to make sure what they had was authentic. DeSmog blog had a complete post with many background links up in an hour. Nobody asked Heartland to comment.
With ClimateGate private contact information was redacted. Not true with Heartland's stolen documents.
With ClimateGate, the e-mails came from computers and servers paid for by taxpayer dollars, were written by people paid for by the public, doing work paid for by the public and were legitimate topics of FOIA requests illegally denied.. Heartland is a private organization that runs on private donations.
With ClimateGate, there is every reason to believe this was a leak from within.No investigation has shown any 'hacking.' With Heartland, within days we have a half baked confession to fraud.
The NYT refused to print the ClimateGate emails because they alleged they were stolen documents. The Heartland documents are stolen, the theif admits it, and the NYT printed them without questioning their accuracy.
With ClimateGate, the skeptics provided the ISP of the anonymous FOIA sender of the emails. That did not happen with FakeGate. Warmists covered up for the thief.
 

Again why don’t you make your own claims instead if linking to random internet bloggers? The fact that you can find kooks on the internet that are willing to say something doesn’t make it true. What remains true is that you oppose such leaks when you think it supports your ideology, but support them when you are told to support them in support of your ideology.



As for the specific claimed you bothered to quote, they are in fact false. For example:
Climate deniers did not in fact “wait to verify the e-mails” they began circulating excerpts within hours of them being uploaded to a Russian web server.

(they did however take time to find out of context quotes they could use to manipulate people such as yourself who were willing to belvie anything without actually reading the e-mails. In later attempts they took time to remove context like when the e-mail was sent and to whom in an attempt to hide the actual discussion taking place in them, something that tripped them up the first time around when reading the e-mails showed the claims being made of their contents were false.)

Private information was not “redacted” in fact nothing was redacted at first nor was there much in the way of private information to begin with. Later on, once they were repeatedly caught quoting things out of context they tried redacting things to hide the context.

Contrary to their claims these were university computers, not government computers the documents were stolen from. Not that stealing government information is a legitimate out; in fact it may well have been a more serious crime.

These documents were evaluated for release under FoI and the FOI requests were rejected. This discussion was supported by subsequent investigations, so despite what your “expert” (AKA internet kook) claims there was no legal case for these documents to be released.
 
In law, there is a principle of lesser harm. That is, it's a defense against an accusation of criminal activity if the accused can establish that his activity was the lesser evil. For example, if you break a window and hotwire a car to get an injured friend to a hospital for emergency attention, and your friend had a genuine emergency and there was no other transportation available, a cop may refuse to arrest, he may arrest and the prosecutor may reffuse to indict, a prosecutor amy indict and a judge may dismiss the case without a trial, or the case may go to trial and a jury may find "not guilty". I suspect we all accept that this "greater harm" argument applies in some cases. We differ as to which cases.
 
Again why don’t you make your own claims instead if linking to random internet bloggers? The fact that you can find kooks...
Why don't you make an argument without insulting people?
...These documents were evaluated for release under FoI and the FOI requests were rejected1. This discussion was supported by subsequent investigations, so despite what your “expert” ... claims there was no legal case for these documents to be released2.
1. Yes. Illegally.
2. Phil Jones escaped prosecution for "statute of limitations" reasons.
 
BTW, it appears he simply convinced them to send him the stuff, so no crime was committed whatsoever.

Heartland, however, may be in serious legal jeopardy because of the disclosures; Seems that they might actually be for-profit and so in violation of the tax laws...
 
Leaker is known. Corroborated authenticity beyond doubt; http://www.real-science.com/gleick-hero-desmogblog

Heartland OWNED.

Yeah, but it's unfortunate for everyone involved that he (probably) faked the policy document. I don't look forward to all of the "See! You AGW alarmists are FRAUDS!!1!" comments I'll no doubt get while arguing this debate elsewhere. The information was damning already -- why release a fraudulent document, and cast unecessary doubt on your cause?
 
Why don't you make an argument without insulting people?


Telling you that links to random intent kooks don’t cut it as an argument isn’t an insult it’s a statement of fact.
1. Yes. Illegally.


Umm no. The fact that the FoI requests were rejected show they were examined and rejected in accordance with the law. The fact that you can find internet kooks who want to make up their own laws doesn’t change this.

2. Phil Jones escaped prosecution for "statute of limitations" reasons.
Multiple investigations confirmed ther4e were no wrongdoings on his part so “statute of limitations” are irrelevant. He worked entirely within the law.

The only crimes committed were committed by the hackers, though there was certainly an intent on the part of your bloggers to violate intellectual property laws by publishing data they did not own.

All this differs from the current case where apparently heartland was convinced to send the documents to a third party without getting an NDA in place and the third party then released them.
 
Telling you that links to random intent kooks don’t cut it as an argument isn’t an insult it’s a statement of fact. ..Umm no. The fact that the FoI requests were rejected show they were examined and rejected in accordance with the law. The fact that you can find internet kooks who want to make up their own laws doesn’t change this.
Multiple investigations confirmed there were no wrongdoings on his part so “statute of limitations” are irrelevant. He worked entirely within the law.
The only crimes committed were committed by the hackers, though there was certainly an intent on the part of your bloggers to violate intellectual property laws by publishing data they did not own.
All this differs from the current case where apparently heartland was convinced to send the documents to a third party without getting an NDA in place and the third party then released them.
False all around. The author of the Common room is no kook. Jones conspired to delete emails to evade FOI and rejected FOI on false grounds. One investigation determined that Jones improperly rejected requests but that he could not be prosecuted on "statute of limitations" grounds.

Look, ma, no insults to parties in this discussion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom