(
Unabogie): "
Why is it wrong to use deception to obtain documents as long as the documents are genuine and not edited1 (ala Breitbart)?"
(
Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "
Okay. Why do the police need a warrant to search your "person, property, papers, and effects"? Can we see your medical records and last five years of tax returns?"
(
lomiller): "
It’s hypocritical to make such a statement2. despite the fact that just over a month you were appealing to the authority of bloggers posting cherry picked3 excerpts from stolen documents4".
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7936701#post7936701
Actually, on review we don’t even need to go back to see your hypocrisy. Because in the very same post where you linked to a site dedicated to spreading misleading excepts
5 from
stolen documents.
(Malcolm):
Bwoods
1. Does "unabogie" refer to Shirley Sherrod? Breitbart says he relayed the entire clip that came to him; that he edited nothing. The clip he posted actually put Sherrod in a positive light, rather courageously telling a story against herself. It was the approving reaction of the NAACP audience, halfway through the story (that is, the part she regretted), that was Breitbart's target, not Sherrod.
2. There's no "statement" here. I asked a question. There is an implied statement: for whatever reason illegal searches are illegal, it's illegal to obtain "papers and effects" by fraud (identity theft).
3. "Cherry picked" implies an unrepresentative sample. If someone murders a spouse, is it "cherry picking" his interactions with other people for the prosecutor to ignore, in making his case, all the other non-lethal interactions the accused has had?
4. Dunno 'bout "stolen". We wander into a grey area here. The UEA emails were apparently leaked by an insider. Someone apparently had authorized access but not authorization to distribute the emails.
5. What's "misleading"? Can you point to a falsehood in any of the posts of that blog?
(
Unabogie): "
First, a journalist is not the police1. Second, the police can lie to you if they're trying to catch you in a crime2.
Again, the question is whether or not the documents are real. And HI confirms that they are, except for one memo which they claim is a forgery.
The more important thing is that they claimed for years to have no ties to oil companies or lobbyists, but yet here they are taking millions3 from oil companies and a secret, special person whose identity is hidden.
I wonder if that person will turn out to be an oil guy?"
1. We agree. My point still stands. The authors of the US Constitution evidently thought that privacy deserved respect. That's an answer to: "Why is it wrong to use deception to obtain documents as long as the documents are genuine..."
2. Under some circumstances. They have to have reason to suspect you of a crime. They cannot legally obtain a citizen's private papers simply to look for some unspecified crime. What crime has Heartland committed?
People might be less enthusiastic about making such allegations if they used their names in these discussions.
3. Oh? Heartland reports total donations of $3,293,371 from
all donors giving more than $10,000. Where do you get this "millions from oil companies"?