Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

Interesting take on this general problem...."Noble Cause Corruption"

http://www.policeone.com/chiefs-she...use-corruption-Do-the-ends-justify-the-means/

Oh.

It appears the phrase "noble cause corruption" was coined by Steve McIntyre regarding Climategate.

I'm sure the local AGW fanatics can stomach still using it to describe phenomena to which it applies?

;)
No doubt it's this post of mine that caused the descent into ad hominems. This post may be considered insulting for two reasons:

(A) it suggests reading something and acknowledging a concept brought forth by McIntyre
(B) it references "the local AGW fanatics" as, well, AGW fanatics.

Well, tough if it offends your little basket of feelings. I think it's a useful concept, and in line with the OP of the thread. And I suggest if you are a AGW fanatic, be proud of it. It's a serious business, saving the world. Someone's got to do it.
;)
 
It's a serious business, saving the world. Someone's got to do it.
;)
And right now you have half the republicons whining about how much it will cost and the other half saying that we don't need to worry because Jesus will be along shortly to fix it, and just about all of them questioning whether it is such a problem in the first place.
 
MHaze would rather, if the world needs saving, that nobody do it. I mean, his political party believes in End Times, right? Immanentizing the Eschaton is so much fun, isn't it, MHaze?

Thanks, you brought in a word I had to look up to see what it means - "Eschaton" (why do I keep wanting to read it "Shatatron".... )

Ben, you could have a point there of a sort. IF some religious group had a preachiness about the imminent apocalypse, then they obviously would view the glassy-eyed AGW fanatics (with their end of the world) as competition, and visa versa. Each would want to have control over the end of the world panic, hysteria and alarmism.

I'm not sure what that means, except to those of us that view all the alarmism and hysteria as equally ridiculous...
 
Exactly, so why did you get it wrong?
Perhaps you need to read the post again. Lomiller's form was "You are __X__."
I suggested "He is __X__".
Also, I'm not sure that ad hominem has to involve insults. Arguing to the man could mean addressing characteristics of the audience ("agree with me because I will flatter you"), seems to me.
In any case, this is not an argument about Heartland or climate science, but about insults. As some wise party suggested, it belongs in another thread.
 
The subject is Heartland.
Not if some pleasant aspects of the subject make the liberally inclined skittish of the basic OP. Then they find it necessary to derail, insult, or misdirect the subject. Ad hom and ridicule are the preferred tactics.

First, in this thread, we found Lomiller and some others go suddenly quiet on their stand that Glieck had "broken no laws". Second, I introduced the concept of - of "Noble Cause Corruption" - from the Great Satan Himself, Steve McIntyre .

Obviously, this has provoked the outbursts and derails and the responsibility lies with those who have dared to bring these arguments in, just as Glieck is faultless, and Heartland is fully culpable.

:rolleyes:
 
Not if some pleasant aspects of the subject make the liberally inclined skittish of the basic OP. Then they find it necessary to derail, insult, or misdirect the subject. Ad hom and ridicule are the preferred tactics.

First, in this thread, we found Lomiller and some others go suddenly quiet on their stand that Glieck had "broken no laws". Second, I introduced the concept of - of "Noble Cause Corruption" - from the Great Satan Himself, Steve McIntyre .

Obviously, this has provoked the outbursts and derails and the responsibility lies with those who have dared to bring these arguments in, just as Glieck is faultless, and Heartland is fully culpable.
You say that becaure you___ (fill in the blank).
 
You say that becaure you___ (fill in the blank).
Yes! It's a Glieck like moment, where as he realized that Heartless Heartland was at fault for all his crimes, where I realize that all the vindictive pettiness and idiocracy of people I come into contact with is of course, all strictly my fault. Forget individual responsibility for things you do. Big government tells you want to do and like a sheeple, you obey. Since you have no free will, bad people can and do influence what you do. After all, who is at fault for your eating cheeseburgers and greasy fries?

You know it's Exxon, Koch, and designated agents infiltrating the internet. And at the core is the Heartland of Darkness.
 
I know it's fox news. I know the wimps of the left despise it. That's why I posted it. Yes, I could have found the issue on an "acceptable" website or source. But no....you guys want to quote jerk offs like mediamatters. Well...

Here YA GO!

Media Matters chief David Brock paid a former domestic partner $850,000 after being threatened with damaging information involving the organization’s donors and the IRS –

Read more: http://www.foxnews.com/politics/201...tner-850g-blackmail-settlement/#ixzz1nd9n2ncL

But it's a "noble cause", so I am sure that whatever their donors are is well and good.

;)
 
Last edited:
Media Matters chief David Brock paid a former domestic partner $850,000 after being threatened with damaging information involving the organization’s donors and the IRS –


When I first read this, I thought it was off-topic. Then I realized mhaze is suggesting an analogy between Brock's situation and the Heartland Institute's.

In mhaze's analogy, the Heartland Institute is being threatened with release of "damaging information involving the organization's donors and the IRS", and should deal with the situation by paying $850,000 to Peter Gleick.

That seems silly to me, but so do most of mhaze's analogies.
 
When I first read this, I thought it was off-topic. Then I realized mhaze is suggesting an analogy between Brock's situation and the Heartland Institute's.

In mhaze's analogy, the Heartland Institute is being threatened with release of "damaging information involving the organization's donors and the IRS", and should deal with the situation by paying $850,000 to Peter Gleick.
....

Why, that's exactly right. ACCORDING TO....

the naive, faithful, and vicious hysterical AGW believers....

Actually it's a sort of joke.

I've listened to Brock, and for a variety of reasons think he's quite disturbed. Gleick, though, seems to have just had a bad AGW month.

Of one sort or another, we all have a bad month here and there. However, if you want to consider organization to organization, yes, the blackmail threat to Block appears to directly imply the organization (considered separately from Block's problems) is bad.

The speculation in this thread about Heartland being "bad" was only speculation, but was carried to the definitely - interesting - buzz level repeatedly.

Media Matters, I think deserves at least equal time.

Oh...wait....they are "the good guys"?

Noble Cause Corruption!
 
Thanks, you brought in a word I had to look up to see what it means - "Eschaton" (why do I keep wanting to read it "Shatatron".... )

Tell me, ye faithless lawyers. Do I have a good suit for defacement of my name in this, or do I have to wait until mHaze drops a "d" into it?
 
Tell me, ye faithless lawyers. Do I have a good suit for defacement of my name in this, or do I have to wait until mHaze drops a "d" into it?
Forsight, answer I cannot, laying no such claim to lawyerness of soul. Best to go seek those spinball lizards of law, and nail said rats of law to the court house door, along with papers as to such redress and compensation as ye seek.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom