Have you changed any major belief as an adult?

When I was 15 years old I deconstructed my mental framework and started all over. Nothing was certain for me from then on. I held beliefs although much less tightly than before. I changed lots of beliefs after I was 18. The amount of woo that I considered plausible has gone way down since then. But as far as major belief changes not really any. The beliefs I had were not a major part of my beliefs and only held tentatively due to an incorrect hypothesis and lack of information.
 
In order :

I have lost these major beliefs

Santa, Easter Bunny, Tooth fairy age 6
Christianity age 12
UFO’s, Ghosts etc age Early 20’s
All other paranormal guff Late 20’s

My latest is however Global warming sceptic.

I was pretty sure up until a year ago that man had minimal or no influence on Global warming. I have since been convinced that putting carbon into the atmosphere DOES have an effect. I still remain sceptical as to the level of the effect but even if it is 10 % that is still bad and correctable.

I was quite proud of myself abandoning this long held tenet.. shows I can still think critically !
 
Last edited:
Oh, I've also learned that people can fool themselves into believing just about anything, and those same people have a very difficult time accepting simple evidence and logic. I used to think everyone was fairly sane, but I've come to realize that a large portion of the planet is suffering from some sort of low-grade insanity. I just haven't figured out why yet.


I saw Christopher Hitchens on CSPAN and he theorized this had something to do with the fact that homo sapiens have (something very close to) "a chimpanzee brain".
 
I used to think everyone was fairly sane, but I've come to realize that a large portion of the planet is suffering from some sort of low-grade insanity. I just haven't figured out why yet.

As I always say evolution provides adequate, not perfect solutions.

People can survive perfectly well suffering from all manner of ills internal and external. The human mind is no less immune to this.
 
I think that like this life, the truth is somewhere embedded in the myth. There may indeed have been a holy man with that name - who knows. Sometimes I wonder whether there would be such a thing as Christianity if it wasn't for Saul's sunstroke.
Well, if you ever get around to watching, "The God That Wasn't There", let me know if you've reconsidered the Saul story was a myth also. Because I think it probably was.

I don't quite know how to merge the evidence as carefully laid out in the film with our modern experiences of religions begun by actual individuals, and I don't know if Mohammad was a real or mythical person. We have evidence of both in history. Surely Zeus and his lightning bolts was a myth from the beginning. People of the day however, believed these figures were real. Yet Joseph Smith and L Ron Hubbard clearly were not myths though Smith's tablets and special glasses are mythical.
 
Something else sprang to mind - it was quite a hurdle for me at the time. ... I found it most distressing that despite trying to reason politely with an apparently educated human being, logic utterly escaped him. Logic and compassion both. I found this a turning point for me. Naive as I once was in thinking that an education provided anyone with intelligence. I won't make that mistake again.
I ran into this when my son wanted to drop chemistry in 9th grade. The Dean was convinced the right thing to do was force the kids to not give up as he saw it. From my perspective my son already had high school credit for advanced classes in middle school, he was depressed, 9th grade is especially stressful for kids and it was absurd that one size fits all (all the freshmen had heavy class loads). The Dean refused and I said, fine, I'll get his doctor to order it based on depression and stress. The Dean had no choice, my son dropped chemistry. He graduated this year, starts college in a month and dropping that class had zero negative impact on him.

But I didn't have to change to be this way. I was born into it. ;) Don't let the people in charge of the school have total control. They have the right to some, but it's a myth you have no say in matters. Go to the school superintendent and get a second opinion on options for your child. If you are in the US, schools have an obligation to protect kids from bullies at school. Don't be afraid to make a big issue of it. It is a big issue.
 
Last edited:
Since the age of 9 I have had unusual experiences. I majored in science at school and spend more time reading non-fiction so it was easier for me when I was younger to dismiss them. Not so easy now. This is only one experience of many, this one was witnessed by my live-in partner.

My first love at 15 was Alan Paterson. It was an intense emotional relationship. Ive been happily married, divorced, fell in love again since then.

I was sleeping, my eyes flew open and a female face in the top right of my vision, in a small spotlight (ive seen her since), told me Alan was dying. I felt that I then awoke (I hadnt). Still dreaming but on what felt like a different level, I called Alan's mother (in reality I havent had any contact with any of them for over 30 years). I asked if it was true, she said he was very poorly, didnt have long.

I said I wanted to see him. She said it would upset me too much, he was in such a bad way. I said she had to understand that I HAD to see him (I had been warned in a dream for a reason). She was silent for a second then said I could come.

I "found myself" at the side of the house I used to visit as a teenager. There was a wheelchair there. It was red and had motors, stripes, badges etc all over it. I thought "trust Alan to have a wheelchair with go-faster stripes". I found myself standing in a darkened bedroom. I stood in the doorway and saw a single bed against the same wall with a figure I didnt recognise in it. Black hair? I thought "this is a dream, I cannot really be standing here" but felt there had to be a purpose.

I sat down on a chair(?) by the bed feeling rather silly. I hadn't a clue what I was supposed to do next. For some daft reason, I lay my cheek against his. After a few moments, there grew the MOST overwhelming and wonderful feeling of love which made me cry. It dissipated and I noticed he'd stopped breathing and I woke up crying.

It was a lovely sunny Sunday morning. My partner was worried. I told him the whole thing, I was still crying. I felt very uncomfortable all Sunday and most of Monday. By the Tuesday I was fine. I read the local paper.

NOT in the death notices but in a column elsewhere there was a story of Alan George Paterson who had been in a car crash three years previously (and confined to a wheelchair since) had died of complications on the Sunday night. He was the same age as my Alan. He used to work in a distillery in Rothes and lived with his mother since his divorce. He died in his mother's home.

This column has to be on record in the press archives. Alan George Paterson was not my Alan JAMES Paterson who is alive and well and apparently living with his third wife. I read the article to my partner who had already been witness to other things. I felt that I had turned a corner, I had to accept that I was developing some sort of unusual ability. I wondered WHY? Someone suggested that perhaps Alan George was dying alone - he'd sent out some sort of cry for help and while I slept, I recognised the name and went there to help him pass over. Nice thought, if true. Although the experience was astounding in itself, the sensation of love that was present as he breathed his last is a memory I will never forget.

Id seen the woman in the spotlight before. She came to me one night to tell me my sister was terminally ill. I woke up feeling "uncomfortable" - its difficult to describe the sensation. My sister had just moved into a flat in Peterhead about 2 hours drive away and I didnt have a car. She hadnt switched on her phone yet. No-one could contact her. I visited my mother who hadnt heard from my sister. I was worried but I wasn't convinced at that point I had experienced anything other than a dream.

Two days later my sister called. She told me, without prompt, that two nights previously she had been very ill over the weekend. She'd had a bug and that night it had gotten to the stage that blood was pouring out of her when she went to the toilet. She lay there believing she was dying. She thought that night of who would find her body, how decomposed it would be by the time anyone came to check she was alright. Luckily she recovered.

Taking the two experiences into account and considering all the other things I'd experienced I am left in no doubt that there's more to the human experience than science can "prove".
Paragraphs...just a suggestion. Some of us read a lot of posts and it's hard to read large blobs of words.
 
Oh yes. Thanks!!! I meant to answer this, but... I just didn't manage to read through it :covereyes
Sorry about the blobs but I couldnt really do justice to the tale giving the short version. I look forward to hearing folks' opinion. Bring it on!
 
Sorry about the blobs but I couldnt really do justice to the tale giving the short version. I look forward to hearing folks' opinion. Bring it on!
Short version? I didn't delete a single word I just divided it into paragraphs.
 
Sorry about the blobs but I couldnt really do justice to the tale giving the short version. I look forward to hearing folks' opinion. Bring it on!

It wasn't the length, I am quite capable of reading long texts, it was the non-exisiting paragraphs that did me in, I'm afraid. Well, I am off to bed now, but I'll get back to you when I wake up again.
 
Taking the two experiences into account and considering all the other things I'd experienced I am left in no doubt that there's more to the human experience than science can "prove".

But don't you think that given the almost infinite number of coincidences that could happen, it would be suprising not to have experiences like these every now and again?
 
But don't you think that given the almost infinite number of coincidences that could happen, it would be suprising not to have experiences like these every now and again?
I think these were too specific to be mere coincidence.
 
I think these were too specific to be mere coincidence.

The probability that a very specific coincidence will happen to someone, somewhere is very high. It happened to you. You shouldn't be freaked out by it.

Also, I find that the dreams I have are very volatile in my mind immediately after waking... unless I tell someone about the dream there and then, or note it down, then it very quickly corrupts in my mind. I would take any coincidence that involved a dream with a pinch of salt - perhaps by reading the paper you reinforced the parts of your dreams that were a match, and discarded those that weren't. In any case, the squishy stuff in our heads isn't a particularly reliable recorder of events.

One question.... do you have a clock radio?
 
Most of my dreams are entirely ordinary and forgettable on waking. These "dreams" are different. They are clear as day, precise and detailed. I didn't delude myself by matching facts to a fuzzy memory. I don't have a need to be special and I dont listen to any radio. Even if I did, the death of a distillery worker might make the village rag but never the national news. I take EVERYthing with a pinch of salt and have some understanding of psychology (and philosophy). When I say "some understanding" I mean I havent a degree - yet. I checked off an awful lot more "hits" than a mere one-off coincidence.

I hold down quite a demanding job and would hope that I'm capable of remembering what I did yesterday accurately or I'll be in trouble :o)
 
Most of my dreams are entirely ordinary and forgettable on waking. These "dreams" are different. They are clear as day, precise and detailed. I didn't delude myself by matching facts to a fuzzy memory. I don't have a need to be special and I dont listen to any radio. Even if I did, the death of a distillery worker might make the village rag but never the national news. I take EVERYthing with a pinch of salt and have some understanding of psychology (and philosophy). When I say "some understanding" I mean I havent a degree - yet. I checked off an awful lot more "hits" than a mere one-off coincidence.

I hold down quite a demanding job and would hope that I'm capable of remembering what I did yesterday accurately or I'll be in trouble :o)

How many of the "precise" details have you confirmed? For example, in the case of your sister the precision was poor - she was not terminally ill, just ill.

What about the man's wheelchair? In your description it sounded like you had a clear vision of what it looked like in the dream. Also, was his mother's house the same as the house you saw in the dream?

How many bits of information in your head can you confidently identify the source of?
 
My sister really believed she was dying - a fair assumption given the blood pouring down the toilet.

As Alan George Paterson (and his mother) are complete strangers, I would be unable to actually go to their home in Rothes. I can still see the wheelchair in my mind's eye, down to the angle I found it at. You know those fluttery things kids stick to the handles of their bikes? He stuck them on his wheelchair. There was a joy stick on the right side (I guess he could have been right-handed then). If he needed that we wouldnt be able to turn the wheels himself. Did I say it was red? I keep meaning to go the library and take a copy of the column. I will try to do that over the next couple of weeks. Not that it will prove anything and anything I say after I get it, it could be argued that I've amended my memory to suit. What I remember at the moment is the wheelchair, his mother was the person he was living with, the house, the position of the bed, his name being the same bar the middle one, his age being the same as my old boyfriend's. The day I had the dream was the Sunday and two days later on the Tuesday, the article was notifying of his death ON the Sunday. The only way I can prove any of these experiences is to tell you straight away, as soon as I get something and wait to see if there's any evidence. That could take a while :o)
 
Taking the two experiences into account and considering all the other things I'd experienced I am left in no doubt that there's more to the human experience than science can "prove".

I have heard that statement many times before, but I don't really understand what is meant by it, so I'm hoping you can explain it to me.

I think of science as a collection of variously confirmed observations and educated guesses (some exquisitely precise) about how those observations are connected. When I think of something as proven, it is either referring to a particular observation that has been reliably confirmed (anyone can observe it under relevant conditions, or it fulfills Hume's caveat* if it is a singular observation), or to a hypothesis or theory that is both necessary, sufficient and useful, and for which there is evidence that excludes any competing ideas.

But the idea that a story about a particular experience cannot always be confirmed is so obvious that stating it cannot be proven is redundant or trivial. So I think that you are referring to a particular idea that science cannot prove (is it that not all of what we consider "mind" is a product of processes occurring within the brain?). Again, the idea that there are still many hypotheses yet to be made and tested is too obvious to be a useful statement. So it looks to me like you are claiming that you have an idea that is not only currently unproven, but can never be proven. But I don't understand what it is that excludes this possibility. For example, this claim has been made in the past with respect to morality, yet science has moved on to successful exploration of morals and ethics anyway.

Do you have an idea about specific characteristics that exclude the possibility of scientific exploration? Or am I on the wrong track about what you are referring to? Can you elaborate (pretty please :)) on what you meant by that statement? I can't narrow it down to one particular meaning.

Linda

* That no testimony is sufficient to establish a miracle, unless the testimony be of such a kind, that its falsehood would be more miraculous, than the fact, which it endeavours to establish.
 
I am a lay-person who is honest about my limitations and hoped that by joining this forum and telling my story, I might learn something and enjoy being part of the debate. I have done a little study in psychology but have no formal training. I have perhaps not expressed myself too well. All I have to work with is the information I have at the time. And right now, the evidence is overwhelmingly that I'm having insights that most people never get to experience. I just want to know why and as the pace has quickened where it's all going to lead. I have no interest in being "special" but I've seen that the paranormal does seem to gather more than its fair share of people who are looking for attention - like showbiz:o) I'm not afraid, just curious.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom