JoeTheJuggler
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2006
- Messages
- 27,766
To answer your question about why people are sometimes reluctant to accept coincidence as an explanation, it's because the experiences seem too improbable, particularly if someone has had multiple experiences with some similar aspects. It seems more reasonable to assume that there is a common cause rather than assuming random chance is all that caused the occurance of multiple improbable events for the same individual.
The fact that an event is improbable does not add significance to its occurrence. Given a billion tries, a one-in-a-million event will occur around 1000 times with no need for any other explanation but chance. That it occurs to you will make it seem eerie, but unremarkable nonetheless.
An explanation is not a hypothesis--especially as applied to anecdotes, which is what these stories of coincidence are.And coincidence, as I have tried to explain previously, is not an explanation. It's an unfalsifiable hypothesis.
Highly improbable events happen all the time. There are LOTS of people and LOTS of candidate events for these sorts of things (dreams or whatever). People forget the vast number of "misses" and remember the one-in-a-million "hit" and think it is somehow significant or in need of explanation. (By the way, the confirmation bias can also reinforce racism or other prejudicial thinking.)
That's why we can't rely on anecdotes when doing important things like science (as testing the safety and efficacy of a drug, for instance).