-Fran- said:
I don't understand this reluctance at all. Can't some of you explain why you are so reluctant?
Beth said:
Hmm...go back to laalaa's description: "I've responded to more than one thread and found myself suddenly surrounded by vehemence, ridicule and having my sanity questioned." This is not a pleasant experience. Is any more explanation than that really necessary?
Is any more explanation necessary? Uhhh... Yes! Because that wasn't an explanation at all, and actually wasn't a reply to what I asked in any way.
You said this to laalaa:
Beth said:
I understand your reluctance to dismiss your experiences as mere coincidences.
OK, laalaa has been reluctant to dismiss her experiences as coincidences. This is obviously something she has always done. She has never considered these particular experiences as coincidences, obviously, because if she had she would not have come here, described the experience and claimed it isn't a coincidence.
So what has her reluctance to do so have to do with any sort of behaviour of any person on this forum? Do you mean she was perfectly willing to consider that it was a coincidence until she got here, and then people were so mean, she decided to throw logic out the window after all, in sheer protest against people's behaviour?
It is quite clear this isn't the case. First of all, people, at least in this thread, has not behaved as badly against her as she says. And second it is quite clear that she has always been reluctant to accept coincidence as an explanation. She has said several times that she knows about natural and logical explanations, but that she has dismissed them all when it comes to her experiences. She has never said why she dismissed them though. And that is what my question above was about.
Why has she, and you, and all other people who share the same ideas as you, always been so reluctant to dismiss your experiences as coincidences?
-Fran- said:
Beth said:
Yes, coincidence is more an explanation than 'god did it'. And not only to me.
Beth said:
"God did it" is sufficient for some people.
It seems so. But what does it have to do with that a coincidence is a valid natural explanation? You can't clump these two together since it is not even remotely the same thing, and has nothing to do with each other. To believe god did it, and to believe in the things laalaa has described here though, are far more related.
Beth said:
But such 'explanations' are not sufficient for everyone.
It doesn't really matter, though, does it? It doesn't make it more real just because some people are not satisfied with the natural world and how it works.
Beth said:
Yes, co-incidences happen. But when similar coincidences recur, particularly if there is a common thread to the 'coincidences', such an explanation wears thin
Only if you don't understand them in the first place. And only if you think that what really happens isn't sufficient enough an explanation for you. Good for you, if that's how you want to see it, but don't claim your world view has anything to do with reality.
Beth said:
and it's reasonable for people to reject such a simplistic dismissal of their experiences and look for other possible causes.
It's reasonable in the light of ignorance, yes, and if they don't fully understand such things as the concept of coincidence.
-Fran- said:
There are no causes to look for! And are you ever successfull in this search for other causes?
Beth said:
Yes?
-Fran- said:
Why? Why would someone's feelings about how small the probabilities are warrant such a belief?
Beth said:
I didn't say anything about belief.
You didn't have to.
Beth said:
This was just a supportive statement to laalaa - I'm hoping she'll return.
Me too, there are so many things I am curious about in her reasoning.
Beth said:
No one other than laalaa can reasonably judge what the probability of such 'coincidences' might be.
Why? That's nonsense. If she describes her dream, as the case was here, and what happened later (or before) anyone can reasonably judge just that. Several of us did. I would say that most of the times the person who actually has the dream is the one who is the
least suitable to judge the probability, especially if he or she does not fully understand the concepts of 'probability' and 'coincidence', and are hampered by his or hers personal feelings and beliefs of it all.
Beth said:
She is the one who knows how often such experiences have occurred to her.
Yes, and she can tell others, and many people with sufficient knowledge in things like this can then make a fairly good evaluation of the probability
Beth said:
If she feels that the probability of such coincidences is simply too small for her to comfortably accept that, then it's quite reasonable for her to look for other explanations.
If she feels that, it is simply a
feeling and does not say anything at all about the possible existance of other causes and explanations.
By the way, can you give some examples of what these other causes and explanations could be? There's a lot of talk of other this and that, but no concrete examples.
Beth said:
Are you looking for reasons to get offended?
Don't need to look very hard in that case. But I wasn't as much offended as really annoyed with this. I've seen it so many times.
Beth said:
Yes, it's just a tongue in cheek expression. I always think of that running gag in Monty Python sketches.
Yup, I think of Monty Python too, very funny sketch. However, there wasn't really very much in laalaa's posts that indicated that she was, in fact, joking, that her tongue was anywhere near her cheek, or that she was referring to Monty Python. It seems to me that she was quite serious. Even if the expression is meant to be a tongue in cheek one, it can still be used in a serious way. And I think that is what she did. Many with her has done that, too, or used similar expressions. And they use them in indignation about not having recieved the respect they think their ideas deserve. They think this disrespect has nothing to do with their actual ideas, and all to do with that skeptics are just a mean bunch. Well, some are, most are not, but that still doesn't make woo believers into a victimized group. Just look at the quote you yourself referred to earlier in this post:
"I've responded to more than one thread and found myself suddenly surrounded by vehemence, ridicule and having my sanity questioned."
She also said this:
"An uneducated fool who has relied on his intuition and has no proof of his existence, is fair game for the self-proclaimed elite - which diminishes us."
All showing that she indeed felt very badly treated, and that simply because we (I) questioned her. But when she used the expression "Spanish Inquisiton" she was suddenly all tongue in cheek? I don't think so. And yeah, that annoys me.
Beth said:
I don't think mentioning the spanish inquisition is disrespectful of people who have been tortured in modern times.
Doesn't have to be, no.
Beth said:
In fact, I find that a serious stretch.
Yeah, I agree on this one, this particular example WAS a stretch. I'm sorry! My point was though that she, and many with her, feels persecuted for their ideas, which I do find a bit offensive in the light of people who really are persecuted for their ideas and actually faces danger because of this, and not just an unpleasant moment on the Internet.
Beth said:
It was just a way for laalaa to say that the response she got was unexpectedly unpleasant. It doesn't imply that she feels she was oppressed or persecuted. At least, I don't read it that way.
Our interpretations differ, yes, That it was unpleasant I understand. I can see that it was. But the unpleasentness lies more in, I think, that she was challenged and questioned, not in that we are just mean, unfair, vehement and so on... Though it's obvious that she interprets reasonable questions, and not agreeing with her, and suggestions that she challenges her own ideas, and learn more - as vehemence, ridicule and having her sanity questioned. This is fairly common I would say, seen it many times.
She could have been honest that she had, in fact, not quite thought this through, and that she couldn't really answer. I would have respected that. Instead she ignored what most of us said, and made herself out to be a poor uneducated layman who was jumped on by all sides by a self proclaimed well-educated elite.
She was implying that she felt persecuted, all right.