Have you changed any major belief as an adult?

To answer the question posed in the first post: I found myself growing more and more conservative (value-wise) as I grew older.

Furthermore, I found out that racism is at least partially justified. (That happened mostly during the period of working on computer maintenance, when 've had to deal with a fair number of people per day. Noone was more easily irritated, verbally abusive and more brash to begin with than the black "guests".)
I've come to dread any contact with that race as a result.

It may not seem politically correct. Frankly? I'm not sorry.

Going out on a limb to reply to this.

First of all, I grew up in Sweden, and myself I am pale as a sheet of paper, so I have no idea what it is really like to be a black person in the USA (Just assuming that's where you're from) or any other country. As I said, I grew up in Sweden with a Swedish mother, but with a Greek father, and yeah, I was bullied about that as a small kid. Wouldn't call that racism though. It was not as common back then that kids had parents that was from another country. I was the only one in my backward little village, and besides, I was a kooky kid and they bullied me for all sorts of stuff.

But at one time in my adult life I got a glimpse of what it can be like to be at the recieving end of prejudice, suspicion and blatant racism every single day.

It all started with that I had injured both my ears and had to go to the hospital (don't ask, it was stupid, and it's another story :o ). My mom drove me there, the doc fixed my ears and then promptly put a bandage around my head with a little bow on top and all. Yes, I looked hilarious! My mom could hardly drive from laughing so much :o

On the way home I had planned to stop by the bank to open an account for my newly started business, but I hesitated to go inside with that silly looking bandage. Well, it was in the middle of a very cold winter, and finally I wound the shawl that I had around my neck around my head instead. Thinking no one would wonder in this cold, and that it concealed the bandage well.

It had the weirdest effect. People stared openly at me when I got inside the bank. An older woman stared hatefully at me and drew back. I took a number and waited for my turn, wondering why it was suddenly colder in here than outside. When it was my turn, a man got up, walked past me as if I didn't exist and went up to the counter. I was too stunned to say a word, and the lady behind the counter didn't say a word about it either, but served the guy with a smile.

When it was finally my turn, I can't really describe the contemptuous look the bank teller gave me. You know, you know something is very wrong, but there's nothing really that you can point at? Well, there would soon be things to point at.

I said I wanted to open an account, and the woman just stared at me and said - right in my face - that she wasn't sure she could help me. I didn't really believed I had heard this so I repeated myself and she sighed and asked to see my ID. Then she says she can not be sure that this really is a legit ID, and that it in any case is very hard to see if it's really me on the ID photo since I am wearing a veil!

Not until then did I understand what it was all about. My bandage-concealing shawl had been taken for the veil of a Muslim woman, and I was being treated accordingly. They thought I was a Muslim Arab woman and suddenly I knew what it was like being treated like **** (I really wish I could use that word for real in this forum, because that is what they did, and there's no nicer word to describe it.)

Well, I told her then that she was mistaken and explained the bandage. Her response: "Well, at this age and day, how can you be sure?" I couldn't believe it. She was slightly sorry that she had been wrong about what I was, but not at all about the way she had treated me.

By this time, the bank manager stepped forward, he had heard the whole thing. But not until he also realized that I was in fact not Muslim, did he react and stepped up to apologize. He took me into another room, gave me the best of service, and got my business bank account fixed in minutes.

Now, afterwards I really regret that I didn't raise hell about this and took my business elsewhere. Why didn't I? I am not sure. I was in some kind of shock I think. I had never been put through something like this before, and didn't know how to react.

Later though I had a whole slew of feelings. Anger, humiliation, indignation...

So, this happened to me ONCE. But it made me realize how people must feel that go through this several times a day, every day. How it must be like to be ignored, looked down upon and badly treated, constantly, just going about your every day business. How can they stand it? It must totally wear you down in the end? How come those totally natural feelings of anger and humiliation doesn't manifest itself in outbursts more often than they do? How can they refrain from not punching people in the faces? That's what I wanted to do to that female bank teller after the first shock wore off, that's for sure!

Has it ever occured to you, that maybe that is the reason that those black people you meet act the way you say they do? And that your reaction to it just assures that this evil wheel keeps spinning?

Of course, there are just plain bastards from all races. But, for me personally, this experience has made me think twice when I meet people that seem to be on the defensive in a more or less aggressive way. Maybe they have a reason to? It has also made me realize how privileged I am.
 
Last edited:
Has it ever occured to you, that maybe that is the reason that those black people you meet act the way you say they do? And that your reaction to it just assures that this evil wheel keeps spinning?

It has, actually. People have openly asked me if I was a Communist once they found out I was from Russia, but that didn't give me a reason to verbally abuse them. Also, it's -always- an assumption that I've been here under a year, due to the accent. (I've been here over half of my life.) Trust me, I know what it feels like to know that you're -never- going to be looked at as a citizen/native member of the country, whether or not you actually are one.


Despite my personal views at that time, 've tried my best to give decent service regardless of race, and the -recurring trend- was that blacks were just more likely to be ********. As if they expect people to treat them better just because of their color, and instantly associate not getting their way with someone acting 'racist' on them.

Frankly, 've come to conclusion that it's best to stick with those of your own race: at least they're less likely to walk all over you in customer service.(Though sometimes, I wonder..)
 
OK, your story is getting a bit more nuanced, and I do understand several of the things you say, and can relate to some as well. But do you really mean that all black people are like this, and that they are, becasue they are black and nothing else? Your first post did come across like that.

It has, actually. People have openly asked me if I was a Communist once they found out I was from Russia, but that didn't give me a reason to verbally abuse them. Also, it's -always- an assumption that I've been here under a year, due to the accent. (I've been here over half of my life.) Trust me, I know what it feels like to know that you're -never- going to be looked at as a citizen/native member of the country, whether or not you actually are one.

You have a point! But all groups of people are often of a prejudiced mind about other groups of people. And some will never quite let you in, no. I've often been asked the most stupid things about me too, by people who should know better, one might think. And I've been in situations where I knew that this group of people will never let me be one of them. But is that racism? Moving to another place and having a hard time fitting in is not quite the same thing as being exposed to systematic racism. It doesn't make prejudices right, and I do not mean to belittle what you have been through, but it really isn't quite the same thing,

Despite my personal views at that time, 've tried my best to give decent service regardless of race, and the -recurring trend- was that blacks were just more likely to be ********. As if they expect people to treat them better just because of their color, and instantly associate not getting their way with someone acting 'racist' on them.

It could also be that they simply expect people to treat them WORSE because of their color, and they then put up a wall even before you have a chance to prove that you weren't going to. I am not saying that is right either, but I can understand it.

However, I have run into situations as well, where what you say actually seemed to have been the case. I was once in a bar with a few friends when a guy from Somalia came up to me and tried to pick me up. I was not there to be picked up, but to socialise with my girlfriends so I politely declined the, rather straight put, offer... and the guy freaked out. He started to yell at me what a racist white bitch I was and that I was basically a whore, who would sleep with anyone, but him, and that only because he was black. That was quite a shocking thing to experience as well. I have since met and also dated several black men who would never act like that, so that individual was an idiot. The whole black race is not.

Things are complicated, and it is sometimes hard to separate individuals from their groups, but we have to try, that's all I am saying. I am not free from prejudices, but I try to be aware of what I am thinking and doing, and what might be behind things.

Frankly, 've come to conclusion that it's best to stick with those of your own race: at least they're less likely to walk all over you in customer service.(Though sometimes, I wonder..)

OK, I realize that situations can be hard, and that you can't solve the deeply rooted problems of racism on your own. But do you really mean that a whole race of people are ALL the same, and are you really saying that you have never run into a real bastard in customer service that was white? Besides, those who were prejudiced toward you because you are from Russia, were they all black? It seems to me that if white people said things like that to you too, and were prejudiced about you because of your accent, and if that is as bad as blatant racism - then it's not safe to stick with your own race either, is it?

I believe what you say about your experiences, but why make it a thing about race? There are a lot of things around us in our societies that shapes and makes what people are and how they behave, but what color they were born with is not one of those things.
 
Last edited:
I suppose I didnt expect the Spanish Inquisition. I wish I'd never told a tale but just asked different sorts of questions. Then I wouldnt have gotten bogged down in the debate "anecdote versus proven-scientific-fact-of-reality".

laalaa, I wanted to say that I appreciate your sharing your experience here. I have had similar experienced in that past few years that have caused me to reconsider previously held beliefs regarding some aspects of what is termed 'paranormal'.

I understand your reluctance to dismiss your experiences as mere coincidences. Coincidence is no more an explanation than is "god did it". It i s an unfalsifiable hypothesis, and usually used as an excuse to stop looking for other causes. If you feel that the probability of your dreams, particularly if you have had several with some common elements, and the later events that seem to be related are sufficiently small, then it's reasonable to consider other possibilities rather than shrugging it off as 'coincidence'.

I also understand your feelings regarding expecting the Spanish Inquisition. It is why I don't post my personal experiences here. But I would like to discuss your dreams further with you if you're willing. Please PM me with your email address and we can converse privately.
 
I understand your reluctance to dismiss your experiences as mere coincidences.

I don't understand this reluctance at all. Can't some of you explain why you are so reluctant?

Coincidence is no more an explanation than is "god did it".

Uh, yes it is!

It i s an unfalsifiable hypothesis, and usually used as an excuse to stop looking for other causes.

There are no causes to look for! And are you ever successfull in this search for other causes?

If you feel that the probability of your dreams, particularly if you have had several with some common elements, and the later events that seem to be related are sufficiently small, then it's reasonable to consider other possibilities rather than shrugging it off as 'coincidence'.

Why? Why would someone's feelings about how small the probabilities are warrant such a belief?

I also understand your feelings regarding expecting the Spanish Inquisition. It is why I don't post my personal experiences here.

Do people who keep crying "Spanish Inquisition" as soon as someone asks them to clarify their vague ideas or ask them to actually argue for their own ideas, actually know what the Spanish Inquisition was???

Oh, I know it's just a tongue in cheek expression, but really, it's so very far from what people here are doing that's it just gets ridiculous to keep saying that. You are not a persecuted minority. And we are not a woo/religious organization who aims to torture you to assure you believe in the right kind of woo. We just want you to be more clear about what the heck you are on about, why you think the way you do, AND what hard facts you have to support your ideas. And so on...

If you don't want to answer, fine! But don't act like you're the victims of some sort of opression or persecution, because that's just silly, and really rather disrespectful of people who actually have been put through the tortures of our modern time versions of the Inquisition.
 
Last edited:
paranormal

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-5980990221766439646
HERE IS AN INTERESTING VIDEO which answers many questions about origin, religion, the presence of other dimensions within the same space, life on other planets,

also; what our capabilities are, depending on the individual, varies,
is seldom recognized, understood, and in many circles, taboo.

hope you enjoy, explains what our military is up to now, but you must watch
in it's entirety

enjoy! :crowded:
 
I used to think it was nearly impossible for the US to be changed drastically from the inside to something historically believed to be war-provokingly worse or for another civil war/widespread civil strife to occur in the US but now I believe that the chance of something like that occuring in the next 50 years is more along the lines of 50/50. It wasn't a conspiracy theory that I found that convinced me but many separate pieces of information that began to add up, but I'm sure the next five or ten years will prove if I'm just being paranoid.
 
I don't understand this reluctance at all. Can't some of you explain why you are so reluctant?

Hmm...go back to laalaa's description: "I've responded to more than one thread and found myself suddenly surrounded by vehemence, ridicule and having my sanity questioned." This is not a pleasant experience. Is any more explanation than that really necessary?

Uh, yes it is!
Maybe to you it is. "God did it" is sufficient for some people. But such 'explanations' are not sufficient for everyone. Yes, co-incidences happen. But when similar coincidences recur, particularly if there is a common thread to the 'coincidences', such an explanation wears thin and it's reasonable for people to reject such a simplistic dismissal of their experiences and look for other possible causes.
There are no causes to look for! And are you ever successfull in this search for other causes?
Yes, sometimes.

Originally Posted by Beth
If you feel that the probability of your dreams, particularly if you have had several with some common elements, and the later events that seem to be related are sufficiently small, then it's reasonable to consider other possibilities rather than shrugging it off as 'coincidence'.

Why? Why would someone's feelings about how small the probabilities are warrant such a belief?

I didn't say anything about belief. This was just a supportive statement to laalaa - I'm hoping she'll return. No one other than laalaa can reasonably judge what the probability of such 'coincidences' might be. She is the one who knows how often such experiences have occurred to her. If she feels that the probability of such coincidences is simply too small for her to comfortably accept that, then it's quite reasonable for her to look for other explanations.
Do people who keep crying "Spanish Inquisition" as soon as someone asks them to clarify their vague ideas or ask them to actually argue for their own ideas, actually know what the Spanish Inquisition was???

Oh, I know it's just a tongue in cheek expression, but really, it's so very far from what people here are doing that's it just gets ridiculous to keep saying that.
Are you looking for reasons to get offended? Yes, it's just a tongue in cheek expression. I always think of that running gag in Monty Python sketches.
If you don't want to answer, fine! But don't act like you're the victims of some sort of opression or persecution, because that's just silly, and really rather disrespectful of people who actually have been put through the tortures of our modern time versions of the Inquisition.

I don't think mentioning the spanish inquisition is disrespectful of people who have been tortured in modern times. In fact, I find that a serious stretch. It was just a way for laalaa to say that the response she got was unexpectedly unpleasant. It doesn't imply that she feels she was oppressed or persecuted. At least, I don't read it that way.
 
Last edited:
-Fran- said:
I don't understand this reluctance at all. Can't some of you explain why you are so reluctant?

Beth said:
Hmm...go back to laalaa's description: "I've responded to more than one thread and found myself suddenly surrounded by vehemence, ridicule and having my sanity questioned." This is not a pleasant experience. Is any more explanation than that really necessary?

Is any more explanation necessary? Uhhh... Yes! Because that wasn't an explanation at all, and actually wasn't a reply to what I asked in any way.

You said this to laalaa:
Beth said:
I understand your reluctance to dismiss your experiences as mere coincidences.

OK, laalaa has been reluctant to dismiss her experiences as coincidences. This is obviously something she has always done. She has never considered these particular experiences as coincidences, obviously, because if she had she would not have come here, described the experience and claimed it isn't a coincidence.

So what has her reluctance to do so have to do with any sort of behaviour of any person on this forum? Do you mean she was perfectly willing to consider that it was a coincidence until she got here, and then people were so mean, she decided to throw logic out the window after all, in sheer protest against people's behaviour?

It is quite clear this isn't the case. First of all, people, at least in this thread, has not behaved as badly against her as she says. And second it is quite clear that she has always been reluctant to accept coincidence as an explanation. She has said several times that she knows about natural and logical explanations, but that she has dismissed them all when it comes to her experiences. She has never said why she dismissed them though. And that is what my question above was about.

Why has she, and you, and all other people who share the same ideas as you, always been so reluctant to dismiss your experiences as coincidences?

-Fran- said:
Uh, yes it is!

Beth said:
Maybe to you it is.

Yes, coincidence is more an explanation than 'god did it'. And not only to me.

Beth said:
"God did it" is sufficient for some people.

It seems so. But what does it have to do with that a coincidence is a valid natural explanation? You can't clump these two together since it is not even remotely the same thing, and has nothing to do with each other. To believe god did it, and to believe in the things laalaa has described here though, are far more related.

Beth said:
But such 'explanations' are not sufficient for everyone.

It doesn't really matter, though, does it? It doesn't make it more real just because some people are not satisfied with the natural world and how it works.

Beth said:
Yes, co-incidences happen. But when similar coincidences recur, particularly if there is a common thread to the 'coincidences', such an explanation wears thin

Only if you don't understand them in the first place. And only if you think that what really happens isn't sufficient enough an explanation for you. Good for you, if that's how you want to see it, but don't claim your world view has anything to do with reality.

Beth said:
and it's reasonable for people to reject such a simplistic dismissal of their experiences and look for other possible causes.

It's reasonable in the light of ignorance, yes, and if they don't fully understand such things as the concept of coincidence.

-Fran- said:
There are no causes to look for! And are you ever successfull in this search for other causes?

Beth said:
Yes, sometimes.

Yes?

-Fran- said:
Why? Why would someone's feelings about how small the probabilities are warrant such a belief?

Beth said:
I didn't say anything about belief.

You didn't have to.

Beth said:
This was just a supportive statement to laalaa - I'm hoping she'll return.

Me too, there are so many things I am curious about in her reasoning.

Beth said:
No one other than laalaa can reasonably judge what the probability of such 'coincidences' might be.

Why? That's nonsense. If she describes her dream, as the case was here, and what happened later (or before) anyone can reasonably judge just that. Several of us did. I would say that most of the times the person who actually has the dream is the one who is the least suitable to judge the probability, especially if he or she does not fully understand the concepts of 'probability' and 'coincidence', and are hampered by his or hers personal feelings and beliefs of it all.

Beth said:
She is the one who knows how often such experiences have occurred to her.

Yes, and she can tell others, and many people with sufficient knowledge in things like this can then make a fairly good evaluation of the probability

Beth said:
If she feels that the probability of such coincidences is simply too small for her to comfortably accept that, then it's quite reasonable for her to look for other explanations.

If she feels that, it is simply a feeling and does not say anything at all about the possible existance of other causes and explanations.

By the way, can you give some examples of what these other causes and explanations could be? There's a lot of talk of other this and that, but no concrete examples.

Beth said:
Are you looking for reasons to get offended?

Don't need to look very hard in that case. But I wasn't as much offended as really annoyed with this. I've seen it so many times.

Beth said:
Yes, it's just a tongue in cheek expression. I always think of that running gag in Monty Python sketches.

Yup, I think of Monty Python too, very funny sketch. However, there wasn't really very much in laalaa's posts that indicated that she was, in fact, joking, that her tongue was anywhere near her cheek, or that she was referring to Monty Python. It seems to me that she was quite serious. Even if the expression is meant to be a tongue in cheek one, it can still be used in a serious way. And I think that is what she did. Many with her has done that, too, or used similar expressions. And they use them in indignation about not having recieved the respect they think their ideas deserve. They think this disrespect has nothing to do with their actual ideas, and all to do with that skeptics are just a mean bunch. Well, some are, most are not, but that still doesn't make woo believers into a victimized group. Just look at the quote you yourself referred to earlier in this post:

"I've responded to more than one thread and found myself suddenly surrounded by vehemence, ridicule and having my sanity questioned."

She also said this:

"An uneducated fool who has relied on his intuition and has no proof of his existence, is fair game for the self-proclaimed elite - which diminishes us."

All showing that she indeed felt very badly treated, and that simply because we (I) questioned her. But when she used the expression "Spanish Inquisiton" she was suddenly all tongue in cheek? I don't think so. And yeah, that annoys me.

Beth said:
I don't think mentioning the spanish inquisition is disrespectful of people who have been tortured in modern times.

Doesn't have to be, no.

Beth said:
In fact, I find that a serious stretch.

Yeah, I agree on this one, this particular example WAS a stretch. I'm sorry! My point was though that she, and many with her, feels persecuted for their ideas, which I do find a bit offensive in the light of people who really are persecuted for their ideas and actually faces danger because of this, and not just an unpleasant moment on the Internet.

Beth said:
It was just a way for laalaa to say that the response she got was unexpectedly unpleasant. It doesn't imply that she feels she was oppressed or persecuted. At least, I don't read it that way.

Our interpretations differ, yes, That it was unpleasant I understand. I can see that it was. But the unpleasentness lies more in, I think, that she was challenged and questioned, not in that we are just mean, unfair, vehement and so on... Though it's obvious that she interprets reasonable questions, and not agreeing with her, and suggestions that she challenges her own ideas, and learn more - as vehemence, ridicule and having her sanity questioned. This is fairly common I would say, seen it many times.

She could have been honest that she had, in fact, not quite thought this through, and that she couldn't really answer. I would have respected that. Instead she ignored what most of us said, and made herself out to be a poor uneducated layman who was jumped on by all sides by a self proclaimed well-educated elite.

She was implying that she felt persecuted, all right.
 
Last edited:
Is any more explanation necessary? Uhhh... Yes! Because that wasn't an explanation at all, and actually wasn't a reply to what I asked in any way.
You asked why laalaa and others, such as myself, are reluctant to post our personal experiences here. It's because it's a very unpleasant experience. You seem to understand why it is unpleasant. So why is it hard to understand the reluctance?
Why has she, and you, and all other people who share the same ideas as you, always been so reluctant to dismiss your experiences as coincidences?
Because while a single dream experience such as laalaa described can be dismissed as a funny coincidence, two is harder, three is really difficult, and by the time a person has had several such dreams over a lifetime and those dreams have a common aspect to them that other dreams don't, the probability of so many 'coincidences' becomes vanishingly small and very hard to accept.

It doesn't really matter, though, does it? It doesn't make it more real just because some people are not satisfied with the natural world and how it works.
Is the snipe about people who are not satisfied with the natural world and how it works really necessary? People have weird experiences and seek explanations. They are not necessarily unsatisfied with the natural world, but simply seek an explanation that fits with their real life experiences.
Why? That's nonsense.
I disagree. There are a great many details that are left out in a written description. You and I don't know about them. Laalaa does. Because she has more information about the incidents that have occurred to her than anyone else, she is in a better position to estimate the probability of coincidence than anyone else might be.
By the way, can you give some examples of what these other causes and explanations could be? There's a lot of talk of other this and that, but no concrete examples.
Not without discussing details of personal events I do not choose to share in this public forum. Sorry.
 
You asked why laalaa and others, such as myself, are reluctant to post our personal experiences here.

*sigh* Is my English worse than usual tonight? I did no such thing!! I answered to this:

Beth said:
I understand your reluctance to dismiss your experiences as mere coincidences.

That is what you wrote, your own words right there! If that wasn't what you meant... well, sorry, but I am not a mindreader, I can only reply to what you actually wrote, and that is what you wrote, and what I answered to. Try to follow now: You said you understood her reluctance to dismiss her experiences as mere coincidence. I replied that I do not understand said reluctance.

Are you with me? Good! You did not write that you understood why she is reluctant to post her experiences here, and so, consequently, I did not reply to that.

It's because it's a very unpleasant experience. You seem to understand why it is unpleasant. So why is it hard to understand the reluctance?

Not hard at all. But as I said, that wasn't what you wrote, and it wasn't what I answered to.

Because while a single dream experience such as laalaa described can be dismissed as a funny coincidence, two is harder, three is really difficult, and by the time a person has had several such dreams over a lifetime and those dreams have a common aspect to them that other dreams don't, the probability of so many 'coincidences' becomes vanishingly small and very hard to accept.

Please read up on coincidences and very large numbers and similar things,

http://skepdic.com/lawofnumbers.html, for example,

you will see that this is not actually the case. And in either case, what says that it is really so? We have only the words of the dreamer that the dreams are of that quality, and the dreamer is very likely to just misunderstand the whole thing from the start, misremember things, rationalize them after the facts, and so on...

Is the snipe about people who are not satisfied with the natural world and how it works really necessary?

I felt it was, and as we all know, when you feel something, then it's real, true and valid!

People have weird experiences and seek explanations. They are not necessarily unsatisfied with the natural world, but simply seek an explanation that fits with their real life experiences.

And there are many such explanations that will fit their experiences, and that doesn't break any natural laws in the process. But It's you all who say that this is not enough.

I disagree. There are a great many details that are left out in a written description. You and I don't know about them. Laalaa does. Because she has more information about the incidents that have occurred to her than anyone else, she is in a better position to estimate the probability of coincidence than anyone else might be.

As long as she can't even tell why she dismissed all the logical explanations, I don't think so.

Not without discussing details of personal events I do not choose to share in this public forum. Sorry.

Convenient. But... fair enough!
 
Last edited:
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-5980990221766439646
HERE IS AN INTERESTING VIDEO which answers many questions about origin, religion, the presence of other dimensions within the same space, life on other planets,

also; what our capabilities are, depending on the individual, varies,
is seldom recognized, understood, and in many circles, taboo.

hope you enjoy, explains what our military is up to now, but you must watch
in it's entirety

enjoy! :crowded:
Care to say a little more about why I should invest more than 1.5 hours on this movie?
 
Care to say a little more about why I should invest more than 1.5 hours on this movie?

I skimmed it. It's sheer and utter tripe! It's basically a series of claims from UFO nuts about the usual Roswell stuff and cover ups and so on and so forth. There's no criticism of the claims whatsoever, and they have picked only that which supports the claims.

It's also very badly made, and there's this very annoying and pompous music that drowns out the narrative voice.

What I could see it dealt only with UFO's and didn't seem to even try explain any of those things that the OP mentioned. Though I could be wrong about that, because I didn't watch every second of it. Really, I tried, but it's just impossible to watch an hour and a half of that and not fall asleep, I just had to keep jumping forward. Though things stayed the same at every jump, so I don't think I missed much.

I think you have to be a serious Roswell nut type of UFO-woo to be able to find anything worthwhile in that film.
 
To respond to the opening post, my transition was much slower. There was no moment when I realized that everything I believed was bunk. I just slowly came to skepticism. While I once was Catholic, now I'm agnostic. I used to want to believe in UFOs, conspiracy theories, and other stuff. Now I know that I shouldn't waste my time on that stuff. I remember going out to read up on some of the latest CT that I had read about or saw on TV, and being very disappointed with the amount of hard facts and primary sources available. That was probably the beginning of my skepticism, but it took me some time before I formalized it.
 
*sigh* Is my English worse than usual tonight? I did no such thing!! I answered to this:



That is what you wrote, your own words right there! If that wasn't what you meant... well, sorry, but I am not a mindreader, I can only reply to what you actually wrote, and that is what you wrote, and what I answered to. Try to follow now: You said you understood her reluctance to dismiss her experiences as mere coincidence. I replied that I do not understand said reluctance.

Are you with me? Good! You did not write that you understood why she is reluctant to post her experiences here, and so, consequently, I did not reply to that.
Your english is fabulous Fran. I am in awe of people who can speak more than one language. I just misunderstood what your question was in reference to. That happens a lot in this type of communication, especially as the quote function doesn't include previously quoted stuff.

To answer your question about why people are sometimes reluctant to accept coincidence as an explanation, it's because the experiences seem too improbable, particularly if someone has had multiple experiences with some similar aspects. It seems more reasonable to assume that there is a common cause rather than assuming random chance is all that caused the occurance of multiple improbable events for the same individual.

Please read up on coincidences and very large numbers and similar things,

http://skepdic.com/lawofnumbers.html, for example,

you will see that this is not actually the case.

Fran, thank you for taking the time to post a link, but I have considerable knowledge about such things. I'm a professional statistician and after many years of working full time and pursuing advanced studies in the field, I should be receiving my Ph.D. in statistics in 2008.

And in either case, what says that it is really so? We have only the words of the dreamer that the dreams are of that quality, and the dreamer is very likely to just misunderstand the whole thing from the start, misremember things, rationalize them after the facts, and so on...
Yes, it's perfectly understandable that people other than the dreamer might question such things. But the person dreaming knows the quality of the dream, the number of details that 'match', etc. When the experience is your own, it is not an anecdote, it is evidence.
I felt it was, and as we all know, when you feel something, then it's real, true and valid!
Sigh. That isn't what I said nor is it what I meant. Are such remarks necessary?

And there are many such explanations that will fit their experiences, and that doesn't break any natural laws in the process. But It's you all who say that this is not enough.
No, there are not always many such explanations. Sometimes it can take considerable effort to uncover a single explanation that fits. Sometimes one there simply can't be found and the event remains mysterious. Dismissing explanations that don't actually fit the experience is not an unreasonable thing for people to do.
As long as she can't even tell why she dismissed all the logical explanations, I don't think so.
What logical explanations has she dismissed for her dreams other than coincidence? And coincidence, as I have tried to explain previously, is not an explanation. It's an unfalsifiable hypothesis.
 
I used to believe Jamie Oliver was a ****. Now I think he's great.

Anything else... nope... Nope, that's it.
 
Do people who keep crying "Spanish Inquisition" as soon as someone asks them to clarify their vague ideas or ask them to actually argue for their own ideas, actually know what the Spanish Inquisition was???

I just thought it was a Monty Python reference. :D
"Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition!" ...
"Right! If that's the way you want it -- Cardinal! Poke her with the soft cushions! Confess! Confess! Confess!"

As for how I've changed since I became an adult... well, at 22 I was still a strong Christian. At 30 I think some form of agnostic is the best description for me. It took a slow process of years to make the change. In my lower 20s I was also quite conservative both socially and economically. Now I'd say that I'm socially liberal and economically moderate.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom