
I need to read "why people believe in weird things". It's what I'm really interested in but forays ino the world of the wierd (and often laughable) has had an interesting side-effect. I refuse to believe in anything but if I have to make a choice, I act on the information I have to date - which is always open to modification. I tend to think that anyone who believes in something has ceased to think and discern. It works both ways. Believing that all things paranormal and untestable in a laboratory is "bunk" is just as dumb. The side-effect is that I've modified my thinking on the paranormal - in its favour. Why? Because I have personal experiences that made my toes curl.
Something like a paradigm shift. The thing that motivated me to start the thread was changing my belief that a real Jesus existed. I had always believed someone like a Joseph Smith had started the Christian religion. I pictured him pulling the fake tricks like some Indian magic man. But now I'm reconsidering that there really isn't any historical evidence other than the Bible and there are a lot of reasons to believe that a myth could have become a 'real' person over time as the story was told and re-told.I dunno - what constitutes a 'major belief' anyway?
I used to think that too. That anything (in anyone's philosophy) can be explained away in logical/scientific terms. I notice how some folks bend like pretzels to have their belief system fit reality - whether scientist or woo-ist. "People believe what they want to believe" they say and that's true on both sides of the coin. Personally I don't believe anything. I feel that "belief" implies that no new information can supplant anything so firmly held as truth.I think one of the things that often feels the most convincing, but that we should also be the most skeptical about, is 'our own personal experiences'. Once you read up on how fantastically many ways our own brain can trick us in, you start to realize that it pays to be skeptical about that.
Toes often curl at the unknown and at that which we can't explain. But when all we have is our own pesonal experiences, more often than not we will see, sooner or later, that there are those who knows more than us, and can explain what we can't. So, please don't stop looking after you have had a personal experience of encountering something really strange, chances are that the answer IS out there, and it's most certainly a natural one.
I think that like this life, the truth is somewhere embedded in the myth. There may indeed have been a holy man with that name - who knows. Sometimes I wonder whether there would be such a thing as Christianity if it wasn't for Saul's sunstroke.Something like a paradigm shift. The thing that motivated me to start the thread was changing my belief that a real Jesus existed. I had always believed someone like a Joseph Smith had started the Christian religion. I pictured him pulling the fake tricks like some Indian magic man. But now I'm reconsidering that there really isn't any historical evidence other than the Bible and there are a lot of reasons to believe that a myth could have become a 'real' person over time as the story was told and re-told.
I used to think that too. That anything (in anyone's philosophy) can be explained away in logical/scientific terms.
I notice how some folks bend like pretzels to have their belief system fit reality - whether scientist or woo-ist. "People believe what they want to believe" they say and that's true on both sides of the coin.
Personally I don't believe anything. I feel that "belief" implies that no new information can supplant anything so firmly held as truth.
All my life I've had curious things happen (as we all do I'm sure).
Only in the past (say) 10 years I'd have to admit that there's more going on than scientists have an empirical test for - yet.
I have examples which can stand alone but the process of changing my outlook towards the paranormal is the thing.
Something else sprang to mind - it was quite a hurdle for me at the time. My daughter had been systematically bullied for two years and become very ill as a result (physically). The school's first act was to tell the bully that my daughter had complained which got her a severe kicking at break time. When I discovered she was too scared to go to school and was ducking out, I arranged for the teachers to note her attendance. Unfortunately the only method they had, was to put her onto a disciplinary system normally used for brats. Parents' Night came around. My daughter's teachers ALL asked me what on earth she had done to warrant such a severe outcome. She was always a pleasant pupil, not an A student maybe but they all appreciated her. They were furious they hadn't been informed the real reason she was put on this system. Instead of supporting her, school management had effectively marked her out as "one to watch". Not good for turning around a negative self-image. I had a meeting with the principal. I talked quietly and reasonably. We agreed that the system was not the ideal choice and in fact inappropriate. I asked the principal if she had done anything to warrant disciplinary action - he said no. So I said "so this should stop". The principal turned to my very sick little girl (12 yrs old) and said that it was all up to her, that she had to be "squeaky clean". I said that all she had to be was a normal child, with no negative attention but positive support and kindness. His decision was final. I found it most distressing that despite trying to reason politely with an apparently educated human being, logic utterly escaped him. Logic and compassion both. I found this a turning point for me. Naive as I once was in thinking that an education provided anyone with intelligence. I won't make that mistake again.
An uneducated fool who has relied on his intuition and has no proof of his existence, is fair game for the self-proclaimed elite - which diminishes us. Without imagination there would be no discovery, no scientific progress. The trouble with empirical science, in my opinion, is that anomalies, although perhaps noted as just such in the scientific process, factor little in the final declaration of what is "fact". We lay -people are served with a fait a complis (sp?) and I do defer to those who have done the research. Anything outside the curve of human experience is ridiculed. But that's OK, science has always done that. Thank goodness for visionaries. None of us can know everything, no matter how many years of study we have under our belt. I realised after my encounter with the school principal that even the most educated amongst us can be really stupid. I will reserve one of my experiences for a separate post.I did not say 'anything'. There are things that are not falsifiable by science. But most things said to be paranormal actually can be explained, and has been explained numerous times. On this forum only there are literally hundreds of examples. And it has nothing to do with different philosophies. A fact is a fact. Explaining things like paranormal phenomena from a philosophical viewpoint using scientific terms in a way they were not meant to be used (i.e. distorting their meaning) is a very woo-way to go about it. That is not what science do at all.
That's true, people do that! But, you have got it slightly wrong here. That is not how science work. Science, by definition, draws conclusions from known facts. A scientist who bend like a pretzel, is in fact not doing science. He may be a scientist - as in having the education, a title and an employment as a scientist, but what he does is not science. "Science" who does that is not science, it's pseudo-science! It's not corrct to say it works like that on both sides of the coin. If you saw "science" that worked that way, then it wasn't science that you saw. It was woo! And that sort of woo is definitely on the same side of the coin as all other woo is.
That's good! That is exactly how science works. It is always ready to change if new facts, that whitstood every effort of falsification, is found.
Yes. All of mine could be easily explained though. What you say here though, does make a few woo-warning bells go off, and does seem to imply some sort of belief after all. However, I can be totally wrong about that, and I am sincerely interested in what your experiences are. Would you give us a few examples? Only then can I understand better what you mean.
Science always have new things to discover, and have never claimed it hasn't. It has been shown time and time again though that what people generally think are things that science has not yet proven, really are not such cases. In most cases it turns out to be something that science explained or debunked ages ago. On this forum we hear people say this all the time, and then when they tell us about this fantastic thing, it's always something that we have heard a 100 times before, and that there are plenty of explanations for, and no proof for, or even evidence against.
I would really like to know what experiences you have. It would really be highly interesting if you have an example of something that is not one of these things. That would really be great to hear about. Please provide examples of experiences you have had that convinced you there were more going on than science can prove today.
I am really curious now!Please do describe these examples!
No doubt about it, that man is an idiot! I am very sorry for your girl, she didn't deserve any of this, and the way they handled this whole thing is just appalling. Few things pisses me off as much as the bullying going in Swedish schools and the totally inept way it is handled in. I sincerely hope things will be all right for your girl.
You are also quite right in that education does not guarantee either a smart person or a nice person! However (and I am not sure this is what you mean, and I apologize if this isn't the point you are trying to make) I can't really see what it has to do with your earlier reasoning about if you should trust science or not, or whether science is a reliable source for explaining weird experiences or not, and so on. Could you maybe explain a bit more what your point is?
To think that a higher education automatically also mean that you are intelligent and nice, is, as you say, a mistake. It does not guarantee that at all. Education provides knowledge, not intelligence. However, it does not mean the opposite either. Many well educated people ARE both intelligent and nice. It would be a mistake also to not acknowledge that. Why make this a turning point? Why not just see to the individual? Did you always think only good things about educated people before, and now after the turning point, you think bad of them all?![]()
An uneducated fool who has relied on his intuition and has no proof of his existence, is fair game for the self-proclaimed elite - which diminishes us.
Without imagination there would be no discovery, no scientific progress.
The trouble with empirical science, in my opinion, is that anomalies, although perhaps noted as just such in the scientific process, factor little in the final declaration of what is "fact".
We lay -people are served with a fait a complis (sp?) and I do defer to those who have done the research.
Anything outside the curve of human experience is ridiculed.
But that's OK, science has always done that.
Thank goodness for visionaries.
None of us can know everything, o matter how many years of study we have under our belt.
I realised after my encounter with the school principal that even the most educated amongst us can be really stupid.
I will reserve one of my experiences for a separate post.