You've taken this personally. I'm sorry if my lack of experience of forums has made my reply appear to be directed at you - it wasn't.
Then I apologize! I did take it somewhat personal, yes, and maybe I was a bit fast to do so. It was only me, really, that had answered to your post then, and it was said quoting my reply, so that was my first reaction.. I did take into consideration though that it might not have been directed to me personally since your reply was a bit odd and didn't seem to address anything in my reply really, hence me wondering why you quoted it at all.
Be that as it may. It's the kind of prejudice that still rubs me the wrong way, I must say. I know many people, like me, come from humble backgrounds and worked very hard for their education. Many of those people had a hard time fitting in at university (myself I could not really stand it in the end and actually never got a diploma, even after five years of studies - the pressure getting too much in the end). To call them an elite who tries to diminish other people is not fair.
I suppose I didnt expect the Spanish Inquisition.
The forum can be tough, but it's hardly the Spanish Inquisition. No one forces you to answer (and I would say that you are, in fact, not really doing that) but you should have expected tough questions.
I wish I'd never told a tale but just asked different sorts of questions. Then I wouldnt have gotten bogged down in the debate "anecdote versus proven-scientific-fact-of-reality".
What questions would that have been?
I tend to think that anyone who believes in something has ceased to think and discern. It works both ways. Believing that all things paranormal and untestable in a laboratory is "bunk" is just as dumb. The side-effect is that I've modified my thinking on the paranormal - in its favour. Why? Because I have personal experiences that made my toes curl.
This was in the first of your posts in this thread. It kind of opened up for that debate right away. So, yeah, you did start it yourself.
What I have done is open a new thread, asking for papers, data, suggested reading from respected sources so I can make an informed decision.
That sounds good! I will check it out.
My mistake was in telling ANYone why. I've responded to more than one thread and found myself suddenly surrounded by vehemence, ridicule and having my sanity questioned.
I don't know about other threads, but I see nothing of this here.
It's a waste of my time. I hardly expect anyone to agree with me and would have relished discussion but there have been few responses from anyone willing to accept that we don't know everything yet.
It
is a waste of time, yes, if you don't read what people do answer. I said this for example:
-Fran- said:
Who has said that we can? Science sure doesn't claim this, I haven't claimed this. No one on this thread has claimed this.
In reply to this:
laalaa41 said:
None of us can know everything, o matter how many years of study we have under our belt.
This is in fact already accepted by most people, and no one is claiming that we know everything. The thing is that it really has nothing to do with this discussion since what we
are discussing (= your claims) is well within what we
can know. That might be why people don't bother to mention it.
And what is your definition of "discussion" then?
I don't believe in the paranormal per se but I do have enough interest in it to explore the possibility.
Personally I don't really see the difference between you saying you don't believe in the paranormal, but then believing in the things you mention? And if you really are interested in exploring the possibility, then the place to start would be to read up on things and discard right away those things that has
been explained already. By weeding such things out first, you will be much closer to finding the things "not yet explained".
I think in all branches of science there must be results that don't quite fit the theory. People suffer from ME, Gulf War Syndrome but they aren't or weren't "officially recognised". In the UK there is a great deal of debate on whether the triple vaccine causes autism in babies with a less than robust immune system at the time of innoculation. Scientists have been trotted out declaring absolutes throughout my lifetime, only later to modify their conclusions.
Again, This is how science works! New facts are discovered that holds water before rigorous testing and scrutiny, and then they modify their conclusions in accordance. What is wrong with this? Isn't it exactly what you want them to do if they find more evidence in favor of things
you think they should consider?
All I'm saying is that it is not yet impossible that there may be more to reality than we yet can prove.
Not impossible, but highly improbable when it comes to the paranormal. In either case, if you really think this, I say again, then first weed out the things that science actually can explain!
There is more to me than this one passing interest. I have many more interests - things I want to learn more about.
I appreciate this. People are complex, I know that, and there are many sides to an individual. But we can't reply to more than what we see written here.
Formally and informally. My personal experience HAS been ridiculed and you do exactly that in your last sentence. Nutty ideas indeed.
This was not directed personally to you, but was a general statement. Many people do have nutty ideas and then they want you to respect their ideas, no matter how nutty they are. This I said in response to your claim that scientists ridicule human experiences. In no way was it a response to your actual idea.
Here's what was written:
laalaa41 said:
Anything outside the curve of human experience is ridiculed.
(A general statement you made about how scientists treat peoples' personal experiences. At least that was what I thought you meant by this. It was a bit vague and I was not sure.)
-Fran- said:
Personal experience is not ridiculed, if that is what you are saying here, it is often just of not much value in some research. There IS a problem with personal experiences when it comes to discern facts. What do you expect anyway? That people should respect anything that other people say, so much that we can't look for the facts? If someone's personal experiences talks against all known facts of reality, yes, then I am sorry, but we can not respect it so much that we will try to change reality to fit with someone's experiences. I respect people, but I am under no obligations to respect their nutty ideas, I am sorry!
(My general answer to your general statement. In reply to what I thought you said scientists do. Not in reply to your claim.)
So, do I think your ideas
are nutty then? Not really. I think you are interpreting your experiences wrong. These particular experiences are very common, and it is as common to interpret them the wrong way. So, no, I do in fact not think they are nutty. I've seen FAR nuttier things being claimed, believe me.
I can't really see that anyone in this thread have ridiculed your personal experience either. Though I haven't read any other thread where you have posted so I don't know what they have said in those threads. But here, all I see are people not agreeing with you, asking you questions, and challenging your own views of your own experiences. How is that ridicule? That you think it's not a very nice experience, I can understand, but ridicule..?