Have you changed any major belief as an adult?

The first thing, laalaa41, that I tell people about skepticism is to be skeptical about yourself. Once you realise the ways in which you can completely misconstrue reality - and realise it's an unavoidable property of your construction - you can start to make sense of some of the crazy things about our world.

So - do you have a special insight into people? Maybe - but you cannot tell until you first assume you don't and then see if you can find a way to show you are.
 
My political beliefs have changed frequently over the years. In general, I have less confidence in free market solutions than I had been in the past.

In terms of skeptical topics, recently, I have reversed what was once a strong opinion about the value of teaching critical thinking as a generalized skill. About two years ago, I became convinced that a skepticical view can only promoted by teaching relevant facts.

Also related to skepticism is a new belief that we can't "live and let live" over serious issues such as "health freedom," or "teach the controversy." I am more in favour of government regulation in these situations than, say, ten years ago.
 
I think these were too specific to be mere coincidence.
You need to read our Coincidence thread where a number of us have detailed some pretty weird coincidences. Like the time my shoe fell apart, miles from nowhere, hitchhiking with a friend up in Canada and right there on the side of the road was a perfectly good pair of Puma tennis shoes that fit. I wore them for a year or more.

Very specific coincidences do happen, and it is hard for people to believe they are coincidences. What they forget however, are all the thousands of dreams they've had which didn't match up with circumstances. So when one coincidently does, it seems like it had to be more than a coincidence.
 
I understand coincidence, have read on Jung's synchronicity (meaningful coincidences) and recognise they can happen more frequently than people sometimes realise - have had personal experience of many of those. I realise also that no matter how good we think we are at self-analysis, we can still see only what we want to see. It helps to try not to be attached to any outcome; to have the confidence that no matter where the "truth" actually is on the sliding scale of greyness - it's simply fun watching listening, learning. I cringe when I hear anyone declaring anything "categorically". If everything under the sun is explanable in mathematical terms, why on earth would I remove myself from the equation? Of course I am skeptical about my own perceptions.
 
Politically, I've slowly drifted from fairly-far-left to moderate-right (in European terms) in about 20 years. I didn't really realize this until about three years ago, when I found myself disagreeing with so many of our left-of-center politicians on major issues.

That's it for my adult years. As a teenager, I read most of the paranormal/UFO stuff I could get my hands on, and predictably, it was all woo literature. I don't remember exactly when I saw reason, but the Columbo episode where the good Lieutenant exposes a fake psychic was a contributing factor.
 
What??? :confused: You're not making much sense here! Who's "the self-proclaimed elite" suppose to be? Me? If that's what you're saying that's quite unfair. I'm no elite of any kind, and though I didn't agree with you, I was being respectful in replying to your posts.

If you meant that generally... it sounds a bit paranoid to me. If this "elite" diminishes you with their education, then fight them at their own game and get the same kind of education! It's not like you are forbidden to aquire it!

And who's the "uneducated fool"? You? Martyr much? :rolleyes: I certainly did not see you as a fool, or meant to diminish you in any way. You posted in this forum, and I disagreed with some things, and simply wanted to know more about what you meant by it all.

As for example, what do you mean by, "having no proof of his (yours?) existence"? :confused:



There hasn't been anyone here who has said that progress does not need imagination. Why would a scientist, a real scientist, working with real science, be someone who lacks imagination?

I suspect that we do not have the same definition of 'imagination'. How do you define it?



Uh? :confused: How do you define "anomalies" here, and in relation to what branch of science?



I fear to say it's fait accompli for, again, being called a member of the the self-proclaimed elite. :rolleyes: You don't have to accept anything served to you. But you must be prepared for that what you do say in opposition will be challenged.



Personal experience is not ridiculed, if that is what you are saying here, it is often just of not much value in some research. There IS a problem with personal experiences when it comes to discern facts. What do you expect anyway? That people should respect anything that other people say, so much that we can't look for the facts? If someone's personal experiences talks against all known facts of reality, yes, then I am sorry, but we can not respect it so much that we will try to change reality to fit with someone's experiences. I respect people, but I am under no obligations to respect their nutty ideas, I am sorry!



I don't think you really get what science do!



Science is, and have always been full of visionaires.



Who has said that we can? Science sure doesn't claim this, I haven't claimed this. No one on this thread has claimed this.



No one has disputed this either. But I repeat, to think that this is the case with all educated persons is simply prejudice! Who says that principal was that highly educated anyway? You asked to see his CV?

Lastly, I wonder a little bit why you quoted my last reply to you at all in this post, since you didn't actually answered to any of it!



Thanks. It will be interesting.
You've taken this personally. I'm sorry if my lack of experience of forums has made my reply appear to be directed at you - it wasn't. I suppose I didnt expect the Spanish Inquisition. I wish I'd never told a tale but just asked different sorts of questions. Then I wouldnt have gotten bogged down in the debate "anecdote versus proven-scientific-fact-of-reality". What I have done is open a new thread, asking for papers, data, suggested reading from respected sources so I can make an informed decision. My mistake was in telling ANYone why. I've responded to more than one thread and found myself suddenly surrounded by vehemence, ridicule and having my sanity questioned. It's a waste of my time. I hardly expect anyone to agree with me and would have relished discussion but there have been few responses from anyone willing to accept that we don't know everything yet. I don't believe in the paranormal per se but I do have enough interest in it to explore the possibility. I think in all branches of science there must be results that don't quite fit the theory. People suffer from ME, Gulf War Syndrome but they aren't or weren't "officially recognised". In the UK there is a great deal of debate on whether the triple vaccine causes autism in babies with a less than robust immune system at the time of innoculation. Scientists have been trotted out declaring absolutes throughout my lifetime, only later to modify their conclusions. All I'm saying is that it is not yet impossible that there may be more to reality than we yet can prove. There is more to me than this one passing interest. I have many more interests - things I want to learn more about. Formally and informally. My personal experience HAS been ridiculed and you do exactly that in your last sentence. Nutty ideas indeed.
 
I have heard that statement many times before, but I don't really understand what is meant by it, so I'm hoping you can explain it to me.

I think of science as a collection of variously confirmed observations and educated guesses (some exquisitely precise) about how those observations are connected. When I think of something as proven, it is either referring to a particular observation that has been reliably confirmed (anyone can observe it under relevant conditions, or it fulfills Hume's caveat* if it is a singular observation), or to a hypothesis or theory that is both necessary, sufficient and useful, and for which there is evidence that excludes any competing ideas.

But the idea that a story about a particular experience cannot always be confirmed is so obvious that stating it cannot be proven is redundant or trivial. So I think that you are referring to a particular idea that science cannot prove (is it that not all of what we consider "mind" is a product of processes occurring within the brain?). Again, the idea that there are still many hypotheses yet to be made and tested is too obvious to be a useful statement. So it looks to me like you are claiming that you have an idea that is not only currently unproven, but can never be proven. But I don't understand what it is that excludes this possibility. For example, this claim has been made in the past with respect to morality, yet science has moved on to successful exploration of morals and ethics anyway.

Do you have an idea about specific characteristics that exclude the possibility of scientific exploration? Or am I on the wrong track about what you are referring to? Can you elaborate (pretty please :)) on what you meant by that statement? I can't narrow it down to one particular meaning.

Linda

* That no testimony is sufficient to establish a miracle, unless the testimony be of such a kind, that its falsehood would be more miraculous, than the fact, which it endeavours to establish.
How can I prove any of this. Most of it happened in the past. I havent photographs, papers, affi-davits (witnesses yes). My best witness was kicked out of the house four years ago. I can't go to the US from Scotland to take Randi's challenge and wouldn't want to anyway. Oh lord why did I tell anyone anything. "If I could turn back time". I'd start again and say "hello, I'm new" - what's the current thinking on the paranormal?
 
Growing up, as a very little kid I think I believed in UFOs. -- Or wanted to at least. Watching Star Trek, I wanted to believe in belevolent aliens who had solved all the ordinary problems we faced. If not believing in, I at least knew about other myths like Bigfoot, and the Loch Ness Monster. That was about the time I also played with Ougi boards, and Zenar Cards.

Somewhere along the way I adopted to the scientific impossiblity of it in our Universe anyway. -- That is if there is intelligent life out there it's too far away to be making regular visits. Bigfoot, and the Loch Ness monster faded into plot devices in Six Million Dollar Man, Bionic Woman, and Doctor Who.
 
How can I prove any of this. Most of it happened in the past. I havent photographs, papers, affi-davits (witnesses yes). My best witness was kicked out of the house four years ago. I can't go to the US from Scotland to take Randi's challenge and wouldn't want to anyway. Oh lord why did I tell anyone anything. "If I could turn back time". I'd start again and say "hello, I'm new" - what's the current thinking on the paranormal?

What are you talking about? What are you trying to prove?

Your response didn't seem to have anything to do with what I said.

:confused:

Linda
 
You've taken this personally. I'm sorry if my lack of experience of forums has made my reply appear to be directed at you - it wasn't.

Then I apologize! I did take it somewhat personal, yes, and maybe I was a bit fast to do so. It was only me, really, that had answered to your post then, and it was said quoting my reply, so that was my first reaction.. I did take into consideration though that it might not have been directed to me personally since your reply was a bit odd and didn't seem to address anything in my reply really, hence me wondering why you quoted it at all.

Be that as it may. It's the kind of prejudice that still rubs me the wrong way, I must say. I know many people, like me, come from humble backgrounds and worked very hard for their education. Many of those people had a hard time fitting in at university (myself I could not really stand it in the end and actually never got a diploma, even after five years of studies - the pressure getting too much in the end). To call them an elite who tries to diminish other people is not fair.

I suppose I didnt expect the Spanish Inquisition.

The forum can be tough, but it's hardly the Spanish Inquisition. No one forces you to answer (and I would say that you are, in fact, not really doing that) but you should have expected tough questions.

I wish I'd never told a tale but just asked different sorts of questions. Then I wouldnt have gotten bogged down in the debate "anecdote versus proven-scientific-fact-of-reality".

What questions would that have been?

I tend to think that anyone who believes in something has ceased to think and discern. It works both ways. Believing that all things paranormal and untestable in a laboratory is "bunk" is just as dumb. The side-effect is that I've modified my thinking on the paranormal - in its favour. Why? Because I have personal experiences that made my toes curl.

This was in the first of your posts in this thread. It kind of opened up for that debate right away. So, yeah, you did start it yourself.

What I have done is open a new thread, asking for papers, data, suggested reading from respected sources so I can make an informed decision.

That sounds good! I will check it out.

My mistake was in telling ANYone why. I've responded to more than one thread and found myself suddenly surrounded by vehemence, ridicule and having my sanity questioned.

I don't know about other threads, but I see nothing of this here.

It's a waste of my time. I hardly expect anyone to agree with me and would have relished discussion but there have been few responses from anyone willing to accept that we don't know everything yet.

It is a waste of time, yes, if you don't read what people do answer. I said this for example:

-Fran- said:
Who has said that we can? Science sure doesn't claim this, I haven't claimed this. No one on this thread has claimed this.

In reply to this:

laalaa41 said:
None of us can know everything, o matter how many years of study we have under our belt.

This is in fact already accepted by most people, and no one is claiming that we know everything. The thing is that it really has nothing to do with this discussion since what we are discussing (= your claims) is well within what we can know. That might be why people don't bother to mention it.

And what is your definition of "discussion" then? :confused:

I don't believe in the paranormal per se but I do have enough interest in it to explore the possibility.

Personally I don't really see the difference between you saying you don't believe in the paranormal, but then believing in the things you mention? And if you really are interested in exploring the possibility, then the place to start would be to read up on things and discard right away those things that has been explained already. By weeding such things out first, you will be much closer to finding the things "not yet explained".

I think in all branches of science there must be results that don't quite fit the theory. People suffer from ME, Gulf War Syndrome but they aren't or weren't "officially recognised". In the UK there is a great deal of debate on whether the triple vaccine causes autism in babies with a less than robust immune system at the time of innoculation. Scientists have been trotted out declaring absolutes throughout my lifetime, only later to modify their conclusions.

Again, This is how science works! New facts are discovered that holds water before rigorous testing and scrutiny, and then they modify their conclusions in accordance. What is wrong with this? Isn't it exactly what you want them to do if they find more evidence in favor of things you think they should consider?

All I'm saying is that it is not yet impossible that there may be more to reality than we yet can prove.

Not impossible, but highly improbable when it comes to the paranormal. In either case, if you really think this, I say again, then first weed out the things that science actually can explain!

There is more to me than this one passing interest. I have many more interests - things I want to learn more about.

I appreciate this. People are complex, I know that, and there are many sides to an individual. But we can't reply to more than what we see written here.

Formally and informally. My personal experience HAS been ridiculed and you do exactly that in your last sentence. Nutty ideas indeed.

This was not directed personally to you, but was a general statement. Many people do have nutty ideas and then they want you to respect their ideas, no matter how nutty they are. This I said in response to your claim that scientists ridicule human experiences. In no way was it a response to your actual idea.

Here's what was written:

laalaa41 said:
Anything outside the curve of human experience is ridiculed.
(A general statement you made about how scientists treat peoples' personal experiences. At least that was what I thought you meant by this. It was a bit vague and I was not sure.)

-Fran- said:
Personal experience is not ridiculed, if that is what you are saying here, it is often just of not much value in some research. There IS a problem with personal experiences when it comes to discern facts. What do you expect anyway? That people should respect anything that other people say, so much that we can't look for the facts? If someone's personal experiences talks against all known facts of reality, yes, then I am sorry, but we can not respect it so much that we will try to change reality to fit with someone's experiences. I respect people, but I am under no obligations to respect their nutty ideas, I am sorry!
(My general answer to your general statement. In reply to what I thought you said scientists do. Not in reply to your claim.)

So, do I think your ideas are nutty then? Not really. I think you are interpreting your experiences wrong. These particular experiences are very common, and it is as common to interpret them the wrong way. So, no, I do in fact not think they are nutty. I've seen FAR nuttier things being claimed, believe me.

I can't really see that anyone in this thread have ridiculed your personal experience either. Though I haven't read any other thread where you have posted so I don't know what they have said in those threads. But here, all I see are people not agreeing with you, asking you questions, and challenging your own views of your own experiences. How is that ridicule? That you think it's not a very nice experience, I can understand, but ridicule..?
 
Last edited:
Be that as it may. It's the kind of prejudice that still rubs me the wrong way, I must say. I know many people, like me, come from humble backgrounds and worked very hard for their education. Many of those people had a hard time fitting in at university (myself I could not really stand it in the end and actually never got a diploma, even after five years of studies - the pressure getting too much in the end). To call them an elite who tries to diminish other people is not fair.

Yes it is a fair assumption. In the UK graduates are feted, petted, pampered, given golden handshakes and the promise of a lifetime job. Mostly without much common sense, they arrive on site with lots of theory and havent a clue how to apply it to real life situations. With the new employment laws, employers cannot even ask for people with 10 - 15 years experience any more.

The forum can be tough, but it's hardly the Spanish Inquisition. No one forces you to answer (and I would say that you are, in fact, not really doing that) but you should have expected tough questions.

You're right, but I have been wasting an awful lot of time repeating myself. Yes I know we fill in the gaps, yes I'm aware coincidences do happen, yes I thought of this, that and the next thing. Pointing out the obvious is not helpful or constructive.

What questions would that have been?

You mean "what question would those have been"? Well they all drill down to the one which prompted me to create the new thread - what's going on the world of science on the subject of the paranormal/ metaphysics/ parapsychology? The majority of replies have had, stall the whole process by declaring that there is categorically, no such thing - its all flaws in our perspective of events - or worse. Delusion, insanity... bla bla bla.


This was in the first of your posts in this thread. It kind of opened up for that debate right away. So, yeah, you did start it yourself.

Yes I did start it myself - I knew that - that was why I joined up, to ask questions :rolleyes: Had I known the effect it would have, I would have kept my experiences to myself

That sounds good! I will check it out.

I've had some interesting replies. I have some reading to do - nice.


I don't know about other threads, but I see nothing of this here.

See below.

It is a waste of time, yes, if you don't read what people do answer. I said this for example:



In reply to this:

I read EVERYTHING. I've sometimes started to respond but thought what a waste of everyone's time it would be just continually refuting/defending/presenting/performing.

This is in fact already accepted by most people, and no one is claiming that we know everything. The thing is that it really has nothing to do with this discussion since what we are discussing (= your claims) is well within what we can know. That might be why people don't bother to mention it.

And what is your definition of "discussion" then? :confused:

Well this is a discussion.

Personally I don't really see the difference between you saying you don't believe in the paranormal, but then believing in the things you mention? And if you really are interested in exploring the possibility, then the place to start would be to read up on things and discard right away those things that has been explained already. By weeding such things out first, you will be much closer to finding the things "not yet explained".

I don't believe in anything. To believe in something I would have to come to some sort of conclusion. Had I decided anything Ive seen or heard were absolute evidence of the paranormal, I wouldn't have looked elsewhere for further information, wouldn't have joined a skeptic's forum. I mean some of the rationalisations if you can call them that, are ridiculously imponderable.


Again, This is how science works! New facts are discovered that holds water before rigorous testing and scrutiny, and then they modify their conclusions in accordance. What is wrong with this? Isn't it exactly what you want them to do if they find more evidence in favor of things you think they should consider?

Gosh I hope this is true. But if one is so firmly entrenched (as many here are) that there is no such thing, then how would new information filter through a brick wall like that?

Not impossible, but highly improbable when it comes to the paranormal. In either case, if you really think this, I say again, then first weed out the things that science actually can explain!

Science thinks it can explain so far you mean surely. I find myself saying - "yes I know that we can think we're remembering but we're not, I know the mind looks for patterns (numbers are the most obvious), I'm aware of this, that, the next thing. I've been disssecting, drilling down and picking apart all my experiences for a long time now. If I'd been able to prove some sort of credentials, stating the obvious could have been avoided.


I appreciate this. People are complex, I know that, and there are many sides to an individual. But we can't reply to more than what we see written here.


This was not directed personally to you, but was a general statement. Many people do have nutty ideas and then they want you to respect their ideas, no matter how nutty they are. This I said in response to your claim that scientists ridicule human experiences. In no way was it a response to your actual idea.

Here's what was written:

(A general statement you made about how scientists treat peoples' personal experiences. At least that was what I thought you meant by this. It was a bit vague and I was not sure.)

(My general answer to your general statement. In reply to what I thought you said scientists do. Not in reply to your claim.)

So, do I think your ideas are nutty then? Not really. I think you are interpreting your experiences wrong. These particular experiences are very common, and it is as common to interpret them the wrong way. So, no, I do in fact not think they are nutty. I've seen FAR nuttier things being claimed, believe me.

I can't really see that anyone in this thread have ridiculed your personal experience either. Though I haven't read any other thread where you have posted so I don't know what they have said in those threads. But here, all I see are people not agreeing with you, asking you questions, and challenging your own views of your own experiences. How is that ridicule? That you think it's not a very nice experience, I can understand, but ridicule..?[/QUOTE]

My perception of my experiences must be wrong because there is no such thing - right?
 
laalaa41 said:
Yes it is a fair assumption. In the UK graduates are feted, petted, pampered, given golden handshakes and the promise of a lifetime job.

Not in my experience.

Mostly without much common sense, they arrive on site with lots of theory and havent a clue how to apply it to real life situations.

I have known many “qualified” engineers like that. University and education in general are more about scoring points rather than learning now. It is sad.

With the new employment laws, employers cannot even ask for people with 10 - 15 years experience any more.

True, but do you really think employers don’t (or can't) pick the person they want?
 
Not in my experience.



I have known many “qualified” engineers like that. University and education in general are more about scoring points rather than learning now. It is sad.



True, but do you really think employers don’t (or can't) pick the person they want?
I worked at a major oil company where they had recruitment events. they'd pay for transport, hotels, events, funky personality tests. I suppose it could be just the oil & gas industry because apparently the average of workers is 54 - an ageing workforce with very few people coming up to learn the skills before this lot retires. So they're kinda desperate. If they manage to caputure some interest of a masters grad - then we're into the realms of handshakes and promises.

I also notice engineers who are particularly good at their technical jobs are promoted into management positions without any aptitude or training for managing people.

Yes I do think they get to choose, but they cant write anything about "extensive experience" on a Job Description or advert without the threat of legal action.
 
Major beliefs changed as an adult:

Born Again Christian until I was 28
Wiccan/Witch from 28 to 40
Now I have no religious affiliations
(it's all on my myspace blog if you're really curious, the short story is I just lost belief over time)
Death Penalty, was pro now against and it was P&T's BS episode that was the catalyst for the change
I was in my late teens for this but I'll count it (young adult) - Abortion, was pro life now pro choice, happened when I realized that no one has the right to tell another person when they should risk their health or lives for what is or what will become another human being
 
I ran into this when my son wanted to drop chemistry in 9th grade. The Dean was convinced the right thing to do was force the kids to not give up as he saw it. From my perspective my son already had high school credit for advanced classes in middle school, he was depressed, 9th grade is especially stressful for kids and it was absurd that one size fits all (all the freshmen had heavy class loads). The Dean refused and I said, fine, I'll get his doctor to order it based on depression and stress. The Dean had no choice, my son dropped chemistry. He graduated this year, starts college in a month and dropping that class had zero negative impact on him.

But I didn't have to change to be this way. I was born into it. ;) Don't let the people in charge of the school have total control. They have the right to some, but it's a myth you have no say in matters. Go to the school superintendent and get a second opinion on options for your child. If you are in the US, schools have an obligation to protect kids from bullies at school. Don't be afraid to make a big issue of it. It is a big issue.
I hear stories like this all the time. Schools here in the UK seem to think that having an Anti-bullying policy is of some use when kids in the playground are beating eachother up. Certainly the teachers I came into contact with lacked training in dealing effectively with bullying. Unfortunately my daughter is now 26. The moment has passed. She was eventually expelled with only one O Grade. Well she was hardly ever there. She's fine now, has some ambitions of going back to college once my grand-children have flown the coop.
 
OK, sorry that I am answering this so late and bringing an old thread up to the surface again. (That seems to have died?) But I started a reply to this a few days ago, when my PC suddenly decided not to cooperate and started to make all sorts of weird trouble. But as it, again, is being nice and cooperative, I thought I should finish what I started.

---

laalaa41 said:
Yes it is a fair assumption. In the UK graduates are feted, petted, pampered, given golden handshakes and the promise of a lifetime job. Mostly without much common sense, they arrive on site with lots of theory and havent a clue how to apply it to real life situations. With the new employment laws, employers cannot even ask for people with 10 - 15 years experience any more.

laalaa41 said:
There is more to me than this one passing interest. I have many more interests - things I want to learn more about.

So, you do not want us to make assumptions about you based on what you have written here? But you call it fair to make assumptions about a very large group of people who have only one thing in common - that they are graduates? I don't call that fair, I call it prejudice!

laalaa41 said:
You're right, but I have been wasting an awful lot of time repeating myself. Yes I know we fill in the gaps, yes I'm aware coincidences do happen, yes I thought of this, that and the next thing. Pointing out the obvious is not helpful or constructive.

All things are not obvious to all people. OK, you know of all these things, but there's nothing in your posts here that indicates that you have really applied them to your own experiences. And all of these things are actually quite sufficient in explaining such experiences. I keep bringing it up because I don't see what there is left that can be possibly paranormal after having considered these things. And if all these natural explanations were discarded - why were they? What in this particular experience told you that it could not have been any of these things that people have suggested? I am not only "pointing out the obvious" here. I, for one, just wants to know more about how you applied these things to your experiences, and why you discarded them.

-Fran- said:
What questions would that have been?

laalaa41 said:
You mean "what question would those have been"?

I made a grammatical error? Thanks! I do that all the time, since English is not my first language.

laalaa41 said:
Well they all drill down to the one which prompted me to create the new thread - what's going on the world of science on the subject of the paranormal/ metaphysics/ parapsychology? The majority of replies have had, stall the whole process by declaring that there is categorically, no such thing -

But the typical "there is no such thing"-reply IS the answer to what is going on in the world of science concerning the subject of the paranormal, and so on. That is what science basically has discovered about it. No tests so far has been able to yield any results that points to that there exists anything paranormal.

laalaa41 said:
its all flaws in our perspective of events - or worse. Delusion, insanity... bla bla bla.

Why do you dislike these kinds of explanations so much?

laalaa41 said:
Yes I did start it myself - I knew that - that was why I joined up, to ask questions

And we answered.

laalaa41 said:
Had I known the effect it would have, I would have kept my experiences to myself

If you read old threads in the forum, you'll see that many people with similar thoughts have been put through much worse.

-Fran- said:
It is a waste of time, yes, if you don't read what people do answer. I said this for example:

laalaa41 said:
I read EVERYTHING. I've sometimes started to respond but thought what a waste of everyone's time it would be just continually refuting/defending/presenting/performing.

I apologize for that, it was unnecessary to word it like that, I made an assumption based on that you answered to so few comments directly, but kept your replies general. It's not a waste of everyone's time at all, it is what this forum is for. I, for one, would be interested!

laalaa41 said:
I don't believe in anything. To believe in something I would have to come to some sort of conclusion. Had I decided anything Ive seen or heard were absolute evidence of the paranormal, I wouldn't have looked elsewhere for further information, wouldn't have joined a skeptic's forum. I mean some of the rationalisations if you can call them that, are ridiculously imponderable.

Your claim is that some personal experiences that people have can not, as of yet, be explained by science, and that it does not rule out the existance of the paranormal. You have come to this conclusion - that science can not explain these experiences, and that it could be paranormal. There are no facts to support this, but plenty of evidence against it. It's a belief.

-Fran- said:
Again, This is how science works! New facts are discovered that holds water before rigorous testing and scrutiny, and then they modify their conclusions in accordance. What is wrong with this? Isn't it exactly what you want them to do if they find more evidence in favor of things you think they should consider?

laalaa41 said:
Gosh I hope this is true. But if one is so firmly entrenched (as many here are) that there is no such thing, then how would new information filter through a brick wall like that?

There is a reason that many people here are "firmly entrenched" in their stance that there is no such thing. It's not like people just got this thought in their heads one day, thought it sounded good, and decided to believe it no matter what. There are research done, there are natural laws to consider, there are facts, there are studies made, and so on, and so on... that you, all put together, can base a pretty accurate stance on. There is no "brick wall". The brick wall is a myth. There has been studies, the "paranormal" didn't work, and as such it was discarded.

-Fran- said:
Not impossible, but highly improbable when it comes to the paranormal. In either case, if you really think this, I say again, then first weed out the things that science actually can explain!

laalaa41 said:
Science thinks it can explain so far you mean surely.

Nope... I meant exactly what I said.

laalaa41 said:
I find myself saying - "yes I know that we can think we're remembering but we're not, I know the mind looks for patterns (numbers are the most obvious), I'm aware of this, that, the next thing. I've been disssecting, drilling down and picking apart all my experiences for a long time now. If I'd been able to prove some sort of credentials, stating the obvious could have been avoided.

Then I ask again, when you picked your experiences apart, why did not a single one of the rational explanations work? What was it that made you discard them all?

laalaa41 said:
My perception of my experiences must be wrong because there is no such thing - right?

Right! One thing that many people do not consider is that if many paranormal phenomena were, in fact, real, it would have serious consequenses in the world and universe as we know it. Many paranormal phenomena, as described by woos, does not go well together with natural laws, physics, biology, and so on. Which means that it is more rational to come to the conclusion that someone's perception of what happened was skewed, rather than that the laws of the universe is wrong. Besides, all people mispercieve all sorts of things all the time. I do it constantly, are you an exception?
 
Last edited:
Laalaa, it is the conclusions you have drawn from what you perceived that are at issue. We know from the scientific (meaning careful, systematic observations) evidence that human brains are hardwired to seek out patterns. But that doesn't always mean the pattern is actually there. So a lot of false conclusions are drawn and it is important to recognize when you should refrain from drawing the conclusion your brain wants to draw but we know from that careful systematic observing is not going to be a correct conclusion.

For some observations, we have no trouble recognizing coincidences. You wear your hat backward and your home team wins. A lot of people will believe or act out this kind of superstition, but most people recognize the hat position was unlikely to have actually influenced the game outcome.

You dream about someone and the dream has a number of elements. In a few days something occurs which has a number of similarities which appear to be matched to things in the dream. People have a harder time recognizing why there appears to be elements in the dream which are still just as likely to be unrelated to real events as the hat and the ball game.

What makes it harder to recognize it is only coincidental? For one, people have not been exposed to this kind of pattern seeking our brains do. Any good magician like James Randi can demonstrate it for you. When you see people like John Edwards do it, people are fooled. When you see it on the psychic detective stories on TV people are fooled. It is all the same and it is the same thing that happens when we think a dream matches something which occurs after the dream.

Things in Mr Randi's 'cold reading', John Edwards' 'cold reading' which he claims is something else, and the psychic detective's 'cold reading' which they claim is something else are all the same phenomena. When something is suggested, your brain finds something that is similar and sees a match. Your brain seeks and finds a 'pattern', something that starts with the letter 'N', water, something warm, a hug, a death, the number 23, ... you could find something that seemed to match any of those things. And that's what our brains do.
 
To answer the question posed in the first post: I found myself growing more and more conservative (value-wise) as I grew older.

Furthermore, I found out that racism is at least partially justified. (That happened mostly during the period of working on computer maintenance, when 've had to deal with a fair number of people per day. Noone was more easily irritated, verbally abusive and more brash to begin with than the black "guests".)
I've come to dread any contact with that race as a result.

It may not seem politically correct. Frankly? I'm not sorry.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom