Have you changed any major belief as an adult?

While I lost my belief in the John Wayne version of America in my early 20s in Central America. ("The Confessions of an Economic Hit Man", is close to the version of America I now hold.) This is another of my "filters" but it increases my skill at recognizing the persuasion tactics rather than decreasing my objectivity.

And I also suffered an emotional crisis when the courts failed me. The better lawyer, not the actual case is what matters in our courts and when that turned into a personal exposure, it was really stressful. And it recently happened to my brother in another case. The experience of the courts failing to actually work the way we've grown up believing they work is sometimes a significant thing in people's lives. I'm trying to convey the emotion to someone who hasn't had the experience but it's like finding out you were adopted when you are 20. There is this weird emotional stress.


Yeah, we get "educated" from an early age that our justice system is infallible, but since it's owned and operated by humans, it's subject to human foibles as well, and mistakes and injustices happen. I've heard it should really be called law system rather than justice system.

I guess what we were talking about was more the loss of innocence thing, which I suppose is one way of changing a major belief. One big "loss of innocence" experience for me as a young 'un was finding out the Earth was round, not flat. It was a big deal for me, but instead of explaining it here, it might be a good idea for another thread.

ETA: Thanks for the link to the book. I've heard of it in passing before and now it's on my list. This quote from the prologue caught my attention:

This is a war that for them [indigenous Peruvians] is about the survival of their children and cultures, while for us [U.S.] it is about power, money, and natural resources. It is one part of the struggle for world domination and the dream of a few greedy men—-global empire.
 
Last edited:
What made you believe in communism in the first place and what made you change?

I think my need to be contrary is what caused me to give Communism a look. I grew up hearing of Communism as being this evil thing, naturally, but when I looked into it it looked like the most perfect form of government. You'll have to consider that I was making these conclusions as a teenager and I think my naivete played a large part in dismissing the evil things that have been done in the name of Communism. It was for the greater good I thought. The theory itself is sound, it just doesn't work with humans. Socialism seemed like the next best thing; it's something that's realistic and progressive, it helps people while keeping governments in check and its economies moving.
 
Hmmm... major beliefs? No. Changed a few minor ones.

I did come to the realization that I was an atheist during adulthood, though.
 
skepticgirl... I was going to law school during the Dover trial, and I felt similarly disappointed in law in general. Libraries of words and spin and so forth-- and it wasn't really about the truth-- it was about selling others on the truth you wanted. I missed science more and more--especially as the Dover trial was going on. To me, governments and politics and law and history is mostly about men and the stories they tell each other to build the truth they want-- whereas, science is just about the truth that is the same for everybody... hierarchy and eloquence and manipulation can't trump facts.
Opinions can change, but the truth keeps being the truth and the facts keep being the facts no matter what people believe. I like those kinds of truths. Opinions and beliefs are fluff and often get in the way of understanding. Many people cannot distinguish between the two, and I blame religion for fostering this notion that there are "higher truths" that mere mortals can't expect to understand.

The McMartin Preschool fiasco was really horrific. I think it's very important to know the way humans fool themselves and each other. I remember Loftus' studies on false memories and the several child molestation accusation horrors of the 80's and 90's-- and I was as disturbed as you mention. I hadn't thought that children could "lie" about such things. Or be lead.

Instead of pledging allegiance to a flag-- I'd like to pledge allegiance to the truth. How can "belief" be more important that "truth"? How can believing a lie be better than admitting you don't know? I think it's disturbing that an evolution of thought or admitting error is seen as "flip flopping" or a sign of weakness... to me it's about honing our understanding of the truth-- It's dogmas that don't change. Understanding evolves.

People like to see themselves as "consistent" and admitting you may have been wrong is hard for humans. I admire how Randi uses his skills to show us how even smart people can be so readily fooled. People are trusting... and society tells us that faith is a way to "know" higher truths. Fortunately, humans have the ability to learn from the mistakes of both themselves and others.
 
The Judge's ruling in Kitzmiller v Dover actually restored some of my faith in the legal system. It does work sometimes.

Now if we can just work on the court's misuse of scientific opinions, the invalidity of most eyewitness testimony, the injustice of having no money for a decent attorney and change some of the restrictions on allowing new evidence in, it might even become a 'just'ice system again one day.
 
I remember a time when I didn't know the difference between homeopathy and herbs/whatever stuffed into a bottle. I also thought chiros went to med school for the longest time.

I'd confuse the terms astrology and astronomy until adulthood, although I knew that they weren't even remotely the same. Now I would never mix the terms up for anything.

When I was a kid I tried really hard to believe in ghosts and gods. I tried. It just never made any logical sense. I sincerely believe I was born to try to get real answers to any questions I had. Once I went to college I couldn't believe the stuff I didn't know beforehand.

I can't believe the majority of Americans and humanity are walking around out there without a clue on what they are missing out on. It's a sad failing of our education systems.
 
... Once I went to college I couldn't believe the stuff I didn't know beforehand.

I can't believe the majority of Americans and humanity are walking around out there without a clue on what they are missing out on. It's a sad failing of our education systems.
After college (the first time because I went back twice more) when I traveled to Central America, I remember being quite surprised at the Maya and Aztec buildings. I had a little history through school as we all do, but it just was so different actually seeing the pyramids and other buildings. Even now I try to tell people who haven't traveled out of the country that you just can't understand the false impression you have of everything when you've only heard about stuff but never seen for yourself.
 
I guess I didn't answer 100% correctly about religion. My extended family was catholic. My mother was of the Christmas-and-Easter variety. She made me go to Sunday school until I was about 14. I guess she just thought I should be exposed to it, but she never gave me any trouble about quitting once she thought I was old enough to decide for myself.

My grandparents are still very Catholic, but luckily my whole family is very accepting, as most of the younger generation is Atheist/Agnostic, and it's never been an issue.

I honestly can't say I took much away from Sunday school, although I will give Catholicism a high five for inventing the school girl uniform. Pure genius.
 
I was really deep into fairy tales as a child. Later on when I first developed an interest in technology, I used to believe almost every claim about it, such as the notion that cars powered by fusion were already possible but suppressed by the industry. Once I learned more about physics these beliefs started to fade.

I also briefly believed that there might be something to astrology after all, although I entertained my own pet hypothesis that personality differences could be explained by the changing seasons in moderate climate zones rather than the movement of distant stars. This is about the farthest I ever explored into woo territory -- political ideologies excluded.

Speaking of which, at about 16 I became deeply involved with socialism. This included attending local meetings of a socialist youth group and rallying for and against various causes. Paying at least lip service to socialist ideology is fairly common in Germany, though, especially among the youth. So it wasn't really a fringe belief, comparatively speaking.

Anyway, the interesting part of the story is that now, at the age of 26, I would describe myself as a pragmatic neoliberal. In two-dimensional political tests I come out close to center. If I lived in the US I would probably vote independent. My socialist ideology was the closest I ever came to religious belief (I grew up and still am atheist). The "conversion" is best described as a gradual wisening-up over the course of several years.

One of the reasons I was prompted to re-examine my beliefs was the discovery that the basic world view underlying socialism is actually pretty much mainstream. A liberal world view, and economic liberalism in particular, doesn't come nearly as natural. Now, before you start shouting at me, note that I said "re-examine" -- not change on a whim. ;)

Thinking everything through, I concluded that socialism just doesn't work. Apart from the inefficient economics of socialism, most of the strong political ideologies (not just socialism, but also anarchism, extreme libertarianism etc.) appear to rely on an unrealistic concept of human nature. Once I accepted the demise of communism as evidence, the deal was basically settled. The success of the Open Source philosophy (I'm a programmer) convinced me that liberalism is basically on the right track. I like the dish best when served with a healthy dose of rationalism and pragmatism, though. Yummy!
 
Last edited:
Wow - who hasn't changed a major belief? Though I guess it depends on your retrospective definition of "major" (I may have considered things "major" in middle school that I can't even remember now). A big chunk of learning rational thought is finding ways to cast off "beliefs" and replace them with evidence-based knowledge.

Did I once truly belive in Santa Claus? I think I did. I know I wanted to.

Anyway, growing up my family was chocked full of intellectuals. My grandparents, parents, aunts and uncles all earned doctorates. My grandmother received her Ph.D. in the 20's when it was nearly unheard of for women in the USA to do so and certainly unheard of for them to teach. Critical thinking, skepticism, etc.. were very basic to all of the dinner table discussions at our house. Also, my family was devoutly Christian.

It never occurred to me that these Christian beliefs weren't something that the great intellects at my house had not already investigated, debated, and determined to be true. It wasn't until my mid 30's that I actually started to think about the real implications of an omnipotent-but-jealous invisible cloud being, a man-god dying for my "sins" thousands of years before my existence, and an exclusive resort for my saved soul upon the death of my body.

I don't think this is at all unusual and I think we all go through it. Some, like me, later than others. At some point we are all faced with the fact that available evidence simply does not support commonly held religious beliefs. We then either cast aside the beliefs, or "compartmentalize" them as a special class of ideas that are separate from and not subject to scientific analysis.

I chose the former, though my faith actually grew initially stronger as I began to question it. The smartest man I've ever known, my grandfather, remained a devout believer to his death (and beyond?).

A major event? Sort of. When my grandfather died I found on his bookshelf a book called "The Passover Plot" that was sort of a critical analysis of Jesus' passion week written by a Rabbi. I read the book in one sitting. It was the first honest discussion of the events I had heard outside of Church and it triggered a flood of thoughts and ideas.
 
I was raised a Lutheran (MIssouri synod), and, even though I always adored science, biology especially, I was able to accept the teachings of my church until I was a teenager. At that point, the youth of my church took a two year (twice weekly, after school) course in the basic beliefs of our faith. We would study the structure of the church's beliefs, and the basis (scriptural, of course) of them.
Now, by the time I was twelve, I had read enough history to realise that a few teachings of my church were, at the very least, questionable (young Earth, literal flood, etc.). But during the course of being taught the basic foundations of Lutheran belief, I realised that my Pastor (who was a good friend of my family) had undergone a rather rigorous theological education (becoming a Lutheran pastor is a lot like becoming a priest, classes in the ancient languages, textural criticism, and so-on), and was fully aware that many of the assumptions of his religion were, at best, untenable. However, Sunday after Sunday, he was able to stand in front of a group of people who trusted him, and give out what he knew were unsubstantiated, if not clearly untrue, assertions about the meaning of life.

It took a few years for me to finally throw off the yoke of Yaweh, but I felt much fresher, even minty, as soon as I did.
 
I once thought Confessions of an Economic Hit Man was valid. Don't think so anymore.
 
I once thought Confessions of an Economic Hit Man was valid. Don't think so anymore.
What changed your mind because I have personal knowledge the author is at least telling true kinds of events. I can't personally say anything about his experiences.
 
I believed in black and white... Now only in shades of gray...

Broes


I don't know if you are referring to this song, but it is one of my favorites (which is actually on youtube, BTW)


Shades of Gray- Monkeys

When the world and I were young,
Just yesterday.
Live was such a simple game,
A child could play.
It was easy then to tell right from wrong.
Easy then to tell weak from strong.
When a man should stand and fight,
Or just go along.

But today there is no day or night
Today there is no dark or light.
Today there is no black or white,
Only shades of gray.

I remember when the answers seemed so clear
We had never lived with doubt or tasted fear.
It was easy then to tell truth from lies
Selling out from compromise
Who to love and who to hate,
The foolish from the wise.

But today there is no day or night
Today there is no dark or light.
Today there is no black or white,
Only shades of gray.

[instumental interlude]

It was easy then to know what was fair
When to keep and when to share.
How much to protect your heart
And how much to care.

But today there is no day or night
Today there is no dark or light.
Today there is no black or white,
Only shades of gray.
Only shades of gray.



I experimented with fundamentalist Christianity as a teenager, and came out of it with strong interest in understanding why people believe the things they do and a strong desire not to demonize people I disagree with.

Although I am more libertarian than socialist (of course it depends on the issue!), I even went so far as to go to meetings of various Communists sects in the 80's, not to argue but to understand where these fellow human beings were coming from. I have always sought out different points of view and have even learned a lot from the insights of those with whom I disagree.
 
I was waiting for the bus one day, and stopped believing in God. Now, it was a long process before I reached that point--many things had happened that led me to discard long-held beliefs. Believing in God just didn't make any sense anymore.
 
First of all, the ending of the book was downright newage nonsense. Before that, the conspiracy theories ran thick, and the author has shown some interest in "alternative" 9/11 explanations. This robs some credibility.

Secondly, some true information may be presented, but in a misleading way. The author does not have an economic education and that handicaps his understanding. There was this part about doing sloppy econometric calculations, since it was all a "smokes and mirrors" discipline.

The total lack of data also left me wondering.

Then there were the "papers" of the author, supposedly published in journals, but the bibliography at the end pointed only to conferences- where papers are not peer-reviewed.

In general, the book contained worse than falsities- it contained half-truths. Much like Castaneda, but then again, I fell for Castaneda as well once upon a time, before I took the time for a more critical review.
 
So I was wondering, what beliefs have you changed and can you say it was a single revelation or something that grew over time? A major science theory or part of a theory is OK. There's no restriction on what kind of belief it was you changed.

You and Linda convinced me that promoting infant circumcision for HIV prevention in Africa is, on balance, an acceptable idea. It took a several pages of discussion on this forum.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom