The end of woo for me: Oft repeated on these forums, a skeptical friend asked me to video and audio tape readings I gave people. Then we would follow up with the folks after a couple of weeks, and compare my memories, their memories, and the truth. I pretty much abandoned all woo and sought evidence to prove any outrageous claims after that.
So you were able to re-evaluate your beliefs with new evidence. I wonder if that is something we possess as skeptics or if it is something in a lot of non-skeptics but they need the right evidence to be convinced to change?
.... blinding partisanship can be (this is not directed at you). Hardcore democrats taught me that they could be zealots on par in hostility and one sidedness as any religious fundamentalist. Hardcore republicans, even the non-religious ones, taught me that there was no amount of spin they wouldn't stoop to in order to engineer an issue into some kind of cultural battle. Hardcore Greens and Libertarians taught me that there is no true green or libertarian, just folks vacillating around their particular pet issues.
Leaving me no affiliation or "in group" to identify with, I learned to think for myself. I learned that I could examine an issue without histrionics and judge it on merit. You know---critical thinking and skepticism. I also decided that I would not judge all republicans evil fundies or all democrats as screaming liberal loonies. I would take them on a case by case basis. Sometimes they are right, and sometimes they are wrong. But I only truly learned to examine an issue with a clear head by stepping away and sorting through all the BS.
There was an article in the 4th qtr 06 issue of Skeptic by Charles Lambdin,
The Fallacy of the Golden Mean, which I was glad someone voiced.
COPYRIGHT 2006 Skeptics Society & Skeptic Magazine
THE FALLACY OF THE GOLDEN Mean, a.k.a. Fallacy of the Mean, Fallacy of Compromise, or Fallacy of Moderation, is based on the assumption that the middle ground is always more likely to be a correct position than the two positions that are identified as the extremes. Just as moderates frequently presume to hold the key to political progress over both ultra-conservatives and extreme liberals, so too in science is it all-too-often assumed a priori that given a heated debate between two extreme positions that the troth lies somewhere in the middle. The middle position often appears as a compromise, and who does not like someone who is willing to compromise?
It is thus quite easy to see that aside from our near-ubiquitous tendency to assume, epistemologically, that the truth really must lie somewhere "in the middle"...
A religious fundamentalist and a "hardcore" political party member as you seem to be referring to is one who is no longer making decisions and drawing conclusions based on evidence. It is not someone who has concluded the evidence leads one to conclude an extreme view.
This can sometimes make one question oneself, "am I seeing the evidence objectively when many people are claiming I am not?" Yet we all know of people throughout history who held the minority view which was later determined to be the correct view.
We all have filters which information is processed through, things which are either in our nature or nurture which affect how we perceive the evidence. When the majority are interpreting the evidence one way, and you are sure of a different conclusion, you do need to examine your filters, and you need to look at what, why and how others might be perceiving things differently. But in the end, if you fall back on the evidence rather than on the majority interpretation, then you won't be relying on the fallacy of the golden mean.
Just a side note, since I obviously have a 'reputation' as someone with strong political convictions, I am not a hardcore Democrat. My filters make me acutely aware of the danger that power corrupts. But more importantly, where I seem to be at odds with a lot of people (hard to say if it's a majority, not all thread lurkers make themselves known) is where I see marketing and other persuasion techniques that for whatever reason, way too many people are oblivious to. If you don't know you are being persuaded by tactics rather than substance, you aren't going to recognize the difference between conclusions based on that persuasion vs what you might conclude if you only saw the evidence.
These persuasion tactics are pervasive throughout our society. I know I am evaluating the evidence and when the golden mean is affected by persuasion tactics I have enough confidence to determine I am not 'hardcore' or dogmatic at all. I am looking at the evidence and my filters are there but they aren't blinding me like I believe they are blinding a lot of other people. And I know that because the evidence is there to show it.