Have you changed any major belief as an adult?

Stellafane - I had a similar "realization" about memory when I saw a PBS special on the brain (with Alan Alda, I believe). I used to think our memories were fixed and unchanging, for the most part (Alzheimer's and other afflictions aside). But in this show, they demonstrated how easy it was to implant false memories. I was stupified! But very cool stuff...
 
From the age of six I read all kinds of UFO literature, Velikovsky, etc. I would tear open any machine that I thought I could get away with. I remember occasions where my family would laugh because they would be talking about something and I would leave to go look at it myself. Although I put inappropriate weight on what truths were likely and unlikely it always was a pursuit of evidence for me. Eventually the pseudoscience books lost any appeal because not only did they fail to ever include any new evidence they showed little interest in real evidence. Worse still was the hostility toward any contrary evidence.

From childhood people would question me about my beliefs. This was often quiet confusing to me. I would try to describe the evidence and they would seem confused. They would often try to pin me down by saying, "so you don't believe/believe X? I would respond with, "are there any other reasons you can think of why I should believe or disbelieve X?" Yes I have always been considered weird.

So have I changed by beliefs. Not really. I have changed priorities on what I am willing to seriously consider. This is a result of choosing to avoid wasting time on things with outrageous odds more than a change in belief.

I still hold a nonconformist (semi-classical) interpretation of physics. In holding these views I study the standard model and every view and especially every bit of empirical evidence to the contrary. The historical reasons for rejecting such an interpretation is very valid. Those who claim the standard model is wrong or a dogmatism are perhaps delusional and definitely off their empirical rocker. Is my approach a long shot? Of course. We have to place bets somewhere. The bets we place do not define the truth but very occasionally they pay off.
 
Have you changed any major belief as an adult?

Only one: That love lasts forever. I've found out as an adult that in the vast majority of relationships, it lasts only as long as a man's most recent paycheck or a woman's first missed menstrual cycle.
 
I used to believe in all the new age stuff, and was studying palmistry. I was giving a reading to someone in the college cafeteria when the person standing next to us said (quite genuinely excited) "Wow, you've just described me perfectly."

That was the first thing that pushed me towards examining the things I believed a little more rigourously.
 
A major belief I changed as an adult...well, religion, obviously.

I was raised Catholic and even as a kid had heavy doubts. I clung to it, though, and struggled with it for years until I was 16 going on 17. I fitted and refitted all sorts of rationalizations and repeatedly patched a bucket that was really a sieve for a time, was satisfied with that.

Then, miraculously, about a month before I turned 17, it just flew out the door. Any beliefs I had left were just gone. I stopped even caring; it wasn't the central question in my life any longer.

I've heard people say they've had a similar experience.
 
Stellafane - I had a similar "realization" about memory when I saw a PBS special on the brain (with Alan Alda, I believe). I used to think our memories were fixed and unchanging, for the most part (Alzheimer's and other afflictions aside). But in this show, they demonstrated how easy it was to implant false memories. I was stupified! But very cool stuff...

There was a documentary (2 actually) about a guy named Clive Wearing who is in a perpetual twilight zone loop because he cannot make new memories... he always feels like he has just woken up for the first time. He cries when he sees his kids, because he missed seeing them grow up--only he didn't; he just can't remember. He greets his wife with the same overwhelming enthusiasm every time she enters the room--he just woke up from a horrendous coma (in his mind) and there she is waiting for him!!! He keeps writing in a journal: "I am now fully awake for the first time". The more recent documentary is called The Man with the 7-Second Memory.

It is so tragic. It got me thinking about how the brain makes up stories and explanations when it doesn't understand things. And it made me think that souls cannot be real. If this man is such an untethered being without a hippocampus... how can anyone be anything without a brain at all. If souls were real, why wouldn't they step in when a person was blind or demented... what could a soul do if all feeling and thinking was in the brain. This had been nagging at me for a while. PBS had a documentary called Secrets of the Mind... with similar victims.

God and such and long stopped making sense to me--too many questions... it couldn't be true... or if something was true, there was no way to tell supposed truth from another. It made me think about truth and how we know what is and isn't. I became very interested in neurology, genetics, and the ways people fool themselves. Randi was a big help. And it was something Dawkins wrote that really drove the point home about faith being a bad way to actually "know" anything. All this brouhaha about faith being good and necessary and this notion that you can "know" stuff via faith, feeling, and/or revelation is clearly untrue and just a means of people fooling themselves and others. I remember making a conscious decision that I'd rather not know something than belief a lie--even if the lie made me feel good.

I was raise Catholic... segued towards new age beliefs as a teen , but was a full "grown up "atheist/materialist by my mid 30s. I'm independent politically with strong progressive leanings.
 
Last edited:
In my young years I was a firm believer in UFOs as ships from other worlds. But I've changed my mind, nowadays I still believe in UFOs, but as objects/phenomena from "this world" that can't be identified due to insufficient information.

As for other paranormal "phenomena", none!, never paid much attention nor have had interest in any other form of "beyond the normal" stuff.
I forgot about this. It isn't so much that I believed in all the fun paranormal stuff but I used to believe the cases presented in books and on TV about 'real' events were really the case. It's lost a lot of the fun to now watch a program because I know they are just giving a fake version of the evidence. So it's my trust in what I'm seeing that has changed. I only believed in the phenomena as something 'unexplained' and I can't recall ever being completely convinced there were ghosts or ETs visiting. I may have believed people really did have premonitions or esp, but again, it's because I took at face value what the story was.
 
The end of woo for me: Oft repeated on these forums, a skeptical friend asked me to video and audio tape readings I gave people. Then we would follow up with the folks after a couple of weeks, and compare my memories, their memories, and the truth. I pretty much abandoned all woo and sought evidence to prove any outrageous claims after that.
So you were able to re-evaluate your beliefs with new evidence. I wonder if that is something we possess as skeptics or if it is something in a lot of non-skeptics but they need the right evidence to be convinced to change?

.... blinding partisanship can be (this is not directed at you). Hardcore democrats taught me that they could be zealots on par in hostility and one sidedness as any religious fundamentalist. Hardcore republicans, even the non-religious ones, taught me that there was no amount of spin they wouldn't stoop to in order to engineer an issue into some kind of cultural battle. Hardcore Greens and Libertarians taught me that there is no true green or libertarian, just folks vacillating around their particular pet issues.

Leaving me no affiliation or "in group" to identify with, I learned to think for myself. I learned that I could examine an issue without histrionics and judge it on merit. You know---critical thinking and skepticism. I also decided that I would not judge all republicans evil fundies or all democrats as screaming liberal loonies. I would take them on a case by case basis. Sometimes they are right, and sometimes they are wrong. But I only truly learned to examine an issue with a clear head by stepping away and sorting through all the BS.
There was an article in the 4th qtr 06 issue of Skeptic by Charles Lambdin, The Fallacy of the Golden Mean, which I was glad someone voiced.
COPYRIGHT 2006 Skeptics Society & Skeptic Magazine

THE FALLACY OF THE GOLDEN Mean, a.k.a. Fallacy of the Mean, Fallacy of Compromise, or Fallacy of Moderation, is based on the assumption that the middle ground is always more likely to be a correct position than the two positions that are identified as the extremes. Just as moderates frequently presume to hold the key to political progress over both ultra-conservatives and extreme liberals, so too in science is it all-too-often assumed a priori that given a heated debate between two extreme positions that the troth lies somewhere in the middle. The middle position often appears as a compromise, and who does not like someone who is willing to compromise?

It is thus quite easy to see that aside from our near-ubiquitous tendency to assume, epistemologically, that the truth really must lie somewhere "in the middle"...
A religious fundamentalist and a "hardcore" political party member as you seem to be referring to is one who is no longer making decisions and drawing conclusions based on evidence. It is not someone who has concluded the evidence leads one to conclude an extreme view.

This can sometimes make one question oneself, "am I seeing the evidence objectively when many people are claiming I am not?" Yet we all know of people throughout history who held the minority view which was later determined to be the correct view.

We all have filters which information is processed through, things which are either in our nature or nurture which affect how we perceive the evidence. When the majority are interpreting the evidence one way, and you are sure of a different conclusion, you do need to examine your filters, and you need to look at what, why and how others might be perceiving things differently. But in the end, if you fall back on the evidence rather than on the majority interpretation, then you won't be relying on the fallacy of the golden mean.


Just a side note, since I obviously have a 'reputation' as someone with strong political convictions, I am not a hardcore Democrat. My filters make me acutely aware of the danger that power corrupts. But more importantly, where I seem to be at odds with a lot of people (hard to say if it's a majority, not all thread lurkers make themselves known) is where I see marketing and other persuasion techniques that for whatever reason, way too many people are oblivious to. If you don't know you are being persuaded by tactics rather than substance, you aren't going to recognize the difference between conclusions based on that persuasion vs what you might conclude if you only saw the evidence.

These persuasion tactics are pervasive throughout our society. I know I am evaluating the evidence and when the golden mean is affected by persuasion tactics I have enough confidence to determine I am not 'hardcore' or dogmatic at all. I am looking at the evidence and my filters are there but they aren't blinding me like I believe they are blinding a lot of other people. And I know that because the evidence is there to show it.
 
Last edited:
In my early teens I staunchly subscribed to Communism. That lasted until my early 20s when I shifted to Socialism.
 
Growing up in the hey days of post-WWII Western capitalism, I assumed that our political institutions were inviolably right, sacrosanct, and completely safe from any political skullduggery, as if it was a natural law.

Yeah, right.
While I lost my belief in the John Wayne version of America in my early 20s in Central America. ("The Confessions of an Economic Hit Man", is close to the version of America I now hold.) This is another of my "filters" but it increases my skill at recognizing the persuasion tactics rather than decreasing my objectivity.

And I also suffered an emotional crisis when the courts failed me. The better lawyer, not the actual case is what matters in our courts and when that turned into a personal exposure, it was really stressful. And it recently happened to my brother in another case. The experience of the courts failing to actually work the way we've grown up believing they work is sometimes a significant thing in people's lives. I'm trying to convey the emotion to someone who hasn't had the experience but it's like finding out you were adopted when you are 20. There is this weird emotional stress.
 
In retrospect, I may have hard core skeptic leanings from a very young age.

I remember watching the Wizard of Oz and finding it completely implausible that 4 people who had just met knew the same song and dance ("we're off to see the Wizard...). There's a lot of fantastical stuff in that movie--but that's the one that really pissed me off. The rest could all be part of "the dream"--but I doubt any dreams are choreographed.
 
I can't really think of anything... I mean, I learn new things all the time, and have to reconsider what I knew, or thought I knew before. But one big, really major thing, something that really played a big part in my life... I don't think so, really. It has more been a life of numerous and continous smaller changes.

I just saw that film yesterday actually. I liked it, it was interesting. Many smart people speaking very well of very interesting things. But there was nothing major that was really groundbreakingly new to me, though there were many minor facts that were new to me.
So it was convincing and you already believed it, or it wasn't convincing?
 
A big one for me was false memories, especially as they related to the day-care abuse scandals of the 1980's and 90's. At the time I totally believed the children, and couldn't imagine why or how they would make up stuff like this. I thought the people accused were the worst sort of scum who ever slithered the face of earth, and couldn't even conceive of how any jury could let any of these vermin off.

But as I learned more, I discovered how the children's testimony was coached and coerced, how false memories could be so easily planted, how so much contradictory evidence was simply ignored to make for a "cleaner" case for the prosecution. The horrifying realization came over me that I was almost certainly totally wrong, that the real victims were the day-care workers, and that political motivations were keeping innocent people in jail. Suddenly woo wasn't harmless or goofy anymore, it was something that needed to be fought.
I saw the Frontline program on The Little Rascals Daycare incident. I was so upset I sent money to Dawn Wilson for her legal defense. A single mom, just the cook at this daycare, and given a life sentence essentially for refusing to plea bargain and admit to something she didn't do. Their convictions were eventually overturned and while the prosecutor wanted to refile the charges, he eventually gave up.

Makes you wonder if the prosecutor ever realized he was wrong and these people were innocent. Why these prosecutors never seem to give up is beyond me, at least the ones you see being interviewed after someone has been clearly shown to either be innocent or at least reasonable doubt exists. It's as if it is too painful for the prosecutors to admit they made an error and someone went to jail because of it.
 
I went from pro-life to pro-choice (to use the common, if not the accurate euphemisms). I'm not sure if that was a major change or just the natural consequence of following a materialist philosophy to its natural conclusion.
I have fluctuated on the death penalty. My current position is we are convicting too many innocent people as evidence by DNA. So until we fix that problem, we need a moratorium. I was against the death penalty on moral grounds when I was younger. But there was this creep in my local area who was convicted of rape. He got out of jail and raped and killed the woman who testified against him, her neighbor who I think also testified and the 8 year old daughter of the rape victim. I had no issues that he got the death penalty.
 
Last edited:
Makes you wonder if the prosecutor ever realized he was wrong and these people were innocent. Why these prosecutors never seem to give up is beyond me, at least the ones you see being interviewed after someone has been clearly shown to either be innocent or at least reasonable doubt exists. It's as if it is too painful for the prosecutors to admit they made an error and someone went to jail because of it.

Yeah, prestige is a dangerous thing. And I can understand it hurts to admit an error if you have invested much in it, but for goodness sake, when a persons reputation, freedom and well, life, depends on it, you have to be prepared to admit you can make mistakes! It's incredibly egotistical not to in cases like this, I think. But maybe it's so painful they don't even realize they do it? :confused:
 
So it was convincing and you already believed it, or it wasn't convincing?

Most of it were things I had heard and/or read about before and already agreed on, so I needed no convincing, no. But I enjoy very much listening to people who can really express themselves well. I think that if I had not known about these things though, it would definitely have given me much to think about. Had I been a fencesitter I think this film very well could have won me over. But it's hard to say, now that I am not... :confused:

Am I making any sense here? :o I wish I could express myself as well as some of the people in the film. :(
 
In retrospect, I may have hard core skeptic leanings from a very young age.

I remember watching the Wizard of Oz and finding it completely implausible that 4 people who had just met knew the same song and dance ("we're off to see the Wizard...). There's a lot of fantastical stuff in that movie--but that's the one that really pissed me off. The rest could all be part of "the dream"--but I doubt any dreams are choreographed.

*LOL* I recognize this so well. I never could stand musicals for this reason :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom