Hardly any critical thinking regarding Ron Paul.

How can the NAU be a crank conspiracy theory if there are people who are pushing for it?
Because there are people psuhing for anything, unless there is significant support it's irrelevant that someone, somewhere supports it.

How did you refute that the CFR endorses the NAU?

"publishing an article in your magazine does not equal an endorsement, if it did then the CFR would be endorsing both the foreign policy of Gulliani and of Edwards, in the same issue no less."

How did you refute that the CFR influences policy?
"Any club with such a diverse membership is clearly a honourary association, not a policy advocate because there's almost nothing it's members would agree on. It even says right there that it's purpose it to "improve the understanding of U.S. foreign policy" not that the purpose is to advocate anything."

Did you read the article posted by the CFR itself?

I read the article by Robert A. Pastor. It is either extremely ignorant or extremely dishonest to attribute the views in it to the CFR. Not only does publishing an article not equal support for the ideas in it, but the "nearly all past and present Presidents, Secretaries of State, Defense and Treasury, other senior U.S. government officials, renowned scholars, and major leaders of business, media, human rights, and other non-governmental groups" who are members of this honourary association almost certainly has nothing to do with the day-to day running of Foreign Affairs magazine.
 
Well, since I never claimed that CFR has anything to do with the government, there is no need for me to list any government officials who advocate this.
So when Ron Paul fear-mongers about how NAFTA will lead to a NAU he is trying to create hysteria over something tha does not even exist, yes?

And you're comfortable with your candidate tilting at windmills when there's real problems to be solved?
 
So when Ron Paul fear-mongers about how NAFTA will lead to a NAU he is trying to create hysteria over something tha does not even exist, yes?

And you're comfortable with your candidate tilting at windmills when there's real problems to be solved?

Fear-mongers?
How is he fear-mongering when the only time he talks about it is when he is asked a question about it?

If there are people who actually push for it then the idea has been brought to the table weather it goes through or not. If the idea has been brought to the table Conspiracy theorist nuts have a right to say "Look, Look, Look, i told you this is what they want!!! NWO blah blah blah." You cant call then they are crazy if it gets talked about. You can reason with them and explain to them why its almost impossible for it to go through, but to tell them the idea doesnt exist is stupid.

Also what do you expect Ron Paul to do when asked about it? Say oh that doesnt exist if he has clearly heard some of the people he deals with talk about it? He has been a Doctor and congressmen for 10 terms so clearly he isnt as crazy as you all claim he is, and there must be some validity to what he says.
 
The conspiracy theory is not that some people support the idea of a NAU. The CT is that the powers that be are clandestinely at work right now, bringing about the Union, without the knowledge or consent of the public, and that NAFTA and other such cooperative measures are simply stepping stones along the way.
 
Obviously that's not a general rule, but on average the only arguments against Ron Paul are either smears, or cynical non-sequitur comments.
This forum is crammed full of rational critiques of libertarian policies, and robust discussions for and against. Since Paul supports a fundamentally libertarian position, those who have made up their mind about the desirability of libertarian policy do not feel the need to make detailed explanations of why they reject Paul. I suppose that if your only experience with political discussion on this forum were threads specifically about Paul, you might come to the conclusion that the opposition was not based on rational analysis. But that doesn't mean that this is the case.
 
Fear-mongers?
How is he fear-mongering when the only time he talks about it is when he is asked a question about it?

If there are people who actually push for it then the idea has been brought to the table weather it goes through or not. If the idea has been brought to the table Conspiracy theorist nuts have a right to say "Look, Look, Look, i told you this is what they want!!! NWO blah blah blah." You cant call then they are crazy if it gets talked about. You can reason with them and explain to them why its almost impossible for it to go through, but to tell them the idea doesnt exist is stupid.
Have you been reading this thread, if you have you will note that there is incontrocertiable evidence that we both can and do call them crazy. Futhermore it is perfectly reasonable for us to do so even if someone does talk about it as long as the proponents of the NAU are few and insignificant.

Also what do you expect Ron Paul to do when asked about it? Say oh that doesnt exist if he has clearly heard some of the people he deals with talk about it? He has been a Doctor and congressmen for 10 terms so clearly he isnt as crazy as you all claim he is, and there must be some validity to what he says.
So is it all doctors And all congressmen who are automatically right, or is it only those who are both? Also could you perhaps give us a full or partial list of proffesions and compinations of proffessions that automatically preclude gross stupidity in a person?
 
The conspiracy theory is not that some people support the idea of a NAU. The CT is that the powers that be are clandestinely at work right now, bringing about the Union, without the knowledge or consent of the public, and that NAFTA and other such cooperative measures are simply stepping stones along the way.

This i do know already, but i was talking in relation to people accusing Ron Paul of feeding into this. All that Ron Paul acknowledged is that there are people he says "In Washington" who wanted this to happen.
He just refuses to act like the topic just totally doesnt exist like other pretend to.
 
This i do know already, but i was talking in relation to people accusing Ron Paul of feeding into this. All that Ron Paul acknowledged is that there are people he says "In Washington" who wanted this to happen.
He just refuses to act like the topic just totally doesnt exist like other pretend to.

So let's hear names, who in Washington wants this? Certainly the voting public needs to know this so they can make the appropriate choice at the polls.
 
Don't imagine for a moment that you (plural) are better than they are.

Not better than Stormfront people? How could we not be better, in at least one major aspect, than Stormfront? These are not rational people we are talking about.

They reject human dignity and they find Ron Paul the least objectionable of the Republican field.

They like RP for the havoc he would wreak on civilization as we know it, and the cover it would give white nationalists for some of the measures they would like to see put in place to return to the bad old days of racism.
 
This i do know already, but i was talking in relation to people accusing Ron Paul of feeding into this. All that Ron Paul acknowledged is that there are people he says "In Washington" who wanted this to happen.
He just refuses to act like the topic just totally doesnt exist like other pretend to.

Ron Paul believes the NAU conspiracy is an active undertaking, involving, among other parties, the governments of the US, Canada, and Mexico.

This is a far cry from simply acknowledging, as you suggest, that more than one person in the city favors the idea.
 
In other words, you are saying it has basis on reality, but it is unlikely to be approved by Canada for pragmatic reasons. So again, how are you disagreeing with me?
There is already an established trading agreement between the three nations; it's been in place for fourteen years now (nineteen years between the U.S. and Canada).

Common currency, open borders, political union, etc., are a whole other different level of union well beyond the practical benefits of a trade agreements. But it's these type of things which are conjured up by the term "North American Union" not revisions or adjustments to NAFTA or other established trading rules.

Ron Paul believes the NAU conspiracy is an active undertaking, involving, among other parties, the governments of the US, Canada, and Mexico.
That was certainly my impression of what he had to say during the Republican debate awhile back.
 
This is the question that keeps popping up, and to which no Ron Paul supporter to date has answered.

Its a stupid question when pointed towards me you morons!
Clearly if you can read i said Ron Paul stated and even put in quotes "Washington". When referring to people in Washington who wanted this. I did not say i know people in Washington or have seen papers with people names in Washington who want this, but i stated Ron Paul said. Huge difference Jackass's!!!! YOu have proved me wrong on nothing!

Now for those who dont know because of there own lack of research....

Ron Paul claims he has not said names because of the fact that these names never appeared on paper and if he were to say names then they could just deny the fact, and act as it was proof Ron Paul was crazy. So he avoids the topic of WHO. Clearly you big thinkers can understand the logic behind that! Paul only says that there was a push for this by those in Washington and doesnt elaborate because he doesnt have the hard evidence against it.
If he were to say names without the documentation there would be no point. They (People in Washington) could just say "No we Didnt" and there goes Ron Paul looking like a "WingNut" again.


Is it true? I dont know, but i cant tell him he is wrong for i have nothing to prove it. I also can not prove he is right, but the fact that you continuously ask this question and act like someones not being able to answer it is proof of its stupidity and how false it must be only shows how ignorant you are.

Im sorry that i do not have the paper documents in which a list of names of people who wanted this is on. Because even if i was able to state names it wouldnt be good enough for you all! You would then ask for some sort of evidence inwhich it proves that this was there intention. Also i never made the claim that i knew who it was sooo please stop asking me like i do!

If i knew these individuals personally and had heard them with my own ears all say they were plotting this and wanted it done within the next 5 years you all would still say i was lying and a loon because of the fact i dont have paper inwhich you can read it, and a confession signed by each member with there fingerprint in the upper right hand corner!

You guys are so smug as well as stupid when it comes to this. Again i dont believe in this huge conspiracy about the NAU and whatnot but i am not jackass enough to look at those who say they have heard of it and been around those discussing it and call them lairs!

So in the end i will again state that Ron Paul (not myself) claims he has heard people in Washington discuss this, and that there was a push for it. Is it true? Again i dont know but i do believe the topic was one that has been brought up before, and its approval was probably seeked between a small group of individuals.

It basically comes down to do you think Ron Paul is lying when he says that these discussions took place or not? NOt me being a loony...Jackasses


So intelligent members of this forum, please tell me where in this statement i say that i know who these people in Washington are...

"This i do know already, but i was talking in relation to people accusing Ron Paul of feeding into this. All that Ron Paul acknowledged is that there are people he says "In Washington" who wanted this to happen."

For those who dont know or are to lazy to read back that (quoted above) is the comment that sparked this question to me....

"So let's hear names, who in Washington wants this? Certainly the voting public needs to know this so they can make the appropriate choice at the polls."

Then this stupid comment....

"his is the question that keeps popping up, and to which no Ron Paul supporter to date has answered."
 
Common currency, open borders, political union, etc., are a whole other different level of union well beyond the practical benefits of a trade agreements. But it's these type of things which are conjured up by the term "North American Union" not revisions or adjustments to NAFTA or other established trading rules.

I can't see the Canadians peacefully agreeing to take on a common currency with us after the mess that W has made of the dollar.

By ranting about the NAU, which does not even exist in as substantial a form as PNAC, RP just exploites a nameless fear of the menacing and intangible, thus undefeatable "Them."

He is playing the same game that W is playing in his unwinnable militarty "war on terror."
 
Ron Paul claims he has not said names because of the fact that these names never appeared on paper and if he were to say names then they could just deny the fact, and act as it was proof Ron Paul was crazy. So he avoids the topic of WHO. Clearly you big thinkers can understand the logic behind that! Paul only says that there was a push for this by those in Washington and doesnt elaborate because he doesnt have the hard evidence against it.
If he were to say names without the documentation there would be no point. They (People in Washington) could just say "No we Didnt" and there goes Ron Paul looking like a "WingNut" again.
So either there is a sinister and shadowy conspiracy among parts of the Washington establishment to bring about a NAU, or else Ron Paul is lying.

So intelligent members of this forum, please tell me where in this statement i say that i know who these people in Washington are...

"This i do know already, but i was talking in relation to people accusing Ron Paul of feeding into this. All that Ron Paul acknowledged is that there are people he says "In Washington" who wanted this to happen."
Quick English lesson for you: Your use of the word "acknowledged" implies a fact which one can "acknowledge" or not, but which is a fact regardless, asking for evidence of this alledged fact is perfectly reasonable. If you wish to acknowledge that you used the word "acknowledge" incorrectly to convey a meaning you didn't intend that is one thing, but don't blame me for having a better understanding of what the words you use means than you have.
 
Again, it is not true that Ron Paul simply claims that some people want a NAU.

Ron Paul claims that there is an active conspiracy working to bring about a NAU against the will of the people, and that legislation like NAFTA is the work of this conspiracy.
 
Of all the candidates running for president, the only person who gets attacked here is Ron Paul.

Well, of course that's a lie; but it is almost true. He does get attacked here more than the other candidates. Maybe if his toadies would stop using this forum to gush about how Ron Paul is the second-effing-coming-of-Christ, he wouldn't attract so much negative attention here.
 
The North American Union is an abstract term for the integration of the economies of Canada, Mexico, and the United States. I was skeptical about the NAU, and I still think people oversensationalize it, so I asked for proof. The Council on Foreign Relations does endorse a single currency (the Amero) and it does endorse a political union to strengthen the "North American Continent" so that the three countries can coordinate and protect themselves from terrorism.

Whether or not this is under way, the intent is there.

I personally don't care that much about a hypothetical NAU either way. But I do oppose any ideologies that are based on the assumption the we must make Homeland Security bigger to protect ourselves from terrorists. As such, I do oppose the Council on Foreign Relations.

http://www.foreignaffairs.org/20040...t-a-pastor/north-america-s-second-decade.html



Hi, I read through that article and nowhere in it did I see where the CFR supported the idea of the Amero or dissolving our borders into a NAU. Care to quote the relevant passages for me?
 
Hold on quick question....

What is the big deal about this super highway anyway when the i35 already basically starts in mexico and ends in Canada???
 
Hold on quick question....

What is the big deal about this super highway anyway when the i35 already basically starts in mexico and ends in Canada???

There is no big deal, it's a crazy conspiracy theory. Leave facts and common sense at the door.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom