Hardly any critical thinking regarding Ron Paul.

Wildcat's assertion that Ron Paul specifically promotes quackery and homeopathy and that it is his intention to do so.
you have not shown this to be a lie.


Actually, my second sentence does follow from the first. In my first sentence I said that I have been addressing the issues, while other people like Wildcat and others have instead been engaging in ad hominem attacks.
show where you have been attacked. criticism of the policies of Ron Paul do not constitute an personal attack, your personal commonest about other posters come close.

It follows that since you are being unfair by calling me out instead of them, you are taunting me.
I am not taunting you I am reminding you of the rules of this forum.
 
So then quoting a CFR article proves what, exactly?

It was a response to someone who said Ron Paul's discussion on an NAU was not grounded on reality.

I simply pointed out that there are political interest groups that indeed endorse and advocate the economical and defensive integration of these three countries.

That's all.
 
you have not shown this to be a lie.

I guess it will be just fine if I call Rudy Giuliani a terrorist given such standards. After all it's not a lie. It's simply an unfounded accusation.

show where you have been attacked. criticism of the policies of Ron Paul do not constitute an personal attack, your personal commonest about other posters come close.

I've been called a cultist in another thread. I think that counts as a personal attack.

I am not taunting you I am reminding you of the rules of this forum.

Alright, then. I'll have a closer look at the rules.
 
It was a response to someone who said Ron Paul's discussion on an NAU was not grounded on reality.

I simply pointed out that there are political interest groups that indeed endorse and advocate the economical and defensive integration of these three countries.

That's all.
If some unofficial organisation working for something was proof it was grounded in reality you'd be hard pressed to find any piece of insanity not "grounded in reality".
 
If some unofficial organisation working for something was proof it was grounded in reality you'd be hard pressed to find any piece of insanity not "grounded in reality".

What difference does it make whether it is "official" or "unofficial"? I think you are missing the point of my response.
 
What difference does it make whether it is "official" or "unofficial"? I think you are missing the point of my response.

The difference is that official organisations do not represent anyone but themselves, and I think you're the one who's missing the point. The NAU is a cranck conspiracy theory with no basis in reality. That some unoffocial organisation might work for it has no bearing on the case unless you can prove it has significant support either in the population, in official circles or better yet, both. However neither is the case, and we can therefore reasonably call RP a cranck for indorsing this nonsense.
 
The NAU is a cranck conspiracy theory with no basis in reality. That some unoffocial organisation might work for it has no bearing on the case unless you can prove it has significant support either in the population, in official circles or better yet, both. However neither is the case, and we can therefore reasonably call RP a cranck for indorsing this nonsense.
My thanks to Kerberos for restating my point more eloquently than perhaps I did.
 
There are posts on this board from people whom other members clearly consider barking moonbats. Some of them are gone for good, and are referred to as lunatics and trolls. A few linger, and we are a little more cautious about how we refer to them. The barking moonbats all seem to share one political preferrence. They almost unanimously like RP.

There are RP supporters whjo are not total moonbats, but generally, they do not include our best and brightest or most congenial fellows.
 
There are posts on this board from people whom other members clearly consider barking moonbats. Some of them are gone for good, and are referred to as lunatics and trolls. A few linger, and we are a little more cautious about how we refer to them. The barking moonbats all seem to share one political preferrence. They almost unanimously like RP.

There are RP supporters whjo are not total moonbats, but generally, they do not include our best and brightest or most congenial fellows.

Thanks for your unwanted words of wisdom.

As for my "MoonBat' defense of myself sense you quite possibly could have been referring to me in that general bashing of the other members of the board, i have this too say.

I am rather new to the political game and will for the most part tell anyone i encounter i just dont know enough to debate with those who have been in the game for years, but refuse to just sit back and take there word for it because they supposedly know more then i.
Which is somewhat how most of the members who are "brightest or most congenial fellows" respond to people like myself. They expect to me just take there word for it, and if through my own research or lack there of proper information yet to be found i dont come to there conclusions i am and or anyone like myself is considered a "MoonBat".

They dont attempt to sway me through proper debating or presentation of facts. Nor do they even attempt to acknowledge me as an individual with an IQ over 85. Just pointless meaningless bashing, and those who share the same ideals jump into the convo with more meaningless bashing and slick terms like "Planet x" or "wingnut".

This board to me looks rather foolish at times with some of the more regular posters coming and taking quick Jabs at those who have views that may be considered slightly off to the left. Yet they claim they are correct with no actual evidence other then there own thoughts and views on what will and cannot work.

It seems you all desperately oppose Ron Paul and all of his ideals yet most know almost nothing about the man and i can safely say that many misinterpret him. I could fish the forums for the dozens of times the man has been miss quoted or interpreted wrong for i know some jerk of a forum clown will ask for the evidence and quoted cases of misinterpretations, but i do not have the time to do so. Does this mean it hasnt happened? Some of you will claim yes, and then try to speak on how my lacking ability to provide such evidence after making such claims no doubly points to me knowing nothing of what i am talking about, thus making me clearly wrong and a "moonbat".

So be it, for i no longer look for the approval of the moronic inhibitors of this forum nor do i need your approval to know my intelligence and my own abilities. I am beyond what most of you would consider to be critical thinking. For i constantly am looking for the information to prove what i believe wrong.

So in turn i will continue to be critical and come to my own conclusions, and if one day through years of "proper" research i am able to finally able to gather enough information to say that everyone here was correct and i have finally been able to prove it to myself. Then that would be great and would mean nothing more to me then i did what i always do, which is question.
BUT....
For all you to claim that i am not critical because i dont agree with you is stupid. I may not have come to your conclusions yet because i have been researching it for a total of 6 months, and being new to something doesnt imply they are stupid or not critical. It implies they just havent received and or come across the proper information.
For all of you to look at the likes of me and say i am not a critical thinker is rather absurd.
Instead i feel most of you have researched enough to come to the conclusions you are comfortable with and then decided they are the final word...."Just food for thought"

P.S.
Its not that all "barking MoonBats" on this forum support Ron Paul. Its that anyone who supports Ron Paul on this Forum you call a "barking MoonBat". There is a big difference my ignorant friend.
 
I can't, for example, think of a racist or a no-planer who speaks ill of RP.

All no-planers and racists are, in my opinion, less than sane.
 
The difference is that official organisations do not represent anyone but themselves, and I think you're the one who's missing the point. The NAU is a cranck conspiracy theory with no basis in reality. That some unoffocial organisation might work for it has no bearing on the case unless you can prove it has significant support either in the population, in official circles or better yet, both. However neither is the case, and we can therefore reasonably call RP a cranck for indorsing this nonsense.

But it does have a basis on reality. I already showed you the article published by the CFR. The CFR is not official, but it does influence foreign policy. Look at a list of their members.

In other words you are not really disagreeing with me, so stop pretending you are.
 
There are posts on this board from people whom other members clearly consider barking moonbats. Some of them are gone for good, and are referred to as lunatics and trolls. A few linger, and we are a little more cautious about how we refer to them. The barking moonbats all seem to share one political preferrence. They almost unanimously like RP.

There are RP supporters whjo are not total moonbats, but generally, they do not include our best and brightest or most congenial fellows.

Well, the general population here doesn't appear any brighter. Most of you are partisan hacks. Obviously that's not a general rule, but on average the only arguments against Ron Paul are either smears, or cynical non-sequitur comments.
 
Last edited:
I can't, for example, think of a racist or a no-planer who speaks ill of RP.

All no-planers and racists are, in my opinion, less than sane.

I suggest you visit Stormfront. The rhetoric there against Ron Paul is just as baseless as it is here.

Don't imagine for a moment that you (plural) are better than they are.
 
But it does have a basis on reality. I already showed you the article published by the CFR. The CFR is not official, but it does influence foreign policy. Look at a list of their members.

In other words you are not really disagreeing with me, so stop pretending you are.

I am most certainly not agreeing with you and I'd appreciate if you would stop putting words in my mouth. You should also stop putting words in the mouth of the CFR. I see no evidence whatsoever in your links that the CFR as such endorses the NAU, publishing an article in your magazine does not equal an endorsement, if it did then the CFR would be endorsing both the foreign policy of Gulliani and of Edwards, in the same issue no less. Actually I very much doubt that the CFR endorses anything at all, you see I did look at a list of it's members and applied some critical thinking.

"Founded in 1921, the Council on Foreign Relations is a non-profit and nonpartisan membership organization dedicated to improving the understanding of U.S. foreign policy and international affairs through the free exchange of ideas. Its 3,400 members include nearly all past and present Presidents, Secretaries of State, Defense and Treasury, other senior U.S. government officials, renowned scholars, and major leaders of business, media, human rights, and other non-governmental groups."

Any club with such a diverse membership is clearly a honourary association, not a policy advocate because there's almost nothing it's members would agree on. It even says right there that it's purpose it to "improve the understanding of U.S. foreign policy" not that the purpose is to advocate anything. So in Sumery the CFR does not in fact endorse the NAU. The CFR does not in fact influence foreign policy as a group (though it's individual members do). The NAU is not in fractgrounded in reality for any reasonable definition of "grounded in reality" or even, as it turns out, for the extremely lenient defintion of "grounded in reality" that you prefer.
 
Last edited:
I am most certainly not agreeing with you and I'd appreciate if you would stop putting words in my mouth. You should also stop putting words in the mouth of the CFR. I see no evidence whatsoever in your links that the CFR as such endorses the NAU, publishing an article in your magazine does not equal an endorsement, if it did then the CFR would be endorsing both the foreign policy of Gulliani and of Edwards, in the same issue no less. Actually I very much doubt that the CFR endorses anything at all, you see I did look at a list of it's members and applied some critical thinking.

"Founded in 1921, the Council on Foreign Relations is a non-profit and nonpartisan membership organization dedicated to improving the understanding of U.S. foreign policy and international affairs through the free exchange of ideas. Its 3,400 members include nearly all past and present Presidents, Secretaries of State, Defense and Treasury, other senior U.S. government officials, renowned scholars, and major leaders of business, media, human rights, and other non-governmental groups."

Any club with such a diverse membership is clearly a honourary association, not a policy advocate because there's almost nothing it's members would agree on. It even says right there that it's purpose it to "improve the understanding of U.S. foreign policy" not that the purpose is to advocate anything. So in Sumery the CFR does not in fact endorse the NAU. The CFR does not in fact influence foreign policy as a group (though it's individual members do). The NAU is not in fractgrounded in reality for any reasonable definition of "grounded in reality" or even, as it turns out, for the extremely lenient defintion of "grounded in reality" that you prefer.

So again, how are you disagreeing with me? You have not refuted any of my claims.
 
So again, how are you disagreeing with me? You have not refuted any of my claims.

So we agree that the NAU is a cranck conspiracy theory and RP is a moron for endorsing it, thanks for clarifying. You see I was under the impresion that you claimed that CFR endorsed the NAU which I refuted and that the CFR influenced policy, which I refuted. Or that the nonexisting indorsement of the CFR for the nonexistent NAU lent credence to the conspiracy theory, which I also, just for good measure, refuted.
 
Last edited:
But it does have a basis on reality. I already showed you the article published by the CFR. The CFR is not official, but it does influence foreign policy. Look at a list of their members.
Ultimately irrelevant unless they can get legislators in the three involved countries to pass legislation which enacts this union. I can't speak for the U.S. or Mexico, but in terms of Canada, any legislation which puts forth closer ties to the U.S. beyond the purely pragmatic economic ones will not be well-received by the considerable majority of the voting public. As it was, the original Free Trade Agreement with the U.S. was the central (and contentious) issue in the 1988 Federal election.

A common currency? A non-starter, especially given that the Canadian dollar is now more highly valued than the U.S. dollar by international currency markets. Political union? An even bigger non-starter.
 
So we agree that the NAU is a cranck conspiracy theory and RP is a moron for endorsing it, thanks for clarifying. You see I was under the impresion that you claimed that CFR endorsed the NAU which I refuted and that the CFR influenced policy, which I refuted. Or that the nonexisting indorsement of the CFR for the nonexistent NAU lent credence to the conspiracy theory, which I also, just for good measure, refuted.

How can the NAU be a crank conspiracy theory if there are people who are pushing for it?

How did you refute that the CFR endorses the NAU?

How did you refute that the CFR influences policy?

Did you read the article posted by the CFR itself?
 
Ultimately irrelevant unless they can get legislators in the three involved countries to pass legislation which enacts this union. I can't speak for the U.S. or Mexico, but in terms of Canada, any legislation which puts forth closer ties to the U.S. beyond the purely pragmatic economic ones will not be well-received by the considerable majority of the voting public. As it was, the original Free Trade Agreement with the U.S. was the central (and contentious) issue in the 1988 Federal election.

A common currency? A non-starter, especially given that the Canadian dollar is now more highly valued than the U.S. dollar by international currency markets. Political union? An even bigger non-starter.

In other words, you are saying it has basis on reality, but it is unlikely to be approved by Canada for pragmatic reasons. So again, how are you disagreeing with me?
 
I don't think anyone here would accuse me of being a Ron Paul supporter. I do agree that some of the Ron Paul criticism I see seems to be dogpiling and not born out of skeptical thinking.

However, many people have legitimate criticisms of Ron Paul's ideas and proposals.

I for one will not bother arguing against some of these unfair Paul criticisms. I'm sick of the Ron Paul advocacy on this forum. Advocacy is not skepticism. I'll turn a blind eye while people dogpile on Paul because some white nationalist retards send him money. I'm sick of you Paul supporters. You are a running sore on this forum and I can't wait for Ron Paul's campaign to go down in flames so that you all go back to posting whereever it was before you started posting here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom