Hardly any critical thinking regarding Ron Paul.

I can't see the Canadians peacefully agreeing to take on a common currency with us after the mess that W has made of the dollar.
It's especially not going to happen now that the Canadian dollar is worth more than the U.S. dollar. We've waited for some some thirty-plus years for that to happen again. It may down from the high of $1.10 US it hit back in November, but as of Friday's market close it was still worth more at $1.0188 US.
 
Just for the record I came to this forum because I'm interested in skepticism, I was a bit surprised at the breadth of topics. I expected more focus on superstition and quackery. Apparently as an RP supporter my timing renders me an object of suspicion as someone who is using 'your' forum to promote Paul. Frankly I can see how having a lot of RP supporters would be irritating to people with different viewpoints, especially if they're really earnest and enthusiastic (and somewhat uncritical). However, I won't be going anywhere when the primaries are over. It would be interesting to track how many RP supporters DO leave at that point, given the numerous predictions of their mass exodus. Are we REALLY overwhelmingly 'newbies'? I've seen some low post counts on both sides, but some very high counts in particular on the anti-Paul side. so...could be.
 
Just for the record I came to this forum because I'm interested in skepticism, I was a bit surprised at the breadth of topics. I expected more focus on superstition and quackery. Apparently as an RP supporter my timing renders me an object of suspicion as someone who is using 'your' forum to promote Paul. Frankly I can see how having a lot of RP supporters would be irritating to people with different viewpoints, especially if they're really earnest and enthusiastic (and somewhat uncritical). However, I won't be going anywhere when the primaries are over. It would be interesting to track how many RP supporters DO leave at that point, given the numerous predictions of their mass exodus. Are we REALLY overwhelmingly 'newbies'? I've seen some low post counts on both sides, but some very high counts in particular on the anti-Paul side. so...could be.

To all the Ron Paul newbies, welcome.
 
To all the Ron Paul newbies, welcome.

Thanks, you are very gracious. I expect I'll align with most of the skeptics on most topics, politics is an arena that is very subjective and where most of the evidence any side can present is suspect, it is hard even for people who otherwise have a lot in common to agree.
 
So when Ron Paul fear-mongers about how NAFTA will lead to a NAU he is trying to create hysteria over something tha does not even exist, yes?

And you're comfortable with your candidate tilting at windmills when there's real problems to be solved?

I'm comfortable with his position on the Iraq War and foreign policy and several others. I could care less about the NAU.
 
Not better than Stormfront people? How could we not be better, in at least one major aspect, than Stormfront? These are not rational people we are talking about.

They reject human dignity and they find Ron Paul the least objectionable of the Republican field.

If only Hillary Clinton and Rudy Giuliani were available as choices to me, I'd choose Hillary Clinton. That doesn't mean Hillary Clinton agrees with most of my views.

In the same way, Ron Paul doesn't agree with those people on racism. In fact, there's only a handful of people there who actually support Ron Paul, as far as I know. The few times I went to see what was going on, people were saying Ron Paul did not further their cause at all.

They like RP for the havoc he would wreak on civilization as we know it, and the cover it would give white nationalists for some of the measures they would like to see put in place to return to the bad old days of racism.

"They like RP for the havoc he would wreak on civilization "

Sources?
 
dubalb said:
Ya gotta love all the Paul Shills who have shown up lately.
Oliver left, which is a good thing for the forum. A German Paul shill we don't need.
@ Mr Masters:

Ron Paul will either succeed or fail based on his own merits, position, and ability to sell his vision.

His rhetorical style is still "the contrarian" which is all well and good when one's role is as a contrarian.

His problem is, insofar as packaging his vision, that he seems unable to adopt the rhetorical style of someone who is leading "the whole of American polity" in the direction where his vision is to lead us. If he wants to win, his message needs to transform toward "here is where I want us to go, come with me" a la Reagan, rather than "Bush sucks" or "foreign adventures are non Constitutional" or other such themes. The lack of a solid message "for" partly explains why John Kerry foundered: too much "I am not the current crook" and not enough "why I am a better choice."

I am not sure whether or not Ron Paul, given his charismatic stubbornness and his habit for sticking to his guns, has the skill and savvy to repackage his vision into that of The Leader of the Free World, like a Texan Phoenix arisen from the rhetoric of The Contrarian, the ashpile he risks being buried in.

If he and his team can change their messages and themes, his delegate count will rise.

If not, he gets stuck in the ashpile of political history as another fringe candidate. He'd be in good company, with Harold Stassen and Ralph Nader.

As I see it, if he were serious, he'd raise his game. If he wants to win, he has to.

I am frankly puzzled as to why his camp sticks to the same old Contrarian rhetoric, and chooses not to progress to "follow me here, this is where I am taking you." The primaries have begun, in freaking Iowa.

I'd like to know, as I vote.

DR
 
Last edited:
In the primaries, contrarian was the way to go in this particular circumstance, where 70% of Americans want us out of Iraq and none of the other Republican candidates (and some of the Democrat candidates) have any plans to spend less than five more years there. The campaign he has run has taken him to the primaries when only his supporters (and not all of them) thought he'd last more than six months. Should he win the nomination, he may need to shift rhetoric. I don't see how a nearly-unknown congressman who's out fundraising some of the 'first-tier' and winning over half the straw polls can be accused of not having raised his game about as high as it will go. We'll soon see if that was high enough.
 
In the primaries, contrarian was the way to go in this particular circumstance, where 70% of Americans want us out of Iraq and none of the other Republican candidates (and some of the Democrat candidates) have any plans to spend less than five more years there. The campaign he has run has taken him to the primaries when only his supporters (and not all of them) thought he'd last more than six months. Should he win the nomination, he may need to shift rhetoric. I don't see how a nearly-unknown congressman who's out fundraising some of the 'first-tier' and winning over half the straw polls can be accused of not having raised his game about as high as it will go. We'll soon see if that was high enough.

To win, you need to be more than a spoiler. All his raised game has achieved is spoiler level.

It is early yet, so I'll not comment further on that, but let's look at some possible outcomes:

Mitt and Ron, P and VP?

Rudy and Ron? P and VP?

McCain and Ron? P and VP?

Do any of those tickets resonate?

DR
 
He's certainly not going to be picked as a running mate by any of the neocons. That would never happen unless he becomes one himself. His chances of becoming POTUS are ten times better than his chances of becoming VPOTUS. Of the choices, maaaybe McCain and Paul.
 
Last edited:
I'm comfortable with his position on the Iraq War and foreign policy and several others. I could care less about the NAU.

It seems from our experiences of RP supporters here that this is common. Support for RP beigns and ends with his (admirable) stance on the War.

But that's not enough - read the bills he's sponsored and opposed, and his quotes such as this gem, on Katrina:

"Is bailing out people that chose to live on the coastline a proper function of the federal government?" he asks. "Why do people in Arizona have to be robbed in order to support the people on the coast?"
Also, from a sourced an evidenced (SFW) opinion piece at the potentially-NSFW doman SuicideGirls.com:

He voted no on establishing a nationwide Amber alert system for missing kids. On January 2nd, 2007, he was the only Representative to oppose a House measure to create a National Archives exhibit on slavery and reconstruction. He voted against hurricane relief funding, even though most of his district is on the Texas gulf coast. He voted no on allowing human embryonic stem cell research.

...

But I don't want to make it sound like Ron Paul votes no on everything. He does come around once in a while. For instance, in July of 1999 he voted to ban gay adoptions in DC. He has also voted to ban partial-birth abortions and to ban Family Planning funding in US aid abroad. (Remember, AIDS will work itself out) Paul also supports a constitutional amendment to allow prayer in schools.


And lastly, for you liberals who are swayed by his anti-war views, Paul is staunchly pro-life. He was given a 0% rating by NARAL, a political organization of the pro-choice movement. Paul believes a fetus is a person, that it is human and has legal rights. He believes if you kill a fetus it is an act of aggression and you should be punished accordingly.
Being anti-War is not enough, frankly.
 
Last edited:
Probably not. Although he's doing much better than I thought he would when I heard he was running, a decent showing to demonstrate there ARE Repubs against staying in Iraq is all I'm expecting.
 
It seems from our experiences of RP supporters here that this is common. Support for RP beigns and ends with his (admirable) stance on the War.

That's not the only reason why I support Ron Paul.

But that's not enough - read the bills he's sponsored and opposed, and his quotes such as this gem, on Katrina:

That's a libertarian stand point. The government shouldn't promote living in danger areas for several reasons, the primary reason being that it endangers people. The second is that it is costly to subsidize the insurance of buildings that have a high risk of being destroyed.

Why should I pay taxes to subsidize a 10 million dollar mansion at the edge of crumbly cliff? It's financial nonsense. The millionaire gets free money from poor people to rebuild his home, again, in a location where it will be destroyed shortly after.

If a regular insurance company couldn't handle such a burden without charging exorbitant rates for insurance from the client, how do you expect the government to adjust without raising taxes?

A more responsible policy that will save more lives is to warn people of the dangers of living in a high-risk area and to encourage them to live in safer places. As a consequence, this also reduces the tax burden, and waste involved in rebuilding homes that really should not be built there in the first place.

As I mentioned before, most of Ron Paul's votes are misunderstood.

Also, from a sourced an evidenced (SFW) opinion piece at the potentially-NSFW doman SuicideGirls.com:

Ron Paul opposes most federal funding. He is personally fine with embryonic stem cell research. And the alleged vote against gay adoptions is inaccurate.

Being anti-War is not enough, frankly.

That's simplistic. And yet, I support Ron Paul for other reasons besides war.

EDIT: As for the other allegations, I don't have the time to address them adequately at the very moment.
 
How do you feel about privacy?

So far as I can tell, Ron Paul feels that we have no right to privacy.

http://www.lewrockwell.com/paul/paul120.html

Well I don't agree with it at many levels, but he is correct. There is no right to privacy under the 14th amendment.

If the Federal Courts stayed out of it, people would notice and pressure Congress or their State Legislatures to amend the Constitution.
 
Well I don't agree with it at many levels, but he is correct. There is no right to privacy under the 14th amendment.

If the Federal Courts stayed out of it, people would notice and pressure Congress or their State Legislatures to amend the Constitution.
There's no need to amend the Constitution. Contrary to Ron Paul's claims, the absence of the enumeration of a right in the text of the Constitution does not imply that we do not have that right. If that wasn't clear enough by the nature of the Constitution (granting and limiting only government's power), the 9th Amendment makes it explicit.

We have a right to privacy. Ron Paul does not understand the fundamental nature of the American legal/political system. He is unqualified to hold public office in the US, much less the Presidency.
 
Ron Paul recently approved a message that called for immigrants to stop coming from 'terrorist states'.

Anybody who uses such a false and polarizing statement in the modern age, does not deserve to be president.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom