Hardly any critical thinking regarding Ron Paul.

Richard Masters

Illuminator
Joined
Dec 27, 2007
Messages
3,031
Of all the candidates running for president, the only person who gets attacked here is Ron Paul. Sure, Ron Paul has some short-comings, and I don't agree with all his positions. I'm even willing to criticize him on the positions I disagree with him on.

However, most of the criticism here either attacks Ron Paul by generalizing about his supporters; Generalizing about Ron Paul via isolated examples of alleged Ron Paul supporters (Guilt by association); Ignoring rational arguments and assuming the worst from the start without evidence (appeal to ignorance).

A senior member here said Ron Paul was responsible for Kevin Trudeau's quackery, and smeared him by suggesting a connection between Ron Paul and cures they don't want you to know about; and homeopathy. That was a prime example of intellectual dishonesty, as Ron Paul has nothing to do with Kevin Trudeau; Ron Paul does not endorse homeopathy, nor does he endorse fake medicine.

A number of you show your incompetence in critical thinking by suggesting Ron Paul should return a single 500 dollar donation (out of over 30 million dollars he has raised so far) from a donor who is a white supremacist.

If you were critical thinkers, you would realize (1) giving money to a white supremacist is wrong; (2) guilt by association is a fallacy; (3) Ron Paul's platform opposes racism and Ron Paul himself has denounced racism.

So the only reason to give money back is to placate his illogical critics. That's called pandering. (4) The money has probably already been spent. (5) I hate Bush and the war in Iraq, but if he, Dick Cheney and Rudy Giuliani sent me money for my campaign, I would keep it and use it promote my anti-Iraq-war causes, not theirs. It would be illogical to return the money.

Many of you assume that Ron Paul is an extreme right-winger, which is also fallacious on many levels. Ron Paul endorses the legalization of drugs; He promotes civil liberties; believes gay people have the right to marry if they choose to do so; Ron Paul opposes the Iraq war and war with Iran (not strictly left or right); Ron Paul opposes subsidies for oil companies and other corporations; Ron Paul opposes the death penalty.

In fact, Republicans consider Ron Paul to be more liberal than the democrats. Seeing as how Ron Paul is more liberal than Hillary Clinton, Obama, Dodd, Richardson, etc., on certain issues (such as drugs and gay marriage), this is not surprising.

Ron Paul was rather rational in opposing the war in Iraq and the Patriot Act. This shows better judgment than most current candidates. Ron Paul predicted in 2001 that the Bush administration would tie Saddam Hussein to 9/11 and strongly advised the House of Representatives to avoid a baseless invasion.

http://thespinfactor.com/thetruth/2007/12/19/is-ron-paul-a-modern-day-prophet/

Ron Paul also predicted the housing bubble and has frequently challenged Federal Reserve Chairman Bernanke on inflation.

Ron Paul challenges Fed Reserve Chairman Bernanke
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qmr6qzuK3zM
Traders cheer on Ron Paul
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WvirM1goFq4

Ron Paul actually explains his policies quite rationally. He tells you exactly why he believes our intervention in the Middle East fuels terrorism. He cites his sources, including studies on suicide bombing compiled and analyzed by experts on terrorism.

Of all the candidates, only Ron Paul explains the reasoning behind his policies. No other candidate besides Chris Dodd is invited to talk about finances and the economy on CNBC and other channels focused on market news. This is because the other candidates know nothing about these topics.

Also, the left-right paradigm is old and outdated. Left-right means something different every 5 years. Every year even. In 1993 the right opposed wars of intervention. In 2007, the right is hawkish and wants to attack Iran, Lebanon, and soon they will want to attack Pakistan.

[l]ibertarianism involves trade offs like any other political ideology. However Ron Paul isn't interested in wiping out Social Security and public health care in one fell-swoop. He understands people currently depend on these programs. Instead, to cut taxes for everyone, he proposes ending the war (a war which has escalated beyond rationality. See irrational escalation of commitment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irrational_escalation ). Our federal spending could be brought to fiscally responsible levels and we could still fund the social programs everyone is worried about.

Ron Paul is offering young people who want to opt out of social security the option to do so. If I want to use my social security money to start a small business, I would be allowed to do so. If want to donate it to charity, I could also do so. If I wanted to remain on public Social Security, I could do so as well.

There is nothing irrational about supporting Ron Paul or his policies. Take the following, for example: In California fluorescent light-bulbs are about to be banned from sale. If you are a pro-environment liberal you want to save energy and the planet. You might not care about the 50,000 people who depend on incandescent lighting industry in California. On the other hand, if you are a pro-business conservative, you could care less about the environment or the 50,000 workers that will be losing their jobs, you simply care about the costs of refurbishing your oil-refinery central offices with new expensive light-bulbs and your investment in GE. The libertarian, on the other hand, cares about both (and more): The libertarian cares about liberty (obviously), the liberty of the liberal to buy whatever light-bulb he wants and promote a clean environment, the liberty of the conservative not to be coerced into replacing his corporations light-bulbs, the liberty of 50,000 workers not to be forced out of their jobs by the government, the liberty of incandescent manufacturers to continue selling their light-bulbs, and the liberty of the common person to buy cheap light-bulbs that work.

But that's not all. Fluorescent light-bulbs contain mercury. As a libertarian I don't want to be forced to buy light-bulbs that might be harmful to my health. As a libertarian, I don't want the government to impose a tax on incandescent lighting either. Why should I not be allowed to buy whatever light-bulb I choose? Is it because it's bad for the environment?

Well, then consider the following: (1) Mercury is bad for the environment and your health. (2) 4% of the population suffers from epileptic seizures when exposed to the flicker of fluorescent lighting. (3) Many people suffer from eye strain and headaches when exposed to fluorescent lighting, especially those taking medications that affect photosensitivity.

So if Congress got the bright idea of outlawing all fluorescent light-bulbs, we would be subjecting over 4% of the population to lighting that causes them harm. Furthermore, they'd have to opt for candles or expensive alternative forms of lighting. Not to mention the millions of people who get eye strain and headaches, the increased cost to the consumer, fewer choices.

Next thing you know, if you want to get an incandescent light-bulb, you have to buy in the black market, travel abroad or import, or get a prescription for incandescent light-bulbs from your doctor whenever your light bulbs burn out.

I didn't even mention the unforeseen unintended consequences of outlawing incandescent light-bulbs.

Ron Paul, despite some shortcomings, is so much of a critical thinker that many of his solutions for current problems are, by nature, counter-intuitive. If you aren't willing to examine his reasoning (and he elucidates on his reasoning far more frequently than any other candidates), then you are being intellectually dishonest when you criticize him.

So instead of baselessly criticizing libertarianism, Ron Paul, and generalizing about his supporters, I invite you to think critically and use relevant evidence.

---

You would be better off criticizing people who are truly irrational, like Rudy Giuliani who is willing to fight 'terrorism' without making an effort at understanding the root of terrorism. Go after Cheney and the neoconservatives for their lies and irrational escalation of the war. Go after Hillary for irrationally and needlessly labeling the Iran Revolutionary Guard a terrorist organization. Go after the top democrats for not making an effort to leave Iraq before 2013. Go after Hillary for wasting time on restricting the sale of video games. Go after the neoconservatives for sending 1/3 of our foreign aid to Israel (which doesn't need it - their GDP per capita is higher than that of Spain and Ireland, slightly less than Italy's [ http://www.wrmea.com/backissues/1297/9712043.html ], two countries which we do not send foreign aid to, which of their own accord send foreign aid to other less fortunate countries).
 
Well I just disagree with his policies, cutting this government program and that. My vote would be better wasted on Kucinich, if I were to vote for a "fringe" candidate.
 
//" If you were critical thinkers, you would realize (1) giving money to a white supremacist is wrong;"

That's the funniest part.//

I agree. I'm wondering why Wolf Blitzer and some of the posters who oppose Ron Paul want him to give money to white supremacists. I'm thinking maybe they are racist. But most likely they are not thinking critically.
 
Actually, there is a lot of critical thinking on Ron Paul here - its just that quite a few people don't like what they see...

And they ESPECIALLY do not like the efforts by his supporters here to "shove" Mr. Paul down our throats...:mad:
 
Well, there's certainly truth in advertising in the OP title. There is indeed a lack of critical thinking among Ron Paul supporters.

Paul gets way too much attention around here, certainly far beyond what he's getting from the mainstream media, and miles beyond what he'll be getting once people actually start voting. As I write this, Paul accounts for 10 of the top 13 posts on this sub-forum. But in the real world:

Ron Paul polls about 4.3% or 1/3rd of Fred Thompson nationally, putting him in sixth place among Republicans. He also polls about 4.3% in Iowa, which translates into sixth place and zero delegates. In New Hampshire he does quite a bit better; 6.4%, which would be good for fifth place.

I do feel sympathetic for the Ron Paul fans; they are about to suffer the same disappointment that I felt back in the early 1960s while rooting for the New York Mets (and with no hope for a miracle).
 
A senior member here said Ron Paul was responsible for Kevin Trudeau's quackery, and smeared him by suggesting a connection between Ron Paul and cures they don't want you to know about; and homeopathy. That was a prime example of intellectual dishonesty, as Ron Paul has nothing to do with Kevin Trudeau; Ron Paul does not endorse homeopathy, nor does he endorse fake medicine.
From Ron Paul's site:
I support the Access to Medical Treatment Act, H.R. 2717, which expands the ability of Americans to use alternative medicine and new treatments.
It is proven, Ron Paul supports quackery.
 
Actually, there is a lot of critical thinking on Ron Paul here - its just that quite a few people don't like what they see...

And they ESPECIALLY do not like the efforts by his supporters here to "shove" Mr. Paul down our throats...:mad:

Well, I'm sorry if people are shoving Ron Paul down your throat. I'm not here to do that. Although I've read these forums before I joined only now because I saw Ron Paul falsely smeared.

Either way, this subsection is specifically for the 2008 Presidential Elections. If you are not interested in politics wouldn't you be better served reading a thread about a different topic?:confused:
 
Well, there's certainly truth in advertising in the OP title. There is indeed a lack of critical thinking among Ron Paul supporters.

Paul gets way too much attention around here, certainly far beyond what he's getting from the mainstream media, and miles beyond what he'll be getting once people actually start voting. As I write this, Paul accounts for 10 of the top 13 posts on this sub-forum. But in the real world:

Ron Paul polls about 4.3% or 1/3rd of Fred Thompson nationally, putting him in sixth place among Republicans. He also polls about 4.3% in Iowa, which translates into sixth place and zero delegates. In New Hampshire he does quite a bit better; 6.4%, which would be good for fifth place.

I do feel sympathetic for the Ron Paul fans; they are about to suffer the same disappointment that I felt back in the early 1960s while rooting for the New York Mets (and with no hope for a miracle).

What is the relevance of how he currently places on national polls? He is 5 percentage points behind the leader in most polls. Other measures of popularity rank him much higher. Even if he wasn't, it doesn't justify smearing him and being intellectually dishonest in your arguments.
 
From Ron Paul's site:

It is proven, Ron Paul supports quackery.

Thank you for stepping up and exposing yourself.

This bill gives the consumer the right to be treated with any medication as long as they have full knowledge of what to expect and are not misled.

This medication or treatment can include drugs that are currently being processed by the FDA, which have not yet received approval.

Do you have proof that ALL drugs and treatments that have been submitted for approval to the FDA are the product of quackery?

You can't, because some drugs have been approved by the FDA, meaning they were at some point unapproved, but effective. A single of those counterexamples is sufficient to show that not all unapproved medications are ineffective.

Supporting your decision to take whatever medication you want is not quackery. Are you done with the smearing?
 
Supporting your decision to take whatever medication you want is not quackery.
Yes, it is. This bill is all about getting homeopathy into the mainstream, which is why it allows specifically for treatments approved by the European Union - which includes homeopathy.

Homeopathy = quackery.
 
What is the relevance of how he currently places on national polls? He is 5 percentage points behind the leader in most polls.

If by "most polls" you mean "no polls" I agree. Perhaps you could present one of these polls for us? If we ignore national polls, where Paul is 17 points behind Giuliani (Fox), 16 points behind Giuliani (NBC/WSJ), 24 points behind Giuliani (USA Today/Gallup), and instead focus on Iowa, he's 25 points behind Huckabee (Strategic Vision), 26 points behind Huckabee (Quad City Times) or 35 points behind Huckabee (LA Times/Bloomberg).

New Hampshire? Paul's 30 points behind Romney (LA Times/Bloomberg), 20 points behind Romney (Boston Globe/UNH), 25 points behind Romney (USA Today/Gallup).

Other measures of popularity rank him much higher. Even if he wasn't, it doesn't justify smearing him and being intellectually dishonest in your arguments.

Perhaps you could point to where I smeared him or was intellectually dishonest in my arguments? Or did you pull that out of your nether regions, like the polls which show him within five points of the leader?
 
Of all the candidates running for president, the only person who gets attacked here is Ron Paul. Sure, Ron Paul has some short-comings, and I don't agree with all his positions. I'm even willing to criticize him on the positions I disagree with him on.
Thank you so much for saying what I don't have the ability to say. I was so hoping and articulate, rational person would come in here and lay it out that way. I'm more a viscerally oriented guy and have wished I had to ability to express myself in such a way that would demand that people be honest about their irrationality about Dr. Paul.
 
//" If you were critical thinkers, you would realize (1) giving money to a white supremacist is wrong;"

That's the funniest part.//

I agree. I'm wondering why Wolf Blitzer and some of the posters who oppose Ron Paul want him to give money to white supremacists. I'm thinking maybe they are racist. But most likely they are not thinking critically.


I think that you and I find it funny for different reasons. You see, I find you funny, whereas you find Wolf Blitzer funny. Wolf Blitzer has a very serious beard.
 
Yes, it is. This bill is all about getting homeopathy into the mainstream, which is why it allows specifically for treatments approved by the European Union - which includes homeopathy.

Homeopathy = quackery.

People are able to buy homeopathic "treatments" anywhere. Just because a bill allows someone to do something, doesn't mean that is its intent.

You should know better than that.

I'm quite aware that homeopathy is quackery.

What you need to learn is that correlation does not equal causation. And you should learn that some events, phenomena or decisions involve more than one cause or more than one reason.

That means there can be more than be a variety of reasons for supporting a particular bill.
 
I learned that the more time I spent detailing how Paul's kooky ideas cannot possibly work as advertised, the shorter the response I receive or simply none at all. I tried to have a discussion with Paul supporters in Denver at a mall and in Chicago at the air show and they refused to engage in a reasonable discussion, one of them actually thought I was a plant. Paul supporters have more or less stopped coming to the weekly political round tables at my local coffee shop, after showing little common courtesy and annoying virtually everyone. You'll find similar stories from colleges:

I dealt with the Paulies on my campus all of last semester. They broke pretty much every election related regulation on my campus, but weren't affiliated with his campaign so the most we could do was call public safety

I feel justified in not engaging Paul supporters beyond short comments on Digg after having tried to engage in more substantial discussion. If Paul was within striking distance in IA, NH or SC I might be more interested.
 
http://www.ronpaul2008.com/straw-poll-results/

http://news.aol.com/political-machine/2007/12/21/straw-poll-dec-21-jan-4/90

http://www.freemarketnews.com/WorldNews.asp?nid=50010

http://www.prisonplanet.com/articles/november2007/191107_zogby_poll.htm

http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/archive/2007/10/14/410525.aspx

http://www.reason.com/blog/show/123914.html

http://www.cnn.com/2007/POLITICS/12/14/s.carolina.poll/index.html#cnnSTCText

http://www.lewrockwell.com/blog/lewrw/archives/017990.html

The following is from July and explains why polls don't reflect reality: http://www.lewrockwell.com/orig8/pitkaniemi1.html

A lot of polls don't actually include an option for Ron Paul for many reasons (some of these polls were designed back in July and didn't account for his rising popularity). A lot of people who will be voting for Ron Paul are not Republicans, didn't vote last election, or at least are not registered Republicans, which means they are ineligible to be polled. Some pollsters use vote multipliers to maintain consistency between one poll and the next.

Also, Zogby has praised Ron Paul, and expects him to surprise everyone. The media consistently ignores Ron Paul or smears him. And his polling continues to improve. Every other Republican (besides Huckabee) continues to poll worse as the primaries get closer.

And don't forget, he gets more money from active duty military and so far he has outraised every Republican.

He doesn't receive money from special interest groups or matching contributions from the government, and the average donation is between 50-100 dollars.

Since he is doing so well in other measures of support, and since the methodology for the national polls doesn't reflect the fact that many young people don't use land-lines anymore, or haven't voted in the past, national polls are not so relevant.



Perhaps you could point to where I smeared him or was intellectually dishonest in my arguments? Or did you pull that out of your nether regions, like the polls which show him within five points of the leader?

I didn't say you (singular) smeared him or were dishonest in your arguments. Please read carefully.
 
I learned that the more time I spent detailing how Paul's kooky ideas cannot possibly work as advertised, the shorter the response I receive or simply none at all. I tried to have a discussion with Paul supporters in Denver at a mall and in Chicago at the air show and they refused to engage in a reasonable discussion, one of them actually thought I was a plant. Paul supporters have more or less stopped coming to the weekly political round tables at my local coffee shop, after showing little common courtesy and annoying virtually everyone. You'll find similar stories from colleges:



I feel justified in not engaging Paul supporters beyond short comments on Digg after having tried to engage in more substantial discussion. If Paul was within striking distance in IA, NH or SC I might be more interested.

It's nice that you never address said "kooky ideas", nor do you explain why they can't possibly work as advertised. This is typical of the posts I've read here. James Randi would be ashamed.
 
I think that you and I find it funny for different reasons. You see, I find you funny, whereas you find Wolf Blitzer funny. Wolf Blitzer has a very serious beard.

I knew you found it different for different reasons, which is why I clarified.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom