Hardly any critical thinking regarding Ron Paul.

Nice appeal to authority. The question isn't whether the Supreme Court is the arbiter, but whether they arbitrated normatively.
Ummm, appealing to the authority of the constitution when discussing the constitution isn't a logical fallacy.
 
Ummm, appealing to the authority of the constitution when discussing the constitution isn't a logical fallacy.

Again, the question isn't whether they have the ultimate legal authority, but whether they are exercising said authority correctly.

ETA: Also, since 3 of the 9 judges disagreed with the outcome it lends less credibility to the logical validity of such an appeal.
 
Last edited:
Host: Let's go to the callers and see how they felt about the Democratic debate last night. Lou in Reno, you're on the air.

Caller: I thought Hillary sounded dishonest. The only honest candidate out there is Ron Paul.

Host: Thanks Lou, lets try keeping on topic. Marla in Topeka, what did you think?

Caller: I'm concerned about whether any of them will abide by the Constitution. The only candidate who will stick to the Consitutional principles of the Founders is Ron Paul.

Host: O.k. Alvin in Long Island, you have a comment about Bill Richardson.

Caller: Yes, he's no Ron Paul.

Host: Let's just go to commercial...
 
Host: Let's go to the callers and see how they felt about the Democratic debate last night. Lou in Reno, you're on the air.

Caller: I thought Hillary sounded dishonest. The only honest candidate out there is Ron Paul.

Host: Thanks Lou, lets try keeping on topic. Marla in Topeka, what did you think?

Caller: I'm concerned about whether any of them will abide by the Constitution. The only candidate who will stick to the Consitutional principles of the Founders is Ron Paul.

Host: O.k. Alvin in Long Island, you have a comment about Bill Richardson.

Caller: Yes, he's no Ron Paul.

Host: Let's just go to commercial...

Did that actually happen or is it satire? It wouldn't surprise me.
 
What is unconstitutional aboutr the court ruling that a state cannot pass a law restricting individual behaviors in which the state has no compelling interest? Is the state harmed in any way if a woman chooses not to be a brood mare or to abstain from sex with her husband and insists that he practice birth control?

It would be a horrendous stretch of logic to conclude that the state had any business telling her that she had no option other than to run that risk or cross her legs.
 
Right. Ron Paul disagrees with the Constitutionality of that decision, which is why we got into this discussion.

Ergo he believes the state should be able to dictate whether you can use birth control, who you have sex with, and the manner in which you have sex. His libertarianism applies only to the federal government, he has repeatedly advocated that the States can legitimately exercise great power over every detail of our lives.

He is an authoritarian on a small scale, which is consistant with "posse comitatus" doctrine, upon which most militia type doctrines are based. He is no libertarian, rather simply another of the great mass of anti-federal power crackpots who wish to ignore the constitutional results of the civil war.
 
Ron Paul's also a bit...hazy....on the history of the Bill of Rights and the Constitution, evident by his statements about separation of church and state.

The real tragedy is that our founders did not intend a separation of church and state, and never envisioned a rigidly secular public life for America. They simply wanted to prevent Congress from establishing a state religion, as England had.

Source: http://www.lewrockwell.com/paul/paul120.html

The problem? The founders actually DID do just what he is saying that they had no intention of doing. How do I, or anyone else who's studied American history know?

Because James Madison was the author of the Bill of Rights and Father of the Constitution. As such, he stated numerous times that there needed to be a wall of separation between church and state. Jefferson, another Founder, thought similarly. Madison, in fact, continued his support for a "wall of separation" between the two long after he left office.

So what's the deal? Why is Ron Paul making such statements that stand in stark contrast to the actual history?
 
Again, the question isn't whether they have the ultimate legal authority, but whether they are exercising said authority correctly.

Of course they are. The Constitution says the Supreme Court has jurisdiction over all questions of law pertaining to the Constitution, period. It does not say that jurisdiction exists only as long as the court uses a strict literalist interpretation of the Constitution; how they interpret the Constitution is the Court's perrogative.
 
Of course they are. The Constitution says the Supreme Court has jurisdiction over all questions of law pertaining to the Constitution, period. It does not say that jurisdiction exists only as long as the court uses a strict literalist interpretation of the Constitution; how they interpret the Constitution is the Court's perrogative.

There are two questions. What the law is and what the law should be. The former is for the most part left to the legislature with the courts filling in the parts in order to apply the law to the facts of the case. There will always be gray areas where reasonable minds can differ.

The latter is a matter of opinion. As to some of Ron Paul's opinions, mostly towards religion, one can point out that while Ron Paul is entitled to his opinion, he is not entitled to his own facts.
 
Mr. Masters,
You are so wrong on so many things it is hard to begin, but I will try.
First, your polling data is made up of straw poll and internet polls which if you know anything you know are meaningless. The one link you provide that supposedly explains away the actual polls is merely a rationalization and would only explain one odd poll but not poll after poll.

Another thing that you are wrong about is the North American Union (NAU) and the Council on Foreign Relations (CFR). You link to an article in the CFR's publication Foreign Affairs but it has no mention of an Amero and even it's vision of this theoretical NAU is much less than anything amounting to a true union. The CFR has not taken a position on the NAU nor anything else for that matter. It is merely an organization for open discussion on American foreign policy by experts. Anyone can read their publication it is available on any decent newstand. Contrary to what some think they are not some shadow group planning one world government, or any other crazy conspiracy. If you would bother to read Foreign Affairs regularly which I have for years it publishes various points of view advocating different positions on many things. It is not an ideological machine with one point-of-view other than a mostly "western" world view.

It is pretty clear, correct me if I am wrong, but you seem to be a conspiracy theorist type (you even link to prisonplanet) and you might want to consider that there is no conspiracy against Ron Paul but maybe his ideas are WRONG and most people can see that.
 
I get the impression the Ron Paul does not want to restore the Constituion but the Articles Of Confederation.
I have problems with the idea that a state can deny basic constitutional rights to a minority and the federal government has no right to interfere.
 
I get the impression the Ron Paul does not want to restore the Constituion but the Articles Of Confederation.

Yes!

I've said this before, it seems to me that Ron Paul would like nothing better than the Articles of Confederation to be restored.
 
Mr. Masters,
You are so wrong on so many things it is hard to begin, but I will try.
First, your polling data is made up of straw poll and internet polls which if you know anything you know are meaningless.

Meaningless? How so? They are not the most authoritative reflection of opinion, but meaningless is quite a stretch. Furthermore, I didn't simply link to "internet polls"... You would do well to take a closer look.

The one link you provide that supposedly explains away the actual polls is merely a rationalization and would only explain one odd poll but not poll after poll.

It explains how current methodology is increasingly outdated. No more, no less.

Another thing that you are wrong about is the North American Union (NAU) and the Council on Foreign Relations (CFR).

What specifically?

You link to an article in the CFR's publication Foreign Affairs but it has no mention of an Amero and even it's vision of this theoretical NAU is much less than anything amounting to a true union.

And what's your objection? I didn't claim it was anything amounting to a "true union".

The CFR has not taken a position on the NAU nor anything else for that matter.

No, it hasn't.

It is merely an organization for open discussion on American foreign policy by experts. Anyone can read their publication it is available on any decent newstand. Contrary to what some think they are not some shadow group planning one world government, or any other crazy conspiracy.

Probably not. I'm not disagreeing with this position, nor have I in the past.

It is pretty clear, correct me if I am wrong, but you seem to be a conspiracy theorist type (you even link to prisonplanet) and you might want to consider that there is no conspiracy against Ron Paul but maybe his ideas are WRONG and most people can see that.

You are dead wrong. I'm not into conspiracy theories and my standard position on the NAU has been one of skepticism.

As I mentioned before, the NAU is hypothetical.

I don't need to resort to wild conspiracy theories to approve of Ron Paul.

I linked to prison planet because they had a relevant article, and for no other reason. To suggest I'm a "conspiracy theorist type" involves engaging in a guilt-by-association fallacy.
 
I didn't know how to respond until I read the Constitution. Look at the 9th and 10th amendments side by side.
I have. What about them?

The Constitution does not grant rights to people. It limits the ability of government to interfere with the rights people already have. As the Declaration of Independence demonstrates, the Founders felt rights were innate, not granted by Government. In our system, the sovereignty comes from the people. We don't need the government to grant us rights, we give them to ourselves.

If you pay attention to the words of the Constitution, you will see admonition not to infringe on rights, or codifying the preservation of rights. This is a different matter from creating rights. If you examine how the Court determines what a right is, you will see that they use precedent, even going back before the adoption of the Constitution, to determine what a right is understood to be. They do not simply look at the text of the Constitution to see if the right is mentioned.

The idea that a right does not exist if it is not found in the Constitution is not consistent with the text of the Constitution, nor with our historical jurisprudence (stretching back centuries into English legal history before we broke off on our own).

I just noticed an argument structure that is used by everyone in every political party to pretend they discredited a candidate.

Either way, the "Subject X does not understand P, therefore Q" meme is overused, frequently with heavy distortion and hyperbole. It might reach thought-terminating-cliché-status someday.
I'm saying that someone who does not understand our Constitution has no business holding office under it. I think I have demonstrated my reasoning for this position perfectly well. I am pretending nothing. Your insults are misplaced.
 
Wait, just to clarify, are we talking about the same Ron Paul who thinks the founding fathers were all christian, founded American on christian principles, and would be "aghast" by todays "government's hostility to religion"?

The same Ron Paul who believes god is mentioned frequently in the constitution (Hint, god was only mentioned 1...2...3...0 times)

Is that who we're talking about?

Speaking of cutting federal spending, is this the same Ron Paul who voted against the house resolution to cut federal spending by $40 billion dollars on federal entitlement programs over 5 years, which would lead to the decrease of "government power" in others lives?

Just wondering...

Sources:

(Sorry for circumventing the no URL rule, but no one would believe me unless I cited sources)

lewrockwell(dot)com/paul/paul148(dot)html

projects(dot)washingtonpost(dot)com/congress/109/house/2/votes/4/


Also, I believe if RP did run as an independant, and got 10% of straw poll vote in his area, he will be sent invitations for debate and air time
 
How can the NAU be a crank conspiracy theory if there are people who are pushing for it?

How did you refute that the CFR endorses the NAU?

How did you refute that the CFR influences policy?

Did you read the article posted by the CFR itself?

Cognitive Dissonance

It's funny how he clearly answered all those questions thoroughly yet you pretended like he didn't, then ignored him when he pointed this out. If you were sent by anti-ron paul people to make all ron paul supporters look like gibbering lunatics you're doing well.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom