Hardly any critical thinking regarding Ron Paul.

Because there are people psuhing for anything, unless there is significant support it's irrelevant that someone, somewhere supports it.

It's not really irrelevant since the original argument was that there was no basis for this. As insignificant as it may be, there is basis for it.

publishing an article in your magazine does not equal an endorsement, if it did then the CFR would be endorsing both the foreign policy of Gulliani and of Edwards, in the same issue no less.

You are correct.

Any club with such a diverse membership is clearly a honourary association, not a policy advocate because there's almost nothing it's members would agree on. It even says right there that it's purpose it to "improve the understanding of U.S. foreign policy" not that the purpose is to advocate anything.

Good point (first sentence), but the same could be said (second sentence) about PNAC.

I read the article by Robert A. Pastor. It is either extremely ignorant or extremely dishonest to attribute the views in it to the CFR. Not only does publishing an article not equal support for the ideas in it, but the "nearly all past and present Presidents, Secretaries of State, Defense and Treasury, other senior U.S. government officials, renowned scholars, and major leaders of business, media, human rights, and other non-governmental groups" who are members of this honourary association almost certainly has nothing to do with the day-to day running of Foreign Affairs magazine.

You are correct. After reading more about this, it turns out he is one of the few people publicly supporting any form of NAU.

Fortunately, I never bought the NAU conspiracy, nor would it bother me much if it were true. The world is naturally growing in the direction of globalization; nor am I a xenophobe, like Tancredo and presumably, Ron Paul.
 
Last edited:
Ergo he believes the state should be able to dictate whether you can use birth control, who you have sex with, and the manner in which you have sex. His libertarianism applies only to the federal government, he has repeatedly advocated that the States can legitimately exercise great power over every detail of our lives.

He is an authoritarian on a small scale, which is consistant with "posse comitatus" doctrine, upon which most militia type doctrines are based. He is no libertarian, rather simply another of the great mass of anti-federal power crackpots who wish to ignore the constitutional results of the civil war.

Your assertion is looking to be more likely. However, more state power would not automatically benefit Ron Paul's more personal social views, as each individual state requires its constituency to elect legislators. Furthermore, the Constitution can be amended to reflect more current views on law, which would definitively overrule these controversial state laws; for example by specifically amending the constitution to include a full right to privacy, instead of relying on Amendment IX, which is subject to Amendment X.

That said, Ron Paul is not as libertarian as I thought (but rather a strict Constitutionalist), and you elaborate well on that.
 
Your assertion is looking to be more likely. However, more state power would not automatically benefit Ron Paul's more personal social views, as each individual state requires its constituency to elect legislators. Furthermore, the Constitution can be amended to reflect more current views on law, which would definitively overrule these controversial state laws; for example by specifically amending the constitution to include a full right to privacy, instead of relying on Amendment IX, which is subject to Amendment X.

That said, Ron Paul is not as libertarian as I thought (but rather a strict Constitutionalist), and you elaborate well on that.

but he ignores things already in the constitution when pushing for state powers, for example, the seperation of church and state.
 
I have. What about them?

The Constitution does not grant rights to people. It limits the ability of government to interfere with the rights people already have. As the Declaration of Independence demonstrates, the Founders felt rights were innate, not granted by Government. In our system, the sovereignty comes from the people. We don't need the government to grant us rights, we give them to ourselves.

If you pay attention to the words of the Constitution, you will see admonition not to infringe on rights, or codifying the preservation of rights. This is a different matter from creating rights. If you examine how the Court determines what a right is, you will see that they use precedent, even going back before the adoption of the Constitution, to determine what a right is understood to be. They do not simply look at the text of the Constitution to see if the right is mentioned.

The idea that a right does not exist if it is not found in the Constitution is not consistent with the text of the Constitution, nor with our historical jurisprudence (stretching back centuries into English legal history before we broke off on our own).

I agree so far, except I didn't make the claim that "a right does not exist if it is not found in the Constitution".

I'm saying that someone who does not understand our Constitution has no business holding office under it. I think I have demonstrated my reasoning for this position perfectly well. I am pretending nothing. Your insults are misplaced.

But you exaggerate and focus on a statement which does not prove that Ron Paul doesn't understand the Constitution; thereby while your logic is essentially valid, your argument is not sound, for the premises are flawed.
 
I get the impression the Ron Paul does not want to restore the Constituion but the Articles Of Confederation.
I think you are right.

I have problems with the idea that a state can deny basic constitutional rights to a minority and the federal government has no right to interfere.

I don't think this is his intention. Although, the more recent letters may suggest just that.
 
Cognitive Dissonance

It's funny how he clearly answered all those questions thoroughly yet you pretended like he didn't, then ignored him when he pointed this out. If you were sent by anti-ron paul people to make all ron paul supporters look like gibbering lunatics you're doing well.

You are right. It may have been cognitive dissonance, although, my assessment of the NAU and CFR was only tentative... So I was taking more of a devil's advocate position, than real investment in the veracity of the claims.

To be honest, I think I make Ron Paul supporters look good. If only they'd throw away some of the more unlikely conspiracy theories, then I wouldn't feel the need to go around breaking the stereotypes.

But unlike my original claim in the first post, I do think other candidates are also getting their fair share of criticism.
 
Uh, all their conspiracy theories are unlikely...there is no CT that is "likely" that they speak about.
 
He does on occasion. Quite hypocritical.

Nevertheless, more consistent than most legislators.

Though I'm glad you can be fair about the issue, I wonder if it's a little more then hypocritical. It's like someone whose primary platform is being tough on illegal immigration but who supports total amnesty, eliminating the border patrol, and giving larger welfare to illegal immigrants. It's not just hypocritical, it ridiculous. It destroys everything he stands for and is indicitive that maybe he's a few cards short of a full deck. Consider that in the context of the discussion, he's willing to allow the states to override the constitution. So what he wants, as other have said, and this is no understatement, is a return to pre-civil war times. Combine that with a couple pieces of evidence that he's a racist and you start to paint an interesting picture of this canidate.
 
Though I'm glad you can be fair about the issue, I wonder if it's a little more then hypocritical. It's like someone whose primary platform is being tough on illegal immigration but who supports total amnesty, eliminating the border patrol, and giving larger welfare to illegal immigrants. It's not just hypocritical, it ridiculous. It destroys everything he stands for and is indicitive that maybe he's a few cards short of a full deck. Consider that in the context of the discussion, he's willing to allow the states to override the constitution. So what he wants, as other have said, and this is no understatement, is a return to pre-civil war times. Combine that with a couple pieces of evidence that he's a racist and you start to paint an interesting picture of this canidate.

Yeah, the newsletters really suggest something different about Ron Paul's choice of political ideology. [l]ibertarianism does reverse some of the entitlements and I suppose if you were racist you would seek to reverse affirmative action. However, there are a lot of people who are not racist, who seek to reverse affirmative action for many different reasons.

His tendency to favor states over the federal government looks like a way to reduce taxes and government involvement in your life but it could also be interpreted as a way to give states more power to enforce morality.

To be completely fair, I've heard him speak ill of neoconservatives (which is more than fine with me) but I haven't heard him speak ill of racists except when prompted. That's why I wish he would just disclose, in more detail, the existence of the newletters, or apologize and explain that he has changed since then.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom