Richard Masters
Illuminator
- Joined
- Dec 27, 2007
- Messages
- 3,031
Because there are people psuhing for anything, unless there is significant support it's irrelevant that someone, somewhere supports it.
It's not really irrelevant since the original argument was that there was no basis for this. As insignificant as it may be, there is basis for it.
publishing an article in your magazine does not equal an endorsement, if it did then the CFR would be endorsing both the foreign policy of Gulliani and of Edwards, in the same issue no less.
You are correct.
Any club with such a diverse membership is clearly a honourary association, not a policy advocate because there's almost nothing it's members would agree on. It even says right there that it's purpose it to "improve the understanding of U.S. foreign policy" not that the purpose is to advocate anything.
Good point (first sentence), but the same could be said (second sentence) about PNAC.
I read the article by Robert A. Pastor. It is either extremely ignorant or extremely dishonest to attribute the views in it to the CFR. Not only does publishing an article not equal support for the ideas in it, but the "nearly all past and present Presidents, Secretaries of State, Defense and Treasury, other senior U.S. government officials, renowned scholars, and major leaders of business, media, human rights, and other non-governmental groups" who are members of this honourary association almost certainly has nothing to do with the day-to day running of Foreign Affairs magazine.
You are correct. After reading more about this, it turns out he is one of the few people publicly supporting any form of NAU.
Fortunately, I never bought the NAU conspiracy, nor would it bother me much if it were true. The world is naturally growing in the direction of globalization; nor am I a xenophobe, like Tancredo and presumably, Ron Paul.
Last edited: