Hardly any critical thinking regarding Ron Paul.

The North American Union is an abstract term for the integration of the economies of Canada, Mexico, and the United States. I was skeptical about the NAU, and I still think people oversensationalize it, so I asked for proof. The Council on Foreign Relations does endorse a single currency (the Amero) and it does endorse a political union to strengthen the "North American Continent" so that the three countries can coordinate and protect themselves from terrorism.

Whether or not this is under way, the intent is there.

I personally don't care that much about a hypothetical NAU either way. But I do oppose any ideologies that are based on the assumption the we must make Homeland Security bigger to protect ourselves from terrorists. As such, I do oppose the Council on Foreign Relations.

http://www.foreignaffairs.org/20040...t-a-pastor/north-america-s-second-decade.html

OMg i love you!!! You actually have done your homework unlike most around. I am not a conspiracy nut, but i do know when the topics exist or not!
 
It's nice that you never address said "kooky ideas", nor do you explain why they can't possibly work as advertised. This is typical of the posts I've read here. James Randi would be ashamed.

Careful when speaking in absolutes, I actually have taken the time to address in particular the realities of the federal budget and various statements Paul has made to drastically cut spending and end personal income taxes without dumping seniors reliant on Social Security and Medicare. vB has a nice feature to look at members post history.
 
I heard R.P. on xm's version of npr last night. I thought he was swell, actually.
I showed up here to learn more, and was overwhelmed by the quantity of threads.

Here's what I'm not getting:

relativity.
The few things that bother me about him are out-weighed by the big stuff, like leaving Iraq. His attitude towards being in a global community seemed by far the best I have heard. The homeopathy stuff is pretty small. The guy's a doctor. He delivers babies.
How quacky could he really be?

Anyway, what's the big alternative to Ron Paul? Kucinich?
Hillary?

Who should I vote for?
 
Richard Masters said:
Of all the candidates running for president, the only person who gets attacked here is Ron Paul.

That's a vile canard. I have also said that I think Dennis Kucinich is a nut job.

Either way, this subsection is specifically for the 2008 Presidential Elections. If you are not interested in politics wouldn't you be better served reading a thread about a different topic?:confused:

If a person wanted to discuss the U.S. presidential election on this forum, where else would you suggest he/she go? :confused:
 
no, then you would be wrong on two counts, instead of one.

Well, it's good to be wrong and admit it. However, I'd like to see your evidence, before I do so.

I'm surprised to see a moderator here, of all places, challenge others on this board without offering evidence.

As a moderator are you not asked to be neutral? Are you supposed to taunt members of this message board? Or are you supposed keep things civilized?
 
Careful when speaking in absolutes, I actually have taken the time to address in particular the realities of the federal budget and various statements Paul has made to drastically cut spending and end personal income taxes without dumping seniors reliant on Social Security and Medicare. vB has a nice feature to look at members post history.

"vB has a nice feature to look at members post history."

Alright, then. I duly apologize. Your original comment came across as another baseless cynical statement, so I overreacted.
 
Ron Paul has not been smeared, other presidential candidates and politicians have been robustly criticised. Ron Paul gets more attention because, unlike any other candidate, some of his supporters are actively trying to use this forum to promote him.


As a moderator are you not asked to be neutral?
no

Are you supposed to taunt members of this message board?
I have not taunted you.

Or are you supposed keep things civilized?
which is why I told you to stop making this about other members and start addressing the issues.
 
I may be, but I haven't read about any other candidate get falsely smeared around here as frequently as Ron Paul.
I might be wrong, but I'm guessing you have a little confirmation bias working here.

how did you determine he deserves obscurity?
He doesn't have anywhere near the support to justify the amount of attention he's getting.

If you are so certain then maybe you can explain how you arrived at your conclusion,
He doesn't have enough support to be a viable candidate. He isn't going to gain that support, because he favors policies that most Americans do not support.

and furthermore, perhaps you can tell me with certainty who will win the election.

Someone who isn't Ron Paul.
 
I went through the first 2 pages of this Section of the boards and surprisingly paul haters bring him up just as much as Paul lovers do.
You mean they start as many threads? That's hardly the same as what you're claiming. New threads can be responses to issues raised in other threads.

Ron Paul would be getting very little attention on this forum if not for Ron Paul supporters. The supporters should have anticipated that the reaction he gets would be largely negative, for the exact same reasons that his candidacy is not drawing more popular support: Most Americans do not support the policies Ron Paul is proposing.

Maybe this is because of wide-spread ignorance, conspiratorial misinformation, or some other phenomena causing only the select few to understand the truth. Or, maybe this is because Paul's ideas do not stand up to rational criticism very well.
 
I heard R.P. on xm's version of npr last night. I thought he was swell, actually.
I showed up here to learn more, and was overwhelmed by the quantity of threads.

Here's what I'm not getting:

relativity.
The few things that bother me about him are out-weighed by the big stuff, like leaving Iraq. His attitude towards being in a global community seemed by far the best I have heard. The homeopathy stuff is pretty small. The guy's a doctor. He delivers babies.
How quacky could he really be?

Anyway, what's the big alternative to Ron Paul? Kucinich?
Hillary?

Who should I vote for?

Well, Ron Paul doesn't endorse homeopathy. He simply supports people's liberty to make decisions for themselves.

Hillary's foreign policy is very much like George Bush's. She's really vague about leaving Iraq (possibly after 2013). She voted to label the Iranian Revolutionary Guard a terrorist organization and she wants to keep bases all over Iraq. She's rather vague on most issues, so I don't trust her to keep her word. She has offered sketches of a few social programs, although it's arguable whether they are practical, needed, or perhaps even counterproductive.

Obama is a fresh and mildly improved version of Hillary. He is slightly more likely to actually end the war, but he opposes gay marriage (he panders to the Christian right on this issue), although he does support "civil unions". He is a little hypocritical on drugs, since he has snorted cocaine, but nevertheless people should be punished for such behavior. Perhaps hypocritical is the wrong word as it is possible that he truly believes people should be punished.

Edwards is rather populist, and somehow overshadowed by Obama's race and Hillary's gender. He has called Bush's "war on terror" a "bumper sticker", which in my opinion, is commendable. He proposed a form of universal healthcare that would require mandatory check-ups. Hillary then adopted Edwards' plan. Edwards thinks homosexuality is immoral and opposes gay marriage.

Richardson is rather experienced in international politics and placed a strong emphasis on fixing the energy crisis by investing in new technology. Richardson speaks Spanish, which is a diplomatic plus.

Dodd also speaks Spanish and is one of the more level headed candidates on the Democratic side. He, like Richardson, also opposes the legalization of drugs or lowering the drinking age to 18. He voted to authorize the Iraq war but now opposes it. He also opposes the embargo on Cuba, which in my opinion is an excellent stance. On most issues he is rather moderate, but more intelligent that his colleagues on the Democratic side (and probably the Republican side).

Kucinich opposes the war in Iraq and voted against it and the Patriot Act, long before others recognized their mistakes. In his own words: "because I read it", regarding the Patriot Act, suggesting that his colleagues who voted for it did not. He wants to create a Department of Peace, which sounds Orwellian to me. He, like Ron Paul, wants to end the War on Drugs, and wants to withdraw from NAFTA. Most of his positions are rather socialist, but well-intentioned.

Biden wants to go straight to Darfur; although he doesn't pander, he appeals his audiences via emotion - pointing out the suffering in Sudan, though most of the time, in the debates, he makes substantial specific points while some of his colleagues (Hillary, Obama) speak in vague generalities.

Then, there is Mike Gravel who is somewhat ineloquent, but quite vocal critic of the war and the Democratic party.

In all, the Democratic Party has quite a few good options if the candidates keep to their word. That's unlikely in the case of Hillary and Obama.

Richardson, Dodd, are quite appealing were it not for some of their stances on liberty. Kucinich is appealing if you oppose the war and government involvement on the social issues, but some of his social programs seem rather elaborate, bloated and unnecessary.

All the democrats seem to welcome immigration, to have a healthcare plan reform and oppose the war. On the other hand, they do want to intervene and keep military bases around the world. They favor social programs over tax cuts.

On the Republican side, there's hardly anybody to highlight.

They mostly oppose immigration, most don't have a federal healthcare plan reform, except for Huckabee and Romney.

They all want to appear to be tough on terror, just like the Democrats want to be tough on Global Warming, so they sensationalize it.

Romney's healthcare plan is a clone of Hillary's but involves some form of privatization (not sure on the details).

If there is someone to highlight as definitely a bad candidate, it would be Giuliani, who has no clue when it comes to terrorism. He thinks terrorists simply attack us because they hate our freedoms, and won't look beyond that explanation. He seems to think the world started on 9/11/01. He probably dates his documents in relation to 9/11.

The majority of Republicans are neoconservatives (except possibly for McCain) in that they want to start wars abroad. They support foreign and corporate welfare, oil subsidies, etc.

The only different candidate on the Republican side is Ron Paul who voted against the war in Iraq, voted against the Patriot Act, wants to reduce spending and leave Iraq. He is a strict Constitutionalist, but also a libertarian, perhaps as a consequence thereof.

Ron Paul opposes the war on drugs, foreign intervention (such as the embargo on Cuba). He opposes setting up puppet governments as we did in Iran in the 1950s, our infamous coups d'etat and foreign aid.

His basic philosophy is we should let people do as they wish as long as they don't harm anyone.

If I were to recommend looking into anyone besides Ron Paul, I think it would be Richardson and Biden. Although, it is easier to advise against Hillary and Giuliani, possibly the most authoritarian candidates currently running for office.
 
Ron Paul has not been smeared

Have you not read the lies people have posted about Ron Paul? I recommend you read the OP. I can show you several threads including this one where people blatantly lie about him. In fact, you chastised me for pointing it out.

Other presidential candidates and politicians have been robustly criticised. Ron Paul gets more attention because, unlike any other candidate, some of his supporters are actively trying to use this forum to promote him.

I can see that being the case.

no

I have not taunted you.

which is why I told you to stop making this about other members and start addressing the issues.

I have been addressing the issues unlike the other members. That's why I called it taunting.
 
The North American Union is an abstract term for the integration of the economies of Canada, Mexico, and the United States. I was skeptical about the NAU, and I still think people oversensationalize it, so I asked for proof. The Council on Foreign Relations does endorse a single currency (the Amero)
The CFR has nothing to do with the government. Please list all elected officials or agencies in the Federal Government who are advocating "integration of the economies of Canada, Maxico, and the United States". Every other Paul supporter on this forum claiming some sort of intent to form a NAU has been unable to name one, will you be the first?
 
I might be wrong, but I'm guessing you have a little confirmation bias working here.

It's a possibility. But it is doubtful as I really expected people here to support Ron Paul, not the the opposite.

He doesn't have anywhere near the support to justify the amount of attention he's getting.

How did he outraise most Republicans and most Democrats if he truly doesn't have such support? How does he consistently win nationwide straw polls if he doesn't have such support?

His record as Congressman is enough to justify the attention he is getting. The amount of money he has raised is enough to justify the attention he is getting.

He doesn't have enough support to be a viable candidate. He isn't going to gain that support, because he favors policies that most Americans do not support.

Do you personally know most Americans? Apparently 70% of people want us out of Iraq. I'd say a majority support Ron Paul on this policy.

The majority of Republicans want taxes lowered. Ron Paul supports this.
The majority of Democrats support gay marriage. Ron Paul is OK with this.
Democrats oppose oil subsidies. So does Ron Paul.
Democrats oppose corporate welfare. So does Ron Paul.
Republicans oppose domestic welfare. Ron Paul does too.

Of the most important current issues, Ron Paul seems to do fine. In fact, in blind polls Ron Paul came out on top.

http://www.prisonplanet.com/articles/november2007/191107_zogby_poll.htm

So apparently people do agree with Ron Paul on his policies.
 
The CFR has nothing to do with the government. Please list all elected officials or agencies in the Federal Government who are advocating "integration of the economies of Canada, Maxico, and the United States". Every other Paul supporter on this forum claiming some sort of intent to form a NAU has been unable to name one, will you be the first?


Well, since I never claimed that CFR has anything to do with the government, there is no need for me to list any government officials who advocate this.
 
Have you not read the lies people have posted about Ron Paul? I recommend you read the OP.
I have read the OP, you have not made your case at all

I can show you several threads including this one where people blatantly lie about him.
please provide one example of an unequivocal lie about Ron Paul.


In fact, you chastised me for pointing it out.
i did not such thing, I told you to stop personalising the issue.



I have been addressing the issues unlike the other members. That's why I called it taunting.
You have been attempting to personalise the issue, if you wish to discuss forum management issues take it to appropriate section. Your second sentence does not follow from your first.
 
I have read the OP, you have not made your case at all

please provide one example of an unequivocal lie about Ron Paul.

Wildcat's assertion that Ron Paul specifically promotes quackery and homeopathy and that it is his intention to do so.

You have been attempting to personalise the issue, if you wish to discuss forum management issues take it to appropriate section. Your second sentence does not follow from your first.

Actually, my second sentence does follow from the first. In my first sentence I said that I have been addressing the issues, while other people like Wildcat and others have instead been engaging in ad hominem attacks. It follows that since you are being unfair by calling me out instead of them, you are taunting me.

Please stop.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom