Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

Can you explain exactly what "******" means, in this context? It sounds like nothing more than an emotional judgment.

As for rigid- it must be rigid. Insurance has to put limits on coverage otherwise there is no way to price for it. Further, all insurance companies are heavily regulated by the states in which they operate. Extending coverage to situations outside of what is contracted for can not only throw off their rate structure- causing them to go bankrupt in short order- it will also lose them their right to write insurance in the state.

If 9 people out of ten pay their liability premiums, should the insurance company be "morally" required to pay the victim of the tenth, unpaid driver just because she's a sweet single mother struggling to raise two kids?

It would have been more sensible for the government to tax him the proper amount in order to cover his fire protection. Now he may end up at a homeless shelter which would likely cost more than his fair share of fire protection.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It would have been more sensible for the government to tax him the proper amount in order to cover his fire protection. Now he may end up at a homeless shelter which would likely cost more than his fair share of fire protection.

Unfortunately for him, he didn't pay his annual $75 fee to the homeless shelter...
 
It would have been more sensible for the government to tax him the proper amount in order to cover his fire protection. Now he may end up at a homeless shelter which would likely cost more than his fair share of fire protection.

How is the government from a city he does not live in going to tax him?
 
Well, that's not the one we live in. Moral decisions cannot be made based on the rules we imagine for fairy-land... and sometimes in this world letting people suffer is the right thing to do.

Do you think that's just a good excuse or extremely logical argument? Possibly both, I would judge. Touché, mon ami :jaw-dropp.

Which doesn't mean we shouldn't try to change stupid and f-ed up rules/system when there are/is such. Why don't just introduce federal or state taxes on firemen services?
 
Last edited:
It would have been more sensible for the government to tax him the proper amount in order to cover his fire protection. Now he may end up at a homeless shelter which would likely cost more than his fair share of fire protection.

So what do you suppose drives people to live outside city limits? From experience, it is often the allure of not having to pay all those high fees and taxes the evil people at city hall want to charge.
 
Which doesn't mean we shouldn't try to change stupid and f-ed up rules/system when there are such. Why don't just introduce federal or state taxes on firemen services?


But a simple, workable system was in place and the guy chose to opt out. It doesn't get any better than that!
 
Which doesn't mean we shouldn't try to change stupid and f-ed up rules/system when there are such.
Absolutely. But just because someone gets hurt doesn't mean the rule is stupid.

Why don't just introduce federal or state taxes on firemen services?
For the same reason the State and Federal government does not tax for local law enforcement. Cost and inefficiency. You're talking about instituting a massive beaurocracy to administrate funds for thousands of small towns and cities with widely varying needs.
 
I see this as likely some kind of administrative problem or dispute between Obion County and city of South Fulton. Maybe the citizens of unincorporated Obion voted on this arrangement? Typically my understanding is that fire districts will offer their services to unincorporated areas and then the governing body (county) will pass that on through taxes to their residents.
I think this is probably what happened, the people voted down an arrangement to put fire service on their property taxes. So the city offered to cover anyone in their area who'd pay $75 instead.

This sounds like a case of immature government to me to bill residents directly.
The government likely can't add such services without voter approval. My parents have a summer house in Indiana, on a lake, in an unincorporated part of the county. For years many of the residents have been trying to get connected to the county water and sewer system, eliminating the need for wells and septic tanks. But the voters have to approve, and every time they voted it down. Now, my parents discovered something when they had to get a permit for a new septic tank a few years ago: the rules have changed, and you now need a much larger drain field than when the lots were developed. There wasn't enough room on their lot to install the septic tank, and theirs was one of the larger lots on that lake! Luckily, they owned an acre of land across the street they were able to utilize for the drain field, but most other property owners there aren't so lucky. Which means the feces (;)) will hit the fan as people need new septic tanks installed, and find they have no room. Maybe, just maybe, that will be enough for the tax assessment to get voter approval.

IOW, people sometimes act against their own interests. Usually to save a few bucks now, not worrying about later.

What if there was a wild fire on county land?
Likely a state responsibility. And it's probably not a big issue there anyway, it isn't the west.

I don't know for sure but it does seem kind of cruel from my interpretation of events for the firefighters to be at the location with the ability to help and did not. If they were so concerned about the money maybe they could have billed Gene for their services after the fact.

-Maus
Then why would anyone pay the $75?
 
It would have been more sensible for the government to tax him the proper amount in order to cover his fire protection. Now he may end up at a homeless shelter which would likely cost more than his fair share of fire protection.
Nah, he can take the $75 he saved to buy a tent and pitch it on his lawn.
 
.
We have that notice on the upper right hand corner of our envelopes to tell us to put a stamp there, the post office won't deliver otherwise... created by those who knew the P.O. would process unstamped mail and charge the recipient the postage.
The P.O. don't do that no more.
Really? I've never seen that. I thought billing the recipient went out long ago?
 
Then why would anyone pay the $75?

That's a good point, but I can't understand the logistics of it if the fire department has to respond anyway for fear of the fire spreading to paying customers.

Fire is indiscriminate in its destruction, it doesn't care who paid, so if the fire department has to go out there anyway to control it they are out the money anyhow.

The fact they spent the money on the call to protect the paying neighbors kind of nullifies the point of it all since they were already out the money.

I guess that's why I see it as a flawed way to run a public service. Selective protection against a non-selective threat.

-Maus
 
That's a good point, but I can't understand the logistics of it if the fire department has to respond anyway for fear of the fire spreading to paying customers.

Fire is indiscriminate in its destruction, it doesn't care who paid, so if the fire department has to go out there anyway to control it they are out the money anyhow.

The fact they spent the money on the call to protect the paying neighbors kind of nullifies the point of it all since they were already out the money.

I guess that's why I see it as a flawed way to run a public service. Selective protection against a non-selective threat.

-Maus

Perhaps the lawyers on board can correct me if I'm mistaken, but I think that if they put out even one fire they are not paid to put out that can create a legal obligation to put out any and every fire they are called about. Am I wrong?
 
That's a good point, but I can't understand the logistics of it if the fire department has to respond anyway for fear of the fire spreading to paying customers.

Fire is indiscriminate in its destruction, it doesn't care who paid, so if the fire department has to go out there anyway to control it they are out the money anyhow.

The fact they spent the money on the call to protect the paying neighbors kind of nullifies the point of it all since they were already out the money.

I guess that's why I see it as a flawed way to run a public service. Selective protection against a non-selective threat.

-Maus

No, there is a huge difference in cost between driving out to watch a fire and fighting it.

Being there to fight if it spread to a property whose owner had paid makes good firefighting sense. Not fighting a fire on a property where the owner hasn't paid makes good economic sense.

Like the fire chief in the video said, it's not the fire department's problem, it's the county's problem."
 
Perhaps the lawyers on board can correct me if I'm mistaken, but I think that if they put out even one fire they are not paid to put out that can create a legal obligation to put out any and every fire they are called about. Am I wrong?

I think it would be pretty easy to argue on a case by case basis, as in: "We had to put out fire A because it threatened the property of someone who had paid, the same condition didn't exist for fire B, so we let the **************** burn!"

I think it's worth pointing out that one of the major problems with a la carte services is that it drastically raises administrative costs. Everyone pays taxes, taxes pay for fire departments, simple.

For this little county the difference in cost won't be great, but if you observe how programs work on the national level, notice how much cheaper medicare is to administrate than private insurance. The difference seems to be about 5% for medicare and about 12% for private insurers, but it's heavily dependent on size:

Nor is it easy to measure administrative costs among private insurers. For one thing, which private insurers? When the Congressional Budget Office examined this issue, it found that administrative costs -- including advertising and profits -- accounted for 12 percent of the average insurer's dollar. But that hid substantial variation among insurers. Among employer-based plans, the largest firms had the lowest costs. Plans covering companies with at least 1,000 employees had a mere 7 percent in administrative costs. Those covering companies with fewer than 25 employees spent 26 percent of premiums on administration. And the individual market was a mess: 30 percent.
http://voices.washingtonpost.com/ezra-klein/2009/07/administrative_costs_in_health.html

Start breaking up departments into smaller components and the cost of administration becomes much higher in relation to the overall budget.

Setting aside the visceral reactions to standing and watching someone's house burn when you have hoses ready to help, this type of glibertarian masturbation fantasy is just stupid from an economics perspective.
 
Last edited:
Being there to fight if it spread to a property whose owner had paid makes good firefighting sense. Not fighting a fire on a property where the owner hasn't paid makes good economic sense.

It really doesn't. Among many other things, the loss in property taxes will be much greater than $75.
 
It really doesn't. Among many other things, the loss in property taxes will be much greater than $75.

It's not a loss to the fire department or the city they work for. It is a loss to the county which it should be because they do not provide fire fighting services.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom