Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

Ugh. All I'm gonna say in this case is, were I one of the fireman, I don't think I could stand by while someone was going through watching their house burn down, and be in the capacity of resolving that issue, and not do it. I don't think I'd be capable of it. I don't have the ability to be in the position to help somebody who needs it and not do it.
 
The guy was an a** not to pay (or maybe he forgot). That doesn't mean you have to be an ar*e and not do your *****' job! He should have to pay for his moral choice (which means extra money after they do their job) and firemen should have to pay for theirs (choosing not to do their jobs, even if on the spot).

I disagree. The type of person who will not pay a $75 firefighting fee for their own home is the type of person who will argue in court that he shouldn't have to pay the costs he agreed to once the fire started because he was under duress and the firefighters were wrong to ask him for the money at a time like that.

This guy gambled with his house and lost. He should have every right to do that. Imagine if this was an insurance issue and the guy phoned up and said, "Ummmm, yeah. My house is on fire and I know I declined coverage a couple months back but I am thinking I would like to buy it now." I know what the insurance companies answer would be.

Plus, the guy said he was willing to pay anything . . . well, lucky him, he gets his chance. He gets to pay for a new house and belongings.

I bet this one incident will make all the other people who were unwilling to pay the fee, reconsider their position.
 
Ugh. All I'm gonna say in this case is, were I one of the fireman, I don't think I could stand by while someone was going through watching their house burn down, and be in the capacity of resolving that issue, and not do it. I don't think I'd be capable of it. I don't have the ability to be in the position to help somebody who needs it and not do it.

There was an incident where I lived several years ago in which the fire occured outside the city limits. When the fire truck arrived and realized the problem, they made sure there was no one in the house and then left. The problem was that the insurance and WCB coverage for the firefighters would not be in effect while they fought the fire because, being outside city limits, they would have had to do it on their own time and not while on the job.

All declined to fight the fire.

[This is from memory and is probably not exactly right but I seem to recall that was the gist of it.]
 
There was an incident where I lived several years ago in which the fire occured outside the city limits. When the fire truck arrived and realized the problem, they made sure there was no one in the house and then left. The problem was that the insurance and WCB coverage for the firefighters would not be in effect while they fought the fire because, being outside city limits, they would have had to do it on their own time and not while on the job.

All declined to fight the fire.

[This is from memory and is probably not exactly right but I seem to recall that was the gist of it.]

Which tells you all you need to know about insurance companies ;).

As I said, "legally" speaking its all ok, fine and dandy; morally... very, very questionable. As for agreeing on costs, there's no need that he agrees to anything. Just mail him the bill and let him fight lost court battle (they were there, they did their jobs, he didn't pay them beforehand so he has to pay now. Nice and simple).
 
Last edited:
There was an incident where I lived several years ago in which the fire occured outside the city limits. When the fire truck arrived and realized the problem, they made sure there was no one in the house and then left. The problem was that the insurance and WCB coverage for the firefighters would not be in effect while they fought the fire because, being outside city limits, they would have had to do it on their own time and not while on the job.

All declined to fight the fire.

[This is from memory and is probably not exactly right but I seem to recall that was the gist of it.]

Yeah, I can see why they wouldn't, and I'm not making any judgements towards the firefighters in this instance. I'm just saying, were I in that position, I wouldn't have it in me to withhold aid.
 
I can see the firemen's point. If they were required to save any house, then the owner could make up the missed fees retrospectively, or even pay an inflated fee retrospectively, where's the incentive for anyone to pay their premiums? Most people don't have house fires. Most people might be inclined just to take the risk, knowing that all they risked was perhaps an increased financial penalty - IF their house actually did catch fire. Funding for the fire service just evaporated.

It's the system that's f-ed up, not the response to it. The system mandates that response.

Rolfe.
 
This is pretty much why I didn't donate to any 9/11 victims charities. Those people would have collected on the life insurance. And if they chose not to buy life insurance, well, too bad.
 
Which tells you all you need to know about insurance companies :mad:.

You mean to tell me that yu think the insurance company should allow someone to buy fire insurance once house is on fire or already burnt to the ground? What part of "Good business practice" did you not understand? :D

As I said, "legally" speaking its all ok, fine and dandy; morally... very, very questionable.

Morally, not an issue at all. Just because the answer to the moral question isn't a happy one for the home owner, doesn't mean it is questionable.

As to the question of "public good being served," I bet most people in the area will now make sure their insurance and fees are paid up.

As for agreeing on costs, there's no need that he agrees to anything. Just mail him the bill and let him fight lost court battle (they were there, they did their jobs, he didn't pay them beforehand so he has to pay now. Nice and simple).

You can send someone a bill for anything you want, that doesn't mean they have to pay it. What you are saying here is that not only should the fire department be out the fee and the money for fighting the fire, they should also incur the costs of suing this idot for refusing to pay.

Most likely they would lose. If he hadn't asked for their help, they would definitely lose.
 
Which tells you all you need to know about insurance companies ;).

As I said, "legally" speaking its all ok, fine and dandy; morally... very, very questionable. As for agreeing on costs, there's no need that he agrees to anything. Just mail him the bill and let him fight lost court battle (they were there, they did their jobs, he didn't pay them beforehand so he has to pay now. Nice and simple).
And then he sues the city for the water damage caused by the firemen and the city has to spend money to defend itself.
 
It tells me that their coverage of people doing dangerous jobs is very ****** and rigid.
Can you explain exactly what "******" means, in this context? It sounds like nothing more than an emotional judgment.

As for rigid- it must be rigid. Insurance has to put limits on coverage otherwise there is no way to price for it. Further, all insurance companies are heavily regulated by the states in which they operate. Extending coverage to situations outside of what is contracted for can not only throw off their rate structure- causing them to go bankrupt in short order- it will also lose them their right to write insurance in the state.

If 9 people out of ten pay their liability premiums, should the insurance company be "morally" required to pay the victim of the tenth, unpaid driver just because she's a sweet single mother struggling to raise two kids?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You mean to tell me that yu think the insurance company should allow someone to buy fire insurance once house is on fire or already burnt to the ground? What part of "Good business practice" did you not understand? :D
I never said such thing. I replied to "firemen out of their city" case, not "house burning, have to buy insurance NOW!" case.

Morally, not an issue at all. Just because the answer to the moral question isn't a happy one for the home owner, doesn't mean it is questionable.

As to the question of "public good being served," I bet most people in the area will now make sure their insurance and fees are paid up.



You can send someone a bill for anything you want, that doesn't mean they have to pay it. What you are saying here is that not only should the fire department be out the fee and the money for fighting the fire, they should also incur the costs of suing this idiot for refusing to pay.

Most likely they would lose. If he hadn't asked for their help, they would definitely lose.

He did ask them, the moment he made his phone call (which should be fairly easy to prove).

Also, I never said system is good. I only said that if you took the view that moral thing to do is the thing that alleviates human suffering the most, then what firefighters did was very questionable, morally speaking.

Or at least thought to say... only things got a bit out of control here. :o English is not my native tongue, you know... Or don't :o
 
Last edited:
Yes, but the government pays our $75 fee to the U.S. for fire protection so everyone is covered.
The "government" means the people we pay our property taxes to, which is the city, and it was the city fire department that was operating outside its jurisdiction.

If the county gave a rodent's rectum about people in its jurisdiction, they would be paying the city governments for those services, instead of leaving it up to county citizens to pay for it themselves.

But again, this is Libertarianism in action, where each individual is expected to contribute of their own free will, or face the conseqences of their own neglect.
 
Can you explain exactly what "******" means, in this context? It sounds like nothing more than an emotional judgment.

As for rigid- it must be rigid. Insurance has to put limits on coverage otherwise there is no way to price for it. Further, all insurance companies are heavily regulated by the states in which they operate. Extending coverage to situations outside of what is contracted for can not only throw off their rate structure- causing them to go bankrupt in short order- it will also lose them their right to write insurance in the state.

If 9 people out of ten pay their liability premiums, should the insurance company be "morally" required to pay the victim of the tenth, unpaid driver just because she's a sweet single mother struggling to raise two kids?

In perfect world, maybe. Sorry about that blunder, I got a bit carried away and made a big logical mistake (or used imprecise language, at the very least). I apologise for everything insurance related. Can we go back to the OP case?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
And then he sues the city for the water damage caused by the firemen and the city has to spend money to defend itself.

And fair judge simply laughs and fines him for wasting court's time... in perfect world.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom