Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

My parents have a summer house in Indiana, on a lake, in an unincorporated part of the county. For years many of the residents have been trying to get connected to the county water and sewer system, eliminating the need for wells and septic tanks. But the voters have to approve, and every time they voted it down. Now, my parents discovered something when they had to get a permit for a new septic tank a few years ago: the rules have changed, and you now need a much larger drain field than when the lots were developed. There wasn't enough room on their lot to install the septic tank, and theirs was one of the larger lots on that lake! Luckily, they owned an acre of land across the street they were able to utilize for the drain field, but most other property owners there aren't so lucky.

My parents are in a similar situation - septic tanks and drain fields are no longer allowed on the lake side of the road where they have a cottage. They have land on the other side, but many of the residents don't.
 
It's not a loss to the fire department or the city they work for. It is a loss to the county which it should be because they do not provide fire fighting services.

Maybe I didn't get your point.

Are you arguing that it only made financial sense for the fire department, because that's probably true. They didn't spend any money fighting the fire and I'm guessing they got a few $75 checks today.

But from the perspective of the region's economy, it was a terrible economic decision.
 
For this little county the difference in cost won't be great, but if you observe how programs work on the national level, notice how much cheaper medicare is to administrate than private insurance. The difference seems to be about 5% for medicare and about 12% for private insurers, but it's heavily dependent on size:
Does this take into account that Medicare fraud is estimated at $80 billion per year, or 20% of the Medicare budget? Maybe a little more administration would cut down on that amount?
 
I'm willing to lay odds that since this made front page national news, fund drives will pop up all over the country to give them cash for a new home.
 
I'm a little confused about this argument. I mean, firefighters work hard and they deserve to get paid for their work, right?

If they put out fires for people who don't think firefighters should get paid then wouldn't more people start going around thinking that firefighters shouldn't get paid?

I'm fine with people deciding not to pay for a service but why should they then get that service anyway? That's punishing all the people who do pay and I would think it would eventually mean that no one would want to pay.

If you want to live in Libertarian land I'm all for it, but don't come begging from the Socialists when something goes wrong. Personally, I'll pay my extra taxes and be happy that I have a support system if my life takes a sudden tragic turn.
 
Maybe I didn't get your point.

Are you arguing that it only made financial sense for the fire department, because that's probably true. They didn't spend any money fighting the fire and I'm guessing they got a few $75 checks today.

But from the perspective of the region's economy, it was a terrible economic decision.

No, it wasn't. As far as it goes, it was brilliant economically as well. The guy was a tightwad. He wasn't willing to put out $75 dollars to protect a huge investment.

Now he has to rebuild and rebuy everything he had. That means more money into the economy than if his house hadn't burned to the ground.

Economically speaking, it was bad for the individual, great for the region.
 
You're talking about instituting a massive beaurocracy to administrate funds for thousands of small towns and cities with widely varying needs.


What, paying for fire services out of tax? Most other places seem to manage it.

Our firemen had a carwash day on Saturday for fundraising. Great fun getting your car washed by a big fire hose! But the money is for charity.

Rolfe.
 
What, paying for fire services out of tax? Most other places seem to manage it.

Our firemen had a carwash day on Saturday for fundraising. Great fun getting your car washed by a big fire hose! But the money is for charity.

Rolfe.

True, but in the county in question, it was determined to forgo this added expense and increased taxes.

The City firefighters were under no obligation to fight the fire. They were there simply to protect the houses of those whom had contracted with the City for fire protection/assistance. This, ironically, is one of the very scenarios presented as reason that FOTL is complete bunk - and it played out precisely how FOTL claim the system is designed to work.


In an earlier post, Clown compared the firefighters standing around to a Dr passing by refusing to administer care to a dying man. There is a slight difference here. The firefighters arrived to ensure the safety of the inhabitants. Once that was accomplished, their duty was completed. There was no further obligation to assist the home owner, while there was in fact incentive to not assist the home owner (he didn't pay for the protection).

The home owner made his decision (poor or not) and therefore now must live with that decision. The firefighters are not at fault for what happened, not even morally. That's just an appeal to emotion.

It's interesting to see socialism meets libertarianism and none of the regular libertarians here to proclaim that their system worked. (note for the record that I am not a libertarian... I'm pretty neutral about the whole thing - i.o.w. I don't care because I pays my taxes/obligations so I gets my protections)
 
What, paying for fire services out of tax? Most other places seem to manage it.
I don't think you actually understand what a US rural county usually entails. It will have a County Seat (local government) that collects taxes, but seldom is in a financial position to offer county-wide police and fire protection. The county seat will have usually have town police, but the (town) Fire Dept may well be Volunteer. Some State level policing may be available within the county, but no fire service; larger population counties may have a county-wide police presence (with a one or a couple officers).

Our firemen had a carwash day on Saturday for fundraising. Great fun getting your car washed by a big fire hose! But the money is for charity.
My local Volunteer Fire Dept (well, local, it's 15 miles away) does the same thing; not car-wash, but other charity events.
 
Does this take into account that Medicare fraud is estimated at $80 billion per year, or 20% of the Medicare budget? Maybe a little more administration would cut down on that amount?

Your own article says $60 billion, but point taken. I guess the best thing to do would be to examine other large, government run health care programs, compare their fraud rates to private insurance fraud rates (it's also worth pointing out that a lot of medicare fraud is committed by private insurers through Medicare Part D), and then compare administration costs.

There's a reason why we pay 2x as much on health care as Europe and Canada and get far worse results.
 
No, it wasn't. As far as it goes, it was brilliant economically as well. The guy was a tightwad. He wasn't willing to put out $75 dollars to protect a huge investment.

Now he has to rebuild and rebuy everything he had. That means more money into the economy than if his house hadn't burned to the ground.

Economically speaking, it was bad for the individual, great for the region.

You're assuming he's willing and able to rebuild. I'm sure the neighbors aren't too pleased about having a burned down house bringing their property values down, either.

You're also assuming that the cost of rebuilding will be spent locally, and that this guy won't hire outside the area.
 
I don't think you actually understand what a US rural county usually entails. It will have a County Seat (local government) that collects taxes, but seldom is in a financial position to offer county-wide police and fire protection. The county seat will have usually have town police, but the (town) Fire Dept may well be Volunteer. Some State level policing may be available within the county, but no fire service; larger population counties may have a county-wide police presence (with a one or a couple officers).
Bull roar. Every County I know of has a Sheriff, with several deputies. They are the county police department.
Out West we have a tradition: When there's a fire, you put it out. worry about the charges later.
It is not unusual to see 3 different fire departments respond to a fire out here--and I have lived in some SMALL towns (<10000, up to 50000 people, 20 to 90 miles from any other town...)

My local Volunteer Fire Dept (well, local, it's 15 miles away) does the same thing; not car-wash, but other charity events.
 
Really? I've never seen that. I thought billing the recipient went out long ago?
.
Along with delivering mail with postage due.
It was returned to the sender.
The P.O. would open the mail if there was no stamp, typically a bill, and get the name of the person the bill was sent to, and send it back to them.
 
No, it wasn't. As far as it goes, it was brilliant economically as well. The guy was a tightwad. He wasn't willing to put out $75 dollars to protect a huge investment.

Now he has to rebuild and rebuy everything he had. That means more money into the economy than if his house hadn't burned to the ground.

Economically speaking, it was bad for the individual, great for the region.
.
Now, that's yer "Positive spin"! :)
 
Okay, so the fire department was already out there, already had their trucks there, already had the ambulances there (I'm guessing), and already had hoses hooked up. Why? Why go out at all?
 
Okay, so the fire department was already out there, already had their trucks there, already had the ambulances there (I'm guessing), and already had hoses hooked up. Why? Why go out at all?

They were worried the fire would spread to a paying person's house.
 
No, it wasn't. As far as it goes, it was brilliant economically as well. The guy was a tightwad. He wasn't willing to put out $75 dollars to protect a huge investment.

Now he has to rebuild and rebuy everything he had. That means more money into the economy than if his house hadn't burned to the ground.

Economically speaking, it was bad for the individual, great for the region.
Thank god you're here, Broken Window Fallacy Man!

If it was taxes, they'd get mandatory payments from everyone, which is more money. This way, they not only get less money, but drum up some of the worst possible press imaginable.

If I'm that guy, I sell my property, buy a new house with the insurance money I get in a competely different area, and it's not great for that city OR that region. Oh, and the negative press garnered from this story hitting the national news means not only do some people move out, but people fail to move there in droves.

Yeah, that was a brilliant move.
 
Bull roar. Every County I know of has a Sheriff, with several deputies. They are the county police department.
OK, but my general thrust in correct; out-of-town police protection and response is not something to bet on.

Out West we have a tradition: When there's a fire, you put it out. worry about the charges later.
Likely Volunteers, although town Departments (also likely Volunteer) may respond. But in the west I tend to agree.

It is not unusual to see 3 different fire departments respond to a fire out here--and I have lived in some SMALL towns (<10000, up to 50000 people, 20 to 90 miles from any other town...)
OK, but East, and even rural East exists.

BTW, a small town is a few hundred. My county seat here in East: 936. In a town out West where I have business interests, county seat: 1400.

Here, no county fire coverage, and call 911 outside city limits, you might get a county mounty in an hour or two. In the West, yes, everybody fights fires (usually grass), same problem with 911.
 
Yep. I've never heard of the fire dept ignoring calls from those that haven't paid their taxes.

Then you don't know much about the history of firefighting, you used to have a small cast iron sign to put in the front of your house to let the fire fighters know you paid up. And that is not even bringing in Crassus and his idea of a fire sale.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom