Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

Then the fire department would have had a more legitimate reason to let the house burn.

Although, in all likelihood, if the fee was that high, no one would pay it, and the fire department would have disbanded for lack of funding.

I don't really follow your point. The reason letting it burn was so absurd was because the fee was so small, a trivial sum. If the sum was non-trivial, it changes things.

Please have enough dignity to avoid the "where do we draw the line" nonsense. Wherever it is, it isn't $75.

It's trivial but critical.
 
And yet it was the lack of government that brought this on.

No, it wasn't. Unless of course, you only see government as a dictatorship.

The elected government set up the system the voters wanted, democracy in action.
 
Are you seriously trying to say here that the county did not choose the system they have in place? (And by "the county" I mean the gov't and the citizens.)

That's something I haven't been able to figure out this whole thread. Apparently, some people don't understand the word "government", the system of government in question, and/or how the subscription system came into being in this county.

One would think skeptics would want to educate themselves on those points before continuing the discussion.
 
No, it wasn't. Unless of course, you only see government as a dictatorship.

The elected government set up the system the voters wanted, democracy in action.

That's just an equivocation over the word "government."
 
Then you don't understand insurance. I don't pay, they do.

Distinguish this fee from any other tax for service arrangement. Unless you consider all taxes "insurance" in case we need to use the military or the police need to catch someone who robbed your house, that's not a particularly meaningful claim from you.

Once again, legally, the fire department could have put out the fire then left a bill. Said bill would have been upheld in court. This would have been the better decision.

"but it's just so hard to collect debts. Never mind that it's done successfully 10,000,000 times a day. This was different it was $75. Don't mess around with that kind of money..."
 
Distinguish this fee from any other tax for service arrangement.

It wasn't a tax, it was a fee. That means people could opt out while with a tax, they couldn't. These people opted out.

Unless you consider all taxes "insurance" in case we need to use the military or the police need to catch someone who robbed your house, that's not a particularly meaningful claim from you.

Well, in a trivial sense they are. they are there to insure the service is available when required.

Once again, legally, the fire department could have put out the fire then left a bill. Said bill would have been upheld in court. This would have been the better decision.

The people involved, who have been down this road before, thought otherwise. With their experience, I would say they are in a better position to know.

"but it's just so hard to collect debts. Never mind that it's done successfully 10,000,000 times a day. This was different it was $75. Don't mess around with that kind of money..."

But then you would be arguing that the $75 idn't worth going to court over.

I am pretty sure S. Fulton agrees. They have decided that fighting to get a nominal fee is absurd so they will just exercise their right ot not fight the fires on non-paying properties.

That's a win, win decision for the people who fund the S. Fulton fire department.
 
Tennessee Council Plans Vote On Fire Protection Plan
Posted by FFN WebTeam on October 8, 2010 at 10:03am in Fire/Rescue News

OBION COUNTY, Tenn. - "It was a great plan, but it never took off."
That's what the creator of a comprehensive, countywide fire protection plan said about a resolution that could have prevented the controversy surrounding last week's Obion County fire.

Richard Chestean designed the detailed plan in 1987. It would have given everyone in the county fire protection. County commissioners liked it and voted yes.

And then nothing happened for 23 years.

A new plan is in the works. Dean Jowers, Obion County's fire commission chairperson, will bring it before the commission in a few weeks.

Jowers said it's similar to Chestean's plan, but doesn't raise taxes and is a subscription service.

"No way to enforce that they pay it, if you charge everybody," Jowers said. "So, a number of people will not pay it."

County leaders will vote on that proposal Oct. 18.

http://www.firefighternation.com/forum/topics/tennessee-council-plans-vote
 
This is ridiculous and absurd. Why don't we punish speeding by destroying someone's car? That would really teach people not to speed.
An excellent idea and one that is in place in a number of US jurisdictions. I'd also apply it to drunk drivers.
Indeed in the UK the North Cambridge force is planning to seize vehicles for avoiding speed humps.....
 
So the "fix" is to make the system of the entire county exactly like the South Fulton system!

But Chestean is against this newest proposal because of the effect it will have on stations like Hornbeak. They now respond to all fires in the area and didn't ask for a dime. Under countywide subscription service, all of Obion County will be just like South Fulton.

"You may only have 40 percent of people within Hornbeak's five mile radius that signed up," Chestean said. "Those 60 percent of other people, if they call Hornbeak, they're gonna say, 'Sorry, you're not on subscription."

He's afraid under that system, you'll see homes like Gene Cranick's throughout Obion County go up in flames, and firefighters forced to watch them burn.
No new taxes! :boggled:
 
So the "fix" is to make the system of the entire county exactly like the South Fulton system!

<snip>


Only if they choose to stand around and watch someone's home burn down, exactly like the South Fulton system!

If they decide to put the fire out and deal with the collection issue after the flames are gone then they'll be exactly like all the other departments with collection systems! instead.

Funny how South Fulton is the only town in the county that isn't going to participate, isn't it?
 
If they decide to put the fire out and deal with the collection issue after the flames are gone then they'll be exactly like all the other departments with collection systems! instead.
The collection system wasn't bringing in the money, was it? And I'd be very interested in seeing how much they actually collect per call to the freeloaders. Is there any legal way they can force collections on these bills?

Funny how South Fulton is the only town in the county that isn't going to participate, isn't it?
What's funny about it? South Fulton is going to continue just as they have, nothing changes for them.
 
Yeah, FSM forbid people get a say in their government and that government do what those people want.

I think you missed my point. Notice how the meaning of government changes in these two sentences:

1) Democracies, Republics, and Oligarchies are all styles of government.

2) Democrats support big government programs like Medicare.

You're arguing against my statement based on definition 1. My comment made use of definition 2.
 
It wasn't a tax, it was a fee. That means people could opt out while with a tax, they couldn't. These people opted out.

Well, in a trivial sense they are. they are there to insure the service is available when required.

Obviously it's different. Notice the specific sense in which I'm arguing, here. I know it's a fee, not a tax, but if we consider that fee "insurance," thereby stressing the meaning of the word, then basically all government services are insurance, rendering the point irrelevant.

The people involved, who have been down this road before, thought otherwise. With their experience, I would say they are in a better position to know.

No, they still have to argue on the merits. The South had much more experience with Segregation than the North. That doesn't mean it was a good idea.

I find it odd that you're arguing that the people who came up with this stupid system must have done so from a position of wisdom, not political Zeitgeist.


But then you would be arguing that the $75 idn't worth going to court over.

Once again, I don't think people really know what they mean by "going to court" over the charge. It would take less than 15min in court, just like speeding tickets. At worst it would be a half hour small claims issue.

I am pretty sure S. Fulton agrees. They have decided that fighting to get a nominal fee is absurd so they will just exercise their right ot not fight the fires on non-paying properties.

No, it means they're idiots. I'm sure S. Fulton enforces speeding tickets. If they had half a brain they could place the fee in a similar legal capacity.

This wasn't about smarts or the best way to fund a fire department. It was about the ascension of backwards political notions. Hopefully this is the worst it gets before people realize how insane these libertarian theories are.

That's a win, win decision for the people who fund the S. Fulton fire department.

Yeah, they showed that guy. Without his $75 they would have folded.
 
The collection system wasn't bringing in the money, was it? And I'd be very interested in seeing how much they actually collect per call to the freeloaders. Is there any legal way they can force collections on these bills?


How many times is this question going to be asked? Until you get an answer you like instead of an honest one?

If you really don't remember, the answer is yes. Obion County isn't in a different country, or on a different continent from South Fulton. There are some common legal structures.

What's funny about it? South Fulton is going to continue just as they have, nothing changes for them.


Well, gee. Let's see. There's been a lot of noise here about how the county forced the town into the subscription service that got them into this predicament, but now it seems that the county can't force them to do anything. Suddenly, I guess.

Somehow South Fulton was being charitable and virtuous by sharing its resources, but when sharing resources involves actually coordinating with everyone else it isn't as attractive.

The other towns in the county that were also offering subscription service separately managed to do so without standing around watching people's homes burn down and still survive financially. Now they are going to do the same thing in concert to eliminate the inconsistent coverage, but South Fulton seems to be reluctant to participate and accept that model. Why is that. What is different about South Fulton's approach, compared to all the other towns in the county.

Oh, yeah. They stand around watching people's homes burn down.

I suppose you're right. Who could blame them for wanting to give up that tradition?
 
Distinguish this fee from any other tax for service arrangement.

You have to pay a tax, you don't have to pay a fee. They had no compulsion to pay this, if it was a tax they would be compelled to pay.

See no one here actually thinks this is a good policy, but it is what they have. How do you override democracy in this case?
 
How many times is this question going to be asked? Until you get an answer you like instead of an honest one?

If you really don't remember, the answer is yes. Obion County isn't in a different country, or on a different continent from South Fulton. There are some common legal structures.
And what legal structure do they have in place for South Fulton to collect from county residents out of South Fulton's jurisdiction?

Well, gee. Let's see. There's been a lot of noise here about how the county forced the town into the subscription service that got them into this predicament, but now it seems that the county can't force them to do anything. Suddenly, I guess.
I don't recall anyone claiming the county forced South Fulton into this arrangement... :confused:

Somehow South Fulton was being charitable and virtuous by sharing its resources, but when sharing resources involves actually coordinating with everyone else it isn't as attractive.
Uh, no. They weren's "sharing" their resources, they were selling them, via yearly subscription. Necessary because adding coverage area increeases their costs, thus they need more funding.

The other towns in the county that were also offering subscription service separately managed to do so without standing around watching people's homes burn down and still survive financially. Now they are going to do the same thing in concert to eliminate the inconsistent coverage, but South Fulton seems to be reluctant to participate and accept that model. Why is that. What is different about South Fulton's approach, compared to all the other towns in the county.
This doesn't even make sense, and is it a question or a statement?

Oh, yeah. They stand around watching people's homes burn down.

I suppose you're right. Who could blame them for wanting to give up that tradition?
Who could blame them for not wanting to be taken advantage of by the county freeloaders?

Do you think that if Yonkers eliminated its fire dept. NYC should cover them for free?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom