Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

I don't know how 'odd' it is. I think that theprestige put forward a pretty reasonable sounding explanation for how this came about.

I wonder if insurance will cover it?

Also, Puppycow, I think that what you're thinking about is 'free riding' rather than 'moral hazard'.

At the end of the day taxes are the best way to do this kind of stuff.
 
Well, we don't know if he was too cheap, or forgot.

Pretty odd way to run a county.

But a pretty sensible and obvious way to run a city: City taxpayers have recourse to the city services their taxes pay for. People outside the city limits, who don't pay city taxes, do not. Nothing very odd about it at all.
 
My father. If possible, he would avoid paying for any kind of insurance.

As for these folks, I wonder if they have cable. If they pay their monthly cable bill, then I have no sympathy for'em. Or if they had paid for fire insurance every year and then somehow FORGOT, but I imagine the city would have (or should have) sent multiple notices.

Why would the city send any notices at all, to someone outside of their jurisdiction, who didn't pay any city taxes, and wasn't entitled to city services (unless he paid extra for those services, through an opt-in program offered by the city to non-taxpayers outside the city limits?)?

The main problem is that this is highly inefficient. It's also irreversible: what if the fire department made a mistake? Not only would this guy lose his home, but the city could get sued for millions, just imagine the headline on Fox: "Taxpayer watches his house burn as government does NOTHING."

Of course, this would be a lying headline on Fox, since the man was not actually a taxpayer (indeed, nobody outside the city limits is a taxpayer).

The fire department should have put out the flame and then given the guy an "inflated" bill (far above the marginal cost of putting out the fire). If he doesn't pay, then they take possession of the property. Bottom line: it shouldn't pay not to pay.

Seems like not providing fire services to people that haven't paid for them is the simplest and most cost-effective way to achieve that goal. Or do you expect the Brazilian Federal Police to patrol your neighborhood, and then charge you an "inflated" bill for not contracting for their services in advance?
 
Why would the city send any notices at all, to someone outside of their jurisdiction, who didn't pay any city taxes, and wasn't entitled to city services (unless he paid extra for those services, through an opt-in program offered by the city to non-taxpayers outside the city limits?)?

Maybe you're just deef. That's OK. I'm guessing this guy would get a notice to pay for this service.

Of course, this would be a lying headline on Fox, since the man was not actually a taxpayer (indeed, nobody outside the city limits is a taxpayer).

We're all taxpayers, and if he's white, then there's no question.

Seems like not providing fire services to people that haven't paid for them is the simplest and most cost-effective way to achieve that goal.

Having fire-fighters stand around waiting for the flames to spread?

Or do you expect the Brazilian Federal Police to patrol your neighborhood, and then charge you an "inflated" bill for not contracting for their services in advance?

I hope not. Brazil is, like, thousands of miles away. I contract with Mexico.
 
Last edited:
This does not happen in Canada.

Yes it does.

I distinctly remember reading an article about a man watching his home burn to the ground. It was in a rural area (possibly a hamlet) in Alberta that had voted to decline to pay for fire department services from the nearest municipality.

Granted, the fire department didn't come out to watch....
 
Also, Puppycow, I think that what you're thinking about is 'free riding' rather than 'moral hazard'.
Looking up the respective definitions, I think it's a little bit of both.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_rider_problem
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_hazard

The classic problem is people who live in a flood-prone area but don't buy flood insurance. Then if there's a major flood affecting lots of people in that area, the federal government declares it a disaster area and they get bailed out anyway. Even those without flood insurance. So why would you buy flood insurance?

Also, this guy was burning trash I think (that's the impression I got from the video). If he had known he wasn't going to get help from the fire department, he might have been more careful.

If the fire department put out the fire, even at a higher cost, it would kind of make paying the $75 in advance less attractive, since the odds of a house fire are pretty low.
 
Well, we don't know if he was too cheap, or forgot.

Pretty odd way to run a county.

Or he wasn't told.
Read the story, he knew he was suposed to pay but decided he didn't want to.
"I thought they'd come out and put it out, even if you hadn't paid your $75, but I was wrong," said Gene Cranick.

Welcome to Loserville, population: Gene Cranick
 
Read the story, he knew he was suposed to pay but decided he didn't want to.

From the article:

The homeowner, Gene Cranick, said he offered to pay whatever it would take for firefighters to put out the flames, but was told it was too late. They wouldn't do anything to stop his house from burning.

Each year, Obion County residents must pay $75 if they want fire protection from the city of South Fulton. But the Cranicks did not pay.

"I thought they'd come out and put it out, even if you hadn't paid your $75, but I was wrong," said Gene Cranick.

The Cranicks told 9-1-1 they would pay firefighters, whatever the cost, to stop the fire before it spread to their house.
"When I called I told them that. My grandson had already called there and he thought that when I got here I could get something done, I couldn't," Paulette Cranick.

Can you show me where the article says he 'decided he didn't want to'? I didn't see that.

Thanks.
 
I don't like the idea that it's $75 across the board. It should depend on house size, type, distance from the nearest hydrant, and distance from the nearest fire station. My homeowners insurance takes all that into account, so why shouldn't fire service do the same?
 
I don't like the idea that it's $75 across the board. It should depend on house size, type, distance from the nearest hydrant, and distance from the nearest fire station. My homeowners insurance takes all that into account, so why shouldn't fire service do the same?

Because most people don't equate fire and police protection to insurance.

And most fire and police departments do not charge on a per cost basis of an incident.
 
We had a similar case locally some years ago. A small municipality had a "fire stamp" arrangement...Only 50 bucks as I recall. A resident who had not paid up watched his house burn as firefighters stood by...
As one who has been in police work for many years, and who works closely with large fire departments, this seems inconceivable. Still, years ago it used to be fairly common for people to have to pay for police services such as having a burglary report done....
This was little more than graft, however.
I suppose with many small-venue emergency services increasingly strapped for funds we might expect more of this sort of thing.
 
From the article:



Can you show me where the article says he 'decided he didn't want to'? I didn't see that.

Thanks.

He quite clearly states that he thought they would come and put it out anyway - indicating his knowledge of the charge, and his decision not to pay.
 
Or you could just, you know, pay for it out of taxes....

Rolfe.

What an incredibly progressive idea.

May I subscribe to your newsletter :) ?

PS: my parents live in a rural home. There are fire department circumscription, and no circumscription is allowed without a fire dept coverage. The fire department is paid out of the local tax automatically. The system as per article sound definitively ALIEN to me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom