Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

Your own article says $60 billion, but point taken. I guess the best thing to do would be to examine other large, government run health care programs, compare their fraud rates to private insurance fraud rates (it's also worth pointing out that a lot of medicare fraud is committed by private insurers through Medicare Part D), and then compare administration costs.

There's a reason why we pay 2x as much on health care as Europe and Canada and get far worse results.


Good point, TW.

@WildCat.

Got any stats on how much of that 80 er ... 60 billion we would save if we eliminated all the private bureaucracies um ... corporations which spend most of their time and energy trying to dream up ways to turn as much as possible of that same money into their profit margin?

And I'm only talking about the ones who aren't engaged in outright fraud.
 
I saw a good comment on this story by a fire fighter on a FFs' blog. Don't have the exact wording, but it was something like this: "Fire fighters watch as house burns down" makes a much better headline than "County Commission continues to ponder what to do about providing fire fighting services to their citizens as house burns down".

I'm sure no fire fighter wants to stand by and watch a house burn. It's probably painful for them.

But if they provide services that aren't paid for, or if they accept payment on the spot, then others will decide they don't need to pay either.

When that happens, they then start providing more services and receive less revenue, and we know what happens to fire stations when that happens -- they have their manpower or hours cut, or the station is closed.

Then the next time there's a fire, there's no one to respond in time, even if you had paid your taxes.

There was a tragic story earlier this year. A boy was choking, the parents took him to the nearby fire station, but it had been closed. The kid died.

It ain't always so easy as doing what seems right at the moment.
 
I can see the firemen's point. If they were required to save any house, then the owner could make up the missed fees retrospectively, or even pay an inflated fee retrospectively, where's the incentive for anyone to pay their premiums? Most people don't have house fires. Most people might be inclined just to take the risk, knowing that all they risked was perhaps an increased financial penalty - IF their house actually did catch fire. Funding for the fire service just evaporated.

It's the system that's f-ed up, not the response to it. The system mandates that response.

Rolfe.

Exactly the problem is that the county has not done some thing to insure that there is fire fighting coverage over the whole county. Blame the county not the city fire fighters who were really out of their area.

As for multiple departments at one fire, that is called mutual aid, and the idea is that my towns fire department and your towns fire department have an agreement that if there is a bad fire we will help the other one out. But see the important part here, both towns have a fire department. A town could not get that to work by forgoing the cost of a fire department and solely calling in the fire department of a different town.
 
Hey I think that the uptake in paying for fire coverage in that county will go up now, don't you?
 
What, paying for fire services out of tax? Most other places seem to manage it.

But not at the level mentioned. Do you have a national firefighters service or are they local municipalities?

The problem here is that he did not live in a municipality, and was in a county that had now county fire department. So he chose to live in an area with out fire fighter coverage paid for in taxes. Then he chose to forgo purchasing the coverage himself.
 
Would he get insurance money?

If I were the insurer, I'd serious consider denying payment, on the grounds that he started the fire and carelessly let it spread to the home, and that he failed to take the precaution of paying for protection from the fire department.

Sounds like gross negligence to me.
 
Bull roar. Every County I know of has a Sheriff, with several deputies. They are the county police department.
Out West we have a tradition: When there's a fire, you put it out. worry about the charges later.
It is not unusual to see 3 different fire departments respond to a fire out here--and I have lived in some SMALL towns (<10000, up to 50000 people, 20 to 90 miles from any other town...)

The towns likely have contracts and agreements with each other to do that. How tied into the local fire departments are you to know the details of such things?
 
Thank god you're here, Broken Window Fallacy Man!

If it was taxes, they'd get mandatory payments from everyone, which is more money. This way, they not only get less money, but drum up some of the worst possible press imaginable.

How is the city supposed to tax people who are not residents of it?

Seems like a lot of the people in the county thought just like this. I wonder if they county will add contracts to provide fire fighting coverage to all residents.
 
Why go out at all?

Because most States in the US have "Good Samaritan" laws - and Firefighters are included. Once the Firefighters arrived and verified that no one's life/limb were in danger, they no longer were obligated to take action. As soon as the fire spread to the house, whose owner had paid his "optional-County-fire protection-tax", the Firefighters again performed their duties.

Don't have to agree with it, but it does make sense in the way that a few other (more eloquent) posters have explained.
 
Three dogs and a cat were killed in the fire. The South Fulton fire chief was assaulted by one of Cranick's relatives yesterday.

Interesting presentation from 2008 below. The county in question is actually served by eight municipal fire departments. Three of them charge a subscription, five of them don't. One of the subscription departments will "maybe" respond to a non-subscriber. They all seem to charge a $500 fee per incident to the property owner, with a 50% collection rate.

Obion County Fire Department Presentation Presented to the County Commission

The county screwed up here. They had the opportunity to fix this, and they didn't. The South Fulton fire department is still a bunch of ********, though. Yeah, yeah, yeah, nobody will pay if they respond. Not everyone is a member of Homo economicus. Have a spaghetti dinner. Have a pancake breakfast. Suck it up. It's a dumb policy that gets houses burnt down, pets killed, and fire chiefs socked in the mouth.

PS, I want my two dollars.
 
Three dogs and a cat were killed in the fire. The South Fulton fire chief was assaulted by one of Cranick's relatives yesterday.

Interesting presentation from 2008 below. The county in question is actually served by eight municipal fire departments. Three of them charge a subscription, five of them don't. One of the subscription departments will "maybe" respond to a non-subscriber. They all seem to charge a $500 fee per incident to the property owner, with a 50% collection rate.

Obion County Fire Department Presentation Presented to the County Commission

The county screwed up here. They had the opportunity to fix this, and they didn't. The South Fulton fire department is still a bunch of ********, though. Yeah, yeah, yeah, nobody will pay if they respond. Not everyone is a member of Homo economicus. Have a spaghetti dinner. Have a pancake breakfast. Suck it up. It's a dumb policy that gets houses burnt down, pets killed, and fire chiefs socked in the mouth.

PS, I want my two dollars.

Appeal to emotion noted.

Interesting that in an instance where the victim truly deserves the blame (he neglected to pay his fire protection fee, same as if the water is turned off for someone who refuses to pay their water bill, or electric, etc), people insist on attacking the Firefighters who were merely adhering to their RoE.

If the family truly cared about the house and their pets, should not they have paid the $75/yr fee? A mere pittance in retrospect.
 
I can see the firemen's point. If they were required to save any house, then the owner could make up the missed fees retrospectively, or even pay an inflated fee retrospectively, where's the incentive for anyone to pay their premiums? Most people don't have house fires. Most people might be inclined just to take the risk, knowing that all they risked was perhaps an increased financial penalty - IF their house actually did catch fire. Funding for the fire service just evaporated.

It's the system that's f-ed up, not the response to it. The system mandates that response.
Make it work like insurance.

You can pay the annual premium ($75) or you can pay the full cost of calling out a fire crew ($thousands). If you haven't paid the premium, the fire department can sue you to recover costs. If you didn't want them to save your house and they did, well, they get the house; everyone's happy.

What you don't do is stand around while the house burns down. That's idiocy at every level.
 
Appeal to emotion noted.
Can you read back from the minutes?

Interesting that in an instance where the victim truly deserves the blame (he neglected to pay his fire protection fee, same as if the water is turned off for someone who refuses to pay their water bill, or electric, etc), people insist on attacking the Firefighters who were merely adhering to their RoE.
It's not at all like people refusing to pay for metered services--people suck at managing diffuse risk. The risk of having your water turned off approaches 100% in short order. Of the Americans without health insurance, how many are/were in a position to buy it, but chose not to? They're idiots, sure, whatever. Where you have predictable idiocy, you have a social liability.

And yes, I insist on attacking those firefighters. They're cowards. I've never heard of rules of engagement in a firefighting context, so I don't really know what it means. I would think that rules related to the safety of firefighters (OORAH!) or the people they're trying to help are manifestly separable from administrative rules. "Son, don't you pick up that hose! We have a fiduciary responsibility!"

If the family truly cared about the house and their pets, should not they have paid the $75/yr fee? A mere pittance in retrospect.
Yes, they should have. Also, the firefighters should have put out the fire irrespective of whether they did. Also, the county should raise property taxes by 0.13 cents to moot this issue. I guess it takes a national embarrassment....
 
So I pay my taxes, some of which support the County Fire Department. A few weeks ago my son broke his arm, and on the way to the hospital, my wife stopped at the fire station to ask if they could stabilize it so my 12 year-old didn't have to spend a twenty-minute car ride being traumatized by holding his brother's flopping mess of an arm.
The firemen put a cardboard splint on it, and filled out a bit of paperwork. It took less than 5 minutes.
A week later we recieved a bill for $115.
The station is manned 24/7, so there was no additional labor costs, those firemen were getting paid. I was a little pissed that I payed $115 for a bit of cardboard, but I figure that it's a case of the money at least going to an undeniably useful orginization.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom