Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

Because most people don't equate fire and police protection to insurance.

And most fire and police departments do not charge on a per cost basis of an incident.

Silly arguments. Fire service through taxes is already done in that way to some extent. I don't pay a flat fee for fire and rescue service, I pay $6.73 per 100 sq ft under roof.
 
I find the whole story very disturbing. It was someone's HOME! Part of them, place they were spending most of their time!

There's difference between public goods and market goods, and this is the most egregious example of messing the two I have ever seen. There's a moral reason you should pay, of course, but there's also a more moral reason you don't cut out free riders when they so desperately need the good/service.
Public goods (and services) are not supposed to be produced for profit, and fire-fighting and police services are the main example of those. That's also the main reason they are usually state produced and financed from taxes.

In my opinion, they should have put out the bloody fire first THEN charged him the cost of intervention and all those years of not paying. That would have been moral, profession conscious way of doing things. I have a nagging suspicion, since it was a small county and all, that there was probably some personal grudge involved in that case, maybe Cranick bragged at firemen that they don't do anything so why he should pay or something...
 
I find the whole story very disturbing. It was someone's HOME! Part of them, place they were spending most of their time!

There's difference between public goods and market goods, and this is the most egregious example of messing the two I have ever seen. There's a moral reason you should pay, of course, but there's also a more moral reason you don't cut out free riders when they so desperately need the good/service.
Public goods (and services) are not supposed to be produced for profit, and fire-fighting and police services are the main example of those. That's also the main reason they are usually state produced and financed from taxes.

In my opinion, they should have put out the bloody fire first THEN charged him the cost of intervention and all those years of not paying. That would have been moral, profession conscious way of doing things. I have a nagging suspicion, since it was a small county and all, that there was probably some personal grudge involved in that case, maybe Cranick bragged at firemen that they don't do anything so why he should pay or something...

I agree with the moral bent of your argument, but in fact I think that this highlights that many 'public' goods in fact have the properties of a 'private' good; in particular, rivalrous consumption and excludability. Meaning basically that one person's increased use of the good decreases the ability of another person to use that good, and that people who have not paid for the good can be excluded from its enjoyment.

Clean air is a perfect public good.



oh wow someone's taken introductory micro
 
Last edited:
Or you could just, you know, pay for it out of taxes...

Socialist.

Seriously though, there's a part of me that is outraged and a part of me that sees the logic. The two together agree that it's best to just avoid this whole situation and pay through taxes. I know this county doesn't have a fire department but surely you could arrange something?
 
Yes it does.

I distinctly remember reading an article about a man watching his home burn to the ground. It was in a rural area (possibly a hamlet) in Alberta that had voted to decline to pay for fire department services from the nearest municipality.

Granted, the fire department didn't come out to watch....

Hmmm I never heard of that before ... I wonder if it's the same in Ontario?

I've never heard of that happening, here in Ontario trucks from several municipalities often show up to fight a fire ...

But perhaps it's more complicated than i think and there is some kind of official reciprocal agreement set up?
 
This, to me, highlights why the FMOTL is such utter nonsense. Here is a clear case, where somebody did not want to pay the fees (which in this case were voluntary) and thus 'did not contract' witht he city. Yet he still acted surprised when they would not provide the service.

The only reasont he fire department did show up, is that his neighbor did pay his fees, so they honored the contract with him and prevented the fire from spreading and burning down the neighbor's house.

On another note, I think the way this area handled not having thier own fire department is appalling and a complete failure on their part. This story also is a great example of why fire services should not be optional.

I know that many parts of Los Angeles county (CA) had a similar situation regarding Police serve, but handled it properly. It would have been too expensive for many of the smaller cities to maintain their own police department, but rather than making it optional, the cities would, as a whole, contract with LAPD to service their cities as well. The smaller city would tax their residents and then pay the larger city a contract price to proved the services to the whole city.

This to me seems like a better solution than this voluntary fee for FD service that was set up.
 
Last edited:
It's a sad thing. I wonder if he actually had the money to pay whatever it cost to have them put out the fire? If so, $75 seems a very small sum indeed.
 
Silly arguments. Fire service through taxes is already done in that way to some extent. I don't pay a flat fee for fire and rescue service, I pay $6.73 per 100 sq ft under roof.

Yes, you pay property taxes based on the value of your house, not on how much it might cost the firefighters or police to help you. And the municipality allocates the funds for fire, police, and other services. And everyone is generally fully covered for fire and police services, regardless of how much they paid into the system.

On another note, I think the way this area handled not having thier own fire department is appalling and a complete failure on their part. This story also is a great example of why fire services should not be optional.

I know that many parts of Los Angeles county (CA) had a similar situation regarding Police serve, but handled it properly. It would have been too expensive for many of the smaller cities to maintain their own police department, but rather than making it optional, the cities would, as a whole, contract with LAPD to service their cities as well. The smaller city would tax their residents and then pay the larger city a contract price to proved the services to the whole city.

This to me seems like a better solution than this voluntary fee for FD service that was set up.

I agree. The county in this case could have easily added the $75 to some form of taxation.
 
Last edited:
I heard on the radio this morning that he lost some pets in the fire, a cat and a couple dogs I think died.

I see this as likely some kind of administrative problem or dispute between Obion County and city of South Fulton. Maybe the citizens of unincorporated Obion voted on this arrangement? Typically my understanding is that fire districts will offer their services to unincorporated areas and then the governing body (county) will pass that on through taxes to their residents. That is if they don't provide the infrastructure for fire services themselves.

This sounds like a case of immature government to me to bill residents directly. What if there was a wild fire on county land? How would the fire department know when to "jump in" if a fire starts on someone's property that may spread to other payer's homes?

I don't know for sure but it does seem kind of cruel from my interpretation of events for the firefighters to be at the location with the ability to help and did not. If they were so concerned about the money maybe they could have billed Gene for their services after the fact.

-Maus
 
Returning from Tonopah Nv on a back road that would take us over the White Mountains, we stopped at a partially burnt restaurant, still somewhat warm, which was next door to the local fire department.
No one had the key to the door to the fire department!
Couldn't get the fire truck out.
Fire was stopped by other means. :)
The OP sounds like there's a reason to prosecute for extortion/protection racket.
 
From the article:



Can you show me where the article says he 'decided he didn't want to'? I didn't see that.

Thanks.
Well, I think most of us are reading ""I thought they'd come out and put it out, even if you hadn't paid your $75, but I was wrong," said Gene Cranick." as meaning that, though of course it is not ironclad.
 
Well, I think most of us are reading ""I thought they'd come out and put it out, even if you hadn't paid your $75, but I was wrong," said Gene Cranick." as meaning that, though of course it is not ironclad.

Yes, Roger, and that was my point. He was interviewed right after the event, while the embers were still glowing.

Late that night, he claimed he had forgotten to pay the fee. I don't know if he was telling the truth or not. I doubt we will ever know.

(btw- I love your avatar) :)
 
Yes, you pay property taxes based on the value of your house, not on how much it might cost the firefighters or police to help you.

No, I pay for fire services roughly based on how much it might cost the firefighters to help me. It is based directly on square footage, not home value.
 
If I am not mistaken, a lot of volunteer fire departments work on this principle. Funding is a major issue in these cases. When I was a kid, most of the small towns in the rural areas near me had "fireman days," picnics, carnivals, street dances, or whatever to raise money. The street dances were the best because back then the firemen weren’t too picky about carding someone with cash for a beer.
 
I remember hearing about something like this many years ago. I don't remember the state, but in separate incidents over many months several houses were allowed to burn down. As a result the state legislature passed a law required fire services to be provided with the cost being passed being passed back to the individual who had refused/failed to pay.
 
He quite clearly states that he thought they would come and put it out anyway - indicating his knowledge of the charge, and his decision not to pay.

And here we have a great example of why the fotl crowd is wrong, again.

As evidenced here it is all fine and dandy to say " i am not going to pay, and i don't expect to get this service." but when the crap hits the fan, or in this case, when the fire hits the livingroom, it is an entirely different story.

I think the fire dept did the right thing here. There is probably a tiny list of people who refuse to pay for this service and easily researched, only a total moron or total freeloader ( i would stick this particular person in the freeloader catagory) would choose not to pay this fee. And only a total a-hole would actually have the stones to say " i didn't know they wouldn't come if i didn't pay the fee. ". Even giving this guy the benefit of the doubt and saying he had no clue why this fee was around, he still should have called somewhere and asked " excuse me, what is this fee for?"

And this is what would happen in freeman land, endless complaining and playing on the sympathies of people everytime their no paying fees ways bit them in the ass.

Don't pay the fee, don't get the service. Seems like a fairly simple concept to my.
 
Well, I think most of us are reading ""I thought they'd come out and put it out, even if you hadn't paid your $75, but I was wrong," said Gene Cranick." as meaning that, though of course it is not ironclad.
.
We have that notice on the upper right hand corner of our envelopes to tell us to put a stamp there, the post office won't deliver otherwise... created by those who knew the P.O. would process unstamped mail and charge the recipient the postage.
The P.O. don't do that no more.
 
I agree with the moral bent of your argument, but in fact I think that this highlights that many 'public' goods in fact have the properties of a 'private' good; in particular, rivalrous consumption and excludability. Meaning basically that one person's increased use of the good decreases the ability of another person to use that good, and that people who have not paid for the good can be excluded from its enjoyment.

Clean air is a perfect public good.



oh wow someone's taken introductory micro


That's more of a mixed good then, example being one fire-station and two fires. But there weren't two fires in this case (says someone who has bachelor's degree in Economy and is learning for master) so it doesn't apply. Better example of public good would be public lights, since there is no excludability and rivalrous consumption. There are also "meritor" goods, in which case government is forcing you to use public good for your own good by fining you if you don't (such as seat belts for your own safety). But that is not the point in this case...

There might not have been any legal obligation on firemen's side. Legally speaking, they might not have done anything wrong. Morally speaking... not so much. I don't know how much this simile matches, but it would be the same as if doctor found a man having cardiac arrest and waited to be paid to save him. Doctors have trained and paid for/to gain skills to save lives. Firemen have trained to gain skills to douse fires, save lives AND property.

The guy was an a** not to pay (or maybe he forgot). That doesn't mean you have to be an ar*e and not do your erfin' job! He should have to pay for his moral choice (which means extra money after they do their job) and firemen should have to pay for theirs (choosing not to do their jobs, even if on the spot).

At least I hope that is the case...
 
Last edited:
And here we have a great example of why the fotl crowd is wrong, again.

As evidenced here it is all fine and dandy to say " i am not going to pay, and i don't expect to get this service." but when the crap hits the fan, or in this case, when the fire hits the livingroom, it is an entirely different story.

I think the fire dept did the right thing here. There is probably a tiny list of people who refuse to pay for this service and easily researched, only a total moron or total freeloader ( i would stick this particular person in the freeloader catagory) would choose not to pay this fee. And only a total a-hole would actually have the stones to say " i didn't know they wouldn't come if i didn't pay the fee. ". Even giving this guy the benefit of the doubt and saying he had no clue why this fee was around, he still should have called somewhere and asked " excuse me, what is this fee for?"

And this is what would happen in freeman land, endless complaining and playing on the sympathies of people everytime their no paying fees ways bit them in the ass.

Don't pay the fee, don't get the service. Seems like a fairly simple concept to my.

Yes, except in this case firemen actually were on the spot. Imagine this situation:

You are getting mugged on the street. There's a policeman nearby and sees it happening. He judges with his expert's eye that your life is not in danger. He has ultra modern mobile phone and approaches you with a question: "Excuse me, sir/ma'am, what is your name? I must check if you paid your taxes, you know."

*types in his phone, connects to server, checks database...*

"Sorry, can't help you. Says here you owe 1200$ in taxes. Unless..." turns to mugger. "Your name and social security number, sir. I must check if you paid your taxes."

*types in his phone, connects to server, checks database...*

"It says here you are due tax return of 45$, sir. Please carry on whatever you are doing." says policeman, then goes away.


That's similar to moral choice firemen had in OP... As I wrote before, they are firemen. It's their job to protect both lives and property.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom