Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

Nobody got hurt.

You want these guys to put themselves at risk for property.

Their wives and daughters might have a different opinion on the matter.
[OT] Don't forget the husbands and sons. I serve with two women. [/OT]
 
You mean no one has attempted to defend such behavior by claiming that it was unreasonable and impractical to expect money to be collected after the incident? That the "deadbeats" would just refuse to pay, and there would be no avenue to enforce collection?

And that is why the South Fulton Fire Dept. was justified in doing nothing when they were already there?

Weird. Must have been some other thread.

Originally Posted by qayak
You thought wrong. The main objection is that the Cranicks didn't pay the fee and so by policy the fire department won't fight fires on their property.

That pretty much covers it.
That should help you out with comprehension.


I comprehend that you are more interested in nitpicking and semantics than acknowledging the rationalizations attempted to support your "main objection". Or defending them.

Nice dodge. Take up dancing.
 
It's obvious why I brough up segregation. I refuse to accept that you're not smart enough to understand, so I can only assume you're just doubling down on contrarianism.

Yeah, so obvious it doesn't mnake any sense and you can't explain it.

Thanks for trying out.

Haha, what?

Nicely dodged . . . well, except for the fact that it's completely obvious you were dodging the point.


Where do I look to find the part where firemen are bound by natural processes to keep their hoses off? Is it the weak force? The strong? Electromagnetism?

I understand your anger at having your argument completely destroyed but acting stupid isn't likely to help.

The process is simple and quite natural.

1) If you pay your fee, the fire department will fight fires on your property. If you don't pay your fee, they won't.

2) Owner doesn't pay fee.

3) Fire fighters don't fight the fire on his property.

4) House burns down.

A pretty basic and natural process based on pre-existing conditions, choices by the participants and, an outcome.

I understand you like to complain about number 3 but it is fruitless. You need to change number 1 in order to have any effect. So, stop complaining and start campaigning the voters of Obion County to do something in their own interest. Others haven't been able to but you have better results with your superior understanding of the meanings of words and all.

I too think these people should have fire protection but it isn't the fire department's fault they don't.
 
You really don't grasp that there are issues here besides just "fire bad", do you?

What? Why don't you just make an argument? These coy little games are obnoxious.

Given that no one on this thread has offered a remotely cogent discussion of the legal issues involved, it's a funny thing indeed when you suddenly become sanctimonious about things you refuse to explain.

I have no idea what you're talking about. In this particular instance, that's your fault.
 
Last edited:
I reckon you have to say it exactly one fewer times than we have to say that it may not, in fact, cost a firefighter nothing to engage a blaze, and that there are longer-term costs to be considered.

We can play this game forever.
To be fair, the FD was already on scene. The majority cost is already committed, so it costs them as much to put out the one guy's fire as it does to protect the other guy's property. They aren't going to leave the scene until the primary fire is out anyway.
 
I comprehend that you are more interested in nitpicking and semantics than acknowledging the rationalizations attempted to support your "main objection". Or defending them.

Nice dodge. Take up dancing.

That has always been the main objection. The rest is just explanation of why the main objection is what it is.

Thanks for coming out but complete fail on your part.
 
Sure they did, in the sense of 'harm'.


Yes. That's kind of what fire departments do (among other things).

However, I think the chances of injury when spraying down a double-wide are pretty remote. We're not talking about rushing into a burning building to save people here.
While direct injuries may be slight, there are all sorts of injuries that happen on a fire scene. ANY fire scene is a risky proposition. While we all train to be safe, **** still happens. What if the guy is storing the propane for his grill in his trailer? He's got natural gas or an LP connection for his stove? One of the first lessons you learn when getting into this job is that people do weird things and no two scenes are ever the same.
 
How is he paying off his debt? It doesn't seem that way to me. He's now living in his 1 year old camper according to news stories... apparently a camper (those things are very expensive) took priority over his payments to the fire department.

<snip>


I don't know. You'll have to ask BobTheDonkey, who brought the subject up in this post, the one I quoted.

My post, the one you quoted, pointed out that BTD seemed to be confusing two different (albeit related) Mr. Cranicks. You seem to be doing the same thing.

Perhaps you should re-read them both, with greater attention to detail.

A statement I cited earlier in this thread had our Mr. Gene Cranick's wife quoted as saying that her son, also by odd coincidence a Cranick, involved in a call some years earlier at another location. He also was deliquent on his subscription. They didn't stand around and watch his house burn down, though, and apparently (according to BTD) he is still making payment for the service.

Damned deadbeat.
 
No problem. Your response is "that's what fire departments do". Which is pure idealism.
It's a problem for your accusations of idealism that this pie-in-the-sky, unrealistically idealistic solution is exactly what happens in 6 of the other 7 municipalities in this county. Particularly given that all of them save one have a significantly smaller tax base.

If people are currently making it work, it's not idealistic. It's practical.

Sure, it's true that fire dept's do put themselves at risk for property.
Right.

But not without some measure of reciprocation, some measure of compensation and appreciation on the part of the people they're risking their safety for.

Isn't that enough for you? Good God, man, what else do you demand from these flesh and blood people to satisfy your armchair idealism?
You have firefighters in this thread telling you that this isn't true. There's long letter at firehouse.com telling you this isn't true. A relevant excerpt:

I have walked the streets of Freehold and Freehold Township seeking funds from a series of generally-unconcerned citizens. They had never called for an ambulance, so why should they give us any money. Heck I remember the time down on Center Street in Freehold when just 15 minutes after knocking on the door of a house and getting no answer, our ambulance was called to that house and we ended up transporting a pregnant lady to the hospital 30 minutes distant. She was never asked to pay and we never asked why they failed to answer our knock at the door. Nothing was said and we did not even get a thank you.

That is just the way it is with real volunteers my friends. I am not complaining, I am just telling the story like it really is. Let me also assure you that I would get up from my computer right now, should my services be needed up the street at the fire station.
I think that's a typical attitude.

If these ideals exist in the field (and they do, overwhelmingly), then you can't describe my disgust at the firefighters' failure to act as 'armchair idealism'.

The problem, instead, is your armchair cynicism.

You want them to go out and expend city resources -- that other folks have paid for -- and risk injury to themselves to protect people who choose not to pay them one single penny, people who simply assume that others will take on the risk when they have been negligent, and for what? For what? To perpetuate the illusion that protection is without cost?
For what? To prevent people's houses from burning down as the fire department stands idly by. Despite multiple attempts to do so in this thread, people can't ignore that this is kind of a major negative externality of the policy. It's insanely disproportionate, wildly inefficient as a means of enforcing subscriptions, etc., etc.

Whatever moral hazard this presents is an unintended consequence. Do you really think anyone wants that? It's unfortunate, but it's manageable.

Better to disabuse people of that notion sooner rather than later.
Execute every tenth soldier in an unfit regiment. Better to disabuse them of the notion that we'll let them get away with incompetence than put the whole army at risk.

They have means at their disposal that are not nearly as egregious as standing idly by as a house burns to resolve whatever problems are represented here. Including, but not limited to, tolerating a few free riders.

You've got that backwards, my friend.

Firefighters put themselves at risk because there is a system in place.
I'm saying that both things are simultaneously true. They couldn't have a fire department with equipment, and they couldn't have a fire department without volunteers. It's mutually dependent relationship.

It's a system that compensates them for their bravery, and for the sacrifice of their time and effort.
No, it doesn't. They're all volunteers.

Hey, I tell you what, let's apply your reasoning to the military, and law enforcement.

Let's have our armed services and our sheriffs and deputies and cops and detectives work for free, and then hand out bills to people whose bacon they save.

Let's burden them with that, turn them into collections departments, have them battle to claim the compensation for their efforts after the fact.
What's the relevance? Something like 70% of firefighters in this country are volunteers. Cops get salaries. They also won't let you get mugged if you haven't paid your taxes. The military do their job of defending our borders in Iraq even if I wish they wouldn't.

And hey, if they get injured or killed, their families can just cool their heels while the litigation works its way through the courts and they try to extract compensation from people who were not inclined to pay in the first place.
Why do you think they'd have standing to sue a non-subscriber? What, exactly, would they be suing him for?

I would guess the fire department has insurance. If they don't, they're in the same boat inside of town or out. You're just restating what we already know: the town foots most of the bill for the fire department.

That ought to work out just fine and dandy.
Yes, it does.
 
That has always been the main objection. The rest is just explanation of why the main objection is what it is.

Thanks for coming out but complete fail on your part.


I understand now. You have an Objection, which you'll defend to your dying breath regardless of any facts or logic which may seem inconvenient to you.

The reasons you have for your Objection, OTOH, are completely irrelevant to your position, and you have no interest in silly tangents into the ways that why you object may be mistaken.

Got it.

I have to admit that my failure to grasp how completely irrational your attitude is was a barrier to me. I'll try to do better. In the future I will just accept as a given that your opinions are irrational, whether they may be or not. That will save me the bother of wasting time on them.
 
A statement I cited earlier in this thread had our Mr. Gene Cranick's wife quoted as saying that her son, also by odd coincidence a Cranick, involved in a call some years earlier at another location. He also was deliquent on his subscription. They didn't stand around and watch his house burn down, though, and apparently (according to BTD) he is still making payment for the service.

And there is exactly the problem the SFFD is having. They put out a fire for a non-subscriber several years ago and still have not been fully reimbursed for it. I doubt that this is an isolated case.

Enough of these accrue and the FD has a major funding shortfall. Contuniung to provide service for non-payers accellerates the problem and soon the FD cannot provide service for paying subscribers either.

Eventually the Fire Chief addresses this in the only way left to him, to refuse service to non-payers. If the residents of Obion County want to avoid this in the future, they need to support the FD through taxes. As long as they continue with a subscription plan, non-payers are going to be left without fire service with the same consequences as Mr. Cranick.
 
So we are back to Yonkers canceling their fire department and just calling in FDNY when ever they need to. After all that will not cost you anything by your own logic.
You are failing to grasp a simple point, forgetting relevant facts from post to post.

Yonkers is large. It has many buildings and citizens! There is congestion! The NYPD would have to buy additional equipment, build new stations, and hire more firefighters to even minimally serve the city as a whole, incurring significant costs they would not otherwise incur, which would have to be passed on to taxpayers.

The rural area served by the SFFD is small. It has few buildings and citizens! I would be surprised if they even had one traffic light. The SFFD can serve it without incurring major new costs (buying new trucks, for example). They won't serve it if doing so causes them to choose between compromising service to the town and buying big ticket hardware (like, say, firetruck).

This is a story that plays out in many small towns all across America!

If, for some bizarre reason, Yonkers had managed to grow to a mid-sized city without ever founding a fire department, I'd be fine with the departments in North Bronx serving Yonkers to the extent that they can without incurring major new costs that they would not otherwise have incurred.

But, of course, Yonkers would have long since burned to the ground if they hadn't.
 
Last edited:
To clarify, how exactly are you going to carry that out?
Difficult to say without relevant training, I suppose. At the very least, I'd walk just as soon as I could be safely relieved. I'd give the chief the dirtiest look I could muster. And, yeah, I think I'd probably turn on a hose. I appreciate that disobeying the chief is to be discouraged, but there are certain things I wouldn't be able to live with, so I suppose it's just a matter of when I reach a breaking point. Maybe I'd have this impulse trained out of me. Maybe that makes me a poor candidate to begin with. I'm ok with that?

And this isn't just internet bravado: I am actively not volunteering for the SFFD as we speak.

While direct injuries may be slight, there are all sorts of injuries that happen on a fire scene. ANY fire scene is a risky proposition. While we all train to be safe, **** still happens. What if the guy is storing the propane for his grill in his trailer? He's got natural gas or an LP connection for his stove? One of the first lessons you learn when getting into this job is that people do weird things and no two scenes are ever the same.
No doubt. But they were already at the scene. They were already taking that risk. They were, apparently, at the scene for quite some time as the trailer burned down, potentially magnifying that risk. I assume they were standing by in case one of those unknown unknowns cropped up.

What's the additional risk incurred by turning on a hose and pointing it at the trailer? I'm guessing it's small enough to discount for the purposes of the general principle that we help where we can.
 
Last edited:
On the risks of suing the homeowner for refusal of payment...

Ummm... first of all, if you look at my original post, you'll see that I've already addressed the issue of private lawyers when I pointed out that municipal lawyers are probably still highly paid.
[...]
Of course, you're also assuming that the case would be handled by regular salaried lawyers. Here in Ottawa the city still occasionally hires outside law firms despite having its own legal department. (Probably wouldn't happen in that case, but it can't be totally discounted.)

Those attorneys will be paid the same amount whether that case is litigated or not, thus the cost to the municipality is zero.

I see... So, do you think the municipality keeps a team of lawyers in suspended animation, waiting to thaw them out when there's work to be done?

I rather suspect that any municipal lawyers probably have other things to do for the taxpayers of the city. And any time spent trying to go to court to get this guy to pay will detract from the time they can spend actually, you know, serving the people who pay their salaries.

And again, that's assuming that the city actually has available legal staff to handle the problem. Like I said, here in Ottawa we have a legal department but still hire outside lawyers for certain situations.

It might be a cost to the attorneys, working more hours for the same amount of pay, but the taxpayers won't suffer.
Ah, NOW I get it... instead of making the guy take responsibility for his dumb-ass actions, you're going to heap more work on the city lawyers, possibly making them work unpaid overtime and having their own lives worse. Nice.

The case, were it argued, is no different (and probably simpler) than endless DUIs, batteries, MIPs, Speeding Tickets, and other nonsense that gets dealt with on a regular basis. It's also highly unlikely that any attorney would actually take this guy's case as the amount it would cost to hire a lawyer would be greater than the amount in controversy.
Never claimed that he would hire a lawyer, nor would he likely put up a successful defense. (Although in the days of McDonald's hot coffee lawsuits, you never know...) But even launching the initial lawsuit costs the city money (or, more likely, diverts city resources away from actually providing real service.) And he can still get out of whatever costs by simply declaring bankruptcy.

I can see 2 reasons to administer a fine:
1) as a form of deterrence
2) to pay for actual physical damages (e.g. salaries, public property, etc.)
You seem to be suggesting the fines would be extremely low (since you are suggesting the total would be under $500). This does very little for either of those purposes.
No, I'm suggesting that being delinquent on a $75 fee is not sufficient cause to allow someone's house to burn down. As incentive to get people to pay ahead of time, a fine attached to after-the-fact firefighting would be adequate. If it goes to court, the minor court costs and administrative fees should be added on.
You know, I don't think you quite understand the concept of an "incentive".

Time and time again, you keep tossing around the "$75 fee", and pointing out relatively low values for possible fines... Yet I don't think I've ever seen you explain:

Why would anyone bother paying any subscription fee if they can get the same service by just paying a small fine after the fact?

The highest amount you've suggested is $500. That works out to less than 10 years of subscription fees. Since I doubt this guy has more than 1 fire a decade, he'd be better off financially to avoid the subscription fees.

After doing some research, there are federal laws allowing an exemption of roughly $20,000 on a principal residence, plus and additional ~$10,000 on furniture and other possessions. And I did find other states that higher exemptions. (Oklahoma for one.) So, its certainly not unreasonable to assume the individual who has his house saved can still live in his place even after declaring bankruptcy.
Oh crap, that means if they had controlled the fire, there is an insanely remote chance that this guy could declare bankruptcy and avoid paying a $200 ticket.
Ummm...first of all, you're suggesting the ticket is $200... yet you want to claim that that's some sort of incentive to get others to pay? And what happened to the $500 value you tossed around earlier?

Secondly, why exactly are you assuming that the fire-fighting fine is the only cost he'd have? Even if the fire was extinguished he'd still probably have smoke/water damage to fix. Then there is any insurance deductible (mine is around $1000 on my house). Not to mention the fact that he may have other debts. Given the fact that the guy ignored repeated mailings/phone calls to get him to pay the subscription service, he may not necessarily be the most fiscally prudent individual.

Did you know that while medical bills are often cited as the most common cause of bankruptcy, many of those bills are actually under $1000? So the concept of someone declaring bankruptcy because of extra debt caused by fire is not that outrageous.

Now, I admit, there is no proof that that is what he would do. However, I haven't seen anything to suggest that the city is guaranteed to receive any payment after the fact.

If you're trying to figure out a way to salvage this retarded system, then yes, you're going to have problems.
Never claimed that the system wasn't retarded. But the blame goes on the voters in the country who decided not to have universal fire coverage. The city (and the fire department) were just doing the best they could.
 
And there is exactly the problem the SFFD is having. They put out a fire for a non-subscriber several years ago and still have not been fully reimbursed for it. I doubt that this is an isolated case.

Enough of these accrue and the FD has a major funding shortfall. Contuniung to provide service for non-payers accellerates the problem and soon the FD cannot provide service for paying subscribers either.


So now we move from wastrel deadbeats who don't pay at all being the justification to not-so-wastrel not-so-deadbeats who can't pay fast enough. If you keep pushing those posts far enough we'll get to anyone who doesn't buy their own personal, single-use fire department in advance.

Maybe there's a time to stop pushing.


Eventually the Fire Chief addresses this in the only way left to him, to refuse service to non-payers. If the residents of Obion County want to avoid this in the future, they need to support the FD through taxes. As long as they continue with a subscription plan, non-payers are going to be left without fire service with the same consequences as Mr. Cranick.


Some of them, at any rate. It appears to depend on the mood the town is in at any given time.

Why are there so many other Fire Chiefs, even in the same state, who acknowledge the same conditions but yet, somehow, manage to fund their departments without standing around watching people's homes burn to the ground?

It's all well and good to hypothesize scenarios of free market inevitability and stand adamantly behind ideological theory, but the facts are in.

Other people in other places manage to work it out. Even with subscriptions. Even with post-incident collections. There's isn't any question that the system can work without letting people's homes burn down, because we have the examples and statements of professionals who have actually done it, but you persist in pretending that it must not be true.

So there isn't any rational doubt that it can be done differently, and a discussion about this incident which is predicated on the assumption that it can't be is starting off in a fantasy world. There are other reasons behind the "why" of this debacle, and they aren't dependent on market theory. Local politics, certainly. Maybe even local personalities.

If you want to take advantage of the tragedy to spout a bunch of pompous claptrap about economic principles that's fine. Just don't think it fools anyone who isn't predisposed towards the same sort of garbage.
 
I see... So, do you think the municipality keeps a team of lawyers in suspended animation, waiting to thaw them out when there's work to be done?

Are you trying to be funny here or do you really not understand how cities, counties, and states employ lawyers? I honestly can't tell.

You know, I don't think you quite understand the concept of an "incentive".

Time and time again, you keep tossing around the "$75 fee", and pointing out relatively low values for possible fines... Yet I don't think I've ever seen you explain:

Why would anyone bother paying any subscription fee if they can get the same service by just paying a small fine after the fact?

It costs $75 for one year of service. If he had paid $75, they would have put out the fire. You're just trying to run up the numbers to make your tenuous case seem remotely reasonable, it isn't.

If the county holds people responsible for every year they don't pay, then the penalty should include those back payments + the fine. It really isn't complicated.

Ummm...first of all, you're suggesting the ticket is $200... yet you want to claim that that's some sort of incentive to get others to pay? And what happened to the $500 value you tossed around earlier?

What motivates you to pay a speeding ticket? The amount?

Secondly, why exactly are you assuming that the fire-fighting fine is the only cost he'd have? Even if the fire was extinguished he'd still probably have smoke/water damage to fix. Then there is any insurance deductible (mine is around $1000 on my house). Not to mention the fact that he may have other debts. Given the fact that the guy ignored repeated mailings/phone calls to get him to pay the subscription service, he may not necessarily be the most fiscally prudent individual.

So? Still doesn't justify letting his house burn down.

Did you know that while medical bills are often cited as the most common cause of bankruptcy, many of those bills are actually under $1000? So the concept of someone declaring bankruptcy because of extra debt caused by fire is not that outrageous.

Yes, that makes perfect sense. Allow the man's house to burn down in case he'll have to declare bankruptcy over a couple hundred dollar fine. This is definitely sensible.

Now, I admit, there is no proof that that is what he would do. However, I haven't seen anything to suggest that the city is guaranteed to receive any payment after the fact.

This is true every time any jurisdiction anywhere for any reason administers a fine on anyone. Yet somehow they're able to get people to pay their fines.

Never claimed that the system wasn't retarded. But the blame goes on the voters in the country who decided not to have universal fire coverage. The city (and the fire department) were just doing the best they could.

And this man shouldn't be scapegoated for the poor decisions of his community. He should be held responsible for his poor decision, which is quite easy to do in ways that don't involve allowing his house to burn to the ground.
 
Difficult to say without relevant training, I suppose. At the very least, I'd walk just as soon as I could be safely relieved. I'd give the chief the dirtiest look I could muster. And, yeah, I think I'd probably turn on a hose.
And if your actions meant that others in the country decided to cancel their fire subscription service (since the department will respond to fires anyways, why bother) and your department was unable to hire enough staff/buy new equipment and risked the lives and property of others as a result, would you feel good about that?
On the risk of fighting even a small fire
No doubt. But they were already at the scene. They were already taking that risk. They were, apparently, at the scene for quite some time as the trailer burned down, potentially magnifying that risk. I assume they were standing by in case one of those unknown unknowns cropped up.

What's the additional risk incurred by turning on a hose and pointing it at the trailer? I'm guessing it's small enough to discount for the purposes of the general principle that we help where we can.
So, who decides what an acceptable risk is? The trailer was unoccupied. Are the contents of a trailer (owned by a non subscriber) worth a 1% risk of death or injury? .1%? .01%?

Fire fighters do risk their lives to save property (even when they are not 'saving lives'). However, we pay them for accepting that risk. I do not think its a moral problem to say that they must accept any risk to save just property.
 
Why are there so many other Fire Chiefs, even in the same state, who acknowledge the same conditions but yet, somehow, manage to fund their departments without standing around watching people's homes burn to the ground?
I suspect it depends on a number of factors... tax base for the area that actually supports the fire fighters, the geographic area and number of houses in the rural non-supported areas, the quality of the roads, average incomes, etc.

Assuming that because one fire department can handle rural regions without payment does not necessarily mean all such fire departments will have that ability. A major city (>1 million) can probably handle small outlying pockets of near by rural dwellers fairly easily, whereas a small town (<10 thousand) will not be able to provide service to far-flung rural areas unless people living in those areas contribute to help support the firefighters.
 
To be fair, the FD was already on scene. The majority cost is already committed, so it costs them as much to put out the one guy's fire as it does to protect the other guy's property. They aren't going to leave the scene until the primary fire is out anyway.

I was referring to (a) the risk of injury and (b) the potential cost of encouraging a moral hazard which could reduce their revenues.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom