Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

He didn't pay the dues, the consequence for want of $75 is that firemen stood by and watched his house burn. They couldn't put out the fire and just choke on $75 because that would send a bad example to the rest of the county.

What is it called when someone is willfully made to suffer to keep others in line?
"Incentive"
 
I just wanted to toss in a bit of vinegar to cut the uncut glurge in that post.

Just wearing a funny yellow coat and riding a big red truck doesn't make anybody any better than anyone else.
Not all of our coats are yellow, nor are all of our trucks red. I prefer slime lime trucks myself, better visibility and all that. :D
 
Here are some thoughts on the subject from other Tennessee Fire Chiefs.

Fire-fighting personnel across East Tennessee seem almost universally outraged by the actions of a small-town fire company on the other end of the state that responded to a house afire but was ordered to let the structure burn because the owner had not paid a $75 subscription fee.

"We don't particularly care who's paid his dues," said Steve Wheeler, chief of the Vonore, Tenn., Fire Department. "If somebody needs help, we help and worry about everything else later."


Apparently "He deserved what he got." is not a universal theme among professionals.

Not all fire-fighting agencies in East Tennessee sell subscriptions for their services, but some that do are adamant that they would never let a structure burn depending on whether the fee had been paid or not.

Among such agencies is Rural/Metro, which handles fire-fighting duties for Knox County under the direction of Chief Jerry Harnish.

The chief said the South Fulton case is a "major topic of discussion" among those in his profession, and he finds it "kind of hard to relate to. People don't join fire departments to not respond to emergencies."

Wheeler's five paid and 15 volunteer firefighters, he said, are driven by the same sense of wanting to help people that causes most to get involved in such potentially dangerous work.

"It's in your blood," he said. "You love it. It's about helping people."


That has a familiar ring to it.

Wheeler said he does not know how the South Fulton team even knew Cranick was not a subscriber.

"We don't ask," he said, adding that he believes the firefighters who responded were probably anxious to attack the flames despite their orders.
Vonore's subscription is $100 a year.

He said his unit would not "let policies and stuff get in the way," and he related a story he heard from a different location in West Tennessee in which firefighters from one jurisdiction responded to a fire that was on the other side of a street that was the dividing line between their area and another agency's.

They let the fire burn until the second agency could respond but ultimately had to pay for the house following litigation.
So maybe there is some question about legal liability as well? Precedent, even?

Blount County residents who fail to subscribe to fire services for $110 will be presented with a hefty bill after firefighters finish their duties at a house fire.

McClanahan said it amounts to $2,200 for the initial call and $1,100 for every hour past the first two that firefighters are on the scene.

Wheeler said his department has no set fee but does ask the homeowner to assign to the fire department any insurance money designated for compensating the fire department.

Harnish said his department's subscription rate averages about 11 cents per square foot of structure, meaning the owner of a 2,500-square-foot home would pay a fee of about $275.

But Knox County's non-subscription charge leaves the others in ashes.
If no subscription is paid, he said, the standard rate is $1,200 per hour for each unit dispatched to the scene.

"And we never send a single engine to a fire," he said. "We send four engines and a ladder truck," meaning the homeowner is charged the hourly fee for each truck.

Knowing that, he said, most people realize it is "more reasonable" to pay the subscription fee.


If post-incident billing is so utterly unworkable and impractical, then why are so many other fire departments in the same state choosing to allow just that, as an alternative to standing around watching a home burn down?
 
Last edited:
You thought wrong. The main objection is that the Cranicks didn't pay the fee and so by policy the fire department won't fight fires on their property.

That pretty much covers it.


You mean no one has attempted to defend such behavior by claiming that it was unreasonable and impractical to expect money to be collected after the incident? That the "deadbeats" would just refuse to pay, and there would be no avenue to enforce collection?

And that is why the South Fulton Fire Dept. was justified in doing nothing when they were already there?

Weird. Must have been some other thread.
 
So they should have imprisoned him, forced the medication down his throat, forcibly restricted his diet? To what extreme must they go before they are absolved of what happens to him?

When your arguments get this strained and absurd, it's time to reevaluate your position.

Yes, there's some scaling test weighing 1) the potential harm, 2) the ability to prevent said harm, 3) the cost to the party preventing said harm, 4) the availability of other remedies...etc.

In the world of adults we recognize that there aren't going to be any definitive lines. Because I cannot define the exact point at which helping someone becomes so burdensome that action is no longer sensible doesn't mean that firemen standing around with fire hoses shouldn't use them even though they haven't been given their $75.
 
You mean no one has attempted to defend such behavior by claiming that it was unreasonable and impractical to expect money to be collected after the incident? That the "deadbeats" would just refuse to pay, and there would be no avenue to enforce collection?

And that is why the South Fulton Fire Dept. was justified in doing nothing when they were already there?

Weird. Must have been some other thread.

Originally Posted by qayak
You thought wrong. The main objection is that the Cranicks didn't pay the fee and so by policy the fire department won't fight fires on their property.

That pretty much covers it.

That should help you out with comprehension.
 
He didn't pay the dues, the consequence for want of $75 is that firemen stood by and watched his house burn. They couldn't put out the fire and just choke on $75 because that would send a bad example to the rest of the county.

Not the case at all. They didn't put out the fire because it was the city/fire department's policy.

What is it called when someone is willfully made to suffer to keep others in line?

This isn't what happened. The fire wasn't fought because he didn't pay. No wrong, no punishment, just a natural process resulting from pre-existing conditions.
 
Because I cannot define the exact point at which helping someone becomes so burdensome that action is no longer sensible doesn't mean that firemen standing around with fire hoses shouldn't use them even though they haven't been given their $75.

But that means you have defined, from your comfy high horse, on behalf of the fire department involved that it wasn't "so burdensome", regardless of their clearly differing opinion.
 
Last edited:
Not the case at all. They didn't put out the fire because it was the city/fire department's policy.

Who cares? Segregation used to be policy, that didn't make it good.

This isn't what happened. The fire wasn't fought because he didn't pay. No wrong, no punishment, just a natural process resulting from pre-existing conditions.

Oh wait, I didn't realize that they didn't fight the fire because he hadn't paid a fee. This whole time I was operating under the misconception that they didn't fight the fire because the man didn't pay a fee.

"Natural process." Hilarious.
 
But that means you have defined, from your comfy high horse, on behalf of the fire department involved that it wasn't "so burdensome", regardless of their clearly differing opinion.

Firemen fight fires. They were standing there with hoses. If aiming a hose at a fire is too onerous for trained firefighters, I think the problems in that county run deeper than we feared.
 
Who cares? Segregation used to be policy, that didn't make it good.

So what? Now you are saying that a person chosing not to pay a fee to protect their property is the same as segregation.

How can you take yourself seriously? Your argument is simply one of whining emotion.

Oh wait, I didn't realize that they didn't fight the fire because he hadn't paid a fee.

From your posts, it is completely obvious that you didn't understand. Now that you do, I see you have nothing more to argue.

"Natural process." Hilarious.

Perhaps it is time you buy a dictionary.
 
So what? Now you are saying that a person chosing not to pay a fee to protect their property is the same as segregation.

How can you take yourself seriously? Your argument is simply one of whining emotion.

Weak. You know next to nothing about the law, continually make naive assertions, and are approaching an obvious example with childish literalism.

It's obvious why I brough up segregation. I refuse to accept that you're not smart enough to understand, so I can only assume you're just doubling down on contrarianism.

From your posts, it is completely obvious that you didn't understand. Now that you do, I see you have nothing more to argue.

Haha, what?

Perhaps it is time you buy a dictionary.

Where do I look to find the part where firemen are bound by natural processes to keep their hoses off? Is it the weak force? The strong? Electromagnetism?
 
Firemen fight fires. They were standing there with hoses. If aiming a hose at a fire is too onerous for trained firefighters, I think the problems in that county run deeper than we feared.

Undoubtably, they do. Which is why falling back to a kindergardener's understanding of "firefighting" isn't a good way to judge the situation.
 
If he's paying off his debt, what is the problem? I thought the main objection hinged on all the "freeloaders" who'd refuse to.
How is he paying off his debt? It doesn't seem that way to me. He's now living in his 1 year old camper according to news stories... apparently a camper (those things are very expensive) took priority over his payments to the fire department.

The guy's a moron, I shed no tears for him. In fact, I'd like to punch him in the face for not getting his pets out of the house during the 2 hours it took for the fire to go from the barrels to the house. What a callous bastard!
 
Last edited:
Undoubtably, they do. Which is why falling back to a kindergardener's understanding of "firefighting" isn't a good way to judge the situation.

What would have happened if he paid $75? Was the inferno so dangerous that they would have stayed away?
 
These guys are volunteers. If someone told me to stand by while a house burnt down, I'd tell him to get bent. Let them 'fire' me if they don't like it.

Refusing to obey that order is a kind of virtuous civil disobedience. It forces the town to adopt a saner policy.
To clarify, how exactly are you going to carry that out?

I've been making slight comments all along, and I've been thinking quite a lot about this. As I've indicated already, I'm a volunteer fireman in rural Iowa (is there an urban Iowa?). I primarly drive and operate the aparatus. I've no interest in going inside a burning building, but I'm more than willing to supply my brother firemen the water they need to do their jobs and keep them safe.

One the one hand, I agree that the resident did get what he paid for. Every year, departments are forced to do more and more with less and less and no one really seems to care. The fire service, especially the volunteer srevice, is frought with budget cuts, dwindling interest and other pitfalls. We have to incorporate more manditory training a top any location specific training that we already have problems getting our members to come out to. Having some resident who willfully rejects our service in the light of day, I have a hard time to muster the sympathy when the boogyman gets him from 'neath the bed.

On the other hand, as Hamradioguy pointed out, I didn't get into the service for glory, honor or any thing else. I wanted a way to give back to my community, make some friends and generally help out. That I get to drive big red trucks and wear a nifty black suit is a side benefit, Pisci. I would have had a hard time watching the property burn. If I was on the pump panel, I'd probably have had my hands on the pump levers (if we didn't already have a line charged to surpress the fire from getting to the neighbors' houses), ready to charge the lines when my IC gave the command.

What I would not have done is wildcatted. That is dangerous. I would not have gone against my chief (from the stories I've read, the SFFD Chief was the Incident Commander on scene). When you're on a scene, you have to trust your commmand that they have a larger picture than what you can see. If he had told us not to fight it, I'd have to trust that he knew what he was talking about. After we left and got back to the station, that's a different story. I would most certainly have taken him to task over it. Where I differ from HRG is that while I, as a fireman, try to stay apolitical while on scene, the chief has to be politically aware or he'll do the department more damage than good. For all we know, a citiy manager came to the chief at the beginning of Sept and told him that if they put our any more non-payer's fires that the FD's budget would be cut.

In anycase, even if some random firefighter on scene had wanted to fight it, without the help of a number of others on scene, they wouldn't get very far. All the chief has to do is shut down the pumps (with a double wide fire, no one is going inside) and no one is fighting it. While it's heart warming to think that you could have broken ranks, the logistincs aren't quite that easy.

Also, while the FFs might see this guy or his family every once in a while, they have to see their command structure WAY more often and their lives can depend on them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom