Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

And if your actions meant that others in the country decided to cancel their fire subscription service (since the department will respond to fires anyways, why bother) and your department was unable to hire enough staff/buy new equipment and risked the lives and property of others as a result, would you feel good about that?
Already covered this. The enforcement is too sporadic to have much of an effect if people are economic robots, and if they are instead social animals there are better, saner, more efficient, less dangerous, more humane ways to motivate people to subscribe than to periodically make an example of someone by letting his house burn as you stand idly by.

So, who decides what an acceptable risk is? The trailer was unoccupied. Are the contents of a trailer (owned by a non subscriber) worth a 1% risk of death or injury? .1%? .01%?
This is no more relevant here than it is in any other fire. Someone makes a call, based on pertinent information. I'm comfortable with saying that the risk of turning to face the trailer and spraying a hose at it vs. the total loss of someone's home is a pretty easy call to make.

Fire fighters do risk their lives to save property (even when they are not 'saving lives'). However, we pay them for accepting that risk.
No. We. Don't. They're all volunteers in South Fulton. Seventy-something percent of firefighters in the US are volunteers. We rarely pay them anything. Fire departments are underfunded in general. Most of them still won't let your house burn down. What makes South Fulton so *********** special?

I do not think its a moral problem to say that they must accept any risk to save just property.
Good thing nobody is claiming otherwise, then.
 
And funnily enough the problem itself it caused by conservative knee-jerk voting down taxes.

There are plenty of people on both sides of that place ideology ahead of the real world.

Good point, that.
 
No, it really isn't. What was the total amount of his freeloading?

Why is his particular freeloading dollar amount important vs the amount of freeloading in the entire system? I suspect it will quickly add up to much more than the cost of his doublewide.
 
The reason there is talk of no cost, no risk is because of the "narrow scope" of this thread. The OP presented a single, specific incident. That incident involved specific circumstances. Under those circumstances, with the firefighters on the scene, there was no moral reason not to save the home.

Actually, there are folks here addressing the wider issues, not about the whole world, but those which were involved in the FD making their choice, and which must be taken into account when deciding if they did the morally correct thing or not.

Those include the potential risk of injury to the fire fighters, potential for future harm by encouraging a moral hazard, and the political relationship between the city and the county.

And hey, you don't know that Jesus isn't involved. He burned down a while back up in Ohio... he might just have taken an interest.
 
Are you sure you're not getting your Mr. Cranicks confused. The mention I saw of another incident involved a different Mr. Cranick (a son) at a different property.

I think it might be a different structure on the same property. It is a 12 acre lot.
 
How is it wrong to say that all the parties in this mess had a share in the blame? It has nothing to do with "easier." And why do you assume that only those who agree with you are taking on the "burden of critical thought?"

I can't see that the fire fighters can be blamed. The decision was made, based on a consideration of the overall situation, and when the time came, they carried out their mission as it had been defined.

Yes, it is "easier" to simply default to a position that blame must be shared all around, but I don't see evidence for that in this case.

And I'm not simply assuming that you're not thinking critically about this. I'm just not hearing valid arguments from you.

Of course, I can also be extremely arrogant, so that's a factor, too.
 
Not all of our coats are yellow, nor are all of our trucks red. I prefer slime lime trucks myself, better visibility and all that. :D

The one next to me is blue. And why the building says engine and it has a ladder in it I don't know.
 
I suspect it depends on a number of factors... tax base for the area that actually supports the fire fighters, the geographic area and number of houses in the rural non-supported areas, the quality of the roads, average incomes, etc.

Assuming that because one fire department can handle rural regions without payment does not necessarily mean all such fire departments will have that ability. A major city (>1 million) can probably handle small outlying pockets of near by rural dwellers fairly easily, whereas a small town (<10 thousand) will not be able to provide service to far-flung rural areas unless people living in those areas contribute to help support the firefighters.


"I suspect". "Assuming".

See a pattern there?

I cited statements by fire protection professionals in the same state, doing the same job, also using subscription plans. They weren't "suspecting" or "assuming" anything. They were commenting on the basis of their professional knowledge and experience, and deplored the action taken by South Fulton.

Why do you "assume" that they are incompetent to judge conditions in another part of the same state? Tennessee isn't that big. Why do you "suspect" that their circumstances are substantially different? Did you investigate their jurisdictions?

Or are you just blowing smoke?
 
It's a problem for your accusations of idealism that this pie-in-the-sky, unrealistically idealistic solution is exactly what happens in 6 of the other 7 municipalities in this county. Particularly given that all of them save one have a significantly smaller tax base.

They provide fire protection without collecting revenue in 6 of the other 7 towns?
 
So now we move from wastrel deadbeats who don't pay at all being the justification to not-so-wastrel not-so-deadbeats who can't pay fast enough. If you keep pushing those posts far enough we'll get to anyone who doesn't buy their own personal, single-use fire department in advance.

Maybe there's a time to stop pushing.
Slippery slope much?

Evidence has been presented that an-after-the-fact-fine is not successful in encouraging other people to pay the initial subscription fee. Hell, I may have been mistaken about it being the same property - but within the same family? The elder Mr Cranick cited the incident at his son's property as reason why they hadn't bothered to ensure they'd paid the subscription fee any of the (at least) 6 times they'd been contacted by the Fire Dept.

Try to twist it all you want, but that's precisely what happened. And between the time that his son's property caught fire and his property caught fire, the Fire Dept changed it's policy. It is unfortunate for Mr Cranick - but so be it.


I find it amazing that people would be such extreme ideologues that anyone who asserts Mr Cranick should take responsibility for his inaction is now a libertarian - regardless of whether they agree with how the system was designed.

I personally detest the system, while at the same time understand why the system in place is the one in place. That doesn't mean I support it. But at the same time, that doesn't mean I'm going to excuse Mr Cranick at the expense of the FF who responded.

If protecting his trailer from fire was this important to Mr Cranick, then he should have ensured his subscription fee was paid. It was a service provided by the Town to the local unincorporated property owners as a favor - there was no obligation (moral or otherwise) for the FF to douse the flames. None.

By refusing to pay, Mr Cranick designated himself as not a member of the community. Therefore, he should not benefit from that community's taxes. Tough, sure. But that's the consequences of his refusal to pay the subscription.
 
They provide fire protection without collecting revenue in 6 of the other 7 towns?
Five. One collects a subscription, but won't let your house burn at a matter of policy. Two will, at least one paper. And apparently at least one will in the real world, too. This is as of 2008.

They all charge a $500 fee per incident, billing it to the homeowner's insurance when possible. Collection rates are 'less than 50%'.

Haven't been able to find any information about how many subscribers South Fulton had prior to this event.
 
You are failing to grasp a simple point, forgetting relevant facts from post to post.

Yonkers is large. It has many buildings and citizens! There is congestion! The NYPD would have to buy additional equipment, build new stations, and hire more firefighters to even minimally serve the city as a whole, incurring significant costs they would not otherwise incur, which would have to be passed on to taxpayers.
Doesn't matter. NYC should be far better able to serve a city the size of Yonkers, which after all is just 1/40th the size of NYC.

If you think South Fulton should be able to provide free service to the county, then you should also think NYC could easily handle firefighting duties in Yonkers should they disband their FD.
 
If these ideals exist in the field (and they do, overwhelmingly), then you can't describe my disgust at the firefighters' failure to act as 'armchair idealism'.

The problem, instead, is your armchair cynicism.

Fire fighters, EMTs, cops, soldiers, National Guard, hospital staff... folks like that regularly provide assistance without compensation in individual cases.

I don't think anyone would dispute that.

I doubt that anyone would go into those professions if they balked at helping other people because they couldn't pay on the spot, or refused to help all persons who couldn't pay at all.

But obviously, the folks in this particular situation -- not the fire, but the broader political and financial situation which triggered the decision to exclude non-subscribers -- came to the conclusion that continuing to provide services to property for those who opted out was untenable.

And I'm not going to play Monday morning quarterback on that decision.

Letting this one trailer burn (because its owner did not take basic precautions) may save lives in the future.

To me, being horrified at the actions of the firefighters is a bit like walking up to an animal shelter worker and saying "Shame on you for killing innocent dogs who never hurt anyone!"
 
"I suspect". "Assuming".

See a pattern there?

I cited statements by fire protection professionals in the same state, doing the same job, also using subscription plans. They weren't "suspecting" or "assuming" anything. They were commenting on the basis of their professional knowledge and experience, and deplored the action taken by South Fulton.

Why do you "assume" that they are incompetent to judge conditions in another part of the same state? Tennessee isn't that big. Why do you "suspect" that their circumstances are substantially different? Did you investigate their jurisdictions?

Or are you just blowing smoke?

Oh, maybe its because I read the link that ponderingturtle posted upthread which was from the Union City Fire Department, another FD in the same county expressing support for the SFFD and explicitly expressing the same concerns that segnosaur is 'assuming' and 'suspecting'.

The fact that they are in the same county, facing the exact same situation that SFFD is facing makes them a bit more credible to me. They however are a bit bigger of a city than South Fulton, so have not yet reached their breaking point, but the tone of the article sure implies that they are close.
 
Doesn't matter. NYC should be far better able to serve a city the size of Yonkers, which after all is just 1/40th the size of NYC.

If you think South Fulton should be able to provide free service to the county, then you should also think NYC could easily handle firefighting duties in Yonkers should they disband their FD.
Another person failing to grasp the basic principle under discussion.

Try to figure out what "at no additional cost to themselves" means.
 
You are failing to grasp a simple point, forgetting relevant facts from post to post.

Yonkers is large. It has many buildings and citizens! There is congestion! The NYPD would have to buy additional equipment, build new stations, and hire more firefighters to even minimally serve the city as a whole, incurring significant costs they would not otherwise incur, which would have to be passed on to taxpayers.

No it wouldn't. They have very high staffing levels. It would streach the resources thinner, but you don't have an issue with that in this county. They are both cases of people deciding to choose not to pay for a service and getting it from their neighbors for free. The county has had a lot of votes to get coverage for everyone. They vote it down.

So if Yonkers voted this way, what is the difference? It is one political entity passing the buck to their neighbors.
The rural area served by the SFFD is small.
And yet I would bet it is a similar size to yonkers. And come on yonkers would not significantly impact the call volume of NYC. Too little population for that.
 
Five. One collects a subscription, but won't let your house burn at a matter of policy. Two will, at least one paper. And apparently at least one will in the real world, too. This is as of 2008.

They all charge a $500 fee per incident, billing it to the homeowner's insurance when possible. Collection rates are 'less than 50%'.

Haven't been able to find any information about how many subscribers South Fulton had prior to this event.

Well, given that, I'm curious as to why you think that this particular town/FD came to the wrong decision when it decided, based on its particular situation, that providing services to property for non-subscribers was untenable.
 
By refusing to pay, Mr Cranick designated himself as not a member of the community. Therefore, he should not benefit from that community's taxes. Tough, sure. But that's the consequences of his refusal to pay the subscription.

He is a Freeman On The Land and refused to contract with city for fire protection.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom