Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

The marginal costs for each additional household covered will be pretty low;
"Low" for NYC, not low for South Fulton, population 2,500. There's probably buildings in NYC with that many people! Once again, the Yonkers example, proportionately, is much less of a problem for NYC than this issue is for South Fulton.

most of the costs of running a fire department are fixed.
Which is exactly why you need a reliable cash flow - to pay those fixed costs. Waiting for a fire and hoping for the best afterwards is no way to fund a fire department.
 
What were the circumstances in that case?

Was there a reasonable expectation of mutual assistance between the departments?

In this case, of course, there was no other department, yet the county nevertheless willingly chose a system which allowed people to opt in or to forego coverage.

Doesn't sound like equivalent circumstances to me.


Wow. How much fun is this? First you ask,

"What were the circumstances in that case?
​
Then, after some aimless mumbling you conclude,

"Doesn't sound like equivalent circumstances to me."

​
Somehow I'm not surprised. I doubt it would be humanly (or even inhumanly) possible to find any circumstances which did, unless you felt they supported your preconceptions. It does make one wonder how you could jump so quickly from not knowing the circumstances to asserting their irrelevance. Oh, wait. Jumping ... conclusions. Never mind, I've got it now.

Even the mumbling was good for a giggle or two.

You consistently ignore (at least you're consistent about something) the simple fact that the county didn't "choose" anything. Even while you're disparaging the county for not doing anything.

The town of South Fulton did the choosing. They chose to designate an area outside of their town limits that they would send their fire department to. Why do you attribute that choice to the county? Are you suggesting some sort of intimidation? Did the county somehow force South Fulton to offer a subscription service?

Could South Fulton just have said, "Nope. Ain't goin' there."? Apparently not, from what you say.

I wonder what would have happened if they had. Perhaps the county would have found the impetus from such a refusal to establish other measures. Of course, if they had done that all those lovely subscriptions would never have made it into the South Fulton budget. What a quandary. What's a mayor to do?
 
Then, after some aimless mumbling you conclude

So, pointing out the differences in the situations which are obvious in your description is "aimless mumbling"?

Got it.

ETA: You yourself said this was a case of contiguous districts. That means it's not at all analogous to the case under discussion here.
 
Last edited:
He didn't pay the dues, the consequence for want of $75 is that firemen stood by and watched his house burn. They couldn't put out the fire and just choke on $75 because that would send a bad example to the rest of the county.

What is it called when someone is willfully made to suffer to keep others in line?

Again, what if it was $75,000 instead of $75?
 
you seem to be ignoring this evidence from the UCFD in the SAME COUNTY. (same link as was provided upthread by pondiringturtle.


and later


Yup, appears to working like charm in Obion County. :rolleyes:

Of course, this is just an opinion piece after all. Its not like the writer is somehow familiar with the specific situation of fighting fighting and keeping a FD funded in Obion county. I mean he is just the fire chief of the Union City Fire Department, the largest Fire Department in Obion County, why would he have any useful insight on the matter? I am sure that firefighters in other counties and other states have a much better grasp of the local situation and difficulties of getting payment from non-subscribers then he does.


Let's see. Did I ignore it? Um. No. I responded to it.

I would expect him to make a statement to that effect. No one is disputing that there isn't a funding problem. Only that there is a problem having firemen stand around watching someone's home burn down.

Is that Union City's policy?

Well, no.

Has it been? Do we have any reports of such incidents by them in the past?

Well, ... no.

What do we know about the county and the towns within it? We know that the towns with fire departments have handled the situation in different ways in the past. Some with subscriptions, some without. We know that they haven't stood by and watched someone's home burn down.

Except for South Fulton.

At least twice, it would seem.

We know that since the last time the South Fulton FD did something similar the county and its municipalities have been working on an agreement to coordinate coverage. Yes it is a subscription system. All of the various municipalities are on-board, and the county 911 system is going to coordinate. They don't seem to be stressing a policy of standing around watching someone's home burn down.

Oh, wait. All of them ... except South Fulton, which has declined to participate, and plans to continue to offer service to the "designated rural areas" of its own choosing. And presumably to continue its other policies.

Does anything about this seem to stand out to you?
 
You consistently ignore (at least you're consistent about something) the simple fact that the county didn't "choose" anything.

Excuse me?

Are you seriously trying to say here that the county did not choose the system they have in place? (And by "the county" I mean the gov't and the citizens.)

Do you contend that God came down from the mountain and imposed this system upon them?
 
The town of South Fulton did the choosing. They chose to designate an area outside of their town limits that they would send their fire department to.

And it was damn nice of them to do it.

This was not something they imposed on the county. The city would have no authority to impose such an arrangement on the county.

I don't know the background details of how the politics was worked out, but clearly it was an agreement between the two governments.

The county did not have to choose this option, and no one could force them to.

They could have chosen a universal tax to be paid to the city to ensure coverage for all.

They could have chosen to set up their own fire dept.

But they did neither of these things.

Instead, they opted for a subscription service.

And that was their choice.

No one obligated the city to agree to this. They could have said, "Screw you, we're only local". No authority I know of could force them to cooperate.

But they agreed, and offered services to subscribers in the county.

One thing is clear... the county opted for an individual subscriber system, and the city agreed to provide services for subscribers.

And when the city actually abided by that agreement, suddenly there's outrage that they would do such a thing.

How dare they do what they contracted to do! How dare they fulfill their obligation to the county according to the county's wishes! Outrageous!
 
So, pointing out the differences in the situations which are obvious in your description is "aimless mumbling"?

Got it.

ETA: You yourself said this was a case of contiguous districts. That means it's not at all analogous to the case under discussion here.


It is a case where a fire department relied on the formality of not being responsible for an area, and stood around watching someone's home burn down.

Do you really see no comparison?

If not, I don't think I can do anything to help you. Your blindness is too willful.
 
It is a case where a fire department relied on the formality of not being responsible for an area, and stood around watching someone's home burn down.

Do you really see no comparison?

If not, I don't think I can do anything to help you. Your blindness is too willful.

Details matter, quadraginta.

Courts do not decide cases on the basis of broad principles without considering the actual situation at hand.

Circumstances are everything.

If you have a case where there are two contiguous districts, each supported by a universal tax providing universal coverage, and both depts are called to a scene, and one arrives before the other, that is not equivalent to a case in which a county freely opts for a subscriber-only service in the absence of any other available coverage and a non-subscriber has a fire.
 
There. I put my post back together for you. Nice try, though.

You consistently ignore (at least you're consistent about something) the simple fact that the county didn't "choose" anything.

Excuse me?

Are you seriously trying to say here that the county did not choose the system they have in place? (And by "the county" I mean the gov't and the citizens.)

Do you contend that God came down from the mountain and imposed this system upon them?

Is that what you thought I said? Very strange.

Tell me. Once South Fulton elected to extend its fire protection service to areas beyond its town limits which it picked out, just exactly what do you suppose the county could do about it?

Apparently nothing, since the county has now worked out a coordinated agreement with everyone else, and South Fulton is still doing what it wants to do, all by itself, with no apparent regard for the county's interests, or any of the other towns which have somehow all found a way to work together.

The town of South Fulton did the choosing. They chose to designate an area outside of their town limits that they would send their fire department to.

And it was damn nice of them to do it.


Was it? It was certainly convenient. All those subscriptions were probably nice. Yes.

This was not something they imposed on the county. The city would have no authority to impose such an arrangement on the county.
They didn't impose diddly on the county. They offered a service to a certain limited set of individuals in an area of their own choice outside their town limits. What authority did they need? What could the county do about it?

I don't know the background details of how the politics was worked out, but clearly it was an agreement between the two governments.
You're right. You don't know. So why was it "clearly" any sort of "agreement" at all?

The county did not have to choose this option, and no one could force them to.
I'm still trying to get you to explain why anyone would even need to force them, or even persuade them, or even consult them to begin with.

They could have chosen a universal tax to be paid to the city to ensure coverage for all.

They could have chosen to set up their own fire dept.

But they did neither of these things.
Cool. You got three whole statements right in a row. Good for you. Keep it up.

Instead, they opted for a subscription service.

And that was their choice.
Well, that didn't last long.

I suppose inaction could be described as a choice of sorts, but not in the sense that you are trying to imply.

That does seem to be what the county is doing this time around. South Fulton still isn't interested, or chosen, or opted, or whatever it is you seem to think the county can do to them if they don't want to do something. Aren't you even the least bit curious why all the rest of the towns are on board, and they aren't?

No one obligated the city to agree to this. They could have said, "Screw you, we're only local". No authority I know of could force them to cooperate.
Right again! You gonna try for another three-inna-row?

But they agreed, and offered services to subscribers in the county.

One thing is clear... the county opted for an individual subscriber system, and the city agreed to provide services for subscribers.

And when the city actually abided by that agreement, suddenly there's outrage that they would do such a thing.
Oh well. I guess a one-inna-row is nothing to be ashamed of.

It is clear to me that the town of South Fulton chose to offer services outside of its town limits.

It's less clear that the county actually "opted" for anything at all. Perhaps they did, but no choice was needful on their part, only inaction, and you have offered nothing beyond incredulity and bland assertions to demonstrate that anything else existed.

My sense is that the county would have been far better off in the long run if there was no subscription system in place by any of the towns. There would have been more of a motive to work out something which relied on the county tax jurisdiction, even if that was ultimately only the county acting as a tax collector for the towns.

A multitude of disjointed, disparate alternatives could not have been of any benefit to the county's ability to develop a mandate among their voters, and subscriptions had to be like low hanging fruit to any municipality which was struggling to maintain the facilities it had.

Bad combination.

Nor is there any substance to your assertion that South Fulton "abided" by anything other than the agreement they (the town, not the county) chose to undertake with individuals (not the county) beyond their town borders.

So perhaps you do not grasp just where the outrage is directed, or why.

How dare they do what they contracted to do! How dare they fulfill their obligation to the county according to the county's wishes! Outrageous!
What obligation to the county?

South Fulton might have been better off from an ethical perspective if they had not elected to extend their service outside of their tax jurisdiction. At least if they were inclined to make the sort of choices they have. I've said that from the very beginning of this discussion.

Having made that commitment they exposed themselves to the dilemma they have found themselves in. The choice that was made was a choice by South Fulton to have its people stand around and watch someone's home burn down.

We have plenty of examples of municipalities confronted with the same dilemma who made a different choice. Most of them, it seems.

You keep talking as if they had no volition in the matter, and they were just picked on by the Big, Bad County. You have shown nothing to substantiate this.

There was an obvious advantage to South Fulton to undertake the additional service they did, a financial one. The question has been asked whether they would have been better off financially if they hadn't. I'm inclined to think that they probably wouldn't have. I suspect that altruism wasn't their primary motive. We do have evidence that it isn't an overriding one.

Something which hasn't been discussed much here is the actual tax base of the county's various components. It isn't an us vs. them, sophisticated townies against snaggle-toothed yokels caricature.

For example. Union City is a factory town with a number of sizable corporate residents, Goodyear Tire not least among them, and the junction of two major rail lines. Well, "union" of two lines, I guess. That's how they got their name. They aren't drawing revenue only from their population. Nor are the people resident within their town limits the only participants in the business of those corporations. The town can't claim that it survives as an island independent of the surrounding county. It would be disingenuous to characterize its involvement with county services as some sort of welfare.

South Fulton used to be part of an industrial community. There was an ice plant which United Fruit relied on to keep more than half the entire country's bananas fresh on their way to market. South Fulton is a fragment of the community which developed around that plant.

It seems that those days are over. There's probably a lot of financial stress as a result, but it is a mistake to assume that the wealth they have or even had was solely a result of their own careful husbandry. The entire region would have been involved. Even the "rural" parts.

The economy that this episode is taking place in is not a simple one which can be described or or evaluated by the simplistic platitudes you keep offering. Even if you were getting them right in the first place, which you aren't.
 
Details matter, quadraginta.

Courts do not decide cases on the basis of broad principles without considering the actual situation at hand.

Circumstances are everything.

If you have a case where there are two contiguous districts, each supported by a universal tax providing universal coverage, and both depts are called to a scene, and one arrives before the other, that is not equivalent to a case in which a county freely opts for a subscriber-only service in the absence of any other available coverage and a non-subscriber has a fire.


So what you're saying is that you can't explain why one fire department standing around watching a home burn down because it isn't their responsibility to put out is different from another fire department standing around watching a home burn down because it isn't their responsibility to put out.

That's what I thought.

That's okay. It'd be mighty hard to explain to a jury, too. Especially one in the same part of the same state which apparently already set one precedent that the first bunch of callous bastards was at fault in spite of the absence of jurisdiction or legal obligation.

If anything the Cranick episode is worse. At least in the first case there was another fire department around to respond. Not in time, maybe, but expected.

South Fulton had their little campfire all to themselves. I don't understand why you think that would make them less culpable in a jury's eyes.
 
Last edited:
Hope not too many semi-legal* Mexicans live in this area, working in semi-legal* forced labour in sweatshops. They would have no incentive (or legal chance) to pay and get this emergency service.

* "semi-legal" = what politicians pretend to ban in legislation, but the police do not enforce in reality
 
Hope not too many semi-legal* Mexicans live in this area, working in semi-legal* forced labour in sweatshops.
You think there's Mexican slavery in the US?

They would have no incentive (or legal chance) to pay and get this emergency service.
Why not? And what do you think happens if they didn't?

* "semi-legal" = what politicians pretend to ban in legislation, but the police do not enforce in reality
I'm more interested in the "forced labor" (otherwise known as slavery) part... you have evidence of this? Or are you just making stuff up? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
You think there's Mexican slavery in the US?


Why not? And what do you think happens if they didn't?


I'm more interested in the "forced labor" (otherwise known as slavery) part... you have evidence of this? Or are you just making stuff up? :rolleyes:

probably making it up. according to wikipedia

As of the census[3] of 2000, there were 32,450 people, 13,182 households, and 9,398 families residing in the county. The population density was 60 people per square mile (23/km²). There were 14,489 housing units at an average density of 27 per square mile (10/km²). The racial makeup of the county was 88.16% White, 9.85% Black or African American, 0.14% Native American, 0.19% Asian, 0.05% Pacific Islander, 0.91% from other races, and 0.71% from two or more races. 1.90% of the population were Hispanic or Latino of any race.

so 1.9% of 32,450 = 616 Latinos in the entire county
total population of cities in county = 17,532 => 46% of ounty population outside cities.
=>aprox. 283 Latinos in unincorporated Obion County. Something tells me they are not being overrun by a tide of illegal immigrants.
 
Fire fighters, EMTs, cops, soldiers, National Guard, hospital staff... folks like that regularly provide assistance without compensation in individual cases.

I don't think anyone would dispute that.

They do but they shouldn't. The problem is that almost everyone in this thread is a socialist, some are just more closeted. Everyone seems to believe that if a PERSON was trapped in the house, then it would be the responsibility of taxpayers in S. Fulton to come to their aide. Why? How is that the responsibility of others? Where do you draw the line on entitlements? It's OK to save someone's life, OK to maybe save certain animals, but not OK to save a house? Everything in this country, if it is a land of freedom, is based on property rights, beginning with self-ownership of your flesh and blood. When you make demands upon ME to spend MY resources regarding a third party, then you're depriving ME of MYYYY property, the fruits of MYYYYYY labor. I in effect become an unwilling slave to the state.

I was in a stadium yesterday and a gent in is mid-50s had a heart attack. I am bad-ass when it comes to CPR -- one of the very best. Probably THE best. But I'm also future-oriented. His wife (I guess) asked if there was a medical professional in the house. "Right here." It suddenly became as quiet as a church, and I used the opportunity to maximize the greatest good. I stood up on a seat and announced, "I can save this man!" A hopeful if tense moment. (I won't mention what a heckler said but we are a society that's increasingly disrespectful.) Where was I? Ah, yes, "I can save this man! ... but I am not going to. Let this be a lesson to everyone not to have heart attacks." You wouldn't know it from the ungrateful stares but, in the long run, I probably saved lives. Naturally some dudley-do-gooder volunteered his services (for free!) and now everyone thinks its OK to hurt themselves while watching WWE.

When we provide services to everyone then we encourage ne'er-do-wellism. Take for instance the homeless. They figure, "Hey it's not so bad if I become homeless." It might even one day become "cool" -- like how it is now with being gay. I've seen homeless people call the police (flag them down, not call-them-call them, don't be ridiculous). They wanted to complain about something, as they usually do. The police officer's proper answer should have been "Get a job!"

The lesson here is as old as time: If you want a helping hand, check the end of your sleeve.
 
Again, what if it was $75,000 instead of $75?

Then the fire department would have had a more legitimate reason to let the house burn.

Although, in all likelihood, if the fee was that high, no one would pay it, and the fire department would have disbanded for lack of funding.

I don't really follow your point. The reason letting it burn was so absurd was because the fee was so small, a trivial sum. If the sum was non-trivial, it changes things.

Please have enough dignity to avoid the "where do we draw the line" nonsense. Wherever it is, it isn't $75.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom