Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

Another person failing to grasp the basic principle under discussion.

Try to figure out what "at no additional cost to themselves" means.
There is an additional cost for increasing the scope (area and buildings) of their service area for South Fulton. Proportionately, more than the FDNY covering Yonkers.

I can't fathom how you think South Fulton can dramatically increase its coverage area without incurring any extra costs. Is it magical?
 
:D

I had been tempted to post this in the "Examples of FOTL failures" thread...

By all means, please do. This is a prime example of the inherent failings of the FOTL ideal, that voluntary contracting with government for only the services that you desire is some sort of utopia.

Me personally. I'd rather be a slave with a house than a free man with a pile of ash.
 
Slippery slope much?


You tell me. You're the one who started down it. I'm just following along behind you.

Evidence has been presented that an-after-the-fact-fine is not successful in encouraging other people to pay the initial subscription fee.
<snip>


Evidence has been presented that it is.

I'm more than willing to give credence to the informed judgment of professionals in the same line of work, in the same part of the country, with the same problems and issues.

Why aren't you?

I mean, they say that they have successfully dealt with same sort of problem. Do you think they are lying? Why would they do that? Why would they diss their own, in the same state, no less. What percentage is there for them to cast baseless aspersions against their own fellow professionals?

Maybe South Fulton was just wrong to do what they did.

It doesn't matter whether or not Cranick was wrong, too. No one is questioning that. Not even the Cranicks.

All of the defense in this thread of South Fulton's decision to let someone's home burn to the ground has been based on ideology and economic theory. That doesn't constitute "evidence". That is known as opinion. There is no "evidence" that the South Fulton FD would collapse into a financial black hole if this fire had been extinguished, or the next one, or the next one. Even into perpetuity.

There is "evidence" that other Fire Chiefs in the very same state have found substantial post-incident fees to be very helpful at encouraging subscription payments. That "evidence" is that they actually did it, and it worked.

You can wave your hands around and talk about the way you believe people will behave all you want. It's still opinion.

When you are offered "evidence" that people are in fact not behaving that way, and you simply choose to disregard it, then it isn't even a very good opinion.
 
He is a Freeman On The Land and refused to contract with city for fire protection.

:D

I had been tempted to post this in the "Examples of FOTL failures" thread...

By all means, please do. This is a prime example of the inherent failings of the FOTL ideal, that voluntary contracting with government for only the services that you desire is some sort of utopia.

Me personally. I'd rather be a slave with a house than a free man with a pile of ash.


Are we watching a baseless rumor being born?

It would seem that his wife, at least, wasn't. Since she claims to have routinely paid the fee in the past, and regretted being delinquent this time. Must have made for hot times in the old homestead even when it wasn't in flames.

You people are a hoot to watch. "No ideology here. Nope. No, no, no. We're just talking facts."

:rolleyes:
 
Piggy said:
Letting this one trailer burn (because its owner did not take basic precautions) may save lives in the future.
It may also cost lives in the future, because you're going to have to let a lot of non-subscriber's homes burn to set the expectation that you will do so every time, while still reporting to the scene when the subscribing neighbor calls, which introduces serious new risks. It could also cause a major ********* that might end up attracting a pack of litigators that end up bankrupting the town. Naive utilitarianism is superficially appealing, but rejected by anyone who's thought about it seriously, because (among other reasons) it places unrealistic demands on our ability to sort out future consequences. Instead, we develop rules of thumb, principles, which we use to guide our actions.

An important principle recognized by practically everyone in the civilized world is that we don't 'make an example' out of people where doing so is completely out of proportion with the antisocial behavior we're trying to address. Where we have incalculable uncertainty, we err on the side of helping people avoid substantial harm where it costs us nothing to do so. Particularly where we've taken a job that entails helping people even where it's quite risky.

To me, being horrified at the actions of the firefighters is a bit like walking up to an animal shelter worker and saying "Shame on you for killing innocent dogs who never hurt anyone!"
There's no element of coercion there--it's not like cats and dogs respond to the threat of being killed by using birth control--so we can't characterize this as punishment. We also have harms that are similar in kind: starvation of many vs. euthanasia of some. There's an element of unfairness we'd recognize were we talking about humans--they are being killed so that others will not suffer and die, which is a tough pill to swallow--but there are plausible arguments for treating persons and quasi-persons differently.
 
It could also cause a major ********* that might end up attracting a pack of litigators that end up bankrupting the town.

Highly unlikely, given the fact that they had opted out of the service.
 
It may also cost lives in the future, because you're going to have to let a lot of non-subscriber's homes burn to set the expectation that you will do so every time

I'd bet you dollars to donuts that everyone in the county takes them at their word right now.

I mean, this has gotten our attention, and we don't even live there.
 
Highly unlikely, given the fact that they had opted out of the service.


I guess you say this because of the overwhelming evidence that people won't attempt a lawsuit unless they have a strong case in their favor.

Yeah. Right.

You reminded me of a quote I cited earlier from another Tennessee fire dept. Chief.

"We don't ask," he said, adding that he believes the firefighters who responded were probably anxious to attack the flames despite their orders.
Vonore's subscription is $100 a year.

He said his unit would not "let policies and stuff get in the way," and he related a story he heard from a different location in West Tennessee in which firefighters from one jurisdiction responded to a fire that was on the other side of a street that was the dividing line between their area and another agency's.

They let the fire burn until the second agency could respond but ultimately had to pay for the house following litigation.


Maybe you missed that part. Note: They stood around and watched the house burn. They had no legal obligation to extinguish a fire outside of their jurisdiction. They lost anyway.

I'm glad I re-visited this, though. I wondered where that episode might have taken place. I may have to do some digging. How many places could there be in western Tennessee with separate fire departments with clearly separate jurisdictions on opposite sides of the same street?

One comes to mind right away.

:D
 
Last edited:
An important principle recognized by practically everyone in the civilized world is that we don't 'make an example' out of people where doing so is completely out of proportion with the antisocial behavior we're trying to address.

There is no "antisocial behavior" involved here.

The county and city set up a system to allow people to pay for particular services or opt out.

All the FD did was to comply with that agreement.

Hopefully, both the city and the county will now come up with a better solution, now that the shorcoming of that arrangement have been made undeniably clear.

And btw, this incident is nothing compared to the true idiocy around where I live.

I live in the rural eastern portion of my county, right up by the county line. There's a small town a few miles to the south of me, right on the border with a larger town in the adjoining county.

About 20 miles to the north of us is a highway leading to the state capital metro area, where a lot of people work (a godawful long commute, but people do it).

Anyway, because of the location of rivers and train tracks -- as well as a historical animosity between the "hicks" over here and the "snobs" over there which has prevented cooperation on road projects -- there's a single road leading out of the town, into the other county at that city (where a lot of wealthy executives and the like have built their homes in exurban enclaves).

The only alternative to this road is to go many, many miles in the opposite direction and then pick up the highway at an onramp ten miles further out from the capital, adding at least half an hour to the trek.

Well, this road out of our county ends in a T intersection, at a stop sign. You have to make a left turn here if you're going to the metro area. The cross street is busy with traffic from that county doing its own commute, as well as traffic for the elementary, middle, and high schools that are clustered immediately south of there. The view to the south is extremely limited due to a hill and a curve. And the speed limit there is 55 mph.

The city in the other county didn't care for us hicks using "their" streets. So to keep the influx out of our county as slow as possible, they refused for years to redirect the road just a few hundred yards to the north, where it could line up with an existing stoplight.

As you can imagine, this intersection -- which was horribly backed up every morning and afternoon with people waiting to make that left turn -- was extremely dangerous. Accidents were common, and we had deaths there every year.

But because the two towns, and the two counties, could not get over their petty bickering, the situation was allowed to continue, costing people their lives.

Finally, this year, stimulus money was used to redirect the road, so that now people can leave that town and get to where they're going without risking life and limb.

I guess they figured if they didn't have to pick up the tab, they could go ahead and do something about it.

Now THAT is stupidity!
 
Fire insurance worked in just the same way back in early American times- insurance companies maintained their own private companies of firefighters, who would respond only to fires in properties insured by their company. If you visit the Atwater Kent Museum in Philladelphia you can see a collection of cast-iron plaques which customers would put on the outside walls of their houses to show which insurer they were signed up with.

This business model could get a bit rough. There's a firefighting museum in Virginia City NV where one of the items of equipment on exhibit is a horse-drawn hose carrier that at one time was used in Philly. The placard says that among its adventures was being flung into the Schuylkill River during a brawl between rival fire companies.

IIRC, during the late Republic Marcus Licinius Crassus had a somewhat similar racket going, which involved rushing to the scene of a fire and buying the property and surrounding ones at fire-sale* prices, after which he would send in his private firefighters to rescue his investment.

*you should pardon the expression ;)
 
I guess you say this because of the overwhelming evidence that people won't attempt a lawsuit unless they have a strong case in their favor.

Yeah. Right.

That, or if they think they have a good chance of getting a settlement anyway.

I'm sure that the possibility of civil action figured into the town/FD's calculus.

I would be surprised if we saw a suit. Doesn't sound like a profitable proposition for an attorney -- represent a client who (a) lived in a trailer and (b) has lost his possessions, in order to sue a city for failing to provide services they were not obligated to provide.

Could be wrong, crazier things have happened. But I wouldn't bet in favor.
 
Maybe you missed that part.

What were the circumstances in that case?

Was there a reasonable expectation of mutual assistance between the departments?

In this case, of course, there was no other department, yet the county nevertheless willingly chose a system which allowed people to opt in or to forego coverage.

Doesn't sound like equivalent circumstances to me.
 
I'd bet you dollars to donuts that everyone in the county takes them at their word right now.

I mean, this has gotten our attention, and we don't even live there.
The fact that it got our attention is precisely why I think they won't do it again.

There is no "antisocial behavior" involved here.

The county and city set up a system to allow people to pay for particular services or opt out.

All the FD did was to comply with that agreement.
I was talking about Cranick's and the other non-subscribers' anti-social behavior there--free-riding on the townsfolk, the behavior the SFFD is trying to curb.

Now THAT is stupidity!
Yep, that's pretty dumb. Somebody probably should have had their house burnt down.
 
Evidence has been presented that it is.

I'm more than willing to give credence to the informed judgment of professionals in the same line of work, in the same part of the country, with the same problems and issues.

Why aren't you?

I mean, they say that they have successfully dealt with same sort of problem. Do you think they are lying? Why would they do that? Why would they diss their own, in the same state, no less. What percentage is there for them to cast baseless aspersions against their own fellow professionals?

you seem to be ignoring this evidence from the UCFD in the SAME COUNTY. (same link as was provided upthread by pondiringturtle.

The remaining 5 city fire departments have for years responded into the county without a subscription service, banking on collecting fees for their services, “after the fact.” The problem has been, that once those people have been provided the service; they often seem to choose not to reimburse. Attempting to charge on a per call basis does not generate the needed funds nor does it give county residents an incentive to support the cities, if they can wait until they actually have a fire to pay anything.
and later
The fire chiefs have spent four years working with the county to address the problem Nothing short of a true fire tax will remedy the situation completely. But for now the county at this time is considering everyone going to a subscription service. Yes, this would help fund the remaining 5 departments, but it will not keep what happened to South Fulton from happening again.

No firefighter wants to see a home go up in flames; but especially for the volunteer departments, the cake sales and fish fries just don’t cut it anymore. One set of gear to out fit a firefighter can exceed $3,000. A fire truck easily costs more than a quarter of a million dollars. How many cakes do you think it will take? And who again is paying for this? The “city” taxpayer.

Yup, appears to working like charm in Obion County. :rolleyes:

Of course, this is just an opinion piece after all. Its not like the writer is somehow familiar with the specific situation of fighting fighting and keeping a FD funded in Obion county. I mean he is just the fire chief of the Union City Fire Department, the largest Fire Department in Obion County, why would he have any useful insight on the matter? I am sure that firefighters in other counties and other states have a much better grasp of the local situation and difficulties of getting payment from non-subscribers then he does.
 
Are we watching a baseless rumor being born?

It would seem that his wife, at least, wasn't. Since she claims to have routinely paid the fee in the past, and regretted being delinquent this time. Must have made for hot times in the old homestead even when it wasn't in flames.

You people are a hoot to watch. "No ideology here. Nope. No, no, no. We're just talking facts."

:rolleyes:

nice job of completely missing the point.

I was not accusing the Cranicks of being FOTL loons, but criticizing the county for setting up a system of fire protection eerily similar to what those FOTL loons propose as the ideal society, which allows individuals to 'opt out' of what the rest of civilization considers basic public services.

The problem is not whether the Cranick's were at fault or not, but that what happened to them is a natural and expected consequence of the asinine system that the county has set up.

With the economy in the tough situation it is now, It is entirely conceivable that a resident of Obion County (with a 10% unemployment rate) loses his/her job and now is spending every cent of savings to not default on the mortgage, so does not have the $75 available to pay the subscription fee. That person is now in the same situation as the Cranick's and may be the next person to watch his/her house burn down.

It was this type of asinine situation that I was insulting by calling it the FOTL ideal.
 
I was talking about Cranick's and the other non-subscribers' anti-social behavior there--free-riding on the townsfolk, the behavior the SFFD is trying to curb.

I know. I don't consider that anti-social behavior. There's nothing anti-social about opting out of coverage. Under the system they have, that's their right.

The FD wasn't punishing anti-social behavior. They were simply accepting their part of the bargain as it stood.
 
Yep, that's pretty dumb. Somebody probably should have had their house burnt down.

If only.

People were actually killed. Year after year.

And these idiots let it go on.

A burned trailer is nothing compared to that.
 
There is an additional cost for increasing the scope (area and buildings) of their service area for South Fulton. Proportionately, more than the FDNY covering Yonkers.
The marginal costs for each additional household covered will be pretty low; most of the costs of running a fire department are fixed. They're probably capable of collecting at least that much. If nothing else, you'd want a subscription for insurance purposes, and they've had at least some success collecting on $500 fees. Don't know if they're still trying to do that.

I can't fathom how you think South Fulton can dramatically increase its coverage area without incurring any extra costs. Is it magical?
I don't really think this is a dramatic increase. They responded to 30 fires within the town in 2008, and 23 outside of town.

And no, it's not magical. It's small. It doesn't have any more than is necessary to provide a minimum level of reliable service to anyone at all. Once you have that, you have enough to provide a reasonable response to fairly large area--enough to cover at least 2,000 households or so, apparently--and you've already taken the biggest budgetary hit. The variable costs (wear and tear, increased risk of equipment loss or injury, whatever else I'm not thinking of) are relatively low.

And you can't significantly reduce that fixed cost by reducing the area covered.

ponderingturtle said:
No it wouldn't. They have very high staffing levels. It would streach the resources thinner, but you don't have an issue with that in this county. They are both cases of people deciding to choose not to pay for a service and getting it from their neighbors for free. The county has had a lot of votes to get coverage for everyone. They vote it down.
I think maybe you don't have a sense of what you're suggesting. There's no way you're going to get an engine from The Rockaways to Yonkers in a reasonable time frame. Only the northernmost parts of New York City have a chance of doing this reliably.

In order to do it, you'd have a shift equipment and manpower north. And there's nowhere to put it. So you're going to have to build new stations. At the very, very least.

So if Yonkers voted this way, what is the difference? It is one political entity passing the buck to their neighbors.
Voted what way?

If you're asking me what I would think if the FDNY were somehow covering all of Yonkers without Yonkers contributing a dime, I would think that New York should negotiate payment for services rendered. If they somehow couldn't do this without allowing houses to burn down, I'd wonder about their competence, but I would oppose letting house burn down to force them to comply.

And then I'd move on. Free ridership is a problem, but I'm not going to let it rule my life when we're talking about not very much money.

And yet I would bet it is a similar size to yonkers. And come on yonkers would not significantly impact the call volume of NYC. Too little population for that.
It's not a matter of whether it would impact the call volume of NYC. It's a matter of whether it would impact the call volume of North Bronx. It would.
 
Last edited:
I don't really think this is a dramatic increase. They responded to 30 fires within the town in 2008, and 23 outside of town.

Good God man!!

What on earth have you been smoking to make a a statement like that?!

How on earth do you conclude that there is no dramatic cost increase when service outside the city has nearly doubled the number of fires they have to fight?

Seriously, what is the logic you used to move from

P1: 30 fires in city
P2: 23 fires outside of city

to

C: Not a dramatic cost increase.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom