Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

Allowing someone's home to burn for want of $75 is insanely disproportionate. What crime, committed with malice, would justify such a punishment?

It's not a punishment to a crime so your analogy doesn't apply.
 
Yup. And this mentality is one of the biggest problems in our country today. Privatized gain, socialized risk.

When will we learn?

You had to bring up the housing/financial crisis. Everyone (well those in the club anyway) was on a nice little earner churning mortgages, because the government would bail them out if it went pear-shaped.
 
Yes, because of Constitutional rules of proportionality.

Allowing someone's home to burn for want of $75 is insanely disproportionate. What crime, committed with malice, would justify such a punishment?

Now obviously the firefighters didn't commit a crime, so don't get ridiculously literal like others have. I am arguing that this sense of proportionality should extend throughout society even when the behavior isn't bound by law. This is one of the ways we create a civil, humane country.

Neither the firefighters or homeowner committed a crime. They just didn't enter into a contract.

What if the fee was $750? $7,500? $75,000? $750,000? Should the firefighters always put out the fire and try to collect later? Where would you draw the line?
 
I didn't bring up that thought experiment for this specific case.

1) Fire departments are now for profit, private industries. There are no fees, no dues, they're just allowed to use the free market to dictate their payment. THey wait until a house is on fire, if no one is there, they put it out and leave a bill. The bill will be enforce through the doctrine of unjust enrichment.

2) If an owner of the home is present, they begin bargaining before the hoses are turned on. That's maximizing their earning potential. Anyone have a problem with that system?

1) The can leave all the bills they want. I'm not paying them if I haven't entered into a contract for those services. Even if I have to for some reason, I give it to the insurance company.

2) Sure. But if we can't reach an agreement, I let it burn down and have the insurance company buy me a brand new house. :)
 
Last edited:
Proper treatment as defined by you. There are other people, equally knowledgable of the law, who think you are completely wrong.

Examples?

Nice emotional appeal. Now you want to drag backward people into your enlightened world because you are so much smarter than the hicks from Obion County. :rolleyes:

Emotional? No, just pointing out the irony. It's amazing that doing something really stupid pursuant to a really stupid system voted on by a group of really stupid people suddenly becomes brilliant when someone has staked out a position in an internet argument.
 
1) The can leave all the bills they want. I'm not paying them if I haven't entered into a contract for those services. Even if I have to for some reason, I give it to the insurance company.

Then you don't understand the law. You will pay or consequences will result.

2) Sure. But if we can't reach an agreement, I let it burn down and have the insurance company buy me a brand new house. :)

And the insurance company points out that you had an opportunity to put out the fire beforehand and denies coverage.
 
Neither the firefighters or homeowner committed a crime. They just didn't enter into a contract.

What if the fee was $750? $7,500? $75,000? $750,000? Should the firefighters always put out the fire and try to collect later? Where would you draw the line?

I literally said it wasn't in a crime in the very post you replied to.

If it's absurdly high, it can be challenged in court.

Yes, the firefighters should always put out the fire if they're capable of doing so. They can recover the cost of their services after the fact.

Similarly, doctors should save people's lives then figure out how to deal with the cost.
 
It's not a punishment to a crime so your analogy doesn't apply.

Please, it was obviously punishment. You didn't pay, we're going to stand idly by and watch your house burn when we have the capability to put it out.

But the concept of "analogy" seems to be causing inordinate problems for the posters in this thread. The principle I'm taking from our Constitution and applying to this case is that of proportionality. The punishment for a crime should be proportional to the severity of the offense.

Now in this case, because the outcome of this situation was fully in the hands of the fire department, I'm arguing that they should abide by the same principle of proportionality. The man failed to pay $75. If I had been a firefighter standing there I would have said, "**** this, I'll write a check for $75 tomorrow, let's put out the fire."

You will undoubtedly argue that this is empty internet bravado, but I have done a similar thing many times with clients who were unable to pay. It was $75.

The proper consequence for failing to pay $75 is a fine or being charged for expenses. It is insane to just let the house burn. And again, there were available legal remedies for the fire department to collect on that bill, as humans living in the United States collect on money owed to them every goddamn day.
 
This thread is starting to astound me. I am reminded of when I read some of the Sword of Truth novels where, Goodkind tried to get political. He set up, what I considered at the time, a ridiculous cariacture of socialism as a strawman to knock down in support of his libertarian views.
One of the most annoying aspects was his portrayal of socialists as lazy wastrels who expected to do nothing and have everything provided for them in the name of equality. Needless to say, based on that blatant strawman, I rejected his political arguments.

Now, I read this thread and there are several people arguing passionately for that very strawman of socialism as if its a good thing and can work in the long run. They do this because this county set up the Libertarian ideal in regards to fire service and it failed miserably and spectacularly.

The problem is that just because Libertarianism did not work, does not mean that a preposterous version of socialism (one in which the city is required to take care of county residents who refuse to put into the system) will work either.

What will work is responsible, real socialism. One in which county residents understand that if they find it such a disgrace that sombody's house is allowed to burn down because he did not pay his FD fees, then they need to as a community (as in evil communism) remove that possibility by paying taxes to support a Fire Department that will provide servcie on demand.

It is easy to get moralistic and blame the SFFD for allowing the house to burn because, when looked at in isolation, it does look like a complete dick move on their part. However, this did not happen in isolation.

Desptie several suggestions that just bill later, use a promisory note or whatever, the evidence suggests that that has already been tried and has not worked. the UCFD (another municipal FD in the same county) already has a website (that's been linked earlier in the thread) in which they complain that they have been left underfunded because of refussals to pay after the fact. It is therefore likely the case for all of the municipal FD in that county.

At some point, the FD will reach its limit in its capcity to serve an area that will not properly fund them. The actions of the SFFD are an indication they have already reached and gone beyond that point. They have spent years providing the service in good faith, while trying to work out the financials with the county, but so far, as long as the servcie is provided, the county sees no reason to address the funding shortfall.

I have a sneaking suspcion (based on election results that show that the county voted even heavier for McCain in 2008 then they did for Bush in 2004) that this has a lot do with Tea Party conservatism and the view that taxes = socialism = evil.

As many have argued in the Health Care threads, why don't people object to socialist Police or Fire departments. Well Obion county did, and this is the result. A stupid, pointless, preventable situation, in which a guy loses his home because Free Market ideals pushed the FD past its breaking point and did not provide a service for the simple and sole reason that it was not paid for.

Note to people of Obion county. Don't expect services to be provided as public services if you refuse to fund them publicly.
 
Last edited:
Please, it was obviously punishment. You didn't pay, we're going to stand idly by and watch your house burn when we have the capability to put it out.

But the concept of "analogy" seems to be causing inordinate problems for the posters in this thread. The principle I'm taking from our Constitution and applying to this case is that of proportionality. The punishment for a crime should be proportional to the severity of the offense.

Now in this case, because the outcome of this situation was fully in the hands of the fire department, I'm arguing that they should abide by the same principle of proportionality. The man failed to pay $75. If I had been a firefighter standing there I would have said, "**** this, I'll write a check for $75 tomorrow, let's put out the fire."

You will undoubtedly argue that this is empty internet bravado, but I have done a similar thing many times with clients who were unable to pay. It was $75.

The proper consequence for failing to pay $75 is a fine or being charged for expenses. It is insane to just let the house burn. And again, there were available legal remedies for the fire department to collect on that bill, as humans living in the United States collect on money owed to them every goddamn day.

You continue to ignore that this was, apparently, not the first time Mr Cranick had "forgotten" to pay his $75 and had to beg the Fire Dept to save his property. In fact, my understanding (what little I've seen about it) is that Mr Cranick was still paying off his debt to the Fire Dept from that first fire a few years prior.

Now, to the Mayor/Fire Chief in SF, this surely seems like a case of a freeloader. He already had his one chance to shape up - and he didn't. In fact, he chose again to not contract with the FD expecting that he'd be able to just beg their assistance in the case of a future fire.

If I'm the Mayor/Fire Chief (or even the Firefighter) involved, I would make the same call "He doesn't want to support our fire service, Let It Burn".


That, my friend, is proportional.
 
This thread is starting to astound me. I am reminded of when I read some of the Sword of Truth novels where, Goodkind tried to get political. He set up, what I considered at the time, a ridiculous cariacture of socialism as a strawman to knock down in support of his libertarian views.
One of the most annoying aspects was his portrayal of socialists as lazy wastrels who expected to do nothing and have everything provided for them in the name of equality. Needless to say, based on that blatant strawman, I rejected his political arguments.

Now, I read this thread and there are several people arguing passionately for that very strawman of socialism as if its a good thing and can work in the long run. They do this because this county set up the Libertarian ideal in regards to fire service and it failed miserably and spectacularly.

The problem is that just because Libertarianism did not work, does not mean that a preposterous version of socialism (one in which the city is required to take care of county residents who refuse to put into the system) will work either.

What will work is responsible, real socialism. One in which county residents understand that if they find it such a disgrace that sombody's house is allowed to burn down because he did not pay his FD fees, then they need to as a community (as in evil communism) remove that possibility by paying taxes to support a Fire Department that will provide servcie on demand.

It is easy to get moralistic and blame the SFFD for allowing the house to burn because, when looked at in isolation, it does look like a complete dick move on their part. However, this did not happen in isolation.

Desptie several suggestions that just bill later, use a promisory note or whatever, the evidence suggests that that has already been tried and has not worked. the UCFD (another municipal FD in the same county) already has a website (that's been linked earlier in the thread) in which they complain that they have been left underfunded because of refussals to pay after the fact. It is therefore likely the case for all of the municipal FD in that county.

At some point, the FD will reach its limit in its capcity to serve an area that will not properly fund them. The actions of the SFFD are an indication they have already reached and gone beyond that point. They have spent years providing the service in good faith, while trying to work out the financials with the county, but so far, as long as the servcie is provided, the county sees no reason to address the funding shortfall.

I have a sneaking suspcion (based on election results that show that the county voted even heavier for McCain in 2008 then they did for Bush in 2004) that this has a lot do with Tea Party conservatism and the view that taxes = socialism = evil.

As many have argued in the Health Care threads, why don't people object to socialist Police or Fire departments. Well Obion county did, and this is the result. A stupid, pointless, preventable situation, in which a guy loses his home because Free Market ideals pushed the FD past its breaking point and did not provide a service for the simple and sole reason that it was not paid for.

Note to people of Obion county. Don't expect services to be provided as public services if you refuse to fund them publicly.

While I wouldn't say "the Libertarian ideal in regards to fire service... failed miserably and spectacularly" - it worked just like it was supposed to- I agree wholeheartedly with this.
 
You continue to ignore that this was, apparently, not the first time Mr Cranick had "forgotten" to pay his $75 and had to beg the Fire Dept to save his property. In fact, my understanding (what little I've seen about it) is that Mr Cranick was still paying off his debt to the Fire Dept from that first fire a few years prior.

So? If they could enforce the prior debt, why not add on a few hundred dollars more. Presumeably there's some existing equity in that home. The fees aren't that much money.

Now, to the Mayor/Fire Chief in SF, this surely seems like a case of a freeloader. He already had his one chance to shape up - and he didn't. In fact, he chose again to not contract with the FD expecting that he'd be able to just beg their assistance in the case of a future fire.

If I'm the Mayor/Fire Chief (or even the Firefighter) involved, I would make the same call "He doesn't want to support our fire service, Let It Burn".


That, my friend, is proportional.

No, it really isn't. What was the total amount of his freeloading?
 
So? If they could enforce the prior debt, why not add on a few hundred dollars more. Presumeably there's some existing equity in that home. The fees aren't that much money.

No, it really isn't. What was the total amount of his freeloading?

Let's say this guy had cholesterol problems and refused to change his diet. He refuses to heed his doctor's advice and stops paying for his $60 office visits and his $4 generic medications. The doctor and the pharmacist stand by and do nothing to force him to comply with their directions. He gets a stroke, loses control of the left side of his body, his speech centre, and basically cannot care for himself anymore, forcing his wife into a permenent care-giver role.

Is that "proportional"? Are they "punishing" him?
 
Some interesting commentary from "Billy G" at http://www.firefighterclosecalls.com/news/fullstory/newsid/118558

BillyG said:
...Word is that the Fire Chiefs of Obion County have worked for many years to offer the county elected folks a proposal of a fire tax or have them just fund the 8 municipality fire departments, a reported $360,000 total, to provide ALL residences of the unincorporated areas of the county, a fire service. However the elected county commission refuses to force a tax on their citizens.

We were also advised that the homeowner (who lost his house) was sent 3 letters reminding him of his fire dues, and after that they called him 3 times and each time he said he would pay, but after the third phone call the FD dropped his name off the list. They still should have put it out. Of course, little did we (us) know that the FD subscription was set up 20 years ago because someone’s house outside a city limits burned, and the city wanted to provide service to those residences (where there is no other fire service) so the subscription service was started to help. City taxpayers did not want to fund a free FD for non-taxpaying residents, outside their city. No one does...
From my point of view as a volunteer FF, I couldn't roll up on a burning house and not do anything. For one thing, it's too much fun. For another, and perhaps slightly more important reason, it's why we're there. And, personally, there's no way I would let the animals die without an attempt to save them if there was a decent chance of making a rescue.

But I'm in a combination system in a wealthy, high-tax county in a high-tax state, with additional money from federal grants and donations, plus automatic mutual aid agreements with other counties with about eight surrounding jurisdictions. Our situation is quite different than the one in question. And, if the above information is correct, this guy bears some responsibility for making a really poor decision. You don't take a chance on losing your home by not paying a $75 fee to maintain the department you want to come put it out if it catches fire.
 
You continue to ignore that this was, apparently, not the first time Mr Cranick had "forgotten" to pay his $75 and had to beg the Fire Dept to save his property. In fact, my understanding (what little I've seen about it) is that Mr Cranick was still paying off his debt to the Fire Dept from that first fire a few years prior.

<snip>


Are you sure you're not getting your Mr. Cranicks confused. The mention I saw of another incident involved a different Mr. Cranick (a son) at a different property.

If he's paying off his debt, what is the problem? I thought the main objection hinged on all the "freeloaders" who'd refuse to.

Oh, well. Let's not let facts or consistency interfere with ideology. It just confuses people.
 
Please, it was obviously punishment. You didn't pay, we're going to stand idly by and watch your house burn when we have the capability to put it out.

Only if you completely ignore what the word "punish" means.

First, it requires that the person being punished did something in the past that the punisher is punishing them for.

Did the home owner commit a wrong against the fire department?

No, they chose not to pay the fire protection fee which they had every right to do. There is no "wrong" here."

Was the fire department the punisher?

No, they are the fire department.

Was failing to fight the fire a punishment?

No, it was a result of a series of previous events with little, or no, moral basis.
 
Let's say this guy had cholesterol problems and refused to change his diet. He refuses to heed his doctor's advice and stops paying for his $60 office visits and his $4 generic medications. The doctor and the pharmacist stand by and do nothing to force him to comply with their directions. He gets a stroke, loses control of the left side of his body, his speech centre, and basically cannot care for himself anymore, forcing his wife into a permenent care-giver role.

Is that "proportional"? Are they "punishing" him?

If they were capable of stopping the stroke and chose not to, yes.

Bad comparison.
 
I thought the main objection hinged on all the "freeloaders" who'd refuse to.

You thought wrong. The main objection is that the Cranicks didn't pay the fee and so by policy the fire department won't fight fires on their property.

That pretty much covers it.
 
Only if you completely ignore what the word "punish" means.

[...]

No, it was a result of a series of previous events with little, or no, moral basis.

He didn't pay the dues, the consequence for want of $75 is that firemen stood by and watched his house burn. They couldn't put out the fire and just choke on $75 because that would send a bad example to the rest of the county.

What is it called when someone is willfully made to suffer to keep others in line?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom