TruthSeeker1234
Banned
- Joined
- Sep 9, 2006
- Messages
- 1,756
All right, as I explained in my edit, I was pointing out that one of your "why gold is a good currency" arguments was circular. You clearly indicate that gold is a good currency because people consider it valuable. You have mentioned that it's primary value is as currency. You are, therefore, claiming gold is valuable because of its use as a currency, and by extension its good qualities as a currency contribute to its value because it is accepted as a currency on the market.
Stop it Johnny. My reasoning is in no way circular. Prior to the existence of gold money, there was a demand for gold as a commodity. That is, people valued it. Commodity monies emerged in response to the problems of barter. Additional demand for gold thus arose, the original demand for gold, plus the new demand for gold as a medium of exchange. The additional demand will make gold more highly valued.
Something which was not valuable could not function as money, because people would not accept it in exchange. Therefore, to function as money, a commodity must have a high pre-existing market exchange value. None of this is circular reasoning.
If you're going to claim gold's value is in its use as currency, you cannot separate its value from its function as a good money. The two are one and the same.
I don't claim gold's value, centuries of human history do. As explained, gold's value derives from the demand for it. This demand is partly due to it's pre-existing value as a commodity, and then additionally due to it's value as a medium of exchange.
The value/weight relationship cannot have meaning without a priori or market value. Your arguments concerned the (as you claim) sudden emergence of gold as a currency standard.
Where on earth have I ever said the gold standard emerged suddenly? I said it emerged spontaneously. The spontaneous emergence of the gold standard took place over thousands of years.
To say that it is valuable as a currency, and was a good choice for currency because of its value/weight ratio is circular.
No. Explained. Many things were used as money, all of them commodities with pre-existing market demand. Gold emerged as the best of the lot.
But that's just distracting from the real issues at hand. Claiming I am intellectually dishonest doesn't make you any more right.
Stop using the strawman fallacy and I'll stop calling you on it.
What stops you from using gold as a currency right now? You keep talking about how people should be free, but they are - nothing stops you from buying and selling gold. You could hold all your money in gold, then sell only enough to pay expenses to those who won't accept gold but want, say, US dollars instead.
In 1913, refusal to accept paper money was made a felony. In 1933, all the monetary gold was confiscated by the government, and its possession was made a felony. Making gold a felony tends to discourage its use, wouldn't you say?
Also, you claim that any money supply is optimal. In a very base way, this tends to be theoretically true in an ideal, model market. However, this tends not to be the case in the real world. Even when the gold standard existed, there were issues related to the money supply. I already gave one historical example of money supply issues with a gold standard you haven't bothered to reply to yet.
Any money supply is optimal. If this were false, then you could not explain why there is even one poor country. All any country would need to do is create more money, and be rich. Money is a medium of exchange, prices will adjust to any supply of money.
Sorry, must have missed your history lesson. Link it.