federal reserve conspiracy!!!

All right, as I explained in my edit, I was pointing out that one of your "why gold is a good currency" arguments was circular. You clearly indicate that gold is a good currency because people consider it valuable. You have mentioned that it's primary value is as currency. You are, therefore, claiming gold is valuable because of its use as a currency, and by extension its good qualities as a currency contribute to its value because it is accepted as a currency on the market.

Stop it Johnny. My reasoning is in no way circular. Prior to the existence of gold money, there was a demand for gold as a commodity. That is, people valued it. Commodity monies emerged in response to the problems of barter. Additional demand for gold thus arose, the original demand for gold, plus the new demand for gold as a medium of exchange. The additional demand will make gold more highly valued.

Something which was not valuable could not function as money, because people would not accept it in exchange. Therefore, to function as money, a commodity must have a high pre-existing market exchange value. None of this is circular reasoning.

If you're going to claim gold's value is in its use as currency, you cannot separate its value from its function as a good money. The two are one and the same.

I don't claim gold's value, centuries of human history do. As explained, gold's value derives from the demand for it. This demand is partly due to it's pre-existing value as a commodity, and then additionally due to it's value as a medium of exchange.

The value/weight relationship cannot have meaning without a priori or market value. Your arguments concerned the (as you claim) sudden emergence of gold as a currency standard.

Where on earth have I ever said the gold standard emerged suddenly? I said it emerged spontaneously. The spontaneous emergence of the gold standard took place over thousands of years.

To say that it is valuable as a currency, and was a good choice for currency because of its value/weight ratio is circular.

No. Explained. Many things were used as money, all of them commodities with pre-existing market demand. Gold emerged as the best of the lot.

But that's just distracting from the real issues at hand. Claiming I am intellectually dishonest doesn't make you any more right.

Stop using the strawman fallacy and I'll stop calling you on it.

What stops you from using gold as a currency right now? You keep talking about how people should be free, but they are - nothing stops you from buying and selling gold. You could hold all your money in gold, then sell only enough to pay expenses to those who won't accept gold but want, say, US dollars instead.

In 1913, refusal to accept paper money was made a felony. In 1933, all the monetary gold was confiscated by the government, and its possession was made a felony. Making gold a felony tends to discourage its use, wouldn't you say?

Also, you claim that any money supply is optimal. In a very base way, this tends to be theoretically true in an ideal, model market. However, this tends not to be the case in the real world. Even when the gold standard existed, there were issues related to the money supply. I already gave one historical example of money supply issues with a gold standard you haven't bothered to reply to yet.

Any money supply is optimal. If this were false, then you could not explain why there is even one poor country. All any country would need to do is create more money, and be rich. Money is a medium of exchange, prices will adjust to any supply of money.

Sorry, must have missed your history lesson. Link it.
 
My english is just fine and I've lived in Europe for just 30 years. :D

Ace I'll add history and economics to the ever expanding list of "Stuff Ace knows diddle squat about". The 20s crash was caused by several reasons, but essentially the stock market was phenomenally over valued. Similar to the web stock boom in the 90s. People were buying stock on the assumption that it would automatically rise. It was a bubble and it burst.

This is the most achingly thunder headed maddeningly stupid argument I've ever seen proposed, since, well, the last time Ace spoke. There's no point even arguing with someone who is so spectacularly wrong. We just need to pick our jaws up off the floor, shake our heads, walk away and wonder, "Millions of sperm, and he was the fastest?"



Oh and BTW. ABBY RULEZ!

Hi 8den-

Anyone who claims to explain the business cycle must explain two empirical points.

1. Why the cluster of entrepreneurial errors? Any investor can make mistakes, but why the big cluster?
2. Why is the mal-investment most heavily concentrated in the capital goods sector?

The ABCT explains this in a very straightforward and compelling fashion. What is your explanation, professor 8den?
 
Stop it Johnny. My reasoning is in no way circular. Prior to the existence of gold money, there was a demand for gold as a commodity. That is, people valued it.


Yes, but why did people value it? Gold can't be planted. It can't be eaten. It can't be converted to energy. Until very recently, gold had no function whatsoever. (It is now of small value in medicine, slightly more value in electronics and I think at its most valuable in the creation of certain industrial chemicals .) Until very recently, the only thing people liked about gold was that it was rare and shiny.

That value - shiny - is utterly arbitrary. There is nothing necessarily true about gold's ability to please the senses. My wife's engagement ring has no gold in it.

Since the demand for gold is arbitrary, your argument is circular. The gold market could collapse tomorrow when a nicer, more aesthetically pleasing substance is isolated. What would gold be worth if platinum did not exist? Or silver? Or even brass?

Something which was not valuable could not function as money, because people would not accept it in exchange. Therefore, to function as money, a commodity must have a high pre-existing market exchange value. None of this is circular reasoning.


Examine:

1. I do not find gold aesthetically pleasing.
2. I do not wish to own gold for its aesthetic properties.
3. Other people put a value on gold.
4. I need to get stuff from other people.
5. If I give them gold, they'll give me stuff in exchange.
6. Even though I do not find gold aesthetically pleasing, I wish to own gold for the value others place on it.
7. Thus, gold has value to me.

Now watch this. Nothing up my sleeves:

1. I do not find paper money aesthetically pleasing.
2. I do not wish to own paper money for its aesthetic properties.
3. Other people put a value on paper money.
4. I need to get stuff from other people.
5. If I give them paper money, they'll give me stuff in exchange.
6. Even though I do not find paper money aesthetically pleasing, I wish to own paper money for the value others place on it.
7. Thus, paper money has value to me.

But the real reason we know that your statement "Something which was not valuable could not function as money" is utter nonsense is because paper is functioning as money. And it's doing so quite well all over the world. And it has no intrinsic value.

Honestly, if you wouldn't work backwards from your conclusions, you'd be able to understand this stuff so much better.
 
Yes, but why did people value it? Gold can't be planted. It can't be eaten. It can't be converted to energy. Until very recently, gold had no function whatsoever. (It is now of small value in medicine, slightly more value in electronics and I think at its most valuable in the creation of certain industrial chemicals .) Until very recently, the only thing people liked about gold was that it was rare and shiny.

That value - shiny - is utterly arbitrary. There is nothing necessarily true about gold's ability to please the senses. My wife's engagement ring has no gold in it.

Since the demand for gold is arbitrary, your argument is circular. The gold market could collapse tomorrow when a nicer, more aesthetically pleasing substance is isolated. What would gold be worth if platinum did not exist? Or silver? Or even brass?




Examine:

1. I do not find gold aesthetically pleasing.
2. I do not wish to own gold for its aesthetic properties.
3. Other people put a value on gold.
4. I need to get stuff from other people.
5. If I give them gold, they'll give me stuff in exchange.
6. Even though I do not find gold aesthetically pleasing, I wish to own gold for the value others place on it.
7. Thus, gold has value to me.

Now watch this. Nothing up my sleeves:

1. I do not find paper money aesthetically pleasing.
2. I do not wish to own paper money for its aesthetic properties.
3. Other people put a value on paper money.
4. I need to get stuff from other people.
5. If I give them paper money, they'll give me stuff in exchange.
6. Even though I do not find paper money aesthetically pleasing, I wish to own paper money for the value others place on it.
7. Thus, paper money has value to me.

But the real reason we know that your statement "Something which was not valuable could not function as money" is utter nonsense is because paper is functioning as money. And it's doing so quite well all over the world. And it has no intrinsic value.

Honestly, if you wouldn't work backwards from your conclusions, you'd be able to understand this stuff so much better.

If what you say is true, government would not have had to use force to impose fiat money.

Here is the crucial difference that you fail to appreciate:

Gold money evolved through free choice. When given the freedom to choose, people chose to accept commodities as money, especially precious metals, and gold above all others. Nobody forced this outcome, it was spontaneous. Please look up "spontaneous" if you are like Jonny5 and don't know what that means.

Fiat money did not evolve through free choice. When given the freedom to choose, people did not choose to accept unbacked paper money, ever. There are exactly zero historical examples of this. Ludwig von Mises proved in a rigorous way that money must originate as a commodity. It must.

Here is your comparison, corrected:

Examine:

1. I do not find gold aesthetically pleasing.
2. I do not wish to own gold for its aesthetic properties.
3. Other people (the market) put a value on gold.
4. I need to get stuff from other people.
5. If I give them gold, they'll give me stuff in exchange.
6. Even though I do not find gold aesthetically pleasing, I wish to own gold for the value others place on it.
7. Thus, gold has value to me.
8. And thus, gold is now demanded for its exchange value, in addition to its pre-existing values.

Now watch this. Nothing up my sleeves:

1. I do not find [unbacked] paper money aesthetically pleasing.
2. I do not wish to own [unbakced] paper money for its aesthetic properties.
3. Other people [the market] do not put a value on [unbacked] paper money.
4. I need to get stuff from other people.
5. If I offer them [unbacked] paper money, they'll tell me to go fly a kite.
6. Because I do not find [unbacked] paper money aesthetically pleasing, and because the market finds it essentially worthless, I do not wish to own [unbacked] paper money.
7. Thus, paper money has no value to me.
8. And thus, [unbacked] paper money is intrinsically worthless, and also worthless to free people as a medium of exchange.



Alternatively:

1. I do not find [redeemable] paper money aesthetically pleasing.
2. I do not wish to own [redeemable] paper money for its aesthetic properties.
3. Other people put a value on [redeemable] paper money, because they can readily exchange it for gold or silver.
4. I need to get stuff from other people.
5. If I give them [redeemable] paper money, they'll give me stuff in exchange.
6. Even though I do not find [redeemable] paper money aesthetically pleasing, I wish to own [redeemable] paper money for its value to others.
7. Thus, [redeemable] paper money has value to me.
8. And thus, [redeemable] paper money, though intrinsically worthless, becomes valued as a medium of exchange.

And finally:

1. I do not find [unbacked] paper money aesthetically pleasing.
2. I do not wish to own [unbacked] paper money for its aesthetic properties.
3. The government makes it a felony to refuse acceptance of [unbacked] paper money, and confiscates all the gold.
4. I need to get stuff from other people.
5. If I give them [unbacked] paper money, they'll go to jail if they refuse to accept it, so they are forced to give me stuff in exchange.
6. Even though I do not find [unbacked] paper money aesthetically pleasing, I wish to own [unbacked] paper money, because the government has left me with no choice, other than to revert to barter.
7. Thus, [unbacked] paper money has value to me.
8. And thus, [unbacked] paper money, though intrinsically worthless, and irredeemable, becomes valued as a medium of exchange.
 
Last edited:
Truthseeker, please respond to my comments. You asked for some critique of that article, and after glancing at two sections I found cause for criticism.
 
@GregoryUrich

To increase the money supply, the Fed buy's financial instruments by crediting the sellers reserve account. No account is debited.

The Fed can also the amount of legal reserves and expand the money supply with no account being debited. What exactly is your point?

Tell me something, how do they balance their books if no debit is being made? Isn't duality one of the generally accepted principles of accountancy?

My god.

It makes one wonder why did you leave this part out of your post even when it was in the same paragraph:

so existing balances held at the Federal Reserve are redistributed from one depository institution to another without changing the total available.

... I believe you are confused with a very simple fact: how exactly do you think The Fed increases the money supply?
 
Gold money evolved through free choice. When given the freedom to choose, people chose to accept commodities as money, especially precious metals, and gold above all others. Nobody forced this outcome, it was spontaneous.


Really? Nobody forced the gold standard?

Jeez.

Well, whatever you do, don't tell this guy.
 
TruthSeeker1234: people are free to use stuff like liberty dollars or gold. Why don't they use it? You are free to choose not to seek financing for a small project by using your home as a security to get a 6% interest rate.

On another note, can you point me to an example of a government forcing people to use fiat currency?

I do hope your example is not some law forbidding you to print print 20's on your backyard.
 
Truthseeker, please respond to my comments. You asked for some critique of that article, and after glancing at two sections I found cause for criticism.

First, I'm asking for criticism of this concept:

The creation of fiat money is theft. It necessarily transfers real wealth away from the late receivers of new money, and into the hands of the early receivers, and especially into the hands of the money creators.

Second, I did not link you to an "article", I linked you to a "treatise".

Your "criticism" amounted to your declaration that devaluation of a money will boost exports, so a strong currency is "bad" for exports and thus bad for the "balance of trade".

Your error is demolished in chapter 1, "The value of exchange".

All trade balances. For every buyer, there is a seller. Both parties expect to benefit, or else they would not agree to trade. If anything, boosting exports is a bad idea, because in involves sending goods away where they are consumed by others. Real wealth consists of real goods and real services.
 
@GregoryUrich



The Fed can also the amount of legal reserves and expand the money supply with no account being debited. What exactly is your point?

Tell me something, how do they balance their books if no debit is being made? Isn't duality one of the generally accepted principles of accountancy?

My god.

It makes one wonder why did you leave this part out of your post even when it was in the same paragraph:

so existing balances held at the Federal Reserve are redistributed from one depository institution to another without changing the total available.

... I believe you are confused with a very simple fact: how exactly do you think The Fed increases the money supply?

Read it again Al and get back to me.
 
First, I'm asking for criticism of this concept:

The creation of fiat money is theft. It necessarily transfers real wealth away from the late receivers of new money, and into the hands of the early receivers, and especially into the hands of the money creators.

Second, I did not link you to an "article", I linked you to a "treatise".

Your "criticism" amounted to your declaration that devaluation of a money will boost exports, so a strong currency is "bad" for exports and thus bad for the "balance of trade".

Your error is demolished in chapter 1, "The value of exchange".

All trade balances. For every buyer, there is a seller. Both parties expect to benefit, or else they would not agree to trade. If anything, boosting exports is a bad idea, because in involves sending goods away where they are consumed by others. Real wealth consists of real goods and real services.

Noooo. The trade balance by definition is amount exported subtracted by amount imported. GDP is increased with a larger trade balance. A negative one must be made up through the capital account. Do you know what that is?

Re: boosting exports bad. What??? Tell that to the companies that work in the country of question. Tell that to the employees of these companies. Foreign trade is bad? You do know that in return for these goods, money is acquired right? Have you ever heard of comparative advantage?

Good grief, what industry do you work in where foreign trade is bad for business and as a result the economy?

Yes, real wealth is real goods and real services. And guess what. A strong dollar means less goods (all goods are "real") can be purchased by other countries. Look up the real exchange rate.

You continously misdefine basic, basic concepts here.

And again, why does this "treatise" treat all inflation as unexpected? He doesn't address unanticipated inflation in his discussion of inflation=bad.

Edited to add: just looked at your link in the above quote. Says zilch about the international exchange rate.
 
On another note, can you point me to an example of a government forcing people to use fiat currency?

Yes. The Federal Reserve Act of 1913. Besides creating the Fed, it made it a felony to refuse to accept "Federal Reserve Notes" in payment of debt. At the time, many contracts were written to be paid in gold. The government effectively tore up all those contracts.

In 1933, the US govt. confiscated all of the monetary gold, making it a felony to even possess. People were indeed put in jail for the "crime" of wanting to hold on to their own gold coins.

These are two very important events in US history. I wonder why they are not taught in school?
 
Truth seeker, do you know how the Keynesian multiplier and the money multiplier are derived?
 
Abby, I said "if anything" boosting exports is bad. If one country ended up with all the dollars, and another ended up with all the goods, the one with the goods wins. As I said, trade balances. When two parties agree to trade, both benefit. Every free trade increases Pareto optimality.

The benefits of trade accrue whether the trading partner is across the street, or across the ocean. Economics does not recognize borders. The analysis is exactly the same. Therefore, there is no such thing as a "trade surplus" or a "trade deficit". These are artificial constructs which serve to indoctrinate people with nationalism and fear of foreigners.

I run a trade deficit with my grocery store. I spend hundreds of dollars a week there, and they never buy anything from me. Ever. Is this a dire problem that needs to be fixed by monetary policy? No.

Yes, definitions are important. For example, inflation. The Austrians subscribe to the quantity theory of money, and inflation is defined as an increase in the quantity of money beyond the increase in goods and services. Rising prices are a symptom of inflation.

On the free market, the supply of money is expected to keep pace with the supply of goods and services, because on the market, all businesses (including the production of money) tend toward the same rate of return on investment. Thus, analyzed correctly, all inflation is "unexpected".

Abby, I know that, according to mainstream econ, Austrian econ is "wrong". The reverse is also true. The difference is, there exist scholarly refutations of Keynesian and Chicago-monetarist economics. I am not aware of any scholarly, rigorous refutations of Austrian theory.

So, I am asking to you to begin by giving us an explanation of where my (Austrian) analysis of fiat money is in error. Again, I say fiat money is theft. I have given a very clear explanation of why that is so. If you disagree, give me an explanation.
 
Truthseeker, do you know what the capital account is?

Because you have a distorted view of how international trade works, and I am a little tired of explaining things to you.

I've made my comments on your treatise repeatedly. You just don't have the abilities to refute Keynes and/or Friedman on your own.

You've linked to a sight that misses things completely (example unexpected inflation, which I have brought up time and time again).

Here's another one. The "treatise" author mentions that a devalued currency is an embarrassment for the countries gov't. This completely misses all the times that gov'ts DEVALUE ON PURPOSE. Look up Nixon and Japan.

But I am done. You have a very poor understanding of things you purport to be wrong.
 
Yes, Abby, I know what is meant by "the capital account".

Gone, eh. So the answer evidently is "No, Abby Scott cannot refute Ace Baker's (Austrian based) claim that fiat money is theft.

Anyone else?
 
TS1234

Besides creating the Fed, it made it a felony to refuse to accept "Federal Reserve Notes" in payment of debt.

So you would rather banks demanding whatever they want as payment for people's debt? I believe it is completely rational to establish by law a currency that financial institution must accept as payment for obligations.

Let's do something, let's challenge these illuminati bastards. Lend me 15,000 US$ and i'll pay them back to you in green bottles filled with sand ... 15 of them. Come on, let's stick it to the man.

In 1933, the US govt. confiscated all of the monetary gold, making it a felony to even possess. People were indeed put in jail for the "crime" of wanting to hold on to their own gold coins.

Are you talking about Executive Order 6102? If so, it was a forced sale not a confiscation of private property. The argument from your side resides on the intrinsic value of gold, you could convert your gold coins to bullions and still have the same wealth ... right?

Getting a little off topic, if the Fed is privately owned: which corporations employ the current board of directors and chairman?
 
Yes, Abby, I know what is meant by "the capital account".

Gone, eh. So the answer evidently is "No, Abby Scott cannot refute Ace Baker's (Austrian based) claim that fiat money is theft.

Anyone else?

Okay, tell me what it is.

Good grief! I gave you criticisms. You still haven't addressed the unexpected inflation I mentioned. You have yet to address the incorrect idea that devaluation is always "embarrasing" to economists. In refutation of that you posted something that has absolutely nothing to do with international trade.

You. Don't. Know. What. You. Are. Talking. About.

This is exactly why I quit our email back and forth. You would make a statement, I would correct it, and you'd make the same statement.

Here, here is your refutation to the fiat = theft arguement: No. No it's not.

There! With less generic backing than the "treatise" you put fourth. That treatise is right up there with intelligent design. It makes distorted, sweepingly simple statements so that individuals with no economic background say, "Gee, that sounds right." Face it, you don't understand the background material enough to say whether or not mr. Ace is correct.


Or else, tell me: why does he avoid unanticipated inflation, why does he avoid devaluation as a valid governmental tool, how are the multipliers derived, what is the IS/LM curve, how do monetarists and Keynesians differ, what is the capital account, what is meant by the real exchange rate.

You need to know this stuff to make the judgements you are making.


Edited to add: See? This is why internet posters are such asses. I post something politely correcting something. It gets thrown back at me. I correct again. What do I then see? The same poop! Over and over and over again! AAAAAAGGGGHHHH. Stupid internets.
 
Last edited:
Abby, I did so address "unexpected inflation", and so does Rothbard. On the free market, all inflation is unexpected, for the reasons given. If you want to explain why you think some inflation is expected and some not, and how that relates to fiat money being theft, or not, go ahead.

You're right, this conversation is like evolution vs. ID, and you're the one who is like the ID'er. The religious zealots have all sorts of "mumbo jumbo" that believers are supposed to regurgitate, just as do mainstream economists. Asking a free-market Austrian economist to endlessly regurgitate the details of fictional econometric constructs is like asking a rational scientist to regurgitate bible prophecy.

When push comes to shove, your only argument is "because I said so". Telling.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom